Date |
Text |
2021-09-21 14:28:40 | THIS PLAN WAS REVIEWED AND FAILED BY PETER LEDUC, FIRE |
| MARSHAL, WITH THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS: |
| |
| |
| 1) LIFE SAFETY SHEETS - THERE IS AN INDICATION OF A |
| SINGLE EXIT OFF OF THE 2ND & 3RD FLOORS. |
| |
| PER NFPA 101 CH 30, NEW APARTMENT BUILDINGS |
| |
| 30.2.4.6 A SINGLE EXIT SHALL BE PERMITTED IN BUILDINGS |
| WHERE THE TOTAL |
| NUMBER OF STORIES DOES NOT EXCEED FOUR, PROVIDED THAT |
| ALL OF THE FOLLOWING |
| CONDITIONS ARE MET: |
| (1) THERE ARE FOUR OR FEWER DWELLING UNITS PER STORY. |
| (2) THE BUILDING IS PROTECTED THROUGHOUT BY AN |
| APPROVED, SUPERVISED |
| AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEM IN ACCORDANCE WITH 30.3.5. |
| (3) THE EXIT STAIRWAY DOES NOT SERVE MORE THAN ONE-HALF |
| STORY BELOW |
| THE LEVEL OF EXIT DISCHARGE. |
| (4) THE TRAVEL DISTANCE FROM THE ENTRANCE DOOR OF ANY |
| DWELLING UNIT TO |
| AN EXIT DOES NOT EXCEED 35 FT (10.7 M). |
| (5) THE EXIT STAIRWAY IS COMPLETELY ENCLOSED OR |
| SEPARATED FROM THE REST |
| OF THE BUILDING BY BARRIERS HAVING A MINIMUM 1-HOUR |
| FIRE RESISTANCE |
| RATING. |
| (6) ALL OPENINGS BETWEEN THE EXIT STAIRWAY ENCLOSURE |
| AND THE BUILDING |
| ARE PROTECTED WITH SELF-CLOSING DOOR ASSEMBLIES HAVING |
| A MINIMUM |
| 1-HOUR FIRE PROTECTION RATING. |
| (7) ALL CORRIDORS SERVING AS ACCESS TO EXITS HAVE A |
| MINIMUM 1-HOUR |
| FIRE RESISTANCE RATING. |
| (8) HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL SEPARATION HAVING A MINIMUM |
| 1?2-HOUR FIRE |
| RESISTANCE RATING IS PROVIDED BETWEEN DWELLING UNITS. |
| |
| THE PROPOSED IS IN DIRECT VIOLATIONS OF (1), (4), (5) & |
| (6) |
| |
| PLEASE REVIEW AND CORRECT OR JUSTIFY WITH SPECIFIC CODE |
| REFERENCES AND DETAILED NARRATIVE. |
| |
| |
| |
| 2) COVER SHEET - THERE IS AN INDICATION OF A FIRE |
| SPRINKLER SYSTEM. |
| |
| THERE ARE NO INDICATIONS OF FIRE SPRINKLER DOCUMENTS IN |
| COMPLIANCE WITH F.A.C. 61G |
| |
| PER FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE SECTION 61G15-32.004, |
| FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS SHALL INCLUDE THE |
| POINT OF SERVICE FOR THE WATER SUPPLY, A LIST OF |
| APPLICABLE NFPA STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO THE PROJECT, |
| CLASSIFICATION OF HAZARD OCCUPANCY FOR EACH ROOM OR |
| AREA, SUPPRESSION SYSTEM TYPE, DESIGN DENSITIES, WATER |
| SUPPLY DATA (FIRE PUMP DATA, HYDRANT FLOW TEST DATA) |
| AND ANY PERFORMANCE BASED INFORMATION SUCH AS |
| PRE-ENGINEERED SYSTEMS. |
| |
| 61G15-30.003 MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR ENGINEERING |
| DOCUMENTS. |
| (1) ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS ARE PREPARED IN THE COURSE OF |
| PERFORMING ENGINEERING SERVICES. WHEN PREPARED FOR |
| INCLUSION WITH AN APPLICATION FOR A GENERAL BUILDING |
| PERMIT, THE DOCUMENTS SHALL MEET ALL ENGINEER?S |
| RESPONSIBILITY RULES, SET FORTH IN CHAPTERS 61G15-31, |
| 61G15-32, 61G15-33, AND 61G15-34, F.A.C., AND BE OF |
| SUFFICIENT CLARITY TO INDICATE THE LOCATION, NATURE AND |
| EXTENT OF THE WORK PROPOSED AND SHOW IN DETAIL THAT IT |
| WILL CONFORM TO THE PROVISIONS OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING |
| CODE, ADOPTED IN SECTION 553.73, F.S., AND APPLICABLE |
| LAWS, ORDINANCES, RULES AND REGULATIONS, AS DETERMINED |
| BY THE AHJ. THE DOCUMENTS SHALL INCLUDE: |
| (A) INFORMATION THAT PROVIDES MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS |
| REQUIRED FOR THE SAFE OPERATION OF THE SYSTEM THAT IS A |
| RESULT OF ENGINEERING CALCULATIONS, KNOWLEDGE AND |
| EXPERIENCE. |
| (B) LIST FEDERAL, STATE, MUNICIPAL, AND COUNTY |
| STANDARDS, CODES, ORDINANCES, LAWS, AND RULES, WITH |
| THEIR EFFECTIVE DATES, THAT THE ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS |
| ARE INTENDED TO CONFORM TO. |
| (C) INFORMATION, AS DETERMINED BY THE ENGINEER OF |
| RECORD, NEEDED FOR THE SAFE AND EFFICIENT OPERATION OF |
| THE SYSTEM. |
| (D) LIST ENGINEERING DESIGN CRITERIA; REFERENCE PROJECT |
| SPECIFIC STUDIES, REPORTS, AND DELEGATED ENGINEERING |
| DOCUMENTS. |
| (E) IDENTIFY CLEARLY ELEMENTS OF THE DESIGN THAT VARY |
| FROM THE GOVERNING STANDARDS AND DEPICT/IDENTIFY THE |
| ALTERNATE METHOD USED TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE |
| STATED PURPOSE OF THESE RESPONSIBILITY RULES. |
| (2) ENGINEERS SHALL LEGIBLY INDICATE THEIR NAME AND |
| BUSINESS ADDRESS, ON ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS. ENGINEERING |
| DOCUMENTS WHICH ARE ISSUED FOR PRELIMINARY OR |
| CONCEPTUAL USE, SHALL CLEARLY NOTE THE INTENDED PURPOSE |
| OF SUCH DOCUMENTS. |
| (3) WHEN ELEMENTS OF THE PROJECT ARE SHOWN ON AN |
| ENGINEERING DOCUMENT ONLY FOR INFORMATION OR |
| CLARIFICATION AND THE ENGINEER DOES NOT INTEND TO |
| ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE ELEMENTS, THE ENGINEER |
| SHALL CLEARLY NOTE ON THE DOCUMENTS THE EXTENT OF HIS |
| RESPONSIBILITY. |
| (4) ENGINEERING DRAWINGS SHALL BE LEGIBLE AND CLEARLY |
| DEFINE AND DELINEATE THE WORK IN THE PROJECT. THEY MUST |
| ALSO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 61G15-23, F.A.C., SEALS. |
| (5) ENGINEERS SHALL CLEARLY NOTE ON ANY PRELIMINARY |
| ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS THAT SUCH DOCUMENTS ARE NOT IN |
| FINAL FORM, BUT ARE BEING TRANSMITTED TO THE PUBLIC |
| AGENCY TO RECEIVE AGENCY REVIEWS, COMMENTS AND |
| INTERPRETATIONS. THE DOCUMENTS MAY SUBSEQUENTLY BE |
| REVISED BY THE ENGINEER TO REFLECT RESOLUTION OF ISSUES |
| WITH THE PUBLIC AGENCY PRIOR TO FINAL ACTION BY THE |
| AGENCY. CHANGES, REVISIONS AND MODIFICATIONS TO A |
| PROJECT MAY PROMPT ADDITIONAL DOCUMENT SUBMITTAL FOR |
| AGENCY APPROVAL ACTION ON THE SAME PROJECT. |
| SPECIFIC AUTHORITY 471.033(2), 471.008 FS. LAW |
| IMPLEMENTED 471.033(1)(G), 471.025(3) FS. HISTORY?NEW |
| 1-26-93, FORMERLY 21H-30.003, AMENDED 11-13-08. |
| |
| ALL FIRE SPRINKLER WORK SHALL BE DONE UNDER SEPARATE |
| PERMIT & SHOP DRAWINGS. |
| |
| PLEASE PROVIDE THE REQUIRED DOCUMENTATION WITH THIS |
| MASTER PERMIT. |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| 2A) CIVIL SHEETS - THERE ARE NO INDICATIONS OF FIRE |
| LINE, FDC AND FIRE DDCV DETAILS. |
| |
| PLEASE PROVIDE DETAILS FOR THE PROPOSED FIRE LINE, FDC |
| AND DDCV LOCATIONS. |
| |
| ALL FIRE LINE UNDERGROUND SHALL BE INSTALLED PER NFPA |
| 24. PLEASE PROVIDE AN APPLICABLE NOTE OF |
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. |
| |
| |
| |
| 3) 1ST FLOOR LIFE SAFETY SHEET - THERE IS AN INDICATION |
| OF A COMMERCIAL SPACE WITH AN AREA OF 1,222 AND SQ FT |
| OF 2,057 OCCUPANCY LOAD. |
| |
| PLEASE CLARIFY IS IS 1,222 OR 2,057 |
| |
| |
| 3A) 1ST FLOOR LIFE SAFETY SHEET - THERE IS AN |
| INDICATION OF 2 DOUBLE IN-SWING EXIT DOES TO THE |
| COMMERCIAL SPACE. |
| |
| SHOULD THESE SPACES BE CONVERTED TO A MERCANTILE OR |
| ASSEMBLY OCCUPANCY THESE DOORS ARE REQUIRED TO |
| OUT-SWING. |
| |
| PLEASE REVIEW AND PROVIDE FOR CLARIFICATION OR CORRECT |
| TO OUT-SWING FOR FLEX SPACE PURPOSES. |
| |
| |
| |
| 4) 1ST FLOOR LIFE SAFETY PLAN - THE SINGLE EXIT |
| STAIRWAY EXITS INTO THE PARKING GARAGE. |
| |
| PER NFPA 101 CH 7, MEANS OF EGRESS. |
| |
| 7.2.3.5 DISCHARGE. |
| 7.2.3.5.1 EVERY SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURE SHALL DISCHARGE |
| INTO A PUBLIC WAY, |
| INTO A YARD OR COURT HAVING DIRECT ACCESS TO A PUBLIC |
| WAY, OR INTO AN EXIT |
| PASSAGEWAY. SUCH EXIT PASSAGEWAYS SHALL BE WITHOUT |
| OPENINGS, OTHER |
| THAN THE ENTRANCE TO THE SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURE AND THE |
| DOOR OPENING TO |
| THE OUTSIDE YARD, COURT, OR PUBLIC WAY. THE EXIT |
| PASSAGEWAY SHALL BE |
| SEPARATED FROM THE REMAINDER OF THE BUILDING BY A |
| 2-HOUR FIRE RESISTANCE |
| RATING. |
| 7.2.3.5.2 THE SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURE SHALL BE PERMITTED |
| TO DISCHARGE |
| THROUGH INTERIOR BUILDING AREAS, PROVIDED THAT ALL OF |
| THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA |
| ARE MET: |
| (1) THE BUILDING SHALL BE PROTECTED THROUGHOUT BY AN |
| APPROVED, SUPERVISED |
| AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEM IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION |
| 9.7. |
| (2) THE DISCHARGE FROM THE SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURE SHALL |
| LEAD TO A FREE |
| AND UNOBSTRUCTED WAY TO AN EXTERIOR EXIT, AND SUCH WAY |
| SHALL BE |
| READILY VISIBLE AND IDENTIFIABLE FROM THE POINT OF |
| DISCHARGE FROM |
| THE SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURE. |
| (3) NOT MORE THAN 50 PERCENT OF THE REQUIRED NUMBER AND |
| CAPACITY OF |
| EXITS COMPRISED OF SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURES SHALL |
| DISCHARGE THROUGH |
| INTERIOR BUILDING AREAS IN ACCORDANCE WITH 7.7.2. |
| |
| THE STAIRWAY CANNOT EXIT INTO THE PARKING GARAGE. |
| |
| PLEASE REVIEW AND CORRECT. |
| |
| |
| |
| 5) THERE IS NO INDICATIONS OF A REQUIRED FIRE ALARM. |
| |
| PER NFPA 101 CH. 30 |
| |
| 30.3.4 DETECTION, ALARM, AND COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS. |
| 30.3.4.1 GENERAL. |
| 30.3.4.1.1 APARTMENT BUILDINGS FOUR OR MORE STORIES IN |
| HEIGHT OR WITH |
| MORE THAN 11 DWELLING UNITS, OTHER THAN THOSE MEETING |
| THE REQUIREMENTS |
| OF 30.3.4.1.2, SHALL BE PROVIDED WITH A FIRE ALARM |
| SYSTEM IN ACCORDANCE |
| WITH SECTION 9.6, EXCEPT AS MODIFIED BY 30.3.4.2 |
| THROUGH 30.3.4.5. |
| |
| 61G15-32.008 DESIGN OF FIRE ALARMS, SIGNALING SYSTEMS |
| AND CONTROL SYSTEMS. |
| |
| (1) FIRE ALARMS, SIGNALING, AND CONTROL SYSTEMS |
| INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, FIRE PROTECTION |
| SUPERVISION AND ALARM CIRCUITS, ACTIVATION CONTROLS, |
| AND REMOTE SIGNALING. |
| (2) THE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM DESIGN SPECIFICATIONS |
| SHALL BE BASED ON APPLICABLE NFPA STANDARDS, WHEN |
| AVAILABLE, OR ALTERNATIVE ENGINEERING SOURCES AND GOOD |
| ENGINEERING PRACTICE WHEN REQUIRED, AND SHALL COMPLY |
| WITH THE PROVISIONS OF RULE 61G15-33.006, F.A.C. |
| SPECIFIC AUTHORITY 471.008, 471.033(2) FS. |
| LAW IMPLEMENTED 471.033 FS. |
| HISTORY--NEW 5-19-93, FORMERLY 21H-32.008. |
| |
| ALL FIRE ALARM WORK SHALL BE DONE UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT |
| & SHOP DRAWINGS. |
| |
| PLEASE REVIEW AND PROVIDE. |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| 6) EXIT SIGNAGE EMERGENCY LIGHTING - THERE DOES NOT |
| APPEAR TO BE ANY CLEAR EXIT SIGNAGE THROUGHOUT THE |
| PROPOSED OCCUPANCIES. |
| |
| 30.2.8 ILLUMINATION OF MEANS OF EGRESS. MEANS OF EGRESS |
| SHALL BE |
| ILLUMINATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 7.8. |
| 30.2.9 EMERGENCY LIGHTING. EMERGENCY LIGHTING IN |
| ACCORDANCE WITH |
| SECTION 7.9 SHALL BE PROVIDED IN ALL BUILDINGS FOUR OR |
| MORE STORIES IN |
| HEIGHT, OR WITH MORE THAN 12 DWELLING UNITS, UNLESS |
| EVERY DWELLING UNIT |
| HAS A DIRECT EXIT TO THE OUTSIDE OF THE BUILDING AT THE |
| FINISHED GROUND LEVEL. |
| 30.2.10 MARKING OF MEANS OF EGRESS. MEANS OF EGRESS |
| SHALL HAVE |
| SIGNS IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 7.10 IN ALL BUILDINGS |
| REQUIRING MORE |
| THAN ONE EXIT. |
| |
| |
| PLEASE REVIEW AND CORRECT OR INDICATE WHERE THE EXIT |
| SIGNS ARE LOCATED. |
| |
| |
| |
| 7) WHEN RESUBMITTING, PLEASE PROVIDE PLAN SHEET |
| REVISION CLOUDS OR NUMBERED NARRATIVE RESPONSES TO THE |
| ABOVE. |
| |
| |
| 8) ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY BE PROVIDED ON THE |
| RE-SUBMITTAL OF THE ABOVE. |
| |
| |
| PETER LEDUC |
| FIRE MARSHAL |
| 561-804-4709 |
| [email protected] |
| |