Date |
Text |
2019-02-25 15:43:11 | 2ND REVIEW FBC-2017 MECHANICAL |
| PERMIT #18090469 |
| 360 S. ROSEMARY |
| 2/22/19 |
| |
| CODES IN EFFECT: |
| |
| FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017 |
| FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017 |
| FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE SIXTH EDITION |
| 2017 |
| FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017 |
| FS- FLORIDA STATUTES |
| FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE |
| WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC SIXTH |
| EDITION 2017 |
| |
| PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED |
| |
| THIS 2ND MECHANICAL REVIEW WILL REFERENCE COMMENTS FROM |
| THE 1ST REVIEW DATED 11/19/18 |
| |
| 1A) OK |
| |
| 1B) REQUESTED AC CALCULATIONS NOT SUBMITTED. |
| |
| 1C) ENERGY CALCULATIONS: A) COOLING TOWER COMPLIANCE |
| DATA MISSING. B) MANY OF THE DX SYSTEMS SHOWN IN THE |
| SCHEDULE ON SHEET M8.02 MISSING. C) LOBBY SYSTEMS SHOWN |
| HAVE INCORRECT CAPACITIES AND EER THAT DO NOT MATCH THE |
| SCHEDULE. D) THE RETAIL AND OFFICE 2-5 SYSTEMS INCLUDED |
| IN THE CALCS ARE NOT SHOWN ON THE PLANS. |
| |
| 2) OK- DEFERRED SUBMITTALS WILL BE ACCEPTED. |
| |
| 3A) COMMENT STILL EXISTS: CO REQUIREMENT- PLEASE |
| ACKNOWLEDGE A COMMISSIONING REPORT WILL BE PROVIDED. |
| |
| 3B) COMMENT STILL EXISTS: CO REQUIREMENT- PLEASE |
| ACKNOWLEDGE A SMOKE CONTROL COMMISSIONING REPORT WILL |
| BE PROVIDED. |
| |
| 4) COMMENT STILL EXISTS: PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE SEPARATE |
| PLANS AND PERMITS ARE REQUIRED FOR THE KITCHEN EXHAUST |
| HOODS, FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS, AND WALK-IN COOLERS. |
| |
| 5) COMMENT STILL EXISTS: ACCORDING TO THE RESPONSE |
| NARRATIVE FROM TLC ENGINEERING, VENTILATION |
| CALCULATIONS INCLUDING THE REQUIRED OUTSIDE AIR AND |
| EXHAUST HAVE BEEN PLACED ON SHEET M8.03, HOWEVER ALL |
| THE PRINT ON THE PLAN SHEET IS TOO FAINT TO READ EXCEPT |
| FOR THE PARKING GARAGE CALCULATION SCHEDULE. |
| |
| 7) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (SHEET M0.1): VENTILATION AIR |
| NOT PROVIDED TO LOBBY 110, ELEV. LOBBY 110A, AND FIRE |
| COMM. 111. THE RESUBMITTED LAYOUT PLAN DOES SHOW CFMS |
| AT DIFFUSER AND RETURN AND EXHAUST GRILL LOCATIONS, AND |
| AS PREVIOUSLY NOTED NO VENTILATION CALCULATIONS HAVE |
| BEEN PROVIDED FOR THE MAIN CORE ROOMS AND SPACES. A) |
| THE NEW OUTSIDE AIR DUCT AND EXHAUST OPENINGS NEED TO |
| BE PROTECTED WITH LOUVERS THAT COMPLY WITH THE AMCA |
| STANDARD 550- SECTIONS 401.5 & 501.3.2 FBC M. PLEASE |
| PROVIDE SUBMITTALS INCLUDING MANUFACTURER'S PRODUCT |
| SPEC SHEETS, AND FL. PRODUCT APPROVALS AND/OR |
| MIAMI-DADE NOA'S FOR THE LOUVERS (MAY BE DEFERRED). |
| |
| 8) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1): EXHAUST VENTILATION |
| CALCULATIONS NOT PROVIDED WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE |
| PARKING GARAGE/LOADING DOCK AREA. PLEASE PROVIDE THE |
| CONTROL SEQUENCE FOR THE SMOKE EXHAUST SYSTEM IN THE |
| GARAGE/LOADING AREA, AND A SUBMITTAL FOR THE SENSORS- |
| SECTION 404.2 FBC M. A) THE PLAN INDICATES EF-1-1 AND |
| EF-1-2 DISCHARGING INTO THE ENCLOSED GARAGE WHICH IS |
| PROHIBITED PER SECTION 501.3 FBC M. |
| |
| 9) OK |
| |
| 10) COMMENT STILL PARTIALLY EXISTS (M0.1): THE RESPONSE |
| NARRATIVE FROM TLC INDICATES A MOTORIZED DAMPER TO BE |
| INSTALLED AT THE RETAIL O/A INTAKE OPENING, HOWEVER |
| NOTE #5 SPECIFIES A BACKDRAFT DAMPER. |
| |
| 11) COMMENT HAS BEEN PARTIALLY ADDRESSED, HOWEVER THE |
| DESIGN HAS THESE DEFICIENCIES (M0.1): A) A FIRE DAMPER |
| CANNOT BE INSTALLED IN THE HAZARDOUS EXHAUST DUCT |
| OPENING FOR THE TANK ROOM- SECTION 510..6.7 FBC M, AND |
| THE EXHAUST DUCT SHALL BE ENCLOSED IN FIRE-RESISTANT |
| RATED CONSTRUCTION FROM THE POINT OF PENETRATION TO THE |
| OUTLET TERMINAL. B) MINIMUM 10' CLEARANCE REQUIRED FROM |
| THE TANK ROOM EXHAUST DUCT OUTLET TO THE VENTILATION |
| INTAKE OPENING FOR THE GENERATOR ROOM. |
| |
| 12) OK |
| |
| 13) OK- SMOKE CONTROL COMMISSIONING REPORT REQUIRED. |
| |
| 14) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1): THE CONDENSING UNITS |
| SHALL BE INSTALLED OUTDOORS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THEIR |
| LISTING. INSTALLING THESE UNITS IN AN ENCLOSED SPACE |
| WILL REQUIRE A LETTER FROM THE MANUFACTURER TO CERTIFY |
| THE ALTERNATIVE INSTALLATION METHOD. |
| |
| 15) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1): NO CONTROL SEQUENCE |
| PROVIDED FOR THE EXHAUST SYSTEM IN THE ENCLOSED |
| GARAGE/LOADING AREA. |
| |
| 16) COMMENTS 16A, B, C, D, & E STILL EXIST (M0.1): FUEL |
| AND TANK VENT PIPING NOW SHOWN ON PLUMBING PLANS. ALL |
| OTHER COMMENTS NOT ADDRESSED INCLUDING THE SUBMITTAL OF |
| THE GENERATOR AND FUEL TANK SPECS. PLEASE NOTE THAT THE |
| GENERATOR SHALL BE CLASSIFIED AS LEVEL 1- SEE SECTION |
| 4.4.1 NFPA 110. THE GENERATOR SHALL ALSO BE UL 2200 |
| LISTED AND LABELED, AND IN COMPLIANCE WITH NFPA 37- |
| SECTION 915.1 FBC M. REFER TO NFPA 30 FOR REQUIRED |
| LISTING AND LABELING OF THE FUEL TANK. A) INDICATE THE |
| EPSS STANDBY LOADS AND EMERGENCY LOADS AS OUTLINED IN |
| SECTIONS 403.4.8.3 AND 403.4.8.4 FBC B. B) REFER TO |
| SECTIONS 4.2 AND 4.3, AND TABLES 4.1 (A) AND 4.1(B) |
| NFPA 110 AND INDICATE THE CLASSIFICATION AND TYPE OF |
| EPSS SYSTEM TO BE INSTALLED. |
| |
| 17) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1 & M2.04): MINIMUM 10? |
| CLEARANCE REQUIRED FROM THE TANK ROOM EXHAUST TO THE |
| GENERATOR INTAKE LOUVER- SECTION 501.3.1 FBC M. |
| |
| 18) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1): NO CLEARANCE HEIGHT |
| FROM GRADE PROVIDED- 10? REQUIRED PER SECTION 501.3.1 |
| FBC M. |
| |
| 19) OK |
| |
| 20) OK- SMOKE CONTROL COMMISSIONING REPORT REQUIRED. |
| |
| 21) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M0.1): REQUESTED SMOKE PURGE |
| CALCULATIONS NOT PROVIDED. THE SMOKE ANALYSIS PROVIDES |
| ONLY THE REQUIREMENT OF AN EXHAUST AIR CHANGE EVERY 15 |
| MINUTES FOR THE AREA INVOLVED. HOW WERE THE FANS SIZED |
| TO MEET THAT REQUIREMENT? |
| |
| 22) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M1.02, 1.03, 1.04, 1.05, |
| 1.06, 1.07, 1.08): A) NO EXHAUST CALCULATIONS PROVIDED. |
| B) NO MAKEUP AIR PROVIDED FOR THE EXHAUST SYSTEMS. C) |
| THE LOCATIONS OF THE EXHAUST OUTLETS DO NOT APPEAR TO |
| BE LOCATED IN THE AREA OF THE HEAVIEST CONCENTRATIONS |
| OF CONTAMINANTS. ADDITIONAL EXHAUST OUTLETS OR |
| CIRCULATION FANS MAY HAVE TO BE PROVIDED- SECTION |
| 502.1.1 FBC M. D) THERE IS A NOTE ON SHEET M1.02 THAT |
| STATES "IF GARAGE IS ENCLOSED, DESIGN DOESN?T WORK" |
| PLEASE REMOVE OR CORRECT THE NOTE. E) M1.08: PLEASE |
| CLARIFY THE NEED FOR THE DUCTS TO EXTEND BELOW THE SLAB |
| AS IS NOTED ON THE PLAN. |
| |
| 23) OK |
| |
| 24) COMMENT STILL EXISTS ((M1.02, 1.03, 1.04, 1.05, |
| 1.06, 1.07, 1.08): A) NO VENTILATION AIR PROVIDED TO |
| THE ELEVATOR AND GARAGE LOBBIES. B) THE EXHAUST FROM |
| EF'S -2-2, 3-2, 4-2, 5-2, 6-2, 7-2, 8-2 SHALL DISCHARGE |
| TO THE OUTDOORS- SECTION 501.3 FBC M. |
| |
| 25) OK- FUTURE OFFICE SPACES UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT. |
| |
| 26) OK |
| |
| 27) OK |
| |
| 28) COMMENT STILL EXISTS (M2.03 & M.401): PLEASE |
| COMPLY. |
| |
| 29) COMMENT STILL PARTIALLY EXISTS (M6.01): THE RISER |
| DRAWING FOR STAIR #2 SHOWS 6 INJECTION POINTS AT 3920 |
| CFMS EACH, HOWEVER THE FAN HAS A TOTAL CAPACITY OF ONLY |
| 7920 CFMS. PLEASE SEE PAGE 1 OF THE SMOKE ANALYSIS |
| WHICH INDICATES 1320 CFMS AT EACH INJECTION POINT. |
| |
| 30 & 31) ACKNOWLEDGED THAT THE REFRIGERANT RISER AND |
| THE WIND LOAD ENGINEERING WILL BE DEFERRED SUBMITTALS. |
| PLEASE PROVIDE A MASTER LIST OF ALL DEFERRED SUBMITTALS |
| ON THE PLANS OR AS A SEPARATELY UPLOADED DOCUMENT. |
| |
| |
| WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE |
| LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM ALONG WITH THE CITY |
| RE-SUBMITTAL FORM. ADDITIONALLY, PLEASE INSERT |
| CORRECTED PLAN SHEETS INTO THE SETS, REMOVE THE |
| PREVIOUSLY REVIEWED SHEETS AND MARK VOID ON THEM, AND |
| KEEP THEM WITH THE SUBMITTALS |
| |
| CHRISTOPHER L. COLE |
| MECHANICAL PLANS EXAMINER |
| 401 CLEMATIS STREET |
| WEST PALM BEACH FL 33401 |
| 561-805-6719 |
| [email protected] |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |