Date |
Text |
2014-09-03 16:05:40 | 8100 (8225) IBIS BOULEVARD |
| PERMIT #14050097 |
| REVIEW COMMENTS - FIRE DEPARTMENT |
| |
| FOR THE ORIGINAL COMMENTS (X3) I OFFER THE FOLLOWING |
| RESPONSE AND POSSIBLE SOLUTION: |
| A MONUMENTAL STAIR/CONVENIENCE OPENING IS REQUIRED TO |
| BE SEPARATED FROM CORRIDORS ON EITHER FLOOR LEVEL PER |
| SECTION 8.6.8.2(3). THE OPENING IS NOT SEPARATED FROM |
| THE CORRIDORS (GALLERY #224 & #252). ADDITIONALLY, EXIT |
| SIGNAGE HAS BEEN ADDED IN ELEVATOR LOBBY #104 ROUTING |
| OCCUPANTS THROUGH THE CONVENIENCE OPENING, PASSED THE |
| OPEN STAIR, INTO A MERCANTILE OCCUPANCY (GOLF SHOP). |
| PER SECTION 8.6.8.2(5), OPENINGS ARE NOT PERMITTED BE |
| PART OF THE MEANS OF EGRESS (IN THIS CASE EXIT ACCESS). |
| WHILE OCCUPANTS DO NOT NEED TO TRAVERSE THE OPEN STAIR |
| FOR EGRESS PURPOSES, THEY WILL, ESPECIALLY WHEN FACED |
| WITH A STRESSFUL SITUATION. SINCE THIS STAIR IS OPEN ON |
| TOP AND ENCLOSED ON BOTTOM, A FIRE SITUATION COULD |
| RESULT IN "COLD SMOKE" ACCUMULATION IN THIS STAIR...THE |
| SAME STAIR OCCUPANTS ARE BEING DIRECTED TO FOR EXIT |
| ACCESS. NO DOOR TAG PROVIDED FOR DOUBLE EXIT ACCESS |
| DOORS LOCATED BETWEEN MONUMENTAL STAIR #111 AND GOLF |
| SHOP. PROVIDING EXIT ACCESS THROUGH THESE DOORS WOULD |
| APPEAR TO CAUSE A CONFLICT WITH TRYING TO SECURE/LOCK |
| THESE DOORS FROM THE GOLF SHOP SIDE TO PREVENT THEFT. |
| |
| A POSSIBLE SOLUTION WOULD BE TO RELOCATE THE BOTTOM |
| STAIR ENCLOSURE AND DOOR TO COLUMN INTERSECTION |
| F/10-11. THIS WAY THE OPENING WOULD BE SEPARATED FROM |
| THE CORRIDOR, AND OCCUPANTS WOULDN'T GET ENTICED INTO |
| USING THE OPEN STAIR FOR EGRESS. THE ONLY ISSUE WOULD |
| BE INSTALLING PASSAGE DOOR HARDWARE ON THE EXIT ACCESS |
| DOORS LEADING THROUGH THE GOLF SHOP. |
| |
| ORIGINAL COMMENTS: |
| SHEET AE104: MONUMENTAL STAIR #209 APPEARS TO BE |
| FUNCTIONING AS A "CONVENIENCE OPENING" PER NFPA 101 |
| SECTION 8.6.8; HOWEVER, REQUIREMENT #3 REQUIRES THAT |
| SUCH OPENINGS SHALL BE SEPARATED FROM CORRIDORS. |
| |
| SHEET AE101: CULTURAL CLASS #125 (71 PERSONS) HAS TWO |
| EXIT ACCESS DOORS THAT HAVE APPROPRIATE SEPARATION; |
| HOWEVER, BOTH DOORS LEAD TO THE SAME CORRIDOR GALLERY |
| #102 WHEREBY ONE FIRE EVENT COULD COMPROMISE BOTH |
| DOORS. PER SECTION 12.2.5.1.2 THE COMMON PATH OF TRAVEL |
| IS LIMITED TO 75 FEET FOR 50 OR LESS OCCUPANTS AND 20 |
| FEET FOR 51 OR MORE OCCUPANTS. THE EXIT ACCESS DOORS |
| SHALL BE ARRANGED FOR OCCUPANTS TO HAVE ACCESS TO AT |
| LEAST TWO EXITS BY SEPARATE WAYS OF TRAVEL PER SECTION |
| 7.5.1.1.1. |
| |
| SHEET AE101: LOUNGE #110 THE COMMON PATH OF TRAVEL IS |
| 135 FEET. PER SECTION 12.2.5.1.2 THE COMMON PATH OF |
| TRAVEL IS LIMITED TO 75 FEET FOR 50 OR LESS OCCUPANTS |
| AND 20 FEET FOR 51 OR MORE OCCUPANTS. |
| |
| WESLEY JOLIN |
| ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL |
| WEST PALM BEACH FIRE RESCUE |
| [email protected] |
| (561) 805-6730 |