City of West Palm Beach eGovPlus

Plan Review Details - Permit 08060582

Plan Review Stops For Permit 08060582

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	3	Status	P	Date	2008-12-01			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-12-01	Time	15:37	Rev Time	0.55
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-12-01	Time	15:37	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-10-20			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-10-20	Time	09:55	Rev Time	0.55
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-10-20	Time	09:55	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-09			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-07-09	Time	15:31	Rev Time	1.11
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-07-09	Time	15:31	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-09 15:36:19	BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
	PERMIT: 08060582
	ADD: 10130 NORTHLAKE BLVD
	CONT: POWER SOURCE
	TEL: (919)818-8700
	FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
	W/ 2007 FBC REVISIONS
	* WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS

	REVIEW
	ACTION: DENIED

	1A)INFORMATIONAL: WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE
	INDICATE THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY PAGES AS
	NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL
	REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE
	REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
	PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND WILL HELP TO
	EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED
	COOPERATION.

	1B) INFORMATIONAL: PLEASE SUBMIT 2 OF ALL SURVEYS,
	PLANS, REPORTS, REVISIONS , PRODUCT APPROVALS AND OR
	SUBMITTALS FOR REVIEW FOR PERMIT. IF YOUR PROJECT WILL
	REQUIRE A RESIDENT INSPECTOR OR IF YOUR PROJECT IS A
	THRESHOLD BUILDING REQUIRING A THRESHOLD INSPECTOR THEN
	(3) THREE SETS OF ALL SAID DOCUMENTS WILL BE REQUIRED
	FOR PERMIT ISSUANCE. 106.1* /2004 SUBMITTAL DOCUMENTS
	WEST PALM BEACH ADMINISTRATIVE CODE.

	1C)INFORMATIONAL106.1.1* W.P.B. ADMINISTRATIVE
	CODE/2004 DRAWINGS & SPECIFICATIONS SHALL CONTAIN
	INFORMATION, IN THE FORM OF NOTES OR OTHERWISE, AS TO
	THE QUALITY OF MATERIALS, WHERE QUALITY IS ESSENTIAL TO
	CONFORMITY WITH THE TECHNICAL CODES. SUCH INFORMATION
	SHALL BE SPECIFIC TO THE TECHNICAL CODES "SHALL NOT BE
	CITED AS A WHOLE OR IN PART, NOR THE TERM "LEGAL" OR
	ITS EQUIVALENT BE USED AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR SPECIFIC
	INFORMATION". CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SHALL BE
	SUFFICIENT CLARITY TO INDICATE THE LOCATION, NATURE AND
	EXTENT OF THE WORK PROPOSED AND SHOW IN DETAIL THAT IT
	WILL CONFORM TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS CODE AND
	RELEVANT LAWS, ORDINANCES, RULES AND REGULATIONS, AS
	DETERMINED BY THE BUILDING OFFICIAL.

	1D ) INFORMATIONAL FL S S 713.13NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT, TO BE FILED WITH THE CLERK OF THE COURT.
	NOTE: 713.13(2) IF THE WORK DESCRIBED IN THE NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT IS NOT ACTUALLYCOMMENCED WITHIN 90 DAYS
	AFTER THE RECORDING THEREOF, SUCH NOTICE IS NULL &
	VOID. NOTE: 713.13(6) THE POSTING OF THE NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT AT THE CONSTRUCTION SITE BEFORE THE FIRST
	INSPECTION.

	1E)INFORMATIONAL: PLANS SUBMITTED FOR PERMIT (FIRST
	TIME REVIEW) AFTER JULY 1ST, 2007 SHALL BE REVIEWED TO
	THE 2004 FBC BUILDING WITH THE2007 SUPPLEMENTS.

	2)1603.1.4 WIND DESIGN DATA.
	THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION RELATED TO WIND LOADS SHALL
	BE SHOWN, REGARDLESS OF WHETHER WIND LOADS GOVERN THE
	DESIGN OF THE LATERAL-FORCE-RESISTING SYSTEM OF THE
	BUILDING:
	1.BASIC WIND SPEED (3-SECOND GUST), MILES PER HOUR
	(KM/HR).
	2.WIND IMPORTANCE FACTOR, I W , AND BUILDING
	CLASSIFICATION FROM TABLE 1604.5 OR TABLE 6-1, ASCE 7
	AND BUILDING CLASSIFICATION IN TABLE 1-1, ASCE 7. 3.
	WIND EXPOSURE, IF MORE THAN ONE WIND EXPOSURE IS
	UTILIZED, THE WIND EXPOSURE AND APPLICABLE WIND
	DIRECTION SHALL BE INDICATED.
	4.THE APPLICABLE ENCLOSURE CLASSIFICATIONS AND, IF
	DESIGNING WITH ASCE 7, INTERNAL PRESSURE COEFFICIENT.

	3) PLANS INDICATE ON SHEET E7 THE CONCRETE FOUNDATION
	AND SLAB BUT FAIL TO PROVIDE ATTACHMENT OF THE
	GENERATOR AND BELLY TANK. 1609.1.3 MOMMENT AGAINST
	OVERTURNING, UPLIFT AND SLIPPAGE.

	JIM WITMER C. B. O.
	BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II

	TEL: (561)805-6715
	FAX: (561)659-8026
	E-MAIL: [email protected]

	PLEASE NOTE: FLORIDA HAS A VERY BROAD PUBLIC RECORDS
	LAW. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS TO OR FROM LOCAL OFFICIALS
	REGARDING CITY BUSINESS ARE PUBLIC RECORD, AVAILABLE TO
	THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. YOUR E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS ARE
	THEREFORE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-11-06			Cont ID
Sent By	btrobaug			Date	2008-11-04	Time	15:17	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	btrobaug			Date	2008-11-04	Time	13:47	Sent To	PC

Notes

2008-11-06 11:02:38




	PROVISO

	250.32(B)(2) GROUNDED CONDUCTOR WHERE (1) AN EQUIPMENT
	GROUNDING CONDUCTOR IS NOT RUN WITH THE SUPPLY TO THE
	BUILDING OR STRUCTURE, (2) THERE ARE NO CONTINUOUS
	METALLIC PATHS BONDED TO THE GROUNDING SYSTEM IN EACH
	BUILDING OR STRUCTURE INVOLVED, AND (3) GROUND-FAULT
	PROTECTION OF EQUIPMENT HAS NOT BEEN INSTALLED ON THE
	SUPPLY SIDE OF THE FEEDER(S), THE GROUNDED CONDUCTOR
	RUN WITH THE SUPPLY TO THE BUILDING OR STRUCTURE SHALL
	BE CONNECTED TO THE BUILDING OR STRUCTURE DISCONNECTING
	MEANS AND TO THE GROUNDING ELECTRODE(S) AND SHALL BE
	USED FOR GROUNDING OR BONDING OF EQUIPMENT, STRUCTURES,
	OR FRAMES REQUIRED TO BE GROUNDED OR BONDED.---IF THESE
	CONDITIONS ARE NOT MET, AN EQUIPMENT GROUND MUST BE
	INSTALLED WITH THE FEEDERS, AND THE NEUTRAL ISOLATED
	INTHE EXISTING MAIN SWITCHGEAR.
2008-11-04 15:16:25

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-17			Cont ID
Sent By	btrobaug			Date	2008-07-17	Time	13:29	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	btrobaug			Date	2008-07-15	Time	08:26	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-17 13:29:05


	THIS REVIEW WAS DONE UNDER THESE CURRENT CODE CYCLES:

	THE 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, 2007 REVISIONS, 2005
	NEC, NFPA-72 2002, NFPA-101 2003, 2004 FBC AS AMENDED,
	CHAPTER 1.AND FOUND NONCOMPLIANT WITH THE FOLLOWING:

	1} THE MANUFACTURERS SPECIFICATIONS REQUESTED IN THE
	PRIOR REVIEW, COMMENT #3, WERE NOT SUBMITTED, THE
	SCHEMATIC ON SHEET E2 DOES NOT CLEARLY INDICATE
	COMPLIANCE WITH 230.76 OR 225.31, 32. PLEASE SUBMIT
	SAME.

	2} SHEET E5 INDICATES A BONDING JUMPER IN THE EXISTING
	SWITCHGEAR IN VIOLATION OF 250.24(A)(5) "LOAD-SIDE
	GROUNDING CONNECTIONS A GROUNDING CONNECTION SHALL NOT
	BE MADE TO ANY GROUNDED CONDUCTOR ON THE LOAD SIDE OF
	THE SERVICE DISCONNECTING MEANS EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE
	PERMITTED IN THIS ARTICLE." THE NEUTRALS AND GROUNDS
	MUST BE SEPARATED IN THE EXISTING SWITCHBOARD AS THE
	APS IS NOW THE FIRST MEANS OF DISCONNECT. ALSO SEE
	250.6 OBJECTIONABLE CURRENT OVER GROUNDING CONDUCTORS
	AND 250.32(B)(1)----- "ANY INSTALLED GROUNDED CONDUCTOR
	SHALL NOT BE CONNECTED TO THE EQUIPMENT GROUNDING
	CONDUCTOR OR TO THE GROUNDING ELECTRODE(S).

	3} THE RESPONSE TO COMMENT #4 FROM THE PEVIOUS REVIEW
	WAS NOT CLEAR, SEE COMMENT #1.

	4} VERIFY THAT 250 MCM EQUIPMENT GROUND COMPLIES WITH
	250.122(F)(1). THIS WOULD DEPEND ON THE AMPERAGE RATING
	OF THE OCP. SEE COMMENT #1.

	5} THE NOTE "E" SHEET E5, SYSTEM GROUNDING LEGEND AND
	NOTE "9" SHEET E2 REGARDING ARTICLE 250.32(A)(2) AND
	USING THE NEUTRAL AS THE GROUND TO THE BUILDING IS NOT
	ALLOWED. ARTICLE 250.32(B)(2) STATES " GROUNDED
	CONDUCTOR WHERE (1) AN EQUIPMENT GROUNDING CONDUCTOR IS
	NOT RUN WITH THE SUPPLY TO THE BUILDING OR STRUCTURE,
	(2) THERE ARE NO CONTINUOUS METALLIC PATHS BONDED TO
	THE GROUNDING SYSTEM IN EACH BUILDING OR STRUCTURE
	INVOLVED". CONDITION #2 CANNOT BE MET . SEE E6"SYSTEM
	CONTROL WIRING, AND SHEET E4 INDICATING CONTROL WIRING
	RUNING BETWEEN THE STRUCTURE AND THE BUILDING AN
	EQUIPMENT GROUND PER 250.122 IS REQUIRED, MAKING
	COMMENT #2 A REQUIREMENT.

	IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CALL.

	BILL TROBAUGH
	ELECTRICAL PLANS EXAMINER
	CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
	561/805-6718

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-11-03			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-11-03	Time	13:15	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-11-03	Time	13:02	Sent To

Notes

2008-11-03 13:15:40	***APPROVED****

	THE COMMENTS FROM THE PREVIOUS FIRE PLAN REVIEW HAVE
	BEEN ADDRESSED; PLAN SHEETS E1.1, E4.1, & SD1 WERE
	STAMPED, INITIALED, AND DATED.


	CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	561-805-6722

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-23			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-07-23	Time	15:02	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-07-23	Time	14:37	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-23 14:58:54	***DENIED****


	1. THE SCOPE OF WORK SHALL NOT INTERFERE WITH EMERGENCY
	RESPONSE ACCESS TO THE BUILDING(S) OR THE VICINITY
	THEREOF (INCLUDING FIRE LANES) .

	2. PLEASE DESCRIBE ANY AND ALL LIFE SAFETY EQUIPMENT
	PLANNED TO BE SUPPLIED BY THE GENERATOR.

	3. STATIONARY GENERATORS USED FOR EMERGENCY OR STANDBY
	POWER SHALL BE INSTALLED , TESTED, AND MAINTAINED TO
	COMPLY WITH NFPA 110.

	4. DIESEL FUEL STORAGE SHALL COMPLY WITH NFPA 30.


	TO EXPEDITE THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS, INCLUDE A RESPONSE
	LETTER INDICATING HOW/WHERE EACH ITEM WAS ADDRESSED


	CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	561-805-6722

Review Stop	FUEL			DIESEL GENERATOR
Rev No	1	Status	P	Date	2008-07-17			Cont ID
Sent By	tgordon			Date	2008-07-17	Time	14:05	Rev Time	0.20
Received By	tgordon			Date	2008-07-17	Time	14:05	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-17 14:05:36	* PROVISO *
	1) FUEL STORAGE TANK MUST BE A MINIMUM OF 5 FEET FROM
	THE BUILDING, PER NFPA 30 4.3.2.1.1.

	2) THE GENERATOR MUST BE A MINIMUM OF 5 FEET FROM ANY
	BUILDING OPENINGS, PER NFPA 37 4.1.4.

	MECHANICAL PLAN REVIEW BY;
	TOM GORDON (561) 805-6729

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	3	Status	N	Date	2008-11-14			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-11-14	Time	09:13	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-11-14	Time	09:13	Sent To

Notes

2008-11-14 09:14:12

TO "BOB"#10

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	2	Status	N	Date	2008-10-02			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-10-02	Time	10:08	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-10-02	Time	10:08	Sent To

Notes

2008-10-02 10:10:56

TO "COMM" BD#61

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	1	Status	N	Date	2008-07-23			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-07-23	Time	14:39	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-06-23	Time	09:20	Sent To

Notes

2008-06-24 16:18:52	TO "COMM" BD#60
2008-06-23 09:21:49	WAITING FOR "COMM" BD

Review Stop	M			MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No	1	Status	P	Date	2008-07-17			Cont ID
Sent By	tgordon			Date	2008-07-17	Time	13:54	Rev Time	0.20
Received By	tgordon			Date	2008-07-17	Time	13:54	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-17 14:04:23	* PROVISO *
	1) FUEL STORAGE TANK MUST BE A MINIMUM OF 5 FEET FROM
	THE BUILDING, PER NFPA 30 4.3.2.1.1.
	2) THE GENERATOR MUST BE A MINIMUM OF 5 FEET FROM ANY
	BUILDING OPENINGS, PER NFPA 37 4.1.4.
	MECHANICAL PLAN REVIEW BY;
	TOM GORDON (561) 805-6729

Review Stop	Z			ZONING
Rev No	3	Status	P	Date	2008-11-25			Cont ID
Sent By	jroach			Date	2008-11-25	Time	18:57	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	jroach			Date	2008-11-25	Time	18:57	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	Z			ZONING
Rev No	2	Status	F	Date	2008-10-16			Cont ID
Sent By	jroach			Date	2008-10-16	Time	17:00	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	jroach			Date	2008-10-16	Time	17:00	Sent To

Notes

2008-10-16 19:47:07	*FAILED*

	1) PLEASE SPECIFY THE TYPE OF LANDSCAPING PROPOSED. THE
	CITY'S LANDSCAPE PLANNER RECOMMENDS THE INSTALLATION OF
	PODOCARPUS. IF IT RESULTS WHERE THIS IS THE ONLY
	OUTSTANDING COMMENT, IT MAY BE INCLUDED AS A PROVISO.

	THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS ARE NEWLY-GENERATED AS A RESULT
	OF THE NEW PROPOSED LOCATION OF THE GENERATOR:

	1) THE GENERATOR CANNOT BE LOCATED WHERE PROPOSED AS IT
	CONFLICTS WITH EXISTING TREES IN THE LANDSCAPE ISLAND.
	THESE TREES ARE REQUIRED AS PART OF THE SITE PLAN AND
	SHALL NOT BE REMOVED. WHY WAS THE GENERATOR RELOCATED?
	ZONING HAD NO OBJECTION TO THE LOCATION OF THE
	GENERATOR ADJACENT TO THE BUILDING...ALL THE NEEDED TO
	BE DONE WAS SCREEN THE GENERATOR WITH A FENCE/WALL,
	LANDSCAPE AROUND THE WALL, AND PROTECT THE LANDSCAPING
	VIA A CURB. PLEASE CONTACT ME REGARDING THIS ISSUE TO
	TRY AND WORK OUT A LOCATION THAT WILL BE SUFFICIENT FOR
	ALL PARTIES.

Review Stop	Z			ZONING
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-14			Cont ID
Sent By	jroach			Date	2008-07-14	Time	12:50	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	jroach			Date	2008-07-09	Time	17:31	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-14 13:35:14	*FAILED*

	1) THE DRIVE AISLE ADJACENT TO THE GENERATOR WILL NEED
	TO BECOME ONE-WAY, AS IT WILL ONLY BE 15 FEET IN WIDTH.
	I SUGGEST THAT A "DO NOT ENTER" SIGN BE INSTALLED IN
	THE LANDSCAPE ISLAND TO PREVENT PEOPLE FROM DRIVING
	SOUTH THROUGH THE AISLE (SEE ATTACHED SKETCH FOR
	LOCATION OF SIGN).

	2) AS NOTED PREVIOUSLY, ALL MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT WILL
	NEED TO BE SCREENED PURSUANT TO SECTION 94-444(B) OF
	THE CITY'S ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS
	(ZLDRS):

	A) THE PROPOSED PVC FENCE SHALL COMPLETELY ENCLOSE THE
	GENERATOR.
	B) THE FENCE SHALL BE LANDSCAPE WITH SHRUBS/HEDGES
	PLANTED AT 2 FOOT INTERVALS.
	C) THE SHRUBS/HEDGES SHALL BE PROTECTED FROM VEHICULAR
	ENCROACHMENT BY MEANS OF CURBING.
	D) THE SWITCHGEAR AND TRANSFORMER SHALL ALSO BE
	PROPERLY SCREENED.

	QUESTIONS/COMMENTS CONTACT JOHN ROACH, SENIOR PLANNER,
	AT (561) 822-1435.
2008-07-09 17:34:05	PLANNING AND ZONING:

	CURRENTLY PENDING MINOR AMENDMENT REVIEW FROM THE
	PLANNING AND ZONING DEPT.

	ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CONTACT JOHN ROACH AT 822-1448.