Plan Review Details - Permit 08040418
Plan Review Stops For Permit 08040418
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2008-12-29 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2008-12-29 Time 10:10 Rev Time 1.33
Received By jwitmer Date 2008-12-29 Time 10:10 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-29 10:11:27REVISON# 4 DATED 10-24-08
 SHEETS: A2.1.2 & A2.2.2

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status F Date 2008-12-01 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2008-12-01 Time 08:36 Rev Time 1.33
Received By jwitmer Date 2008-12-01 Time 08:36 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-01 08:48:42BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 08040418
 ADD: 1 HARVARD CIRCLE
 CONT: SUFFOLK CONSTRUCTION
 TEL: (561)644-6405
 FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2007 FBC REVISIONS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 REVISION# 4 REVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 1) DISCREPANCY IN PLANS, SECOND FLOOR LIFE SAFETY
 A2.1.2 AND THE SECOND FLOOR CORE AREA PLAN A2.2.2 DO
 NOT MATCH IN THE LOBBY AREA (201), CONFERENCE ROOM
 (202) AND HALLWAY (203) FROM PLAN TO PLAN, PLEASE
 CORRELATE PLANS TO MATCH. 106.1.2 ADDITIONAL
 INFORMATION REQUIRED, 1008.1.2.
  
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)805-6731
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
 PLEASE NOTE: FLORIDA HAS A VERY BROAD PUBLIC RECORDS
 LAW. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS TO OR FROM LOCAL OFFICIALS
 REGARDING CITY BUSINESS ARE PUBLIC RECORD, AVAILABLE TO
 THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. YOUR E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS ARE
 THEREFORE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2008-08-27 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2008-08-27 Time 11:34 Rev Time 0.77
Received By jwitmer Date 2008-08-27 Time 11:34 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-27 11:35:32NEW A4.1.2

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2008-07-03 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2008-07-03 Time 08:48 Rev Time 2.22
Received By rregueir Date 2008-07-03 Time 08:48 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-03 08:49:52PHASE II INTERIOR OFFICE RENOVATIONS

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-05-03 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2008-05-03 Time 15:29 Rev Time 4.20
Received By jwitmer Date 2008-05-03 Time 15:29 Sent To  
Notes
2008-05-03 15:31:09BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 08040418
 ADD: 1 HARVARD CIRCLE
 CONT: SUFFOLK CONSTRUCTION
 TEL: (561)644-6405
 FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2007 FBC REVISIONS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 REVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 1A) INFORMATIONAL: WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE
 INDICATE THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY PAGES AS
 NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL
 REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE
 REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
 PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND WILL HELP TO
 EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED
 COOPERATION.
  
 1B) INFORMATIONAL: PLEASE SUBMIT 2 OF ALL SURVEYS,
 PLANS, REPORTS, REVISIONS , PRODUCT APPROVALS AND OR
 SUBMITTALS FOR REVIEW FOR PERMIT. IF YOUR PROJECT WILL
 REQUIRE A RESIDENT INSPECTOR OR IF YOUR PROJECT IS A
 THRESHOLD BUILDING REQUIRING A THRESHOLD INSPECTOR THEN
 (3) THREE SETS OF ALL SAID DOCUMENTS WILL BE REQUIRED
 FOR PERMIT ISSUANCE. 106.1* /2004 SUBMITTAL DOCUMENTS
 WEST PALM BEACH ADMINISTRATIVE CODE.
  
 1C) INFORMATIONAL 106.1.1* W.P.B. ADMINISTRATIVE
 CODE/2004 DRAWINGS & SPECIFICATIONS SHALL CONTAIN
 INFORMATION, IN THE FORM OF NOTES OR OTHERWISE, AS TO
 THE QUALITY OF MATERIALS, WHERE QUALITY IS ESSENTIAL TO
 CONFORMITY WITH THE TECHNICAL CODES. SUCH INFORMATION
 SHALL BE SPECIFIC TO THE TECHNICAL CODES "SHALL NOT BE
 CITED AS A WHOLE OR IN PART, NOR THE TERM "LEGAL" OR
 ITS EQUIVALENT BE USED AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR SPECIFIC
 INFORMATION". CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SHALL BE
 SUFFICIENT CLARITY TO INDICATE THE LOCATION, NATURE AND
 EXTENT OF THE WORK PROPOSED AND SHOW IN DETAIL THAT IT
 WILL CONFORM TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS CODE AND
 RELEVANT LAWS, ORDINANCES, RULES AND REGULATIONS, AS
 DETERMINED BY THE BUILDING OFFICIAL.
  
 1D ) INFORMATIONAL: PLANS SUBMITTED FOR PERMIT (FIRST
 TIME REVIEW) AFTER JULY 1ST, 2007 SHALL BE REVIEWED TO
 THE 2004 FBC BUILDING WITH THE 2007 SUPPLEMENTS.
  
 2) ON THE HEADER STRIP FOR THE ARCHITECTURAL SHEETS
 PLEASE PROVIDE THE LOCATION OF THE PROJECT.
 61G1-16.004 FL. ADMIN. CODE. PLANS PREPARED BY A
 REGISTERED ARCHITECT SHALL INCLUDE A TITLE BLOCK WHICH
 MUST:
 - STATE THE FIRM NAME, ADDRESS AND TELEPHONE NUMBER
 - STATE THE FIRM LICENSE NUMBER
 XX - STATE PROJECT NAME & LOCATION
 - STATE DATE PREPARED
 - INCLUDE AN ORIGINAL SIGNATURE AND DATED SEAL INCLUDE
 THE PRINTED NAME OF THE
 ARCHITECT SEALING THE PLANS
  
 3) FLORIDA ENERGY CODE PROJECT SUMMARY SHEET INDICATES
 THE USE OF METHOD A, WHERE THERE ARE UNKNOWNS ON SHEET
 A2.2.1 AND A2.2.2 FUTURE EXPANSION AREAS.
 PLEASE REVIEW SECTION 13-400.0C.4 FOR WHICH FORM MAY BE
 USED. NOTE LEVEL 3 ALTERATIONS INCLUDE ANY WORK
 COMPLETED WITHIN ANY 12 ?MONTH PERIOD.2004 EXISTING
 BUILDING CODE 305.1.
  
 4) ENERGY CERTIFICATION SHEET IS LEFT UNSEALED. EACH OF
 THE DISCIPLINES WOULD NEED TO SEAL FOR THEIR PORTION OF
 WORK THEY ARE CERTIFYING. TRUE THERE SHOULD BE ONLY ONE
 SEAL PER PAGE SO FOR EXAMPLE JOEVEN VALENZUELA WOULD
 SIGN AND SEAL A INDIVIDUAL SHEET FOR THE LIGHTING AND
 ELECTRICAL TOM CAOOELLIN WOULD ALSO DO THE SAME FOR THE
 MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING AS WELL AS STEVEN KNIGHT FOR
 ARCHITECT OF RECORD.
 PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, REPORTS OR OTHER DOCUMENTS
 PREPARED BY THE DESIGN PROFESSIONAL AND BEING FILED FOR
 PUBLIC RECORD SHALL HAVE THE SIGNATURE AND SEAL OF THE
 DESIGN PROFESSIONAL AFFIXED TO THE DOCUMENT.
 FL ADMIN CODE 61G15-23.002 ENGINEERS
 FL ADMIN CODE 61G16.003 ARCHITECTS
  
 5) ENERGY INPUT DATA REPORT SHEET# 3 FOR WALLS
 INDICATES THE EXTERIOR WALLS ARE TO HAVE A R-VALUE OF
 12.5, SHEET A7.2.3 INDICATES DETAIL# 1 AS AN EXTERIOR
 WALL BUT NOT R-VALUE IS PROVIDED FOR THE INSULATION.
 THE WINDOW AND EXTERIOR WALL (EFIS) PERMIT 08010752
 INDICATES THE STO INSULATION BOARD IS TO BE 1? THICK
 BUT I CAN NOT FIND IN THE NOA SUPPLIED A R-VALUE NOR ON
 LINE FROM THE STO WEB-SITE. PLEASE PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
 INFORMATION AS TO COMPLY WITH THE ENERGY CODE AND
 SECTION 13-402.1.
  
 6) ENERGY INPUT DATA REPORT SHEET# 5 FOR DOORS THIS
 SHEET INDICATES THERE ARE A TOTAL OF (7) 3?-0?X 7?-0?
 SOLID CORE FLUSH DOORS WHEREAS SHEET A7.2.1 INDICATES
 THERE ARE (13) 3?-0?X7?-0? DOORS. THE OTHER ISSUE IS ON
 THIS SHEET FOR DOOR INFORMATION AND FRAME ALL EXISTING
 DOOR INFORMATION INDICATES EXISTING, PLEASE PROVIDE
 TYPE OF MATERIALS FOR DOOR AND FRAME, UNDER REMARKS YOU
 CAN INDICATE EXISTING DOORS.
 PLEASE REVISIT AND CORRECT THE INPUT DATA REPORT
 SECTION 13-403.
  
 7) SHEET A2.2.1 NEW WORK NOTES:
 7A) NOTE A INDICATES NEW HANDRAILS IN STAIRWAYS 1,2& 3.
 THERE IS NO MENTION OF NEW HANDRAILS FOR EITHER THE
 ENTRY RAMP NOR THE 2 FRONT ENTRY STAIRS. THIS SAME
 SHEET INDICATES A PORTION OF THE MAIN LOBBY AND
 EXTERIOR DECK ARE GOING TO BE RAISED WITH A
 NEW DECK. THIS NEW DECK WILL INCREASE THE STAIRS WITH
 AT LEST ONE NEW RISER AND WILL
 CREATE A STEEPER RAMP SINCE THE START OF THE RAMP AND
 MID LANDING ARE FIXED POINTS.
 7A)(1) PLEASE PROVIDE THE ELEVATION CHANGE FROM THE
 EXISTING SURFACE TO THE NEW FINISH, WILL THIS NEW RISER
 BE CONSISTENT WITH THE OTHER RISERS IN EACH OF THE
 EXTERIOR STAIRS? 1009.3.1.SHEET A4.1.1 INDICATE TREAD
 BUT NOT THE RISER HEIGHT?
 7A)(2) PLEASE PROVIDE DETAILS FOR THE NEW HANDRAILS FOR
 THE 2 EXTERIOR STAIRS. 1009.14 & 11-4.9.4. A4.1.1
 DETAIL 1 THE END OF THE HANDRAIL APPEARS TO BE GREATER
 THAN 27? FROM GRADE. SEE 11-4.4.1 AND FIGURE 19. 7A)(3)
 PLEASE PROVIDE THE NEW SLOPE FOR THE EXISTING RAMP,
 PLEASE SEE 11-4.8.2.
 7A)(4) PLEASE PROVIDE DETAILS FOR THE NEW HAND RAIL FOR
 THE RAMP. 11-4.8.5.
 7A((5) A4.1.1 ENLARGED LOBBY AREA INDICATES ON THE
 STAIRS THE HANDRAIL EXTENSION BEING A TOTAL OF 1?-2?
 AWAY FROM THE LAST TREAD. SEE 11-4.9.4(2).
 7A)(6) A4.1.1 DETAIL 1 INDICATES THE HANDRAIL TO BE 1
 ?? SQUARE TUBING. 11-4.9.4 HANDRAILS SHALL COMPLY WITH
 SECTION 11-4.26 PLEASE PROVIDE THAT THE SQUARE TUBING
 PROVIDES THE EQUIVALENT GRIPPING SURFACE AS 11-4.9.4.
  
 7B) NOTE (B) INDICATES THAT THE NO. 2 STAIRWAY IS OPEN?
 106.1.2 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED.
  
 7C) THE ELEVATOR MACHINE ROOM IS MISSING RATING OF SOME
 WALLS AND DOOR SEE 3006.4.
  
 8) SHEET A8.1.1 WALL DETAIL 100 TYPO PLEASE CORRECT THE
 STUD GAUGE THICKNESS TO REFLECT THAT OF UL 465. 106.1.2
 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED.
  
 9) SHEET A2.2.2 NOTES K & M BOTH INDICATE THROUGH
 PENETRATIONS TO THE FIRST FLOOR BUT THE MECHANICAL
 PLANS DO NOT INDICATE DAMPERS. SEE FBCB 716.1. JIM
 WITMER C. B. O.
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)805-6731
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
 PLEASE NOTE: FLORIDA HAS A VERY BROAD PUBLIC RECORDS
 LAW. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS TO OR FROM LOCAL OFFICIALS
 REGARDING CITY BUSINESS ARE PUBLIC RECORD, AVAILABLE TO
 THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. YOUR E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS ARE
 THEREFORE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 8 Status P Date 2009-01-14 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2009-01-14 Time 15:16 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2009-01-14 Time 15:16 Sent To  
Notes
2009-01-14 15:18:24OLD SHEETS PLACED IN SETS TO COMPLETE ELECTRICAL.
 SOME OTHER SHEETS WHICH WERE CLAIMED TO NOT BE NEEDED
 WERE REMOVED ON 12/31 BY MATT KIZIAH

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 7 Status F Date 2008-12-30 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-12-30 Time 09:59 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-12-30 Time 09:59 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-30 09:59:41 
 ** DENIED REVISIONS**
  
 1) NOTE: THE SETS SUBMITTED ARE NOT COMPLETED. ONLY ONE
 SET CONTAINS ALL THE FOLLOWING REVISED SHEETS FROM
 PREVIOUS REVIEW. THE NEW SETS DO NOT CONTAIN SOME OF
 THE PREVIOUS REVISED SHEETS WHICH STILL NEED TO BE A
 PART OF THE COMPLETED SETS.
 THE ONE OLD SET CONTAINS:
 E, 0.05,1.01,1.02,1.03,2.01,2.02,3.02,6.01, AND 7.01.
 THE OTHER THREE SETS CONTAIN:
 E, 1.01, 2.01, 6.02, 6.03 AND 7.01.
  
 PLEASE SUBMIT ALL REVISED SHEETS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW
 WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT HAVE BEEN REVISED HOWEVER STILL
 NEED TO BE PART OF THE REVISIONS.
 PLEASE CALL TO GO OVER.
  
  
  
 ** IMPORTANT **
 ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
 FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
 ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
 SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
 DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC. SHOULD BE PLACED
 INTO TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
 ANY DELAYS.
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
 TYPED IN A CLEAR MANNER PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
 CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
  

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 6 Status F Date 2008-12-01 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-12-01 Time 14:26 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-12-01 Time 14:26 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-01 14:26:16 
 ** FAILED REVISION**
  
  
 1) NOTE: PLEASE COORDINATE ALL LIGHTING ON PLANS WITH
 REVISED LIGHTING PERFORMANCE CALCULATIONS.
 13-400.3.A, 13-101.1.1, 13-415.2, 13-415.2.ABC.1.1,
 .1.2 AND .1.3.
 PLEASE SEE FOR EXAMPLE THE FIXTURE *T* HAS HAD ALL
 INFORMATION ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND REMOVED HOWEVER THE
 PLANS STILL INDICATE MANY *T* FIXTURES.
  
 2) NOTE: PLEASE SEE COMMENTS FROM BUILDING REVIEWER AS
 THE FLOOR LAYOUTS NEED TO BE COORDINATED.
 IT IS NOT CLEAR WHICH IS THE CORRECT ONES TO REVIEW.
 AN EXAMPLE: PLEASE SEE SECOND FLOOR LIFE SAFETY PLAN
 WHICH CONTAINS AN EXIT SIGN DIRECTLY OCCUPANTS BACK
 INTO THE BUILDING. THE ELECTRICAL PLANS DO NOT CONTAIN
 THIS SAME EXIT SIGN. OCCUPANTS ARE NOT TO BE DIRECTED
 BACK INTO THE BUILDING AND SHOULD FOLLOW THE EGRESS
 PATH AS DESIGNATED. THIS HAS BEEN CIRCLED ON SHEET
 A2.12
 NFPA- 101, 7.8, 7.9.
  
 ** THE ABOVE TWO ARE SOME EXAMPLES WHICH COORDINATION
 IS NEEDED.
 FBC 106.1.1
  
  
 **IMPORTANT**
 ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
 FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
 ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
 SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
 DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC. SHOULD BE PLACED
 INTO TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
 ANY DELAYS.
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
 TYPED IN A CLEAR MANNER PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
 CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
  

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2008-08-18 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-08-18 Time 16:53 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-08-18 Time 16:53 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-18 16:53:20DOCUMENTS BROUGHT IN. STAMPED, OK.

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 4 Status F Date 2008-08-18 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-08-18 Time 16:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-08-18 Time 16:41 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-18 16:41:43 
  
 ** TEMPORARY FAILED REVIEW **
  
  
  
  
 1) NOTE:NEED TO SUBMIT PERMIT APPLICATION. NEED TO
 SUBMIT THE PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT
 SHEETS FOR THE TRANSFER SWITCHES WHICH ARE PART OF THE
 SCOPE OF WORK.
  
  
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
 TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
 CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.
  
  
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2008-08-05 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-08-05 Time 08:08 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-08-05 Time 08:08 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-05 08:08:25 
 **DENIED 3RD REVIEW**
  
 ** PLEASE SEE SOME COMMENTS FROM THE PREVIOUS REVIEW
 ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING. PLEASE ALSO SEE SOME
 NEW COMMENTS BASED ON CHANGES MADE TO PLANS AND THE
 NEED FOR COORDINATION.
  
 1) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW THE THREE SETS OF PLANS ARE NOT
 COMPLETE AND ARE MISSING TWO ELECTRICAL SHEETS FROM ONE
 SET. THIS PROJECT ONLY REQUIRES TWO SETS AND UP TO
 THREE MAY BE STAMPED HOWEVER THE THIRD SET NEEDS TO BE
 COMPLETE BEFORE IT COULD BE STAMPED. AS PLANS ARE
 COMING BACK FOR OTHER ELECTRICAL COMMENTS AND
 CORRECTIONS PLEASE EITHER COMPLETE THE THIRD SET OR
 REMOVE FROM SUBMITTING.
  
 2) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETED ENERGY CALCULATIONS
 WITH AN INPUT DATA REPORT WHICH COORDINATES WITH PLANS.
 THE INPUT DATA REPORT WILL BE NOTED AS IDR FOR THE
 REMAINDER OF THIS REVIEW.
 THESE SECTIONS OF CODE APPLY. 13-415.2,
 13-415.2.ABC.1.1,.1.2 AND .1.3. 13-400.A.3, 13-101.1.1
 (AT A MINIMUM).
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE EXTERIOR LIGHTING ON PLANS ARE GREATER
 THAN THAT OF THE INFORMATION ON THE IDR.THE 250W
 FIXTURES ARE HIGHER ON PLANS. THE 175W WALL FIXTURES
 ARE HIGHER ON PLANS. IF COMMENTS WERE BASED ON THESE
 FIXTURES ONLY, THIS WOULD NOT CONSTITUTE AS A GROSS
 ERROR AS STATED IN THE CODE. HOWEVER SEE COMMENTS
 BELOW.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE FIXTURE LEGEND AS THIS SHOWS TYPE TT
 FIXTURE(S) YET COULD NOT LOCATE ANY OF THESE ON PLANS?
 THE FIXTURE LEGEND LIST THIS FIXTURE IN CONFERENCE ROOM
 BASED ON PLANS THIS WAS NOT SHOWN. PLEASE ALSO SEE THE
 FIXTURE LEGEND LIST 201WATTS FOR THIS TYPE OF FIXTURE
 YET THE IDR DOES LIST ANY 201W FIXTURE OR 200W
 FIXTURE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SEVERAL LOCATIONS WHICH THE LIGHTING METHOD
 OF CONTROL INDICATE *MAN ON/OFF* YET THIS CAN NOT BE
 POSSIBLE WHEN THE CODE REQUIRES AUTOMATED DEVICES AND
 THE PLANS DO SHOW AUTOMATED DEVICES. ROOMS/AREAS/SPACES
 247,248,260,255 ETC ETC.
 SOME LOCATIONS OF LIGHT FIXTURES ON PLANS SUCH AS *NL*
 FOR NIGHT LIGHTS WOULD STATE THE MANUAL ON/OFF YET
 THERE ARE LOCATIONS IN WHICH THE LIGHTING IS BEING
 AUTOMATICALLY CONTROLLED.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THERE ARE TWO SPACES 255. EACH SHOWING
 SEPARATE FIXTURE COUNTS AND YET NEITHER COORDINATE WITH
 PLANS. ALSO EACH SHOWING MANUAL ON/OFF.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THERE ARE TWO SPACES 219. EACH SHOWING
 SEPARATE FIXTURE COUNTS AND YET NEITHER COORDINATE WITH
 PLANS. ALSO EACH SHOWS MANUAL ON/OFF.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 202, PLANS SHOW 8 FIXTURES, THE IDR
 SHOWS 6.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEESPACE 234 WHICH INDICATES 1-67WATT FIXTURE
 YET BASED ON THE FIXTURE NOTED ON PLANS AND THE
 INFORMATION ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND THIS SHOULD BE 134
 WATTS TOTAL.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE: PLEASE SEE SPACE 233 WHICH INDICATES 1-67
 WATT FIXTURE YET BASED ON TYPE OF FIXTURE ON PLANS
 WHICH CORRELATES WITH THE FIXTURE LEGEND THE FIXTURE
 LEGEND CALLS FOR 134WATTS.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 266 AS PLANS INDICATES 5 OR 6 FIXTURES
 DEPENDING ON SPACE LINES AND THE IDR SHOWS ONLY ONE
 FIXTURE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 267 AS THE PLANS SHOWS ONE FIXTURE AND
 THE IDR SHOW MORE. WHICH DESIGN WILL BE USED?
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE IDR NO SPACE 221 COULD BE LOCATED THEREFORE
 NO FIXTURE AS SHOWN ON PLANS IS IN THE IDR.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 101 ON PLANS. THE PLANS CALL FOR
 4-TYPE *D* FIXTURES WHICH ARE 52WATTS BASED ON LEGEND
 YET THE IDR DOES NOT CONTAIN ANY 52WATT FIXTURES FOR
 THIS SAME ARE.
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 101 ON PLANS. THE PLANS CALL FOR
 12-TYPE *C* 50.4W FIXTURE BASED ON LEGEND YET THE IDR
 DOES NOT INDICATE ANY OF THESE 50W FIXTURES.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 134.THE IDR SHOWS 28 WATT FIXTURES
 YET THE PLANS DO NOT INDICATE ANY OF THESE FIXTURES?
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SPACE 141 AS THE IDR INDICATES 1-67 YET
 PLANS INDICATES 2.
  
 ** AS GIVEN ON PREVIOUS REVIEW THESE ARE EXAMPLES AND
 IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST. THIS CONSTITUTES AS GROSS
 ERRORS BOTH ON FACT THERE ARE MORE FIXTURES AND WATTAGE
 ON PLANS NOT IN THE IDR AND THE IDR SHOWING FIXTURES
 WHICH ARE NOT ON PLANS. THE LIGHTING ON PLANS AND
 CALCULATIONS NEED TO COORDINATE.
  
 3) NOTE: PLEASE INDICATE MAXIMUM TIMES FOR ALL DEVICES.
 PLEASE KNOW THE SYMBOL LEGEND MAY STATE THE MAXIMUM
 TIMES FOR OCCUPANCY SENSOR TYPE DEVICES. THE OVER RIDES
 AS NOTED ON THE LIGHTING CONTROL PLANS DO SHOW THE
 30MINS MAX AS REQUIRED PER 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2.
  
 4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE ROOM/AREA 248 WHICH SHOWS A FIXTURE
 *E* FOR EMERGENCY HOWEVER BY THE FIXTURE LEGEND NO
 BATTERY BACK UP IS NOTED ON LEGEND.
 ON PREVIOUS REVIEWS THE EMERGENCY FIXTURES HAVE CHANGED
 YET SOME OF THESE ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING THE
 MINIMUM FOR THE LIFE SAFETY CODE. RESPONSE MENTIONS A
 NOTE WAS GOING TO BE ADDED TO PLANS FOR THE 100% BACK
 UP OF LUMENS ON FIXTURES HOWEVER THIS NOTE COULD NOT BE
 LOCATED. SINCE THE EMERGENCY LEVELS OF PHOTO-METRICS
 WERE NOT PROVIDED THE NOTES IS REQUIRED OR PROVIDE
 LEVELS UNDER EMERGENCY POWER/BACK UP.
 7.8.1.3, 7.9.1.2, 7.9.2.2
  
 5) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SOME ITEMS N RISER WITH PANEL
 SCHEDULES STILL NEED TO COORDINATE.
 SOME EXAMPLES ARE NOTED.
  
 PLEASE SEE PANEL 1H1. THE MDP LIST 4/0 YET THE RISER
 NOTE FOR THESE FEEDERS INDICATE 3/0.
 PLEASE SEE PANEL 1LEQ WHICH SHOWS 225AMP MCB ON RISER
 YET THE PANEL SHOWS A 200AMP MCB.
 PLEASE SEE 1HL ON RISER WHICH INDICATES A FEED TO PANEL
 2HL YET THE PANEL SCHEDULE FOR 1HL DOES NOT LIST ANY
 BRANCH CIRCUIT TO THE PANEL 2HL.
 310.16, 240.4, 408.4 ETC
 FBC 106.3.5.1.2, 106.1.1 FOR CLARITY AND COORDINATION.
  
 6) NOTE: THE PREVIOUS REVIEW GAVE NOTICE TO FS
 553.80(2)(B) WITH RESPECT TO REPEAT COMMENTS FOR CODE
 COMPLIANCE. EVEN AS THERE ARE SEVERAL CODE SECTIONS
 REPEATED, BASED ON THE CHANGE IN THE METHOD OF ENERGY
 CALCULATIONS THE CALCULATIONS ARE NOT THE SAME. THE
 NEXT REVIEW HOWEVER WILL BE THE THIRD REVIEW OF SAID
 METHOD *A*. THIS FEE HAS NOT BEEN ASSESSED HOWEVER IF
 CALCULATIONS COME BACK IN ON THE NEXT REVIEW WITHOUT
 COORDINATION WITH PLANS THIS REVIEWER WILL HAVE NO
 CHOICE TO ASSESS FEE OF FOUR TIMES THE PLAN REVIEW FEE
 AS STATED IN STATUTE ABOVE. THIS IS A STATUTORY
 REQUIREMENT.
 THIS FEE OF $18,632.79 WOULD BE THE AMOUNT ASSESSED.
  
  
  
 IMPORTANT**
 ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
 FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
 ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
 SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
 DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
 TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
 ANY DELAYS.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
2008-08-04 17:00:342008-08-04 17:01:34
 NOTES TO FOLLOW ON 8/5

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2008-07-01 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-07-01 Time 13:03 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-07-01 Time 13:03 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-01 13:03:50 
  
  
  
 ** DENIED2ND REVIEW **
  
 ** PLEASE SEE THERE ARE COMMENTS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW
 WHICH ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING ALONG WITH SOME
 NEW COMMENTS DUE TO CHANGES AND NEW INFORMATION ON
 PLANS NOT ON PREVIOUS PLANS.
  
 ** PLEASE BE SURE TO ADDRESS ALL COMMENTS AS SOME ARE
 REPEAT CODE SECTIONS. IF THERE ARE QUESTIONS ABOUT ANY
 OF THE NOTES BELOW PLEASE CALL TO GO OVER.
  
 *** AS STATED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW. THERE IS SOME ITEMS
 NOT YET SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW SO THOSE ITEMS CAN NOT YET
 BE REVIEWED FOR COMPLIANCE.
  
  
 1) NOTE:THE PREVIOUS PLANS REFERENCED SOME NOTES FOR
 FIRE PUMP ALTHOUGH NOT IN PROJECT. THE PREVIOUS REVIEW
 NOTE #1 STATED TO PLACE THE 2003 NFPA-20 ON PLANS DUE
 TO FIRE PUMP REFERENCE. SINCE THERE IS NO FIRE PUMP,
 NFPA-20 DOES NOT NEED TO BE REFLECTED ON PLANS. IF THIS
 WERE THE ONLY COMMENT THIS WOULD BE REDLINED.
  
 2) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS REVIEW WITH RESPECT TO
 REFERENCE OF LIFE SAFETY AND EMERGENCY SYSTEMS.
 RESPONSE MENTIONS ALL REFERENCE TO THESE SYSTEMS WILL
 BE REMOVED. PLEASE NOTE SYSTEMS AS OPTIONAL STAND-BY
 ONLY. PLANS ALONG WITH RISER STILL REFLECT L AND EQ .
 WHY ARE THERE TWO SEPARATE REFERENCES TO TYPE OF
 SYSTEMS? PLEASE INCLUDE ONLY THE DESIGNATIONS OF SOME
 SORT TO * OPTIONAL STAND-BY* ONLY.
 THE PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTE #2 ALSO REQUESTED TO SUBMIT
 THE MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT SHEETS FOR THE ATS UNITS
 HOWEVER NO SPECS/SUBMITTALS OR DOCUMENTS WERE
 SUBMITTED.
 PLEASE SUBMIT.
 NEC 701,700, 702. 702.6, 110.3, 90.7
 NFPA-110
 FBC 106.1.1, 106.1.2 FOR CLARITY AND COORDINATION.
  
  
 3) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE SUBMITTED ENERGY CALCULATIONS
 ARE NOT IN COMPLIANCE FOR THE MINIMUM REQUIRED BY FBC
 CHAPTER 13.
 PLEASE SEE SECTIONS 13-415.2.ABC.1.1, .1.2, .1.3,
 13-415.2.
 PLEASE SEE SOME EXAMPLES WILL BE NOTED BELOW. THE INPUT
 DATA REPORT WILL BE NOTED AS IDR.
 ** IT IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT THESE ARE *SOME*
 EXAMPLES ONLY AND ARE *NOT* AND EXHAUSTED LIST OF ALL
 ITEMS WHICH MAY NOT BE LISTED OR COMPLIANT.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE IDR FOR EXTERIOR LIGHTS. THE LIGHTING
 SHOWN ON THE IDR DOES NOT COORDINATE WITH PLANS. ONE OF
 THESE ITEMS IS ALL THE SITE LIGHTING. NONE OF THE SITE
 LIGHTING IS SHOWN ON THE IDR. WHERE ARE ALL OF THE 250W
 FIXTURES? WHERE ARE THE 175W FIXTURES?
 PLEASE TAKE A LOOK AT THE *Q* FIXTURES.
 ** MAKE NOTE THERE WILL BE COMMENTS BELOW WITH RESPECT
 TO EXTERIOR LIGHTING WHICH MAY CHANGE ON PLANS.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE ROOM AREA #110, 202, 234, 244, 243 ETC AS THERE
 ARE FIXTURES SHOWN ON PLANS WHICH ARE NOT LISTED ON THE
 FIXTURE LEGEND. HOW CAN THESE BE VERIFIED IF THE
 FIXTURES ARE NOT LISTED ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND?
 ** FIXTURES *AA*?
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE *DD* FIXTURES ON THE IDR AND PLANS. PLEASE
 SEE FIXTURE LEGEND WHICH INDICATES THESE AS 30WATTS YET
 THE IDR SHOWS A DIFFERENT VALUE FOR THE SAME FIXTURE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE HE FIXTURE IS MISSING FROM THE FIXTURE
 LEGEND. CAN NOT CONFIRM THE RATING ETC WITH THE IDR.
 THE FIXTURE CAN NOT BE *ASSUMED* TO BE THE SAME AS THE
 *H* AS THE *H* IS NOTED A PENDANT AND THE SYMBOL FOR
 THIS SAME FIXTURE IS TYPICAL FOR A
 RECESSED/CEILING/WALL MOUNTED FLUORESCENT TYPE
 FIXTURE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 THE IDR FOR WATER HEATERS ONLY SHOW ONE WATER HEATER AT
 9KW. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE WHEN THE PLANS SHOW AT LEAST
 3 WATER HEATING SYSTEMS WHICH ARE ALL ELECTRICAL? **
 PLEASE BE SURE TO ADJUST OTHER SYSTEMS SUCH AS PIPING
 ETC TO COORDINATE.
  
 ** THESE ARE SOME EXAMPLES GIVEN AS A BENEFIT.
  
 4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SOME ITEMS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW FOR
 LIGHTING CONTROLS ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING ALONG
 WITH NEW COMMENT DUE TO REVISED ITEM ON PLANS. PLEASE
 SEE SECTIONS 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2, .1.3 AND .1.4.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE NEW OS SENSOR NOTED ON THE SYMBOL LEGEND
 INDICATES UNIT WITH *DAYLIGHT COMPENSATION* YET THE
 LIGHTING CONTROLS SHOWN ON THE IDR INDICATES *OCCUPANCY
 SENSOR WITHOUT DAYLIGHT SAVING*.
 PLEASE COORDINATE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE PREVIOUS NOTE WITH RESPECT TO CONTROL OF
 ALL EXTERIOR FIXTURES. A COUPLE OF THE *Q* FIXTURES ON
 PLANS ARE NOTED WITH A PHOTO-CELL NEXT TO THE FIXTURE
 HOWEVER NOT ALL.
 PLEASE SEE 13-415.1.ABC.1.4 FOR THE TWO PERMITTED
 METHODS. ONE OR THE OTHER IS REQUIRED.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 THE RESPONSE MENTIONS TO SEE 7.03 AND 7.04 FOR EXTERIOR
 LIGHTING CONTROL AS THE SITE LIGHTING IS NOTED TO COME
 FROM THE LIGHTING CONTROL PANEL.
 HOW ARE THESE FIXTURES ON THE SAME LIGHTING CONTROL
 PANEL WHICH CONTROLS INTERIOR LIGHTS AS SHOWN?
 HOW ARE THESE SEPARATED?
 HOW DOES THIS LIGHTING CONTROL PANEL COMPLY WITH ONE OF
 THE TWO REQUIRED METHODS OF EXTERIOR LIGHTS? ONE METHOD
 PERMITTED IS PHOTO-SENSOR TYPE OR ASTRONOMICAL TIME
 CLOCK. WHEN ON ANY TIMED SCHEDULING THEN A MINIMUM
 BATTERY BACK UP IS REQUIRED FOR THE MINIMUM TIMES AS
 STATED IN THE SECTION OF THE CODE ABOVE.
  
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE INDICATE HOW THE SCHEDULING AND ZONES TAKE
 PLACE.
 PLEASE SEE THE SECTION OF THE CODE ABOVE
 13-415.1.ABC.1.1 AS THE SYSTEMS ON EACH FLOOR SHALL BE
 INDEPENDENT. IT IS NOT PERMITTED TO HAVE THE LIGHTING
 CONTROL PANEL ON THE FIRST FLOOR CONTROL THE LIGHTING
 ON THE SECOND FLOOR, OR REVERSE.
  
 ** THESE ARE SOME EXAMPLES**
 PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE THE FOLLOWING COMMENT TWO
 COMMENTS.
  
 5) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS REVIEW COMMENTS WITH
 RESPECT TO THE MINIMUM LIGHTING LEVELS TO BE SHOWN IN
 PHOTO-METRICS FOR LIFE SAFETY CODE.
 THE RESPONSE MENTIONS TO SEE NEW LEVELS SHOWN ON E3.01.
 PLEASE TAKE A LOOK AT PLANS AS THE PLANS SHOW TWO
 TYPICAL STAIRS UNDER NORMAL ONLY.
 HOW CAN THE STAIRS BE TYPICAL WHEN THE LAYOUTS ARE NOT
 THE SAME?
 HOW CAN THE STAIRS BE TYPICAL LIGHTING LEVELS WHEN THE
 SAME LIGHT FIXTURES ARE NOT USED IN ALL STAIRS? AN
 EXAMPLE OF THIS IS *ME* FIXTURES AND *CE* FIXTURES.
 PLEASE VERIFY THESE FIXTURES UNDER EMERGENCY LEVELS.
 WILL THE BACK UP BALLAST PROVIDE THE 100 PERCENT RATING
 OF THE LUMEN OUTPUT AS THE NORMAL LEVEL?
 THIS WAS THE REASON FOR SHOWING THE LEVELS UNDER NORMAL
 AND EMERGENCY AND FOR EACH DIFFERENT STAIRWAY. PLEASE
 SEE NFPA-101 2003 7.8.1.3, 7.9.2.1, 7.9.2.2 FAC
 61G15-33.004
  
 6) NOTE: THE PLANS NOW INDICATE NEW OCCUPANCY SENSORS
 FOR SOME OF THE EGRESS LIGHTS IN THE STAIRS. THIS IS
 PERMITTED BY BOTH THE LIFE SAFETY CODE AS WELL AS THE
 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE HOWEVER BOTH CODES REQUIRE THESE
 TYPES OF DEVICES TO *FAIL SAFE ON*.
 PLEASE ADJUST THE UNITS FOR STAIRS AND INCLUDE ON
 PLANS/SYMBOL LEGEND FOR FAIL SAFE ON DEVICES. NFPA-101
 2003 7.8.1.2.2, FBC 1006.2
  
 7) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE TO ADJUST PANEL SCHEDULES AS
 CIRCUITS SHALL BE SPECIFIC TO ROOMS AND AREAS IN WHICH
 THEY FEED. PLEASE SEE PANEL *1L1* WHICH INDICATES
 DOZENS OF CIRCUITS TO *RECEPTACLES*. THESE WOULD
 INDICATE THE ROOM OR NUMERICAL DESIGNATION ON PLANS.
 NEC 408.4, 310.16, 240.4,220.44 ETC
 FBC 106.1.1, 106.5 FOR CLARITY, ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
 AND RECORD PLANS.
  
 8) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE PLANS DO NOT INDICATE ANY
 EXTERIOR LIGHTS ON ANY OF THE THREE DOORS ON THE
 NORTH/NORTHEAST SIDE OF THE BUILDING.
 PLEASE KNOW ANY REVISIONS WOULD BE COORDINATED WITH
 OTHER SYSTEMS SUCH AS LOADS, CONTROLS, FIXTURE COUNTS
 ETC.
 ** NOTED ONLY** NO RESPONSE NEEDED.
  
 9) NOTE: PLEASE SEE MISSING EXIT SIGN ON FIRST FLOOR
 FOR EGRESS INTO STAIR #4.
 LS-1017.10.1.1
  
 10) NOTE: PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE ACCESS
 CONTROL SNOW CLEARLY INDICATED ON PLANS. PLEASE SEE
 NFPA-101 2003 7.2.1.5, 7.2.1.5.1, 7.2.1.5.2 AS ALL
 DEVICES SHALL NOT IMPEDE MEANS OF EGRESS IN ANY
 CONDITION UNDER NORMAL OR UNDER EMERGENCY CONDITIONS.
 THIS INFORMATION IS REQUIRED ON BASE DESIGN EVEN AS THE
 ACCESS CONTROL SYSTEM WILL BE UNDER SEPARATE PERMIT AND
 PLANS.
 DOORS SHALL BE ARRANGED TO BE OPENED READILY FROM THE
 EGRESS SIDE WHENEVER THE BUILDING IS OCCUPIED. LOCKS,
 IF PROVIDED, SHALL NOT REQUIRE THE USE OF A KEY, A
 TOOL, OR SPECIAL KNOWLEDGE OR EFFORT FOR OPERATION FROM
 THE EGRESS SIDE.
  
 11) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 645.10 AS THE MEANS OF SHUTTING
 OFF THE MECHANICAL SYSTEM SHALL BE SIMILAR TO THE SAME
 SHUT OFF REQUIRED FOR OTHER ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT. THE
 PUSHBUTTON FOR *OFF* WAS NOTED FOR THE PANEL HOWEVER
 THE A/C SYSTEM IN THIS SPACE DOES NOT INDICATE THE SAME
 TYPE OF SHUT OFF AT THE EGRESS DOOR.
 PLEASE ADD AND ADJUST ALL PLANS ACCORDINGLY.
  
 12) NOTE: THE PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTED FBC 3006.2 WITH
 RESPECT TO THE ELEVATOR EQUIPMENT ROOM AND VENTILATION
 REQUIREMENTS. THE RESPONSE MENTIONS NEW EF-3 WAS ADDED
 YET NO CIRCUITING WAS LOCATED ON PLANS FOR UNIT,
 DISCONNECT ETC
 EF-#1 AND #2 ARE NOTED ON PANEL SCHEDULE HOWEVER NOT
 NEW #3.
 PLEASE ADJUST.
 240.4, 220, 422, 310.16, ETC
 FBC 106.1.1, 106.1.2 FOR CLARITY AND ADDITIONAL
 INFORMATION.
  
 13) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SITE LIGHTING PLANS ALONG WITH THE
 ELECTRICAL RISER DIAGRAM INDICATES AN *EQUIPMENT
 GROUNDING CONDUCTOR* AHEAD OF THE FIRST MEANS OF
 DISCONNECT. THIS IS NOT PERMITTED.THE GROUNDED
 CONDUCTOR IS BONDED AT THE FIRST MEANS OF DISCONNECT
 PER CODE.WHEN THIS TAKES PLACE IF AN EQUIPMENT
 GROUNDING CONDUCTOR WAS INSTALLED BEFORE THIS FIRST
 MEANS OF DISCONNECT THIS WOULD CREATE OBJECTIONABLE
 CURRENTS BETWEEN THE NEUTRAL AND THE EQUIPMENT GROUND.
 PLEASE SEE 250.24, 250.6 AS ADJUST RISER AND PLANS.
  
 14) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 240.13 AND 230.95. THE GFP WAS
 ADDED AND NOW SHOWN ON THE MAIN DIST BOARD INSIDE THE
 BUILDING. PLEASE SEE THE SECTIONS OF THE CODE AS THIS
 IS REQUIRED AT THE MAIN. THE NEW MAIN OUTSIDE IS A NEW
 FUSED DISCONNECT. HOW WILL THE GFP BE PROVIDED ON A
 FUSED SAFETY SWITCH?
 PLEASE VERIFY THE MAIN DIST BOARD INSIDE STILL
 CONTAINING A MAIN.
 PLEASE ADJUST AND REVISE PLANS ACCORDINGLY.
  
 15) NOTE: PLEASE SEE RISER AS THE *1TL* TRANSFORMER IS
 SHOWING 1/0 CONDUCTORS ON THE SECONDARY SIDE WHICH
 TERMINATES INTO A 200AMP MAIN CIRCUIT BREAKER AT PANEL
 *1LL*. THE 1/0 CONDUCTORS ARE NOT RATED.
 240.21, 240.4, 310.16. AN EXAMPLE OF THIS WAS GIVEN ON
 PREVIOUS REVIEW FOR CONDUCTORS FORM *1TN* THOSE WERE
 CORRECTED.
  
 16) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE CONDUCTORS FROM THE MDP TO
 TRANSFORMER *1TN*. THESE ARE NOTED ON THE RISER WITH A
 #10 FOR THE FEEDER LEGEND WHICH SHOWS 1/0 ONCE AGAIN ON
 A 200AMP BREAKER.
 PLEASE SEE 240.4, 310.16, 110.14 AS 1/0 IS NOT RATED
 FOR THE 200AMPS.
  
 17) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE THE SCHEDULE FOR MDP AS
 THIS SHOWS 150AMP BREAKER/OVER CURRENT PROTECTION FOR
 THE SAME *1TN*. PLEASE COORDINATE.
 PLEASE SEE 450.3 AS THE MAXIMUM OVER CURRENT PROTECTION
 FOR THIS SIZE TRANSFORMER IS NOT PERMITTED TO BE OVER
 125%.
 240.4, 310.16, 450.3 ETC
 PLEASE ADJUST AND COORDINATE ALL.
 FBC 106.1.1, 106.1.2
  
 18) NOTE: THE RISER NOTES AND SHOWS THE DISCONNECT AND
 GFI RECEPTACLE FOR CHILLER HOWEVER PLEASE LOCATE ON THE
 PLANS THE ACTUAL LOCATION OF THESE ITEMS.
 210.63, 440.11.
  
 19) NOTE: PLEASE PLACE NOTE ON PLANS FOR *ALL DEVICES*
 TO MEET 11-4.27. THE RESPONSE MENTIONS THE FIRE ALARM
 DEVICES NOW INDICATE HEIGHTS. HOWEVER THE SECTION OF
 CODE REFLECTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW WAS NOT FOR FIRE
 ALARM DEVICES.
 THE CODE SECTION IS GIVEN BELOW:
 **
 11-4.27 CONTROLS AND OPERATING MECHANISMS. 11-4.27.1
 GENERAL.
 CONTROLS AND OPERATING MECHANISMS REQUIRED TO BE
 ACCESSIBLE BY SECTION 11-4.1 SHALL COMPLY WITH SECTION
 11-4.27.
 11-4.27.2 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE.
 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE COMPLYING WITH SECTION 11-4.2.4 THAT
 ALLOWS A FORWARD OR A PARALLEL APPROACH BY A PERSON
 USING A WHEELCHAIR SHALL BE PROVIDED AT CONTROLS,
 DISPENSERS, RECEPTACLES AND OTHER OPERABLE EQUIPMENT.
 11-4.27.3 HEIGHT.
 THE HIGHEST OPERABLE PART OF CONTROLS, DISPENSERS,
 RECEPTACLES, AND OTHER OPERABLE EQUIPMENT SHALL BE
 PLACED WITHIN AT LEAST ONE OF THE REACH RANGES
 SPECIFIED IN SECTIONS 11-4.2.5 AND 11-4.2.6. ELECTRICAL
 AND COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM RECEPTACLES ON WALLS SHALL BE
 MOUNTED NO LESS THAN 15 INCHES (380 MM) ABOVE THE
 FLOOR.
 EXCEPTION: THESE REQUIREMENTS DO NOT APPLY WHERE THE
 USE OF SPECIAL EQUIPMENT DICTATES OTHERWISE OR WHERE
 ELECTRICAL AND COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS RECEPTACLES ARE
 NOT NORMALLY INTENDED FOR USE BY BUILDING OCCUPANTS.
 11-4.27.4 OPERATION.
 CONTROLS AND OPERATING MECHANISMS SHALL BE OPERABLE
 WITH ONE HAND AND SHALL NOT REQUIRE TIGHT GRASPING,
 PINCHING, OR TWISTING OF THE WRIST. THE FORCE REQUIRED
 TO ACTIVATE CONTROLS SHALL BE NO GREATER THAN 5 LBF
 (22.2 N).
 ** THIS WAS EXTRACTED FROM THE FBC FOR INFORMATION.
 THIS MAY AFFECT OPERATING DEVICES IN AREAS FOR ADA SUCH
 AS BREAK ROOMS ETC.
  
 20) NOTE: PLEASE SEE FS 553.80(2)(B) WITH RESPECT TO
 REPEAT COMMENTS FOR CODE COMPLIANCE. THIS IS ONLY A
 NOTICE GIVEN AT THIS TIME AS SOME OF THE SAME CODE
 SECTIONS GIVEN IN PREVIOUS REVIEW ARE REPEATED. PLEASE
 KNOW AT THIS TIME SOME PLANS ARE BEING RETAINED ALONG
 WITH ONE SET OF CALCULATIONS.
  
 ** THIS OFFICE EXPRESSES THAT IF THERE ARE ANY
 COMMENTS, QUESTIONS OR CLARIFICATION NEEDED TO PLEASE
 DO NOT HESITATE IN CONTACTING THIS OFFICE.
 PLEASE SEE BELOW FOR CONTACT INFORMATION.
  
 ** IMPORTANT**
 ONCE ALL REVIEWS ARE DONE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP FOR
 CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE ALL
 OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED SHEETS
 INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. DO NOT
 LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
 TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID ANY
 DELAYS.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPT.
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-05-01 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-05-01 Time 15:12 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-05-01 Time 15:12 Sent To  
Notes
2008-05-01 15:12:25** DENIEDREVIEW **
  
 **** IMPORTANT****
 PLEASE SEE COMMENTS BELOW: AS THERE IS INFORMATION,
 DOCUMENTS, PLANS ETC WHICH ARE NOT SUBMITTED SOME ITEMS
 FOR CODE COMPLIANCE CAN NOT BE REVIEWED AT THIS TIME.
 PLEASE SEE THE LIST OF COMMENT BELOW BASED ON PLANS AND
 DOCUMENTS WHICH WERE SUBMITTED. IT IS IMPORTANT TO
 UNDERSTAND THAT DUE TO MUCH NEED FOR CHANGES FOR CODE
 COMPLIANCE AND ITEMS WHICH CAN NOT BE REVIEWED THERE
 MAY VERY WELL BE NEW COMMENTS ON THE FOLLOWING REVIEW
 WHICH CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME.
  
 1) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE PLANS SUBMITTED SHALL CONTAIN
 THE LATEST ADOPTED CODES UNDER THE FLORIDA BUILDING
 CODE ALONG WITH STATUTORY ADOPTED CODES. PLEASE SEE THE
 FOLLOWING SHALL BE STATED ON PLANS. SOME CODES BELOW
 ARE BEING REQUESTED TO BE STATED AND SHOWN ON
 ELECTRICAL AS WELL AS COVER SHEETS.
 2004 FBC W/2007
 2003 NFPA-101
 2002 NFPA-72
 2003 NFPA-20
 2005 NFPA-70
  
 PLEASE KNOW SOME SHEETS REFERENCE A FIRE PUMP AS NOTED
 ON E6.05 SEE NOTES WITH RESPECT TO ANY FIRE PUMP.
 PLEASE SEE THERE ARE SEVERAL SHEETS IN WHICH CODES ARE
 BEING REFLECTED FROM THE 1999 NFPA-70 (NEC).
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE E0.03 AND 0.04, NOTES FOR GROUNDING IS
 STATING 250.26 FOR SEPARATELY DERIVED SYSTEMS. THIS
 CHANGED IN THE 2002 AND 2005 NEC.
 PLEASE SEE THESE SAME SHEETS FOR NOTES ON WIRING WHICH
 REFLECTS 370.20/21 HOWEVER THIS IS NO LONGER IN EFFECT
 FOR EQUIPMENT AS STATED. THE 2002 AND 2005 WERE BOTH
 CHANGED AND THE SECTIONS 370 OF THE NEWER CODES
 ACTUALLY REFLECT THE CABLEBUS.
 ** THE IS ONLY A COUPLE OF EXAMPLES AND IS NOT AN
 EXHAUSTED LIST OF LOCATIONS. THIS IS GIVEN AS A BENEFIT
 ONLY AND IS IN NO WAY ALL POSSIBLE LOCATIONS.
  
  
 2) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE THE ADDRESS TO THE LOCATION OF
 THIS PROJECT IS LISTED ON ALL TITLE BLOCKS ON ALL
 SHEETS.
 PLEASE SEE FAC 61G1-16.004, 61G15-23.002, FBC ADMIN
 SECTION 106.5.
  
 3) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE COLOR CODING SHOWN ON E0.03
 SHALL BE BROWN, PURPLE AND YELLOW FOR 277/480V
 SYSTEMS.
 ORANGE AS STATED IN NEC 110.15 IS ONLY FOR A
 *HIGH-LEG*. THE 277/480V IS NOT A HIGH-LEG.
 PLEASE KNOW AS THE NEC DOES NOT PROVIDED COLOR CODING
 FOR THIS PARTICULAR SYSTEM THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 ALONG WITH ALL OF PALM BEACH COUNTY HAD TECHNICAL
 AMENDMENTS WHICH WERE IN EFFECT FOR MORE THAN 30 YEARS.
 EVEN THOUGH THIS TECHNICAL AMENDMENT IS NO LONGER IN
 EFFECT IN KEEPING WITH COORDINATION, SAFETY AND
 CONTINUITY OF OTHER WIRING WHICH ALREADY EXISTS IN THIS
 AHJ PLEASE ADJUST.
 90.4
  
 4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE E6.05 WHICH SHOWS GROUNDING DETAIL
 WHICH MENTIONS TO FIRE PUMP YET NO FIRE PUMP,
 ELECTRICAL FOR FIRE PUMP ETC WAS LOCATED ON ANY OTHER
 SHEET(S).
 IF A FIRE PUMP IS INDEED GOING TO BE INSTALLED PLEASE
 SUBMIT ALL INFORMATION INCLUDING MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT
 SHEETS FOR SUCH SYSTEM/UNIT.
 PLEASE SEE 695 OF NFPA-70 AND ALL OF 2003 NFPA-20.
  
 5) NOTE: PLANS ARE SPECIFICALLY CALLING FOR A *LIFE
 SAFETY* AND *EMERGENCY* TRANSFER SWITCHES YET THE PLANS
 DO NOT SHOW ANY GENERATOR.
 THERE IS NO ELECTRICAL ON THE EMERGENCY SIDE ON EITHER
 OF THE TRANSFER SWITCHES. IF THIS IS A TRUE LIFE SAFETY
 REQUIRED SYSTEM UNDER 700 OR 701, THEN THE GENERATOR
 AND ALL OTHER REQUIRED SHALL BE IN THE DESIGN FOR
 MINIMUM CODE COMPLIANCE UNDER NFPA-101, 20, 110, 70
 ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW AS NO INFORMATION, SPECS, MANUFACTURES CUT
 SHEETS, ETC WAS SUBMITTED NO REVIEW OF *MINIMUM* CODE
 COMPLIANCE CAN BE DONE AT THIS TIME. IF THERE IS A
 LEGALLY REQUIRED SYSTEM OR LIFE SAFETY SYSTEM, PLEASE
 IDENTIFY AND INCLUDE ALL FOR MINIMUM CODE COMPLIANCE.
 IF LOADS ARE ONLY GOING TO BE OPTION STAND-BY THEN
 PLEASE ADJUST ALL PLANS ETC FOR CODE COMPLIANCE. PLEASE
 CAREFULLY REVIEW NEC 700,701 AND 702 FOR ACTUAL LOADS.
 *** IMPORTANT**
 PLEASE KNOW IF A GENERATOR IS GOING TO BE INSTALLED THE
 PLANS FOR ALL OTHER TRADES SHALL BE REVISED TO INCLUDE
 ANY SUCH UNIT.
 PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE ELEVATIONS ON
 SITE/BUILDING/STRUCTURAL SHEETS.
 PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE ON SITE PLANS FOR
 CIVIL/ZONING REVIEWS.
 PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE SCREENING AS REQUIRED BY
 ZONING.
 PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE STRUCTURAL SLAB DETAILS FOR
 UNIT, TIE DOWNS ETC.
 PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE SIZE OF FUEL TANK AS
 DEPENDING ON SIZE THERE MAY BE NEEDS FOR REVIEW AND
 STAMP BY DERM.
  
 THE ITEMS LISTED ABOVE ARE NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST AS
 THERE WILL BE COMMENTS FROM OTHER TRADES. THESE NOTES
 WILL BE FORWARDED TO OTHER TRADES.
 PLEASE SUBMIT THE MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT SHEETS FOR
 BOTH TRANSFER SWITCHES. 90.7, 110.3, 700, 701, OR 702.
 FBC 106.3.5.1.2, 106.1.2
  
 6) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE ENERGY CALCULATIONS SUBMITTED.
 PLEASE KNOW AS THE BUILDING IS NOT BEING DONE AS A
 WHOLE BUILDING AND STILL INCLUDED SHELL SPACES METHOD
 *A* MAY NOT BE USED.
 PLEASE SEE 13-400.3.B, 13-400.3.C, 13-101.1.3,
 13-101.1.6 ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW EVEN AS METHOD *A* WAS SUBMITTED IN THE
 INFORMATION SHOWN ON THE INPUT DATA REPORT AND
 CALCULATIONS DOES NOT CORRELATE WITH PLANS.
 PLEASE KNOW THE INPUT DATA REPORT WILL BE NOTED AS IDR
 FOR REMAINDER OF THIS COMMENT.
 PLEASE KNOW THAT ALL INFORMATION ON PLANS SHALL
 COORDINATE WITH THE IDR. ALL COMPONENTS OF THE BUILDING
 FOR ENERGY EFFICIENCIES SHALL BE INCLUDED. SOME
 EXAMPLES WILL BE GIVEN BELOW FOR ITEMS WHICH ARE
 MISSING
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE IDR WHICH ONLY SHOWS A TOTAL OF FOUR
 LIGHT FIXTURES. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE WHEN THE IDR
 CLEARLY REQUIRES THE TYPES OF LUMINAIRES, THE NUMBER OF
 *EACH* OF THOSE LUMINAIRES, THE WATTAGE ON EACH OF
 THOSE LUMINAIRIES ETC.
 BASED ON THE IDR SUBMITTED THIS DOES NOT MEET THE
 *MINIMUM* REQUIRED.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE ONCE AGAIN SEE THE IDR WHICH SHOWS ONLY 16-42
 WATT FIXTURES. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE WHEN THE PLANS
 CLEARLY SHOW THE *Q* FIXTURE ALONE BEING 75W. PLEASE
 KNOW THAT *ALL* EXTERIOR LIGHTING IS REQUIRED BY CODE
 TO BE FIGURED INTO THE IDR FOR EXTERIOR CALCULATIONS
 AND ALLOWANCES.
 THE FIXTURES ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND ALSO INCLUDE OTHER
 EXTERIOR LIGHTS HOW THESE ARE NOT SHOWN.
  
 ** THIS IS ONLY TWO EXAMPLES. ONE FOR INTERIOR AND ONE
 FOR EXTERIOR AND THIS IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST. THESE
 EXAMPLES ARE GIVEN AS A BENEFIT ONLY AND ARE NO WAY ALL
 ITEMS ON THE IDR WHICH DO NOT COORDINATE WITH THE
 SUBMITTED PLANS.
 ** PLEASE SEE COMMENTS FROM OTHER TRADES AS THERE ARE
 OTHER BUILDING COMPONENTS WHICH DO NOT COORDINATE.
 PLEASE SEE SECTIONS NOTED ABOVE ALONG WITH 13-415.2,
 13-415.2.ABC.1.1, .1.1, AND .1.3. (ETC)
  
 ** AS THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS NOT YET COMPLETE ON PLANS
 THERE MAY VERY WELL BE ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ON THE
 FOLLOWING REVIEW.
  
 7) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2, .1.3 AND
 .1.4.
 PLEASE SUBMIT MORE INFORMATION ON PLANS FOR LIGHTING
 CONTROLS. THERE IS A NOTE ON E0.01 WHICH STATES ALL
 LIGHTING SHALL MEET CHAPTER 13, HOWEVER QUOTING THE
 CODE IN LIEU OF ACTUAL MINIMUM DESIGN IS NOT
 PERMITTED.
 PLEASE SEE AS NO SITE PARKING LOT LIGHTING WAS SHOWN ON
 PLANS COMPLIANCE WITH .1.4 AS NOTED ABOVE CAN NOT
 VERIFIED. ONCE PLANS ARE COMPLETE FOR ALL LIGHTING
 REVIEW OF ALL SYSTEMS ETC WILL BE REVIEWED.
 PLEASE SEE SOME EXAMPLES WILL BE GIVEN BELOW HOWEVER
 THESE ARE IN NO WAY AN EXHAUSTED LIST.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SEVERAL OUTSIDE OFFICES WHICH APPEAR TO SHOW
 A STANDARD LIGHT SWITCH. HOW DOES THIS DEVICE WORK AS
 AN OVER RIDE OR WITH THE SYSTEM AS PROPOSED?
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE SECTIONS OF CODES NOTED AS EACH FLOOR IS
 REQUIRED TO CONTAIN A SEPARATE SYSTEM IF LIGHTING
 CONTROL PANELS ARE TO BE INSTALLED.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLANS NOTE THAT ALL LIGHTING SHALL BE TURNED OFF AND
 CODE DOES REQUIRE THIS. PLEASE VERIFY LIGHTING CONTROLS
 IN STAIRS AND OTHER LOCATIONS WHICH DO NOT APPEAR TO
 SHOW ANY CONTROLS.
 PLEASE SEE LIFE SAFETY CODE 101, 7.8.1.2.2 AND FBC
 1016.1 FOR REQUIRED FAIL SAFE ON FOR EGRESS LIGHTING.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE KNOW THERE IS NOTHING IN THE CODE WHICH PERMITS
 NIGHT LIGHTS. THIS AHJ WILL PERMIT SOME NIGHT LIGHTS
 FOR SECURITY AS LONG AS LEVEL DOES NOT EXCEED 1 FT
 CANDLE AVG ON EGRESS PATHS.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE NO OUTSIDE LIGHTING AND CONTROLS SHOWN FOR
 OTHER FIXTURES. SOME FIXTURES ON BUILDING ARE NOTED AS
 ON PHOTO-SENSOR HOW NOT ALL. THERE IS A LIGHTING
 CONTACTOR DETAIL HOWEVER NO ALL LIGHTING LISTED.
  
 AS NOTED THIS IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST AND IS GIVEN AS
 A BENEFIT ONLY.
  
 8) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETED LOAD CALCULATIONS FOR
 PANELS AND SERVICE.
 NEC 220, 220.12, 220.14, 220.42, 220.44 ETC
 PLEASE SEE THAT ALL CONTINUOUS LOADS SHALL BE SHOWN AT
 125%. 215.3, 230.42
  
 9) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THAT THE LOCATION OF THE MAIN FOR
 THE BUILDING IS NOT ACCEPTABLE TO THIS AHJ. THE
 LOCATION OF THE MAIN IS NOT LOCATED AT THE NEAREST
 POINT OF ENTRANCE IN AN EMERGENCY. FIRE DEPARTMENT
 PERSONNEL MUST HAVE A QUICK AND READY ACCESS TO THE
 MAIN LOCATION WITHOUT A SUBSTANTIAL TRAVEL DISTANCE
 THROUGH A BUILDING WHICH MAY BE ON FIRE.
 PLEASE RELOCATED ACCESS, ADD ACCESS, ADD MAIN ETC. THIS
 MAY BE GONE OVER WITH THIS AHJ.
 230.70,71, 72, 76, 79 ETC
  
 10) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 110.26C2 AS THE DOOR SWING ON THE
 MAIN ELECTRICAL ROOM SHALL NOT SWING IN.
 THE DOOR IS REQUIRED TO SWING OUT AND IS REQUIRED TO
 CONTAIN PANIC HARDWARE ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW THE ROOM, EQUIPMENT; DOOR ETC WILL ALL
 DEPEND ON DESIGN TO COMPLY WITH NOTE #9 ABOVE. IN ANY
 CASE 1200AMP EQUIPMENT WILL BE REQUIRED TO CONTAIN
 DOOR(S) WITH OUT-SWING.
  
 11) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETED PHOTO-METRICS FOR
 EGRESS STAIRS UNDER NORMAL AND EMERGENCY CONDITIONS.
 PLEASE SE NFPA-101 7.8.1.3, 7.9.2.2
 FAC 61G15-33.004
  
 12) NOTE: PLANS CONTAIN A NOTE ON RISER FOR GF
 PROTECTION OF MAIN HOWEVER PLEASE BE SURE TO INCLUDE
 SPECIFIC INFORMATION ON THE MDP/MAIN.
 240.13, 230.95.
 PLEASE KNOW IF THERE ARE ANY REQUIRED LIFE SAFETY
 SYSTEMS, SELECTIVE COORDINATION PER 240.13.
  
 13) NOTE: PLEASE SEE RISER WHICH SHOWS 800AMP OVER
 CURRENT PROTECTION ON PANEL 1-HEQ WHICH IS A 400AMP
 PANEL. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE?
 110.9, 90.4, 240.4 ETC
  
 14) NOTE: PLEASE SEE RISER AND PANEL SCHEDULES AS ALL
 OF THESE PANELS ON THE SECONDARY SIDE OF THE
 TRANSFORMERS REQUIRE MAINS.
 THERE ARE SEVERAL CODE SECTIONS AND SOME EXAMPLES OF
 WHICH PANELS ARE GIVEN BELOW.
 1L1,
 1LEQ,
 1LLS. ETC
 PLEASE SEE 240.21, 240.4, 310.16, 408.36 ETC
 THIS IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED EXAMPLE.
  
 15) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THAT ALL CONDUCTORS ON THE
 SECONDARY SIDE OF TRANSFORMER SHALL TERMINATE IN OVER
 CURRENT PROTECTION AS NOTED ABOVE IN NOTE #14. THESE
 CONDUCTORS SHALL ALSO BE RATED FOR THAT OCP.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE CONDUCTORS GOING INTO *1L1* WHICH ARE
 SHOWN AS 500MCM. THESE CONDUCTORS PER 110.14, 110.3,
 AND 310.16 ARE ONLY RATED FOR 380AMPS.
 IN THIS PARTICULAR SCENARIO YOU MAY NOT GO TO THE NEXT
 SIZE UP WHEN THE OCP LISTED PER 240.6 DOES NOT
 COORDINATE WITH THE CONDUCTOR RATING.
 MUST MEET OR EXCEED OCP ON THE SECONDARY SIDE. (MIN
 600MCM)
  
 16) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETE NOTES ON PLANS PER
 13-413.1.ABC.2.1 AND .2.2.
 THE NOTES ON ELECTRICAL SHEET COVER PAGE DOES PARTIALLY
 LIST THIS HOWEVER NOT ALL.
 PLEASE KNOW THIS WAS CONFIRMED WITH DCA/FBC AS THE
 EXACT WORDING AS LISTED IN THE CODE WAS THE INTENT TO
 HAVE LISTED ON PLANS.
  
 17) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PANELS *1L1 AND 1L12* ON RISER
 APPEARS TO BE SHOWN AS A TWO SECTION PANEL HOWEVER PER
 THE PANEL SCHEDULE THESE ARE TWO SEPARATE PANELS AND
 EACH PANEL DOES NOT CONTAIN THE SAME PANEL RATING. ONE
 IS LISTED AS 400AMP AND THE OTHER AS 225AMP. PLEASE
 COORDINATE AND ADJUST.
 110.3,90.7 ETC
 FBC 106.1.2, 106.3.5.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND
 COORDINATION.
  
 18) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETE PLANS FOR NEW OR
 EXISTING SITE LIGHTS.
 PLANS MENTION THIS HOWEVER AT THIS TIME THESE CAN NOT
 BE CONFIRMED.
 PLEASE SEE NOTES ABOVE WITH RESPECT TO LIGHTS,
 CALCULATIONS ETC.
 FBC 106.3.5.1.2
  
 19) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SITE ELECTRICAL PLANS SPECIFICALLY
 CALL FOR A GROUND RING AND TO SEE DETAIL ON E6.05 YET
 E6.05 DOES NOT SHOW ANY GROUND RING AS PART OF THE
 GROUNDING ELECTRODE SYSTEM DETAIL.
 PLEASE VERIFY ??
 250.50
 FBC 106.1.2, 106.3.5.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND
 COORDINATION.
  
 20) NOTE: PLEASE VERIFY SERVER ROOM. IS THIS AN IT ROOM
 AS DEFINED IN NFPA-75, NFPA-70?
 PLEASE SEE 645.1 AND .4.
 PLANS SHOW RATED WALLS, FIRE DAMPERS, A/C , FM 200
 SYSTEM ETC HOWEVER NO SHUT OFF PER 645.10 WAS LOCATED
 ON PLANS.
 PLEASE KNOW THERE ARE SEVERAL UNANSWERED QUESTIONS WITH
 RESPECT TO THIS ROOM.
  
 21) NOTE: PLEASE SEE NFPA-70 620.23 FOR REQUIRED
 DEDICATED CIRCUITS IN MACHINE ROOM.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE THE LIGHTING CIRCUIT FEEDING THIS ROOM
 CURRENTLY ALSO FEEDS SEVERAL OTHER LIGHTING FIXTURES
 OUTSIDE OF THIS ROOM WHICH IS NOT PERMITTED BY CODE.
 PLEASE KNOW THIS IS NOT A NEW CODE. PLEASE ADJUST
 PLANS.
  
 22) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 620.24 WHICH REQUIRE DEDICATED
 CIRCUITS FOR PIT/HOIST-WAY LIGHTS AND RECEPTACLES.
 PLEASE SEE PLANS AS THE CIRCUIT WHICH FEEDS THE PIT GFI
 WHICH IS *1L1-30* ALSO FEEDS MECHANICAL ROOM
 RECEPTACLES, RECEPTION AREA ETC.
 PLEASE ADJUST; THIS IS NOT A NEW CODE.
  
 23) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE ELEVATOR MACHINE ROOM PER FBC
 3006.2 IS REQUIRED TO CONTAIN SEPARATE CONDITIONING.
 PLEASE SEE COMMENTS FROM MECHANICAL REVIEWER AS THIS
 WILL AFFECT ELECTRICAL PLANS AS NOTED.
 ** THIS IS BEING GIVEN FOR INFORMATION ONLY.
  
 24) NOTE: PLEASE SEE CONDUCTORS ON RISER FOR
 TRANSFORMER *1TN* WHICH SHOWS 200AMP OCP ON MDP ON 1/0
 CONDUCTORS WHICH ARE ONLY RATED FOR 150AMPS PER
 310.16.
 PLEASE CORRECT AND ADJUST.
 THIS IS NOT WHAT IS SHOWN ON MDP SCHEDULE. MDP SCHEDULE
 INDICATES 150AMP BREAKER AND NOT 200AMP.
 FBC 106.1.2, 106.3.5.1.2 FOR COORDINATION.
  
 25) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETE THE CERTIFICATION
 SHEETS ON THE SUBMITTED ENERGY CALCULATIONS.
 THE COVER SHEET WAS SIGNED, DATED AND SEALED HOWEVER
 THIS SHOULD BE ON THE CERTIFICATION SHEETS.
 PLEASE ALSO SEE OTHER INFORMATION REQUIRE ON THESE SAME
 SHEETS SUCH AS OWNER/AGENT SIGNATURE IS REQUIRED. FBC
 13-103.1.1.1, FAC 61G15-23.002
  
 26) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE TO STATE ALL MAXIMUM TIMES ON
 OVER RIDE DEVICES. PLEASE SEE THE LOCATIONS OF EACH
 OVER RIDE SHALL BE LOCATED SO THE OCCUPANT CAN VISUALLY
 SEE THE LIGHTING IN WHICH THEY ARE CONTROLLING. THERE
 ARE EXCEPTIONS ON THE CODE HOWEVER NO INFORMATION COULD
 BE LOCATED ON PLANS ON HOW *PILOTS/INDICATORS LIGHTS*
 WILL BE USED OR INSTALLED.
 PLEASE SEE 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2.
  
 27) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SYMBOL LEGEND MENTIONS THE USE OF
 WHAT APPEARS TO BE A SPRING WOUND TIMER FOR SOME
 LOCATIONS.
 PLEASE SEE FBC 11-4.27.4 WHICH DOES NOT PERMIT THE USE
 OF THESE DEVICES.
 THIS MAY ALSO BE LIMITED TO SOME LOCATIONS AS PERMITTED
 BY CODE.
  
 28) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT AND PROVIDE AN ENLARGED
 ELECTRICAL ROOM PLAN TO SCALE FOR THE MAIN ELECTRICAL
 ROOM.
 BASED ON THE EQUIPMENT SHOWN AND MINIMUM CLEARANCES
 REQUIRED IN 110.26 THERE IS CONCERN OVER THE SIZE OF
 THE ROOM AND EQUIPMENT AS SHOWN.
 PLEASE SEE MANUFACTURES MINIMUM CLEARANCE FOR
 TRANSFORMER, VENTILATION ETC.
 PLEASE SEE 110.26, 450.9, 450.13, 450.21 ETC.
  
 29) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SHEET E1.03 WHICH APPEARS TO USE A
 SQUARE BOX WITH A C INSIDE AS ONE OF THE SYMBOLS LOCATE
 AT DOOR. THIS SYMBOL ON E0.02 MENTIONS THIS IS A
 LIGHTING CONTACTOR. WHAT IS THIS?
 FBC 106.1.2, 106.3.5.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND
 COORDINATION.
  
 30) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SYMBOLS ON THE SHEET E1.03 AS
 THERE ARE DEVICES WHICH APPEAR TO PARTIAL FIRE
 DEVICES.
 FOR EXAMPLE:
 PLEASE SEE STAIR #2 WHICH SHOWS A PARTIAL FIRE DEVICE.
 THIS IS ONE EXAMPLE:
  
 31) NOTE: PLEASE INCLUDE MAXIMUM HEIGHT FOR ALL DEVICES
 PER ADA 11-4.27.
 PLEASE PLACE NOTE ON PLANS TO INCLUDE.
  
 32) NOTE: PLEASE CLARIFY THE *SPECIAL OUTLET* IN THE
 BREAK-ROOM KITCHEN AREA. 1L12, 8, 10,12.
 FBC 106.1.2, 106.3.5.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND
 COORDINATION.
  
 33) NOTE: PLEASE PLACE NOTES ON PLANS FOR THE FOLLOWING
 PER FBC SECTION 2704.1 WHICH REQUIRES BONDING OF METAL
 FRAMING MEMBERS.
 METAL FRAMING MEMBERS SHALL BE BONDED TO THE EQUIPMENT
 GROUNDING CONDUCTOR FOR THE CIRCUIT THAT MAY ENERGIZE
 THE FRAMING AND BE SIZED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
 NATIONAL ELECTRIC CODE, TABLE 250.122. FOR THE PURPOSE
 OF THIS SECTION, A GROUNDED METAL OUTLET BOX ATTACHED
 TO THE FRAMING SHALL BE PERMITTED.
  
 34) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW DUE TO THE EXTENT OF THE COMMENTS
 ABOVE, ONE ROLL OF PLANS ARE BEING RETAINED BY THIS
 OFFICE ALONG WITH ONE SET OF ENERGY CALCULATION
 SUBMITTED.
  
 ** THIS OFFICE EXPRESSES THAT IF THERE ARE ANY
 COMMENTS, QUESTIONS OR CLARIFICATION NEEDED TO PLEASE
 DO NOT HESITATE IN CONTACTING THIS OFFICE.
 PLEASE SEE BELOW FOR CONTACT INFORMATION.
  
 ** IMPORTANT**
 ONCE ALL REVIEWS ARE DONE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP FOR
 CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE ALL
 OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED SHEETS
 INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. DO NOT
 LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
 TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID ANY
 DELAYS.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPT.
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]

Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2009-01-07 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2009-01-07 Time 14:23 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2009-01-07 Time 14:23 Sent To  
Notes
2009-01-07 14:24:13REVISION DATED 12/9/08

Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 4 Status F Date 2008-12-04 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2008-12-04 Time 15:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2008-12-04 Time 15:19 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-05 10:45:12***DENIED***
  
 1) SEE BUILDING COMMENT #1 REGARDING DISCREPENCY WITH
 PLANS.
  
  
 MIKE WENNERGREN, ASST. FIRE MARSHAL
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 FIRE PREVENTION (561) 804-4756

Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2008-08-28 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2008-08-28 Time 10:03 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2008-08-28 Time 10:03 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-28 10:03:47STAMPED SHEETS E1.0.3 AND E2.0.3.

Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2008-07-08 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2008-07-08 Time 11:25 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2008-07-08 Time 11:25 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-08 11:30:03***APPROVED PROVISO***
  
 1) FIRE PLAN REVIEW IS OK BUT WILL REMAIN AS FAILED
 UNTIL THE ELECTRICAL REVIEW HAS PASSED. AT THAT TIME,
 ELECTRICAL SHEETS WILL BE STAMPED FOR FIRE ALARM WORK.
  
 2) IN ADDITION TO THE FIRE SPRINKLER AND FIRE ALARM
 SYSTEMS, SEPARATE SHOP DRAWINGS AND PERMIT REQUIRED FOR
 ACCESS CONTROL SYSTEM. WORK SHALL COMPLY WITH NFPA 101,
 2003 EDITION, SEC. 7.2.1.6.2.
  
  
 MIKE WENNERGREN, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 FIRE PREVENTION (561) 804-4756

Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-05-15 Cont ID  
Sent By mawillia Date 2008-05-15 Time 17:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mawillia Date 2008-05-15 Time 16:22 Sent To  
Notes
2008-05-15 17:17:09*****DENIED*****
  
  
 1.THE PROJECT SITE ADDRESS SHALL BE IN THE TITLE
 BLOCK OF EACH SUBMITTED PLAN SHEET.
  
 2.STRUCTURES UNDERGOING CONSTRUCTION, ALTERATION, OR
 DEMOLITION OPERATIONS SHALL COMPLY WITH NFPA 241.
  
 3.COMBUSTIBLE WASTE MATERIALS, DUST, AND DEBRIS SHALL
 BE REMOVED FROM THE SITE AT THE END OF EACH SHIFT OR
 MORE FREQUENTLY AS NECESSARY FOR SAFE OPERATION.
  
 4.NFPA 101, LIFE SAFETY CODE, 2003 EDITION SHALL BE
 REFERENCED.
  
 5.SPECIFY THE NEW WALL AND CEILING FINISH MATERIALS
 IN TERMS OF CLASS A, CLASS B, OR CLASS C.
  
 6.SHOW THE LOCDATION OF THE 2A10BC RATED FIRE
 EXTINGUISHERS ON THE LIFE SAFETY SHEETS.
  
 7.INCLUDE ON THE APPROPIATE MECHANICAL AND/OR FIRE
 ALARM SHEET THAT:DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS SHALL INITIATE
 A GENERAL FIRE ALARM.
  
 8.PROVIDE THE PRESCRIPTIVE STRENGHT FOR THE NEW
 HANDRAIL/GUARDRAILS TO BE INSTALLED.
  
 9.PLANS MENTION: 1) A FIRE PUMPAND2) A GENERATOR.
 PLEASE SUBMIT SPECIFICATIONS AND/OR CUT SHEETS FOR
 THESE DEVICES.
  
  
 TO EXPEDITE THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS, INCLUDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER INDICATING WHERE EACH ITEM WAS ADDRESSED
  
  
 CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 561-805-6722

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 6 Status N Date 2008-12-11 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-12-11 Time 10:19 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-12-11 Time 10:19 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-11 10:19:20TO "COMM" BD#17

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 5 Status N Date 2008-11-10 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-11-10 Time 09:02 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-11-10 Time 09:02 Sent To  
Notes
2008-11-10 09:02:32TO "COMM" BD#14

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 4 Status N Date 2008-08-14 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-08-14 Time 09:28 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-08-14 Time 09:28 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-14 09:35:15TO "COMM" BD#48

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2008-07-17 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-07-17 Time 14:45 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-07-17 Time 14:45 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-17 14:51:52TO "COMM" BD#50/PLANS ON RACK

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2008-06-04 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-06-04 Time 11:03 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-06-04 Time 11:03 Sent To  
Notes
2008-06-04 11:03:22TO "COMM" BD#43

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2008-05-15 Cont ID  
Sent By mawillia Date 2008-05-15 Time 16:22 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mawillia Date 2008-04-17 Time 11:10 Sent To  
Notes
2008-04-17 11:10:41TO "COMM" BD#54

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 6 Status N Date 2009-01-14 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2009-01-14 Time 19:56 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2009-01-14 Time 19:56 Sent To  
Notes
2009-01-14 19:56:27REVISIONS PASSED DURING PREVIOUS REVIEW CYCLE.

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2008-11-15 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2008-11-15 Time 17:06 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2008-11-15 Time 17:05 Sent To  
Notes
2008-11-15 17:06:27REVISED M1.01, M2.01

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2008-08-28 Cont ID  
Sent By tgordon Date 2008-08-28 Time 12:17 Rev Time 0.00
Received By tgordon Date 2008-08-26 Time 14:54 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2008-08-06 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2008-08-06 Time 16:23 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2008-08-05 Time 10:53 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-06 16:23:14REVIEW #: 3RD
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/ 2007 SUPPLEMENTS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
  
 THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS ARE NUMBERED TO CORRESPOND WITH
 PREVIOUS REVIEW COMMENTS AS WELL AS DESIGNER'S WRITTEN
 RESPONSES FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONTINUITY.
  
 COMMENTS 1 THROUGH 4: OK
  
 COMMENT #5: AS INDICATED IN THE WRITTEN RESPONSE FROM
 THE DESIGN TEAM, A NOTE HAS BEEN ADDED INDICATING HOW
 SMOKE DAMPERS ARE TO BE CONTROLLED. HOWEVER, THE TYPE
 AND LOCATION OF SMOKE DETECTORS SHOWN ON ELECTRICAL
 PLANS TO BE USED TO CONTROL THE DAMPERS DO NOT
 CORRESPOND WITH THE NOTE ON THE MECHANICAL PLANS. THE
 SMOKE DETECTORS AS SHOWN ALSO DO NOT MEET THE CRITERIA
 FOR CONTROLLING ALL SMOKE DAMPERS SHOWN ON THE PLANS AS
 REQUIRED. PLEASE SEE THE FOLLOWING CODE SECTION WITH
 OPTIONS LISTED:
  
 607.3.2.1 SMOKE DAMPER ACTUATION METHODS.
  
 THE SMOKE DAMPER SHALL CLOSE UPON ACTUATION OF A LISTED
 SMOKE DETECTOR OR DETECTORS INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH SECTION 607 OF THIS CODE AND SECTIONS 907.10 AND
 907.11 OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, BUILDING AND ONE
 OF THE FOLLOWING METHODS, AS APPLICABLE:
  
 1. WHERE A DAMPER IS INSTALLED WITHIN A DUCT, A SMOKE
 DETECTOR SHALL BE INSTALLED IN THE DUCT WITHIN 5 FEET
 (1524 MM) OF THE DAMPER WITH NO AIR OUTLETS OR INLETS
 BETWEEN THE DETECTOR AND THE DAMPER. THE DETECTOR SHALL
 BE LISTED FOR THE AIR VELOCITY, TEMPERATURE AND
 HUMIDITY ANTICIPATED AT THE POINT WHERE IT IS
 INSTALLED. OTHER THAN IN MECHANICAL SMOKE CONTROL
 SYSTEMS, DAMPERS SHALL BE CLOSED UPON FAN SHUTDOWN
 WHERE LOCAL SMOKE DETECTORS REQUIRE A MINIMUM VELOCITY
 TO OPERATE.
 2. WHERE A DAMPER IS INSTALLED ABOVE SMOKE BARRIER
 DOORS IN A SMOKE BARRIER, A SPOT-TYPE DETECTOR LISTED
 FOR RELEASING SERVICE SHALL BE INSTALLED ON EITHER SIDE
 OF THE SMOKE BARRIER DOOR OPENING.
 3. WHERE A DAMPER IS INSTALLED WITHIN AN UNDUCTED
 OPENING IN A WALL, A SPOT-TYPE DETECTOR LISTED FOR
 RELEASING SERVICE SHALL BE INSTALLED WITHIN 5 FEET
 (1524 MM) HORIZONTALLY OF THE DAMPER.
 4. WHERE A DAMPER IS INSTALLED IN A CORRIDOR WALL, THE
 DAMPER SHALL BE PERMITTED TO BE CONTROLLED BY A SMOKE
 DETECTION SYSTEM INSTALLED IN THE CORRIDOR.
 5. WHERE A TOTAL-COVERAGE SMOKE DETECTOR SYSTEM IS
 PROVIDED WITHIN AREAS SERVED BY AN HVAC SYSTEM, DAMPERS
 SHALL BE PERMITTED TO BE CONTROLLED BY THE SMOKE
 DETECTION SYSTEM.
  
 NOTE THAT SPOT-TYPE DETECTORS MAY NOT BE USED TO
 CONTROL DAMPERS WHICH ARE IN A DUCTED SYSTEM. THEY ARE
 ONLY FOR DAMPERS IN TRANSFER OPENINGS AS SHOWN IN
 OPTION #3 ABOVE. PLEASE PROVIDE A CONTROL METHOD WHICH
 IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE METHODS AS PRESCRIBED ABOVE.
 A SEQUENCE OF PERATIONS MAY BE HELPFUL ON THE PLANS THE
 DEMONSTRATE COMPLIANCE. PLEASE CORRECT AND RESUBMIT.
  
 COMMENTS 6 THROUGH 21: OK
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J. REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2008-06-30 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2008-06-30 Time 13:31 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2008-06-27 Time 11:29 Sent To  
Notes
2008-06-30 13:31:25REVIEW #: 2ND
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/ 2007 SUPPLEMENTS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
  
 THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS ARE NUMBERED TO CORRESPOND WITH
 PREVIOUS REVIEW COMMENTS AS WELL AS DESIGNER'S WRITTEN
 RESPONSES FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONTINUITY.
  
 1. THE REFERENCE STANDARD HAS BEEN CORRECTED. HOWEVER,
 SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION FOR USE OF THE IAQ PROCEDURE
 WAS NOT PROVIDED AS REQUESTED IN PREVIOUS REVIEW
 COMMENT #1. PROVIDE SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH ASHRAE 62.1-2004 SECTION 6.3.2 AND FBCB
 106.1.2.
  
 2. THE 40X16 SUPPLY DUCT FROM AHU 1-2 IS PENETRATING A
 FIRE RESISTANCE RATED WALL AT THE ELEVATOR EQUIPMENT
 ROOM #155 WITH NO PROTECTION. SHOW HOW THIS DUCT
 PENETRATION IS TO BE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM
 607.5.
  
 3 AND 4: OK
  
 5. SMOKE DAMPERS HAVE BEEN SHOWN IN REQUIRED LOCATIONS
 IN THE CORRIDOR. HOWEVER, THE DAMPER ACTUATION METHOD
 INDICATED IN KEY NOTE #1 DOES NOT MEET THE REQUIREMENTS
 OF FBCM 607.5.4.1. GIVEN THE HVAC DESIGN AND
 CONFIGURATION OF THE BUILDING, IT APPEARS THAT UNDER
 FBCM 607.5.4.1, OPTIONS 1, 4 OR 5 WOULD BE APPLICABLE.
 THE USE OF ONE DUCT SMOKE DETECTOR AT THE AHU DOES NOT
 MEET ANY OF THE OPTIONS LISTED UNDER THIS SECTION
 BECAUSE IT IS NOT WITHIN 5 FEET OF THE DAMPERS AND IT
 DOES NOT QUALIFY AS TOTAL-COVERAGE SMOKE DETECTION.
 ADDITIONALLY, THE 10X10 AIR TRANSFER OPENING FSD SHALL
 BE ACTUATED BY OPTION 3 OR 4. THE OTHER FIRE/SMOKE
 DAMPERS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH THE CORRIDOR SHALL BE
 ACTUATED BY METHOD 1 OR 3 AS APPROPRIATE FOR THE
 APPLICATION. EXAMPLE:
 THE FIRE/SMOKE DAMPERS IN THE WALL WEST OF
  
 6. OK EXCEPT, PLEASE VERIFY THAT ONE 30X12 TRANSFER AIR
 OPENING IS SUFFICIENT TO RETURN ALMOST 4000 CFM FROM
 THE MAIN LOBBY, RECEPTION AND FORMAL CONFERENCE AREAS
 IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 601.4 AND FBCB 106.1.2.
  
 7 THROUGH 10: OK
  
 11. SMOKE DAMPERS ARE SHOWN ON PLANS AS REQUIRED.
 PLEASE SEE COMMENT #5 REGARDING DAMPER ACTUATION
 REQUIREMENTS.
  
 12. NOTHING IS SHOWN ON THE AHU SCHEDULE REGARDING
 AUXILIARY DRAIN PROTECTION. PLEASE SHOW COMPLIANCE WITH
 FBCM 307.2.3.
  
 13. OK. SEE COMMENT #5 FOR SMOKE DAMPER ACTUATION
 REQUIREMENTS.
  
 14 THROUGH 19: OK
  
 20. MECHANICAL PORTIONS OF THE ENERGY CALCULATIONS ARE
 OK.
  
 21. OK
  
 NOTE: THE PRINTING OF MECHANICAL FLOOR PLANS, M1.01 AND
 M2.01, ARE OF POOR QUALITY. MANY OF THE SMALL NUMBERS
 RELATED TO DUCT SIZES AND AIR TERMINAL DESIGNATIONS
 ILLEGIBLE. CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SHALL BE OF
 SUFFICIENT CLARITY TO INDICATE THE LOCATION, NATURE AND
 EXTENT OF THE WORK PROPOSED AND SHOW IN DETAIL THAT IT
 WILL CONFORM TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS CODE IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCB 106.1.1. WHEN RE-SUBMITTING,
 PLEASE ENSURE THAT ALL RELEVANT INFORMATION ON FLOOR
 PLANS IS CLEAR AND LEGIBLE.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J. REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]

Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-05-06 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2008-05-06 Time 10:47 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2008-05-01 Time 11:33 Sent To  
Notes
2008-05-06 10:47:37REVIEW #: 1ST
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/ 2007 SUPPLEMENTS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
  
 1. PG M0.01: DESIGN CRITERIA SCHEDULE CALLS FOR
 VENTILATION TO BE DESIGNED PER ASHRAE 62.1-2007. THIS
 IS NOT A REFERENCED STANDARD UNDER THE 2004 FBC. THE
 CORRECT STANDARD IS ASHRAE 62.1-2004 IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 403.4 AND FBCM CHAPTER 15. VENTILATION SYSTEMS
 SHALL BE DESIGNED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS STANDARD OR
 FBCM SECTION 403. IF ASHRAE 62.1-2004 IS USED, DECLARE
 ON PLANS WHETHER THE VENTILATION RATE (VR) OR INDOOR
 AIR QUALITY (IAQ) PROCEDURE IS USED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 SECTION 6.1.
  
 ALSO, PROVIDE SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION. IF USING THE VR
 PROCEDURE IS USED, PROVIDE OUTDOOR AIR CALCULATIONS
 WITH SPACE-BY-SPACE OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATIONS, OCCUPANT
 LOADS, OUTDOOR AIR REQUIRED AND OUTDOOR AIR PROVIDED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 6.2. IF THE IAQ PROCEDURE IS
 USED, PROVIDE DOCUMENTATION AS REQUIRED BY SECTION
 6.3.2.
  
 2. PG M1.01 AND M2.01: THE LOCATIONS OF RATED WALL
 ASSEMBLIES FROM LIFE SAFETY PAGES A2.1.1AND A2.1.2 WERE
 USED FOR REVIEW OF MECHANICAL FLOOR PLANS TO CHECK FOR
 PROPERLY PROTECTED DUCT PENETRATIONS OF WALL
 ASSEMBLIES. IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT ARCHITECTURAL FLOOR
 PLANS AND LIFE SAFETY PLANS ARE NOT COORDINATED WITH
 REGARD TO THE LOCATIONS OF RATED WALL ASSEMBLIES.
 REVIEW OF DUCT PENETRATION WILL BE BASED ON THE LIFE
 SAFETY PLANS. PLEASE MAKE SURE ANY CHANGES RELATED TO
 WALL ASSEMBLIES ARE COORDINATED BETWEEN ARCHITECTURAL,
 LIFE SAFETY AND MECHANICAL PLANS.
  
 3. PG M1.01: FLOOR PLAN SHOWS A 20X12 UNPROTECTED DUCT
 PENETRATION OF THE 1-HOUR RATED WALL BETWEEN TRAINING
 AREA 145 AND BREAKROOM 143. SHOW HOW THIS PENETRATION
 IS TO BE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.5.
  
 4. PG M1.01: THERE IS A FIRE DAMPER SHOWN IN THE 8 INCH
 ROUND DUCT PENETRATING THE WALL BETWEEN W.H. CLOSET 117
 AND MEN?S LOCKER/SHOWER 114. THIS WALL IS NOT SHOWN TO
 HAVE A FIRE RESISTANCE RATING ON THE LIFE SAFETY PLAN
 OR THE ARCHITECTURAL FLOOR PLAN. FIRE DAMPERS ARE TO BE
 INSTALLED IN RATED ASSEMBLIES IN ACCORDANCE WITH THEIR
 LISTING AND MANUFACTURER?S INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS
 PER FBCM 607.2. PLEASE COORDINATE FLOOR PLANS WITH
 MECHANICAL PLANS, SHOWING PROTECTED PENETRATIONS ONLY
 AT RATED ASSEMBLIES.
  
 5. PG M1.01: LIFE SAFETY PLAN SHOWS CORRIDOR 144 TO BE
 1-HOUR FIRE RESISTANCE RATED. THREE OF THE FIVE DUCT
 PENETRATIONS IN THIS CORRIDOR ARE REQUIRED TO BE
 PROTECTED WITH SMOKE DAMPERS IN ADDITION TO THE FIRE
 DAMPERS ALREADY SHOWN ON THE PLANS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 607.5.4 AND FBCB 715.3.3. THE OTHER TWO
 PENETRATIONS (12 INCH ROUND DUCT FEEDING SERVER ROOM
 147) ARE EXEMPT FROM THE SMOKE DAMPER REQUIREMENT IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.5.4(3). ALSO, SHOW HOW THESE
 SMOKE DAMPERS ARE TO BE ACTUATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 607.5.4.1.
  
 6.PG M1.01 AND M2.01: MECHANICAL FLOOR PLAN INDICATES
 THAT THIS DESIGN IS USING A PLENUM CEILING WITH OPEN
 END DUCTS BACK TO AHU-1-1 AND AHU-2-1. THERE ARE SOME
 AREAS OF THE FLOOR PLAN WHERE RATED WALL ASSEMBLIES,
 WHICH ARE CONSTRUCTED FROM FLOOR TO DECK OR FLOOR TO
 ROOF, WILL IMPEDE THE FLOW OF RETURN AIR BACK TO THE
 OPEN END DUCTS. THESE AREAS WOULD INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING
 EXAMPLES:
 MAIN LOBBY 101
 RECEPTION AREA 102
 FORMAL CONFERENCE 103
 CORRIDOR 144
 TRAINING AREA 145
 LOBBY 201
 CONFERENCE 202
 HALLWAY 203
 CORRIDOR 263
  
 PLEASE CHECK THE ENTIRE FLOOR PLAN TO ENSURE THAT THESE
 AND POSSIBLE OTHER AREAS ARE PROVIDED WITH BALANCED
 RETURN AIR FLOW IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 601.4. PLEASE
 ENSURE THAT ANY ADDED DUCT PENETRATIONS OR AIR TRANSFER
 OPENINGS ARE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.5
 AND FBCB 710.7 WHERE APPLICABLE.
  
 7. PG M1.01 AND M2.01: PLAN SHOWS DUCTS FOR EF-1, EF-2
 AND GRV-1 PENETRATING THE FLOOR/CEILING ASSEMBLY
 BETWEEN 1ST AND 2ND FLOORS. SHOW THESE PENETRATIONS TO
 BE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.6.
  
 8. PG M2.01: FLOOR PLAN SHOWS A 62X16 UNPROTECTED DUCT
 PENETRATION AT THE FIRE-RESISTANCE RATED WALL BETWEEN
 HALLWAY 203 AND FAX/PRINTING 204. SHOW HOW THIS
 PENETRATION IS TO BE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM
 607.5.
  
 9. PG M2.01: FLOOR PLAN SHOWS A 10 INCH ROUND
 UNPROTECTED DUCT PENETRATION AT THE FIRE-RESISTANCE
 RATED WALL BETWEEN FAX/PRINTING 204 AND CONFERENCE 202.
 SHOW HOW THIS PENETRATION IS TO BE PROTECTED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.5. ALSO, THERE IS A FIRE
 DAMPER SHOWN IN THIS SAME DUCT LINE IN THE 7 INCH ROUND
 DUCT BUT IT IS NOT LOCATED AT THE WALL ASSEMBLY. PLEASE
 CORRECT BY COORDINATING MECHANICAL WITH ARCHITECTURAL
 AND LIFE SAFETY PLANS, ENSURING FIRE DAMPERS ARE
 INSTALLED ONLY AT RATED WALL OR FLOOR/CEILING
 ASSEMBLIES IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.2.
  
 10. PG M2.01: FLOOR PLAN SHOWS A FIRE DAMPER IN THE 10
 INCH ROUND DUCT FEEDING VAV -1 IN HALLWAY 203. THERE IS
 NO WALL ASSEMBLY WHERE THE FIRE DAMPER IS LOCATED ON
 PLANS. PLEASE CORRECT BY COORDINATING MECHANICAL WITH
 ARCHITECTURAL AND LIFE SAFETY PLANS, ENSURING FIRE
 DAMPERS ARE INSTALLED ONLY AT RATED WALL OR
 FLOOR/CEILING ASSEMBLIES IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM
 607.2.
  
 11. PG M2.01: LIFE SAFETY PLAN SHOWS CORRIDOR 263 TO BE
 1-HOUR FIRE RESISTANCE RATED. THE FOUR DUCT
 PENETRATIONS IN THIS CORRIDOR ARE REQUIRED TO BE
 PROTECTED WITH SMOKE DAMPERS IN ADDITION TO THE FIRE
 DAMPERS ALREADY SHOWN ON THE PLANS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 607.5.4 AND FBCB 715.3.3. ALSO, SHOW HOW THESE
 SMOKE DAMPERS ARE TO BE ACTUATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 607.5.4.1.
  
 12. SHOW MEANS AND LOCATION OF AUXILIARY OR SECONDARY
 DRAIN PROTECTION ON ALL APPLIANCES WITH COOLING COILS
 IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 307.2.3.
  
 13. NO MEANS OF VENTILATION OR AIR CONDITIONING IS
 SHOWN ON PLANS FOR THE ELEVATOR MACHINE ROOM. SHOW HOW
 THIS ROOM IS TO BE VENTILATED OR CONDITIONED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCB 3006.2
  
 14. NO ROOF MECHANICAL PLAN WAS PROVIDED. SHOW LAYOUT
 OF ROOF WITH LOCATIONS OF EFS AND GRV. SHOW COMPLIANCE
 WITH FBCM 401.5 AND 401.6. ALSO, SHOW HOW ROOFTOP
 EXHAUST FANS ARE TO BE ACCESSED FOR SERVICE. WHERE
 EQUIPMENT AND APPLIANCES REQUIRING ACCESS ARE INSTALLED
 ON ROOFS OR ELEVATED STRUCTURES AT A HEIGHT EXCEEDING
 16 FEET, SUCH ACCESS SHALL BE PROVIDED BY A PERMANENT
 APPROVED MEANS OF ACCESS, THE EXTENT OF WHICH SHALL BE
 FROM GRADE OR FLOOR LEVEL TO THE EQUIPMENT AND
 APPLIANCES? LEVEL SERVICE SPACE IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM
 306.5.
  
 15. PG M5.01: THE RATIO OF THE FAN SYSTEM POWER TO THE
 SUPPLY FAN AIRFLOW RATE (MAIN FAN) OF EACH HVAC SYSTEM
 AT DESIGN CONDITIONS SHALL NOT EXCEED THE ALLOWABLE FAN
 SYSTEM POWER SHOWN IN TABLE 410.1.ABC.1.1.1. IF OPTION
 2 OR 3 OF THIS SECTION IS CLAIMED, PLEASE PROVIDE
 SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION AND CALCULATIONS. EXAMPLE:
 AHU-1-2 SHOWS 5,100 CFM WITH A 10 HP MOTOR. THIS GIVES
 A RATIO OF 1.96 HP PER 1,000 CFM, WHICH IS IN EXCESS OF
 THAT ALLOWED BY THE TABLE. PLEASE CHECK ALL FANS.
  
 16. PG M6.01: AHU CONDENSATE DRAIN DETAIL, THIS DETAIL
 DOES NOT CORRESPOND WITH THE MANUFACTURER?S
 INSTRUCTIONS. CONDENSATE DRAINS SHALL BE TRAPPED AS
 REQUIRED BY THE EQUIPMENT OR APPLIANCE MANUFACTURER IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 307.2.4. A COPY OF THE CONDENSATE
 TRAP DETAIL FROM THE MANUFACTURER IS ATTACHED TO THESE
 COMMENTS. PROVIDE A DETAIL WHICH CORRESPONDS WITH THE
 MANUFACTURER?S REQUIREMENTS OR DEFER TO THE
 MANUFACTURER?S INSTRUCTIONS.
  
 17. PG M6.02: ROOF MOUNTED FAN DETAIL, NOTE CALLS FOR
 DETAIL ON ARCHITECTURAL AND STRUCTURAL PLANS. NO SUCH
 DETAIL COULD BE FOUND TO SHOW HOW CURBS ARE TO BE
 ATTACHED TO STRUCTURE. PLEASE PROVIDE MISSING
 INFORMATION, SHOWING HOW CURB IS TO BE ATTACHED TO
 WITHSTAND ANTICIPATED WIND LOADS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBCM 301.13. ALSO, PROVIDE ADDITIONAL DETAIL SHOWING
 THE NUMBER AND SIZE OF FASTENERS TO BE USED TO ATTACH
 FANS AND GRV TO CURBS TO WITHSTAND ANTICIPATED WIND
 PRESSURES. IN ADDITION, SHOW GRV AND FANS THEMSELVES
 ARE DESIGNED TO RESIST ANTICIPATED WIND PRESSURES IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 301.13.
  
 18. PG M7.01: PROVIDE OPTIMUM START CONTROLS AS
 REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCB 13-407.1.ABC.2.4.2.
  
 19. PG M7.03 WATER TEMPERATURE RESET CONTROLS ARE
 REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCB 13-411.1.ABC.1.3.
  
 20. ENERGY CALCULATIONS: A METHOD A COMPLIANCE FORM HAS
 BEEN SUBMITTED. HOWEVER, THIS IS NOT AN ACCEPTABLE
 METHOD FOR THIS PROJECT. NONRESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS THAT
 ARE PERMITTED PRIOR TO DESIGN COMPLETION OR WHICH WILL
 BE FINISHED IN SECTIONS AT A TIME AFTER CONSTRUCTION OF
 THE SHELL SHALL COMPLY WITH EITHER METHOD B OR C OF
 SUBCHAPTER 13-4 OF THE CODE PRIOR TO GRANTING OF A
 PERMIT TO BUILD IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCB 13-101.1.6. THE
 ENERGY CALCULATIONS CAN NOT BE REVIEWED AT THIS TIME
 DUE TO THE INCORRECT METHOD BEING SUBMITTED. PLEASE
 SUBMIT A METHOD B OR C COMPLIANCE FORM FOR REVIEW.
  
 21. HANSON PROFESSIONAL SERVICES SHALL PROVIDE A VALID
 ENGINEERING BUSINESS CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION
 NUMBER ON EACH SHEET OF MECHANICAL PLANS IN THE TITLE
 BLOCK IN ACCORDANCE WITH FAC RULE 16G15-23.002.
  
 NOTE: PLEASE RESPOND TO EACH COMMENT IN WRITING, WITH
 EXPLANATION AS TO HOW EACH COMMENT WAS ADDRESSED AND
 WHERE THE RELEVANT INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND. ALSO
 PLEASE RETURN ONE SET OF OLD/VOIDED PLANS FOR
 REFERENCE.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J. REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 6 Status P Date 2009-01-22 Cont ID  
Sent By lwagner Date 2009-01-22 Time 10:11 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lwagner Date 2009-01-22 Time 09:12 Sent To  
Notes
2009-01-22 09:36:23REVISION OK- SHEET P-2.01
  
 NOTE: 3RD COPY OF P-2.01 NOT FOUND. REMOVED P-2.01 FROM
 2ND SET FOR CSD SET

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2008-12-03 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2008-12-03 Time 15:47 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2008-12-03 Time 15:47 Sent To  
Notes
2008-12-03 15:48:29REVISION APPROVED -- SHT P1.01

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2008-08-04 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2008-08-04 Time 09:18 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2008-08-04 Time 09:18 Sent To  
Notes
2008-08-04 09:28:44PASSED/PROVISO
 SHT A7.1.1 ROOM 246 WALLS WITH IN 2 FEET OF THE WATER
 CLOSET SHALL COMPLY WITH SECTION 1210.2. PAINTED WALLS
 DO NOT COMPLY WITH THIS REQUIREMENT.

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2008-07-30 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2008-07-30 Time 14:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2008-07-30 Time 14:20 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-30 14:23:53DENIED
 REFERENCE: FBC-2004 PLUMBING
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11
 FBC-2004 BUILDING
  
 ****FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW:
 ******FROM PREVIOUS REVIEWS:
  
 1. OK
 2. OK
 3. OK
 4. OK
 5. OK
 6. OK
 7. OK
 8. OK
 9. OK
 10. OK
 11. OK
 12. OK
  
 13. SHT A7.1.1 ROOM FINISH SCHEDULE FOR ROOM 246. SHOW
 COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1210.1 REQUIREMENT FOR FLOORS
 TO HAVE A SMOOTH, HARD, NONABSORBENT SURFACE. CARPET
 DOES NOT COMPLY WITH THESE REQUIREMENT. PLEASE SHOW
 COMPLIANCE.
 ****RESPONSE NOTED, BUT NOT INDICATED ON THE FINISH
 SCHEDULE.
 ******RESPONSE NOTED, BUT SHT A7.1.1 HAS NOT BEEN
 SUBMITTED.
  
 14. OK
 15. OK
 16. OK
 17. OK
 18. OK
 19. OK
 20. OK
  
 ***********NEW COMMENT***********
  
 1B. SUBMIT A MINIMUM 2 SETS OF CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS
 REQUIRED. LOOSE SHEETS NOT APPROVED. COMPLETE PLANS NOT
 SUBMITTED. ONE SET OF OLD (REV 1) PLANS SUBMITTED AND 3
 SETS OF LOOSE SHEETS SUBMITTED. FULL SETS OF PLANS NOT
 SUBMITTED. SECTION 106.1.
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER,
 WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING
 THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
 PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. REMOVE
 ALL VOID SHEETS FROM ALL PLANS AND PLACE
 ONE SET OF THEM LOOSELY ON TOP OF THE
 COLLATED PLANS TO BE REVIEWED.
 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 805-6731
 E-MAIL [email protected]
  

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2008-07-07 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2008-07-07 Time 07:55 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2008-07-03 Time 15:53 Sent To  
Notes
2008-07-07 08:06:12DENIED
 REFERENCE: FBC-2004 PLUMBING
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11
 FBC-2004 BUILDING
  
 ****FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW:
  
 1. OK
 2. OK
 3. OK
 4. OK
 5. OK
 6. OK
 7. OK
  
 8. SUBMIT DETAILS AND ELEVATIONS FOR THE TOILET ROOM
 AND THE BATHROOM SHOWING COMPLIANCE WITH SECTIONS
 11-4.16, 11-4.19, 11-4.21, 11-4.22 & 11-4.23 WITH ALL
 SUBSECTIONS AND FIGURES. INDICATE THE SIZE OF THE
 SHOWER. SEE SECTION 11-4.21.2 & FIG 35(A). ****RESPONSE
 NOTED, BUT SHOW COMPLIANCE FOR THE FOLLOWING:
 __FOR W/C'S:
 A. 11-4.16.5 FLUSH CONTROLS (TO THE WIDE SIDE) __FOR
 LAVS"
 A. 11-4.19.2 CLEARANCE (29" MIN. NOT MAX.)
 __FOR SHOWERS:
 A. 11-4.21.3 SEAT (HEIGHT)
 B. 11-4.21.5 CONTROLS
 C. 11-4.21.6 SHOWER UNIT
 D. 11-4.21.7 CURBS (1/2" MAX)
  
 9. OK
 10. OK
 11. OK
 12. OK
  
 13. SHT A7.1.1 ROOM FINISH SCHEDULE FOR ROOM 246. SHOW
 COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1210.1 REQUIREMENT FOR FLOORS
 TO HAVE A SMOOTH, HARD, NONABSORBENT SURFACE. CARPET
 DOES NOT COMPLY WITH THESE REQUIREMENT. PLEASE SHOW
 COMPLIANCE.
 ****RESPONSE NOTED, BUT NOT INDICATED ON THE FINISH
 SCHEDULE.
  
 14. OK
 15. OK
 16. OK
  
 17. SUBMIT AN ISOMETRIC WATER RISER DIAGRAM FOR THE
 BREAK ROOM SINK, DRINKING FOUNTAINS, DISHWASHER ETC
 SHOWING ALL PIPE SIZES, VALVES AND , WHERE REQUIRED,
 WATER HAMMER ARRESTORS PER 604.9, (ANY ICE MAKERS,
 DISHWASHERS ETC), INSTALLED NEAR THE FIXTURES IN AN
 "EFFECTIVE RANGE" NOT IN THE CEILING. SECTIONS
 106.3.5.1.3, 601.1, 604 - TABLE 604.5 & PDI-WH 201.
 ****RESPONSE NOTED, BUT WATER HAMMER ARRESTOR IS
 REQUIRED AT THE DISHWASHER BUT NOT SHOWN.
  
 18. OK
 19. OK
 20. OK
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER,
 WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING
 THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
 PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. REMOVE
 ALL VOID SHEETS FROM ALL PLANS AND PLACE
 ONE SET OF THEM LOOSELY ON TOP OF THE
 COLLATED PLANS TO BE REVIEWED.
 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 805-6731
 E-MAIL [email protected]

Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-05-03 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2008-05-03 Time 09:52 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2008-05-02 Time 18:52 Sent To  
Notes
2008-05-03 11:12:38DENIED
 REFERENCE: FBC-2004 PLUMBING
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11
 FBC-2004 BUILDING
  
 1. SUBMIT EXISTING FLOOR PLANS FOR 1ST & 2ND FLOOR AS
 WELL AS A DEMO PLAN SHOWING THE LOCATION ALL PLUMBING
 PIPES TO DEMO'D. SECTION 106.1.2.
  
 2. A PLUMBING DEMO PERMIT IS REQUIRED. (SEE PERMIT #
 08010573 WHICH INDICATES A COMPLETE INTERIOR
 DEMOLITION). SECTIONS 106.1.2 & 704.5.
  
 3. SHTS A2.2.1 & A2.2.2 DEMO NOTES #4 & #5 WERE NOT
 FOUND ON THE FLOOR PLAN. PLEASE CORRELATE. SECTION
 106.1.1.
  
 4. PER TABLE 403.1 3 DRINKING FOUNTAINS ARE REQUIRED.
 HI/LOW DRINKING ARE CONSIDERED 2 FIXTURES IF THEY HAVE
 SEPARATE TRAPS & SUPPLIES. IF THE HI/LOW DRINKING
 FOUNTAINS HAVE ONLY ONE TRAP AND ONE WATER SUPPLY THEN
 ONLY 2 FIXTURES ARE SHOWN. PLEASE INDICATE ON THE RISER
 DIAGRAMS THE TRAP AND SUPPLY REQUIREMENTS. SECTIONS
 106.3.5.1.3, 606.2(1) & 1002.1.
  
 5. SHTS A 2.2.1 & A2.2.2 ROOMS 148, 269 & 271 INDICATES
 JANITOR ROOMS. PLEASE INDICATE IF THERE ARE OR WERE
 MOP/SERVICE SINKS IN THESE ROOMS. ALSO INDICATE IF THE
 SINKS WERE DELETED. PLEASE CLARIFY. SECTION 106.1.2.
  
 6. SHTS A2.2.1 & A2.2.2 INDICATES THE TOILET ROOM
 DETAILS CAN BE FOUND ON SHT A4.1.1 DETAILS 1, 2 & 3.
 THE DETAILS WERE NOT FOUND ON SHT A4.1.1. PLEASE
 CLARIFY/CORRELATE. SECTION 106.1.1.
  
 7. SHTS A2.2.1 & A2.2.3 DO NOT SHOW THE BREAK ROOM SINK
 AS SHOWN ON SHT P1.01. PLEASE SHOW THE SINK ON ALL
 FLOOR PLANS AS THERE APPEARS TO BE A CONFLICT WITH THE
 REQUIRED CLEAR FLOOR SPACE AND THE FURNITURE. SECTIONS
 106.1.1 & 11-4.16.2.
  
 8. SUBMIT DETAILS AND ELEVATIONS FOR THE TOILET ROOM
 AND THE BATHROOM SHOWING COMPLIANCE WITH SECTIONS
 11-4.16, 11-4.19, 11-4.21, 11-4.22 & 11-4.23 WITH ALL
 SUBSECTIONS AND FIGURES. INDICATE THE SIZE OF THE
 SHOWER. SEE SECTION 11-4.21.2 & FIG 35(A).
  
 9. SUBMIT A DETAIL AND AN ELEVATION FOR THE BREAK ROOM
 SINK SHOWING COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 11-4.24 WITH ALL
 SUBSECTIONS AND FIGURES. FORWARD APPROACH REQUIRED AND
 CABINET DOORS ARE NOT APPROVED IN THE CLEAR FLOOR
 SPACE.
  
 10. SUBMIT A DETAIL AND ELEVATION FOR THE ACCESSIBLE
 DRINKING FOUNTAINS SHOWING COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION
 11-4.15 WITH ALL SUBSECTIONS & FIGURES AS WELL AS
 SECTION 11-4.1.3(10)(A) PROVISIONS FOR THOSE WHO HAVE
 DIFFICULTY BENDING OR STOOPING.
  
 11. SHT A4.1.2 TYPICAL TOILET ACCESSORIES INDICATE THE
 GRAB BARS AT 3'1". PER SECTION 11-4.16.4 & FIG 11-29
 GRAB BARS SHALL BE INSTALLED 33"-36" ABOVE THE FLOOR.
 PLEASE CORRECT DETAIL.
  
 12. SHT A7.1.1 ROOM FINISH SCHEDULE FOR ROOM 112. SHOW
 COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1210.2 REQUIREMENT FOR WALLS
 WITHIN 2' OF THE W/C SHALL HAVE A SMOOTH, HARD,
 NONABSORBENT SURFACE TO A HEIGHT OF 4' ABOVE THE FLOOR.
 PAINTED GWB DOES NOT COMPLY THE THE REQUIRED FOR A
 "HARD" SURFACE. PLEASE SHOW COMPLIANCE.
  
 13. SHT A7.1.1 ROOM FINISH SCHEDULE FOR ROOM 246. SHOW
 COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1210.1 REQUIREMENT FOR FLOORS
 TO HAVE A SMOOTH, HARD, NONABSORBENT SURFACE. CARPET
 DOES NOT COMPLY WITH THESE REQUIREMENT. PLEASE SHOW
 COMPLIANCE.
  
 14. SHT A7.1.1 ALL EXISTING TOILET ROOMS INDICATED AS
 EXISTING SHALL COMPLY WITH SECTIONS 1210.1 & 1210.2 AS
 WELL.
  
 15. SHT P1.01 PLUMBING DEMO NOTES 1, 2 & 5 INDICATE THE
 DEMO'D PIPING TO BE CAPPED AND SEALED BELOW THE FLOOR.
 PER SECTION 704.5 IN THE REMOVAL OF ANY DRAINAGE
 SYSTEM, DEAD ENDS SHALL BE PROHIBITED. ALL DEMO'D
 PIPING SHALL BE CAPPED OFF WITHIN 2FT OF THE BRANCH
 LINE OR BUILDING DRAIN LINE. PLEASE INDICATE ON PLANS.
  
 16. SUBMIT AN ISOMETRIC SANITARY RISER DIAGRAM FOR THE
 BREAK ROOM SINK, AND DRINKING FOUNTAINS SHOWING ALL
 PIPE SIZES, TRAPS, VENTS ETC. SECTIONS 106.3.5.1.3 &
 701.1 AS WELL AS TABLES 710.1(1) & 710.1(2), 901.2.1 &
 1002.1.
  
 17. SUBMIT AN ISOMETRIC WATER RISER DIAGRAM FOR THE
 BREAK ROOM SINK, DRINKING FOUNTAINS, DISHWASHER ETC
 SHOWING ALL PIPE SIZES, VALVES AND , WHERE REQUIRED,
 WATER HAMMER ARRESTORS PER 604.9, (ANY ICE MAKERS,
 DISHWASHERS ETC), INSTALLED NEAR THE FIXTURES IN AN
 "EFFECTIVE RANGE" NOT IN THE CEILING. SECTIONS
 106.3.5.1.3, 601.1, 604 - TABLE 604.5 & PDI-WH 201.
  
 18. SHT P3.01 TRAP PRIMERS ARE INDICATED TO THE SHOWER
 DRAINS ON THE SANITARY RISER DIAGRAM BUT ARE NOT SHOWN
 ON THE WATER RISER DIAGRAM. PLEASE CLARIFY & CORRELATE.
 SECTIONS 106.1.1 & 1002.4.
  
 19. SHT P3.01 THE SANITARY RISER DIAGRAM IS IDENTIFIED
 ASTHE DOMESTIC WATER RISER DIAGRAM AND THE WATER
 RISER DIAGRAM IS IDENTIFIED AS THE SANITARY WASTE &
 VENT RISER DIAGRAM. PLEASE CORRELATE. SECTION 106.1.1.
  
 20. SHT P4.01 SUBMIT CALCULATIONS FOR THE EXPANSION
 TANK FOR ELECTRIC WATER HEATER - EWH-1. ON-LINE
 CALCULATIONS CONFLICT WITH EXPANSION TANK SIZE
 SUBMITTED ON THE PLANS. (SEE ATTACHED SHEET). SECTION
 604.9.
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER,
 WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING
 THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
 PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. REMOVE
 ALL VOID SHEETS FROM ALL PLANS AND PLACE
 ONE SET OF THEM LOOSELY ON TOP OF THE
 COLLATED PLANS TO BE REVIEWED.
 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 805-6731
 E-MAIL [email protected]

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2008-11-13 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2008-11-13 Time 10:42 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2008-11-13 Time 10:42 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2008-08-25 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2008-08-25 Time 15:42 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2008-08-25 Time 15:42 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2008-07-24 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2008-07-24 Time 23:28 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2008-07-24 Time 23:28 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2008-06-17 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2008-06-17 Time 14:31 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2008-06-17 Time 14:31 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-04-29 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2008-04-29 Time 09:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2008-04-29 Time 09:10 Sent To  
Notes
2008-04-29 09:14:06***FAILED***
  
 1) THE PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK EXCEEDS 50% OF THE VALUE
 OF THE STRUCTURE.THEREFORE, PURSUANT TO SECTION
 94-441(C) OF THE CITY'S ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT
 REGULATIONS, THE SUBJECT PROPERTY SHALL BE BROUGHT INTO
 COMPLIANCE WITH ARTICLE XIV OF THE ZLDRS.A LANDSCAPE
 PLAN SHALL BE PROVIDED SHOWING THE EXISTING
 LANDSCAPING, AS WELL AS ANY NEW LANDSCAPING THAT IS
 REQUIRED TO BRING THE SITE INTO COMPLIANCE.
  
 QUESTIONS/COMMENTS, CONTACT JOHN ROACH, SENIOR PLANNER,
 AT (561) 822-1435.


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved