Plan Review Details - Permit 07080965
Plan Review Stops For Permit 07080965
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2008-01-18 Cont ID  
Sent By shill Date 2008-01-18 Time 14:30 Rev Time 0.00
Received By shill Date 2008-01-18 Time 14:30 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2008-01-17 Cont ID  
Sent By shill Date 2008-01-17 Time 09:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By shill Date 2008-01-17 Time 09:20 Sent To  
Notes
2008-01-17 09:48:41****CORRECTIONS****
  
 SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
 561-805-6724 [email protected]
  
 FBCFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
 FBC EBFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
 CODE
 FBC RFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL
 FBC* CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
  
 FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 FSFLORIDA STATUTE
  
  
 1.SEE PREVIOUS LIST, SOILS REPORT REQUIRED.PROVIDE
 TWO ORIGINAL SOILS REPORTS, WITH ORIGINAL SIGNATURE,
 SEALED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FS471.
  

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-11-20 Cont ID  
Sent By shill Date 2007-11-20 Time 11:14 Rev Time 0.00
Received By shill Date 2007-11-20 Time 11:14 Sent To  
Notes
2007-11-20 11:18:08****CORRECTIONS****
  
 SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
 561-805-6724 [email protected]
  
 FBCFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
 FBC EBFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
 CODE
 FBC RFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL
 FBC* CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
 FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 FSFLORIDA STATUTE
  
 FROM PREVIOUS LIST:
  
 1.)ADDRESSED.
  
 2.)SEE ZONING COMMENTS REGARDING CONVEYANCE OF CITY
 PROPERTY.THIS IS NOT REFLECTED ON THE SITE PLAN. DOES
 THE SITE PLAN SHOW ALL CURRENT PROPERTY LINES? WILL
 UNITY OF TITLE BE REQUIRED?
  
 3.)DECLARE THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PARKINGS SPACES
 INCLUDING NEW SPACES, TOTAL NUMBER OF ACCESSIBLE
 SPACES, FBC11-4.1.295)(A).
  
 4.)PROVIDE A COMPLETE SITE PLAN SHOWING BUILDING
 LOCATION AND ALL ACCESSIBLE PARKING SPACES,
 FBC11-4.6.2.
  
 5.)ADDRESSED.
  
 6.)DECLARE GOVERNING CODE.INCLUDE 2007 AMENDMENTS
 IN THE GOVERNING CODE.
  
 6.)PROVIDE PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR THE MODIFIED
 BITUMEN.PRODUCT APPROVALS ARE TO BE REVIEWED BY
 DESIGNER OF RECORD FBC*106
  
 7.)PROVIDE A SOILS INVESTIGATION REPORT FBC1802.2.
  
 8.)IT APPEARS THAT THE ELEVATED DECK WILL BE
 APPROXIMATELY 7' ABOVE GRADE.GUARD(RAIL)S REQUIRED,
 FBC1012.1.THE PLANTERS SHOWN ARE NOT CONTINUOUS AND
 DO NOT MEET THE HEIGHT REQUIREMENT.
  
 NEW COMMENTS:
  
 9.)IT IS UNCLEAR HOW THE COMMENTS HAVE BEEN
 ADDRESSED.PLEASE INCLUDE A RESPONSE LETTER IN THE
 NEXT SUBMITTAL.
  
 10.)SEE ATTACHED FS553.80(2)(B).A 4X PLAN REVIEW
 FEE WILL BE CHARGED ON THE NEXT SUBMITTAL IF THE
 COMMENTS ARE NOT PROPERLY ADDRESSED.

Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-10-01 Cont ID  
Sent By shill Date 2007-10-01 Time 14:57 Rev Time 0.00
Received By shill Date 2007-10-01 Time 14:57 Sent To ENG
Notes
2007-10-01 15:08:59****CORRECTIONS****
  
 SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
 561-805-6724 [email protected]
  
 FBCFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
 FBC EBFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
 CODE
 FBC RFLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL FBC*
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
  
 FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 FSFLORIDA STATUTE
  
 1.)SEE ZONING COMMENTS REGARDING ACCESSIBLE PARKING.
  
 2.)SEE ZONING COMMENTS REGARDING CONVEYANCE OF CITY
 PROPERTY.THIS IS NOT REFLECTED ON THE SITE PLAN.
 DOES THE SITE PLAN SHOW ALL CURRENT PROPERTY LINES?
 WILL UNITY OF TITLE BE REQUIRED?
  
 3.)DECLARE THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PARKINGS SPACES
 INCLUDING NEW SPACES, TOTAL NUMBER OF ACCESSIBLE
 SPACES, FBC11-4.1.295)(A).
  
 4.)PROVIDE A COMPLETE SITE PLAN SHOWING BUILDING
 LOCATION AND ALL ACCESSIBLE PARKING SPACES,
 FBC11-4.6.2.
  
 5.)DECLARE WIND DESIGN CRITERIA, FBC1603.1.4.
  
 6.)DECLARE GOVERNING CODE.INCLUDE 2007 AMENDMENTS
 IN THE GOVERNING CODE.
  
 6.)PROVIDE PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR THE MODIFIED
 BITUMEN.PRODUCT APPROVALS ARE TO BE REVIEWED BY
 DESIGNER OF RECORD FBC*106
  
 7.)PROVIDE A SOILS INVESTIGATION REPORT FBC1802.2.
  
 8.)IT APPEARS THAT THE ELEVATED DECK WILL BE
 APPROXIMATELY 7' ABOVE GRADE.GUARD(RAIL)S REQUIRED,
 FBC1012.1.THE PLANTERS SHOWN ARE NOT CONTINUOUS AND
 DO NOT MEET THE HEIGHT REQUIREMENT.
  

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2008-01-23 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-01-23 Time 14:30 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-01-23 Time 14:30 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2008-01-11 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2008-01-11 Time 16:17 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2008-01-11 Time 16:17 Sent To  
Notes
2008-01-11 16:17:48*** DENIED REVIEW ***
  
 1) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT ELECTRICAL PLANS SHOWING MINIMUM
 CODE COMPLIANCE FOR ANY EGRESS, EXITS AND EXIT
 DISCHARGE FROM STRUCTURE.
 LS 101 2003 7.8 AND 7.9
  
 2) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THAT ANY NEW AREAS, CIRCUITS,
 ELECTRICAL ETC WHICH IS GOING TO BE PART OF THIS
 STRUCTURE IS TO BE SUBMITTED AT THIS TIME.
 FBC 106.3.5.1.2, 106.1.2, NEC 210,220,230,225,408, 240,
 310.16 ETC.
 PLEASE CLARIFY SCOPE OF WORK.
  
 ** PLEASE BE SURE TO ADDRESS COMMENTS. IF THERE ARE ANY
 QUESTIONS, ANY COMMENTS NOT TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR OR
 NOT UNDERSTOOD IN ANYWAY PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE IN
 CONTACTING THIS REVIEWER.
  
  
  
 * ** IMPORTANT**
 ONCE ALL REVIEWS ARE DONE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP FOR
 CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE ALL
 OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED SHEETS
 INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. DO NOT
 LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
 PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
 SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
 TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
 PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
 THIS WILL HELP IN THE REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID ANY
 DELAYS.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]

Review Stop ENG ENGINEERING CSD
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2008-01-15 Cont ID  
Sent By rchokshi Date 2008-01-15 Time 13:37 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rchokshi Date 2008-01-15 Time 11:52 Sent To  
Notes
2008-01-15 13:37:12PASSED
  
 REFERENCE: E-MAIL DATED 1/15/08,FROM PAUL BURI,

Review Stop ENG ENGINEERING CSD
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-11-19 Cont ID  
Sent By rchokshi Date 2007-11-19 Time 09:40 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rchokshi Date 2007-11-19 Time 09:24 Sent To  
Notes
2007-11-19 09:39:56***FAILED**** PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING:
  
  
 1. PLEASE PROVIDE A COPY OF NOTICE OF INTENT (NOI).
 PLEASE APPLY AT FDEP, NPDES STORMWATER SECTION FOR
 NOI.
 YOU CAN GET NOI INFO FROM
 WWW.DEP.STATE.FL.US/WATER/STORMWATER/NPDES/
 NOTICE OF INTENT DEP FORM 62-621.300(4)(B),
 EFFECTIVE MAY 1, 2003
 OUR RESPONSE TO YOUR LETTER OF 10/31/07 :AS SOON AS
 WE GET A COPY OF NOI, WE WILL REVIEW AGAIN.
  
 2.AFTER EX-FILTRATION TRENCH, DRY DETNSION, WET
 DETENSION ETC., WHERE STORM WATER GOES EITHER CITY
 STORM WATER SYSTEM OR OTHER SYSTEM??PLEASE SHOW ON
 DRAWINGS DETAIL OF THE CONTROL STRUCTURESWITH
 ELEVATIONS, NOTCHES, BLEEDING ELEVATION, ETC.
  
 PLEASE RESPOND EACH ITEM IN DETAIL TO EXPEDITE YOUR
 PERMITTING PROCESS
  
 RASIK CHOKSHI805-6723

Review Stop ENG ENGINEERING CSD
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-10-02 Cont ID  
Sent By rchokshi Date 2007-10-02 Time 11:45 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rchokshi Date 2007-10-02 Time 11:30 Sent To  
Notes
2007-10-02 11:45:04***FAILED**** PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING:
  
  
 1. PLEASE PROVIDE A COPY OF NOTICE OF INTENT (NOI).
 PLEASE APPLY AT FDEP, NPDES STORMWATER SECTION FOR
 NOI.
 YOU CAN GET NOI INFO FROM
 WWW.DEP.STATE.FL.US/WATER/STORMWATER/NPDES/
 NOTICE OF INTENT DEP FORM 62-621.300(4)(B),
 EFFECTIVE MAY 1, 2003
 2. PLEASE SHOW ON DRAWING ALL CITY STANDARDS NOTES FOR
 SIDEWALK, DRIVEWAY, APPROACH, PARKINGS, HANDICAP
 PARKINGS, DUMPSTER ENCLOSURE, YOU CAN GET A C D FROM
 1000, 45 STREET FOR ALL THESE CITY STANDARDS NOTES.
 PHONE# 494-1040
 3. PLEASE SHOW ON DRAWINGSDUMPSTER & ITS ENCLOSURE
 DETAILS PER CITY OF WPB, &LOCATION ON DWG, LOCATION
 MUST BE ACCESSIBLE FOR PICKUP TRUCK.
 4. PLEASE SHOW ON CALCULATTION THAT YOU HAVE CONSIDERED
 FLOOD ZONE AREA, & 5,10, 25, 100 YEAR FLOOD CRITERIA
 TO DETERMINE THE FIRST FLOOR ELEVATION, PARING LOT
 ELEVATION, CROWN OF THE ROAD ELEVATION, SIDEWALK ETC.
 5. PLEASE SHOW ON DRAINAGE DRAWINGTHE SITE AREA,
 GREEN, LAKE,PARKING AREA, IMPERVIOUS,PERVIOUS AREAYOU
 ARE DEVELOPING FOR THIS PROJECT . PLEASEMAKE SURE
 THESE AREAS SHOWN ON DRAINAGE DRAWINGS MUST MATCH WITH
 AND USED IN STORM WATER QUALITY CALCULATIONS.
 6. PLEASE SHOW ALL STORM WATER PIPES AROUND YOUR SITE
 SO, WE CANSEE THE LAYOUT OF STORM WATER PIPES FROM
 ALL OTHER STORM WATER PIPES. PLEASE SHOW DETAIL OF THE
 CONTROL STRUCTURESWITH ELEVATIONS, NOTCHES, BLEEDING
 ELEVATION, ETC ON DRAWINGS, CALCULATION FOR
 EXFILTRATION TRENCHES, PLEASE SHOW DRY DETENTION/WET
 DETENTION AREAS IN STORM WATER CALS.
 7. ALSO PLEASE SHOW ALL CATCH BASINS NEAREST,AROUND
 YOUR SITE FOR STORM WATER DRAIN.
 8. PLEASE PROVIDE A COPY OF SFWMD PERMIT,, &STORM
 WATER QUALITY CALCULATIONS. STORM WATER CALS MUST BE
 APPROVED FROM 100045TH STREET ENGINEERING SERVICES.
 9. PLEASE SHOW ON DRAWINGS THE POLLUTION PREVENTION
 DETAILS,CLOTHES USED FOR SILT ETC., PLANS SHOWING SILT
 FENCE AROUND THE SITE & CATCH BASINS.HEIGHT OF FENCE
 SHOULD BE HIGH ENOUGH PER FDEP TO STOP DUST &
 PARTICLES.
 10. WATER & SEWER PLANS MUST BE APPROVED FROM 45TH
 STREET (MANNY G.), UTILITY DEPT BEFORE WE APPROVED.
  
 PLEASE RESPOND EACH ITEM IN DETAIL TO EXPEDITE YOUR
 PERMITTING PROCESS
  
 RASIK CHOKSHI805-6723

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 8 Status N Date 2009-04-10 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2009-04-10 Time 13:47 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2009-04-10 Time 13:47 Sent To L
Notes
2009-04-10 13:47:54TO "Z" BOX/REV--(FOR LANDSCAPING)

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 7 Status N Date 2008-01-18 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2008-01-18 Time 12:19 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2008-01-18 Time 12:19 Sent To B
Notes
2008-01-18 12:19:59TO "Z" BOX/SUBMITTAL

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 6 Status N Date 2007-12-20 Cont ID  
Sent By mmiller Date 2007-12-20 Time 17:44 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mmiller Date 2007-12-20 Time 17:44 Sent To ENG
Notes
2008-01-04 15:42:301/4/08----ROUTED TO "COMM' BD#9--PER "RBROWN"
2007-12-20 17:44:19ROUTED TO ENGINEERING MMILLER

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 5 Status N Date 2007-12-19 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-12-19 Time 11:15 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-12-19 Time 11:15 Sent To Z
Notes
2007-12-19 11:16:12TO "Z" BOX/RESUB

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 4 Status N Date 2007-11-14 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-11-14 Time 08:58 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-11-14 Time 08:57 Sent To ENG
Notes
2007-11-14 08:58:20TO "ENG" BOX/RESUB

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2007-11-06 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-11-06 Time 10:14 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-11-06 Time 10:14 Sent To Z
Notes
2007-11-06 10:15:04TO "Z" BOX/RESUB

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2007-10-01 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-10-01 Time 12:49 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-10-01 Time 12:49 Sent To B
Notes
2007-10-01 12:50:12TO "SHILL" DESK/PER "RBROWN"

Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-09-04 Time 11:07 Sent To  
Notes
2007-09-04 11:07:50TO "Z" BOX

Review Stop L LANDSCAPING
Rev No 1 Status P Date 2009-04-13 Cont ID  
Sent By rkussner Date 2009-04-13 Time 13:53 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rkussner Date 2009-04-13 Time 10:59 Sent To Z
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 5 Status N Date 2009-04-13 Cont ID  
Sent By eschneid Date 2009-04-13 Time 14:13 Rev Time 0.25
Received By eschneid Date 2009-04-13 Time 14:13 Sent To  
Notes
2009-04-13 14:14:03LANDSCAPE PLAN REVISIONS.

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2008-01-23 Cont ID  
Sent By eschneid Date 2008-01-23 Time 10:24 Rev Time 0.00
Received By eschneid Date 2008-01-23 Time 10:23 Sent To  
Notes
2008-01-23 10:25:431) APPROVED WITH THE REDLINE OF THE PARKING STALL
 DETAIL.
  
 2) A SEPARATE IRRIGATION PERMIT IS REQUIRED.

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2007-12-20 Cont ID  
Sent By eschneid Date 2007-12-20 Time 14:48 Rev Time 0.00
Received By eschneid Date 2007-12-20 Time 14:48 Sent To I
Notes
2007-12-20 14:51:26FAILED
  
 1) THE LANDSCAPE AND CIVIL PLANS DO NOT MATCH -
 SPECIFICALLY THE PLANTER BOXES ON THE SIDE OF THE DECK
 ARE NOT THE SAME.THE MOST RECENT (12/7/07) APPROVED
 LANDSCAPE PLAN SHALL BE USED.
  
 2) REVISE THE PARKING DETAIL TO SHOW 12 INCHES BETWEEN
 THE DIVIDER STRIPES.I HAVE REDLINED ONE SET OF PLANS
 AS AN EXAMPLE.
  
 CONTACT ERIC SCHNEIDER @ (561) 822-1435.

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-11-13 Cont ID  
Sent By eschneid Date 2007-11-13 Time 14:31 Rev Time 0.00
Received By eschneid Date 2007-11-12 Time 15:05 Sent To I
Notes
2007-11-12 15:16:43FAILED
  
 1) PROVIDE VERIFICATION THAT BRAMAN HAS SATISFIED THE
 CONDITIONS OF RESOLUTION NO. 299-07 AND THAT THE CITY
 HAS CONVEYED THE PROPERTY TO BRAMAN (REPEAT COMMENT).
  
 A. PROVIDE A COPY OF THE RECORDED DISCLAIMER FOR THE
 ABANDONED PORTION OF THE ROW.
 B. PROVIDE A COPY OF THE RECORDED DRAINAGE EASEMENT. C.
 PROVIDE A COPY OF THE RECORDED UTILITY EASEMENT. D.
 PROVIDE A COPY OF THE RECORDED UNITY OF TITLE.
  
 2) THE SUBMITTED PLANS DO NOT MATCH THE PLANS APPROVED
 AS PART OF RESOLUTION NO. 300-07 (REPEAT COMMENT). NOTE
 THAT KILDAY AND ASSOCIATES SUBMITTED A MINOR AMENDMENT
 TO THE DSI (LANDSCAPE PLAN INCLUDED WITH THE PERMIT),
 BUT THESE PLANS DO NOT MATCH THE PLANS SUBMITTED BY
 SIMMONS AND WHITE AS PART OF THE PERMIT. THE PERMIT
 SIMMONS AND WHITE PLANS DO NOT MATCH THE KILDAY
 LANDSCAPE PLAN.
  
 3) THE IRRIGATION SYSTEM FOR THE NEW LANDSCAPE SHALL BE
 SUBMITTED WITH THIS PERMIT OR ON A SEPARATE PERMIT.
 THIS PERMIT WILL NOT BE APPROVED UNTIL THE IRRIGATION
 SYSTEM IS SUBMITTED.
  
 4) KILDAY AND ASSOCIATES HAS STATED THAT THE WESTERN
 ENTRY DRIVE FROM OKEECHOBEE BOULEVARD IS GOING TO BE
 WIDENED TO 30 FEET.THE AFFECTS THE EASTERN PORTION OF
 THE SUBMITTED ENGINEERING PLAN AND SHALL BE CORRECTLY
 SHOWN.
  
 CONTACT ERIC SCHNEIDER @ (561) 822-1435.

Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-10-01 Cont ID  
Sent By eschneid Date 2007-10-01 Time 12:34 Rev Time 0.00
Received By eschneid Date 2007-10-01 Time 12:34 Sent To I
Notes
2007-10-01 12:39:43FAILED
  
 1) PROVIDE VERIFICATION THAT BRAMAN HAS SATISFIED THE
 CONDITIONS OF RESOLUTION NO. 299-07 AND THAT THE CITY
 HAS CONVEYED THE PROPERTY TO BRAMAN.
  
 2) THE SUBMITTED PLANS DO NOT MATCH THE PLANS APPROVED
 AS PART OF RESOLUTION NO. 300-07.
  
 3) THE PARKING DETAIL ON SHEET 4 OF 4 DOES NOT MATCH
 THE CITY DETAIL.
 A. LOCATION OF ADA SYMBOL 2 FEET FROM BEGINNING OF
 SPACE.
 B. SPACE BETWEEN ADA STRIPE AND NORMAL SPACE STRIPE IS
 INCORRECT.
 C. THE DOUBLE STRIPES SHALL FORM A BOX AT THE END.
  
 CONTACT ERIC SCHNEIDER @ (561) 822-1435.


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved