Plan Review Notes
Plan Review Notes For Project Z22080023
Project Number Z22080023
Review Stop L
Sequence Number 2
Notes
Date Text
2022-12-13 16:02:33FROM: RAY CARANCI, SENIOR LANDSCAPE PLANNER
 561-822-1462
 PROJECT: 2000 S DIXIE CAREFREE Z22080023
 DECEMBER 13, 2022
 I HAVE REVIEWED THE ABOVE REFERENCED PETITION, AND
 PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS:
  
  
 1. ADDRESS THE FOLLOWING ON TREE DISPOSITION PLAN FOR
 THE PROJECT:
 ??? SATISFIED. IDENTIFY ALL TREES AND PALMS.
 ??? SATISFIED. REMOVE TREES AND PALMS FROM THE LIST FOR
 309 BARCELONA.
 ??? SATISFIED. CORRECT THE PLAN TO REFLECT THE TREE AND
 PALM INVENTORY FROM THE PREVIOUS PETITION FOR THE TREES
 AND PALMS THAT EXISTED AS RECORDED.
 ??? SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING COLUMNS ON ONE
 DISPOSITION CHART FOR THE SUBJECT SITE: ID NUMBER,
 SPECIES, CANOPY DIAMETER, CATEGORY, CONDITION, SQUARE
 FOOTAGE MITIGATION DUE, DISPOSITION, AND PROVIDE THE
 INFORMATION FOR EACH TREE IN EACH COLUMN.
 ??? SATISFIED. FOLLOWING THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE
 CURRENT CODE SECTION 94-448, PROVIDE THE INDIVIDUAL AND
 TOTAL CANOPY MITIGATION DUE FOR ANY PROPOSED REMOVALS.
 TREES PROPOSED TO BE REMOVED WITH A CANOPY DIAMETER OF
 20 FEET OR MORE SHOULD HAVE THE MITIGATION SQUARE
 FOOTAGE CALCULATED BASED ON THE ACTUAL DIAMETER. TREES
 LESS THAN 20 FEET CANOPY DIAMETER AND PALMS SHOULD SHOW
 THE CATEGORY MITIGATION DUE.
 ??? SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE CANOPY MITIGATION DUE TOTAL
 AT THE BOTTOM OF THE CHART FOR ALL REMOVALS.
 ??? SATISFIED. PROVIDE ONE CHART FOR THE CANOPY CREDITS
 BY SPECIES AND CATEGORY PROVIDED BASED ON THE PROPOSED
 PLANT LIST FOR THE SITE AND THE ADJACENT RIGHT OF WAY.
  
 2. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SECTION 94-448 (D)(3) REQUIRES
 NATIVE TREES AND PALMS IN GOOD CONDITION TO BE
 PRESERVED ON SITE OR RELOCATED. ANSI A 300 (PART 5)
 STANDARDS SPECIFY EXAMPLES OF SUITABILITY RATINGS OF
 GOOD, MODERATE, OR POOR FOR RELOCATION. PROVIDE AN
 ARBORISTS REPORT RATING THE CONDITION AND RELOCATION
 POTENTIAL FOR THE NATIVE TREES AND PALMS.
 ARBORIST REPORT WAS NOT SUBMITTED, APPLICANT STATED IT
 WILL BE SUBMITTED LATER.
  
 3. ONGOING. COMMENT FROM 9/30/20: SUBMIT A LANDSCAPE
 PERMIT PLAN FOR 309 BARCELONA MEETING THE MINIMUM CODE
 REQUIREMENTS FOR RESIDENTIAL LANDSCAPING AND MITIGATING
 FOR TREES REMOVED.
 A TREE ALTERATION PERMIT APPLICATION WAS SUBMITTED FOR
 THE ADDITIONAL TREES REMOVED, AND THE PERMIT WAS ISSUED
 WITH CONDITIONS. MITIGATION IS DUE FOR ALL THE TREES
 REMOVED AND MUST BE ADDRESSED WITH REPLACEMENT OF TREES
 ON SITE OR PAYMENT IN LIEU. THE MINIMUM LANDSCAPE
 REQUIREMENTS MUST BE MET ON SITE WITH A LANDSCAPE
 PERMIT PLAN TO BE SUBMITTED. NO MITIGATION HAS BEEN
 PROVIDED TO DATE FOR ANY TREES REMOVED FROM THE SITE.
  
 THIS IS THE FIRST REVIEW OF THE LANDSCAPE PLAN FOR 309
 BARCELONA. PER SECTION 94-448, ALL TREE REPLACEMENT
 MUST BE ON THE SUBJECT SITE TO BE COUNTED TOWARD
 MITIGATION DUE. THE 2 LIVE OAK TREES PROPOSED IN THE
 RIGHT OF WAY CANNOT BE COUNTED UNLESS THEY ARE WITHIN
 THE PROPERTY LINE, AS THIS PROPERTY IS SEPARATE FROM
 THE CPD.
  
 THE TREE ALTERATION PERMIT TP19-1785 THAT REPLACED
 PERMIT TP 17-1618 EXPIRED ON APRIL 30, 2020.THE
 LANDSCAPE PLAN SHEET LP-4 AND TREE DISPOSITION PLAN
 SHEET TD-2 MUST BE SUBMITTED UNDER LANDSCAPE PERMIT
 18030706 IN ORDER FOR THIS COMMENT TO BE SATISFIED.
  
 THE LANDSCAPE PLAN SHEET LP-5 NEEDS BE SUBMITTED UNDER
 PERMIT 18030706.
  
 9/7/22: OFFSITE LANDSCAPING CANNOT BE COUNTED TOWARD
 THE REQUIREMENTS ON SITE. REMOVE CHARTS AND DATA FOR
 309 BARCELONA AND SUBMIT UNDER THE LANDSCAPE PERMIT
 18030706 FOLLOWING THE MITIGATION DUE FROM TREE
 ALTERATION PERMIT TP 19-1785. LIVE OAK TREES IN THE
 RIGHT OF WAY ADJACENT TO THIS ADDRESS MAY NOT BE
 REMOVED WITHOUT SEPARATE PERMIT FROM THE CITY.
  
 4. SATISFIED. CORRECT THE DATA TABLE TO SHOW THE
 REQUIRED OPEN SPACE AREA AS 40% OF THE SITE AND
 CALCULATE THE REQUIRED TREES, FLOWERING TREES AND
 SHRUBS FROM THAT FIGURE.
  
 5. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHADE TREES ARE PREFERRED FOR
 STREET TREES TO MEET THE INTENT OF PROVIDING SHADE FOR
 PEDESTRIANS ON THE SIDEWALK. THIS IS MENTIONED TO
 COMPENSATE FOR THE WAIVER TO PROVIDE LESS REQUIRED
 LANDSCAPING. COCONUT PALMS ARE NOT APPROPRIATE AND
 SHOULD BE REPLACED WITH SHADE TREES.
 CLUSIA ROSEA SHAPE TENDS TO BE VERY WIDE, SO WILL BE
 DIFFICULT TO MANAGE PROVIDING CLEARANCE FOR VEHICLES
 ABOVE 13???6??? AT THE STREET EDGE. STAFF SUGGESTS A
 MORE MANAGEABLE SPECIES SUCH AS LIVE OAK OR GREEN
 BUTTONWOOD AT A LARGER SIZE THAN THE USUAL 20 FOOT
 HEIGHT REQUIREMENT TO IMPROVE THE STREETSCAPE. THE
 PARALLEL PARKING SPACES ALONG FLAMINGO SHOULD HAVE
 ADDITIONAL BULB OUT ADDED SO THERE IS NOT SUCH A LONG
 GAP IN THE STREET TREE PLACEMENT.
  
  
 6. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW STRUCTURAL SOIL OR SOIL
 CELLS BENEATH THE PAVED AREAS ADJACENT TO TREES TO
 PROVIDE ROOT AREA FOR THE TREES ALONG THE STREETS TO
 ASSURE THEY ARE SUSTAINABLE.
 PROVIDE A SEPARATE PLAN SHOWING THE LOCATIONS OF THE
 STRUCTURAL SOIL, THE NOTE PROVIDED IS NOT SPECIFIC
 ENOUGH.
  
 7. SATISFIED. PROVIDE AN OPEN SPACE DIAGRAM TO
 DEMONSTRATE THE AREAS PROVIDED AS OPEN SPACE AND
 LANDSCAPE AREAS ON SITE WITHIN THE PROPERTY LINES TO
 PROVIDE REFERENCE FOR THE WAIVER REQUESTS.
  
  
 8. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. PROVIDE MEASUREMENTS AND
 CALCULATIONS FOR THE BUFFER TREES REQUIRED FOR ALL
 BUFFER LENGTHS PER SECTION 94-443 B. AND INDICATE HOW
 THIS WILL BE AFFECTED THROUGH THE WAIVER REQUESTS.
 INDICATE THE WIDTH OF ALL LANDSCAPE BUFFERS PROVIDED ON
 THE LANDSCAPE PLAN.
 PROVIDE A LIST FOR EACH BUFFER AS TO WHAT TREES ARE
 BEING COUNTED TOWARD THE REQUIREMENTS.
  
 9. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. PROVIDE LOCATIONS OF LIGHTING
 ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN TO AVOID CONFLICTS WITH
 LANDSCAPING.
 LIGHTING LOCATIONS SHOWN ALONG THE EAST BUFFER DISPLACE
 BUFFER TREES. ADJUST THE LOCATIONS OF THE LIGHTING TO
 MAINTAIN THE 30 FOOT REQUIRED SPACING FOR THE TREES.
 SABAL PALMS CAN BE ADJUSTED TO AVOID CONFLICT.
  
  
 10. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW LOCATIONS OF ROOT
 BARRIERS TO PROTECT INFRASTRUCTURE AND TREES FROM
 CONFLICTS. THIS INCLUDES WATER, SEWER, DRAINAGE,
 SIDEWALKS AND CURBS, AND ANY FIELD STRUCTURES THAT
 COULD BE IMPACTED BY TREE ROOTS.
 CHANGE ROOT BARRIER DETAIL TO HARD PLASTIC TYPE SIMILAR
 TO DEEPROOT AND REMOVE REFERENCE TO BIO BARRIER.
  
  
 11. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW LOCATIONS OF ALL GROUND
 MOUNTED EQUIPMENT INCLUDING FPL TRANSFORMERS, A/C
 UNITS, ETC., AND PROVIDE SCREENING FOR ALL GROUND
 MOUNTED EQUIPMENT AND UTILITIES.
 LOCATIONS TO BE PROVIDED OR AREAS INDICATED ON THE PLAN
 TO ACCOMMODATE REQUIRED EQUIPMENT. GIVEN THE REQUEST
 FOR WAIVERS FOR LANDSCAPE AREA AND JUSTIFICATION
 PROVIDED, THESE AREAS NEED TO BE PLANNED FOR, AS SPACE
 IS LIMITED AND CANNOT BE CHANGED AFTER APPROVAL OF
 WAIVERS.
 12/13/22: ALL EQUIPMENT, GREASE TRAPS, FIRE HYDRANTS,
 AND UNDERGROUND WATER, SEWER AND DRAINAGE LINES MUST BE
 SHOWN ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN. THERE ARE MULTIPLE AREAS
 WHERE THE UTILITIES NEED TO BE ADJUSTED TO AVOID
 CONFLICT WITH THE PROPOSED TREES.
  
 12. ONGOING. THE RIGHT OF WAY ON S DIXIE HWY IS FDOT
 RIGHT OF WAY AND IS SUBJECT TO REVIEW AND PERMITTING BY
 FDOT. PROVIDE PRELIMINARY REVIEW OF ANY STREETSCAPE
 PROPOSED WITHIN THE FDOT RIGHT OF WAY.
  
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 12/13/22:
 13. ALL PLANTS MUST HAVE THE BOTANICAL NAME PROVIDED ON
 THE PLANT LIST.
  
 14. THE SEAGRAPE TREES IN THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER ALONG
 THE RESIDENTIAL LOTS FOR THE NORTH PARCEL MUST BE SHOWN
 INDIVIDUALLY ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN TO SHOW THAT THE
 SPACING REQUIREMENT IS MET. THEY CANNOT BE SHOWN AS A
 HEDGE, AS HEDGES ARE LIMITED TO 10 FEET IN HEIGHT, AND
 THIS IS NOT MEETING THE BUFFER REQUIREMENTS.
  
 15. THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER AND WALL MUST BE CONTINUED
 ALONG THE PROPERTY LINE AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE
 NORTH PARCEL.
  
  
 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
 1. PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OR RELOCATION OF ANY TREES ON
 THE PROPERTY, A TREE ALTERATION PERMIT SHALL BE
 SUBMITTED, REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE DEVELOPMENT
 SERVICES DEPARTMENT, PLANNING DIVISION.
  
 2. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE
 RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PERMITTING AND INSTALLATION OF THE
 STREET TREES AND RIGHT OF WAY LANDSCAPING AND
 IRRIGATION APPROVED WITH THIS PETITION.
 3. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE
 RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THE ROAD RIGHT OF
 WAY LANDSCAPING AND IRRIGATION. THIS WILL BE THROUGH A
 SEPARATE MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY.
  
  Print


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved