| Date |
Text |
| 2023-01-30 13:11:12 | FROM: RAY CARANCI, SENIOR LANDSCAPE PLANNER |
| | 561-822-1462 |
| | PROJECT: 410 N ROSEMARY Z22080012 |
| | JANUARY 30, 2023 |
| | I HAVE REVIEWED THE ABOVE REFERENCED PETITION, AND |
| | PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS: |
| | |
| | |
| | 1. SATISFIED. SECTION 94-448 (D)(3) REQUIRES NATIVE |
| | TREES AND PALMS IN GOOD CONDITION TO BE PRESERVED ON |
| | SITE OR RELOCATED. ANSI A 300 (PART 5) STANDARDS |
| | SPECIFY EXAMPLES OF SUITABILITY RATINGS OF GOOD, |
| | MODERATE, OR POOR FOR RELOCATION. PROVIDE AN ARBORISTS |
| | REPORT RATING THE CONDITION AND RELOCATION POTENTIAL |
| | FOR THE NATIVE TREES AND PALMS. |
| | THERE ARE 7 SABAL PALMS THAT ARE FLORIDA NATIVE SPECIES |
| | INDICATED AS GOOD CONDITION ON THE TREE DISPOSITION |
| | PLAN AND THE ARBORISTS REPORT. REVISE DISPOSITION PLAN |
| | AND LIST TO SHOW AS RELOCATE. |
| | 2. SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE INDIVIDUAL AND TOTAL CANOPY |
| | MITIGATION DUE FOR ANY PROPOSED REMOVALS. TREES |
| | PROPOSED TO BE REMOVED WITH A CANOPY DIAMETER OF 20 |
| | FEET OR MORE SHOULD HAVE THE MITIGATION SQUARE FOOTAGE |
| | CALCULATED BASED ON THE ACTUAL DIAMETER. TREES LESS |
| | THAN 20 FEET CANOPY DIAMETER AND PALMS SHOULD SHOW THE |
| | CATEGORY MITIGATION DUE. |
| | REMOVE MITIGATION DUE FROM SABAL PALMS FOR RELOCATION. |
| | ALSO, SABAL PALMS ARE CATEGORY 3, AND IF REMOVED WOULD |
| | REQUIRE 100 SQ FT CANOPY MITIGATION EACH. |
| | 3. MAKE THE FOLLOWING CORRECTIONS TO THE TREE |
| | DISPOSITION PLAN: |
| | ??? SATISFIED. BASED ON THE ARBORIST REPORT FINDINGS, |
| | IDENTIFY TREE #504 SPECIES. |
| | ??? SATISFIED. TREE #510 IS NOT LOCATED ON THE SUBJECT |
| | PROPERTY. NEED TO VERIFY IF IT HAS BEEN REMOVED. |
| | |
| | 4. SATISFIED. PER SECTION 94-442(B)Q. SHOW TREES AND |
| | PALMS ON THE ADJACENT PROPERTIES WITHIN 10 FEET OF THE |
| | PROPERTY LINE. |
| | |
| | 5. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHEET A1.4 SHOWS THE DIAGRAMS |
| | OF THE REQUIRED AND PROVIDED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN |
| | SPACE AREAS FOR THE ZONING DISTRICT NWD-8 BUT LACKS THE |
| | INFORMATION OF THE REQUIRED AND PROVIDED SQUARE FOOTAGE |
| | AND HOW THE OPEN SPACE TYPES MEET THE REQUIREMENTS. THE |
| | PUBLIC OPEN SPACE AREAS IDENTIFIED AS COURTYARD DO NOT |
| | MEET SOME OF THE REQUIREMENTS AS SHOWN. SHOW HOW THE |
| | STANDARDS FOR THE TYPES OF OPEN SPACE ARE MET FOR |
| | VEGETATED AREAS AND TREE CANOPY SQUARE FOOTAGE BASED ON |
| | TABLE IV-8 ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN. LANDSCAPE PLANS MUST |
| | MATCH THE ARCHITECTURAL PLANS AND CLEARLY IDENTIFY THE |
| | OPEN SPACE TYPE THEN DEMONSTRATE HOW THE REQUIREMENTS |
| | OF THAT TYPE ARE MET. |
| | 11/3/22: |
| | PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING: |
| | PUBLIC OPEN SPACE |
| | ??? SATISFIED. OPEN SPACE SHEET A1.4- LABEL EACH OF THE |
| | 4 AREAS SHOWN AS COURTYARD. |
| | ??? NOT SATISFIED. OPEN SPACE SHEET A1.4-SHOW THE TOTAL |
| | REQUIRED AND TOTAL PROVIDED SQUARE FOOTAGE FOR PUBLIC |
| | OPEN SPACE MATCHING SHEET A0.2 |
| | 1/30/23 REQUIRED AND PROVIDED NEED TO BE CLEARLY SHOWN |
| | FOR PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN SPACE. |
| | ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE TREE SPECIES AND |
| | QUANTITIES COUNTED TOWARD TREE CANOPY PROVIDED FOR EACH |
| | COURTYARD SPACE ON SHEET L-1 |
| | 1/30/23 THE LIVE OAKS ARE BEING COUNTED AS TREE CANOPY |
| | FOR THE PUBLIC OPEN SPACE BUT ARE NO LONGER INSIDE THE |
| | PERIMETER OF THE OPEN SPACE. |
| | SEMI-PUBLIC OPEN SPACE |
| | ??? SATISFIED. OPEN SPACE SHEET A1.4-SHOW THE AREA |
| | COUNTED TOWARD WALK UP GARDEN AND SHOW THE VEGETATED |
| | AREA PROVIDED WITHIN THAT TO MEET THE 40% REQUIREMENT. |
| | ??? SATISFIED. SHOW THE REQUIRED 7 FOOT DEPTH ON THE |
| | DIAGRAM. |
| | PRIVATE OPEN SPACE |
| | ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. OPEN SPACE SHEET A1.4- SHOW |
| | THE AREA COUNTED AND LABEL THE TYPE OF OPEN SPACE |
| | 1/30/23 POOL DECK IS NOT AN OPEN SPACE TYPE. IS IT |
| | ROOFTOP GARDEN? |
| | ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW THE VEGETATED AREA |
| | COUNTED TO MEET THE REQUIREMENT |
| | 1/30/23 NOT SHOWN. |
| | ??? NOT SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE TREE SPECIES AND |
| | QUANTITIES COUNTED TOWARD TREE CANOPY PROVIDED FOR EACH |
| | PRIVATE OPEN SPACE ON SHEET L-1 |
| | 1/30/23 NOT SHOWN. |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | 6. SATISFIED. SITE PLAN SHEET A1.0 DOES NOT MATCH THE |
| | LANDSCAPE PLAN. |
| | |
| | 7. SATISFIED. IDENTIFY RELOCATED TREES OR PALMS ON THE |
| | PLANT LIST AND COUNT THEM TOWARD THE REQUIRED TREES IF |
| | THEY ARE TO BE USED ON SITE. |
| | SEE COMMENTS #1 AND #2. |
| | |
| | |
| | 8. SATISFIED. PROVIDE CALCULATIONS FOR REQUIRED STREET |
| | TREES AT MAXIMUM SPACING EVERY 30 FEET OR PORTION |
| | THEREOF FOR EACH STREETSCAPE LENGTH, AND SHOW THE |
| | NUMBER PROVIDED PER SECTION 94-113 AND 94-116 FOR THE |
| | PROPOSED 4TH STREET ADJACENT TO THE SITE. |
| | DISREGARD 94-116 REFERENCE. SHOW THE CALCULATIONS FOR |
| | THE STREET TREE REQUIREMENT FOR EACH SIDE OF THE |
| | PROPOSED 4TH ST. IN THE STREET TREE REQUIREMENT CHART. |
| | |
| | 9. SATISFIED. PROVIDE THE REQUIRED 4 FOOT WIDE PLANTING |
| | STRIP ALONG THE CURB FOR ALL STREETSCAPE SECTIONS AND |
| | PROVIDE A DETAIL AND SHOW THE LOCATIONS OF THE REQUIRED |
| | STRUCTURAL SOIL UNDER THE ADJACENT SIDEWALK OR |
| | HARDSCAPE AREAS. |
| | PROVIDE A SEPARATE EXHIBIT SHOWING THE LOCATIONS OF |
| | STRUCTURAL SOIL CLEARLY. |
| | |
| | |
| | 10. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW THE REQUIRED LANDSCAPE |
| | BUFFERS INSIDE ALL NON RIGHT OF WAY PROPERTY LINES ON |
| | THE LANDSCAPE AND SITE PLAN. BUFFER OF 5 FEET IS |
| | REQUIRED ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE SOUTH BUILDING AND AT |
| | THE NORTH PROPERTY LINE WITH THE TREES SPACED AT 30 |
| | FOOT INTERVALS. ADDRESS HOW THE STREETSCAPE WILL BE |
| | PLACED INSTEAD OF THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER THAT WOULD BE |
| | REQUIRED FOR THE PROPOSED 4TH ST. |
| | LANDSCAPING PROPOSED MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS, BUT |
| | CONFLICTS WITH PROPOSED DRAINAGE LINES WOULD PREVENT |
| | INSTALLATION. |
| | 1/30/23 STILL CONFLICTS AS THERE IS A SPACING |
| | REQUIREMENT WITH ROOT BARRIER REQUIRED BY STORMWATER |
| | ENGINEER, AND TREES HAVE BEEN REMOVED IN THE SECTION |
| | ADJACENT TO THE LOADING AREA. |
| | |
| | 11. SATISFIED. PROVIDE DETAIL ON HOW IMPROVEMENTS FOR |
| | THE PROPOSED 4TH STREET WILL BE INSTALLED ON THE |
| | ADJACENT PROPERTY, MODIFYING WHAT IS REQUIRED FOR THAT |
| | PROPERTY INCLUDING THE BUFFER AND STREETSCAPE |
| | REQUIREMENTS. |
| | STAFF NEEDS TO KNOW WHEN THE DESIGNED IMPROVEMENTS WILL |
| | BE INSTALLED AND WHO WILL MAINTAIN THEM. |
| | |
| | 12. SATISFIED. ARTIFICIAL TURF AREAS PROPOSED MUST MEET |
| | THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 94-451, INCLUDING ALL AREAS |
| | THAT ARE ALLOWED BY CODE MUST NOT BE VISIBLE FROM A |
| | ROAD OR STREET. ARTIFICIAL TURF CANNOT BE PLACED IN |
| | REQUIRED LANDSCAPE AREAS. |
| | THERE MUST BE A FENCE OR OTHER MEANS OF SCREENING |
| | INDICATED FOR THE ARTIFICIAL TURF AREA SO IT IS NOT |
| | VISIBLE FROM THE ROAD OR STREET. ARTIFICIAL TURF CANNOT |
| | DISPLACE REQUIRED LANDSCAPING IN THE 5 FOOT LANDSCAPE |
| | BUFFER. |
| | 1/30/23 REMOVED FROM PLAN. |
| | |
| | 13. SATISFIED. THE EXISTING FPL TRANSMISSION LINES |
| | ALONG ROSEMARY AVE. WILL BE REMOVED AND PLACED |
| | UNDERGROUND IN THE FUTURE AND THE STREETSCAPE DESIGNED. |
| | THE APPLICANT IS REQUIRED TO INSTALL AND MAINTAIN THE |
| | STREETSCAPE SO A PLAN MUST BE DEVELOPED THAT ACCOUNTS |
| | FOR THE FUTURE DESIGN OF THE STREETSCAPE. |
| | PER STAFF AND THE CRA, STREETSCAPE IS TO BE PROPOSED |
| | THAT MEETS THE CURRENT CODE REQUIREMENTS ON ROSEMARY |
| | AVE. TREES ARE TO BE LIVE OAKS MEETING THE 20 FOOT |
| | HEIGHT REQUIREMENT WITH THE 4 FOOT WIDTH PLANTING STRIP |
| | ADJACENT TO THE CURB. |
| | |
| | 14. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW ALL EXISTING AND PROPOSED |
| | WATER AND SEWER AND DRAINAGE LINES ON THE LANDSCAPE |
| | PLAN. SHOW LOCATIONS OF BACKFLOWS AND ADJUST LOCATIONS |
| | OF UTILITY LINES TO RESOLVE CONFLICTS WITH EXISTING AND |
| | PROPOSED TREES AND LANDSCAPING. |
| | DRAINAGE LINES AND EXFILTRATION TRENCHES LOCATED ALONG |
| | THE NORTH AND EAST BUFFER ARE IN CONFLICT WITH REQUIRED |
| | LANDSCAPING AND MUST BE PLACED IN A DIFFERENT LOCATION. |
| | 1/30/23 EXFILTRATION STILL IN CONFLICT WITH BUFFER |
| | TREES, AND THE PROPOSED LOCATIONS OF THE BACKFLOWS |
| | RESTRICT THE SIDEWALK AND THE PLANTING AREAS FOR THE |
| | TREES. |
| | |
| | 15. SATISFIED. SHOW COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 94-445 L. |
| | PLANT SPECIES. A MINIMUM OF 60 PERCENT OF PLANT |
| | MATERIAL ADDED SHALL BE FLORIDA NATIVE OR DROUGHT |
| | TOLERANT SPECIES SELECTED FROM THE CITY LIST OR THE |
| | LIST OF SPECIES IN THE MOST RECENT EDITION OF SOUTH |
| | FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT WATERWISE SOUTH |
| | FLORIDA LANDSCAPES. PROVIDE THE ACTUAL PERCENTAGE BASED |
| | ON THE PLANT LIST. |
| | |
| | 16. SATISFIED. PROVIDE SCREENING HEDGES FOR ALL GROUND |
| | MOUNTED VALVES AND EQUIPMENT AND ADD A NOTE THAT ALL |
| | EQUIPMENT WILL BE SCREENED. |
| | |
| | ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 11/3/22: |
| | |
| | 17. SATISFIED. THE AUSTRALIAN PINE 515D MAY BE |
| | INDICATED AS TO BE REMOVED FROM THE ADJACENT CITY OWNED |
| | PARCEL. THIS IS A PROHIBITED INVASIVE EXOTIC SPECIES |
| | AND MAY BE A SAFETY PROBLEM DURING FUTURE CONSTRUCTION |
| | DUE TO ITS SIZE AND PROXIMITY TO THE PROPERTY LINE. |
| | |
| | 18. SATISFIED. REVISE THE FLORIDA FRIENDLY POINTS CHART |
| | TO ADD 5 POINTS TO ACHIEVE THE REQUIRED 50 POINTS. |
| | |
| | ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 1/30/23: |
| | |
| | 19. JAPANESE BLUEBERRY AND SIMPSONS STOPPERS MUST MEET |
| | THE MINIMUM 12 FOOT REQUIRED SIZE, CORRECT THE PLANT |
| | LIST SPECIFICATION. |
| | |
| | 20. ADJUST STREET TREE SPACING ON ALL TREES TO MEET THE |
| | 30 FOOT MAXIMUM. |
| | |
| | 21. STREET TREES HAVE BEEN RELOCATED TO ADJACENT TO THE |
| | CURB PER CODE REQUIREMENT, 4 FOOT WIDE PLANTING STRIP |
| | NEEDS TO BE ADDED. |
| | CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL |
| | 1. PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OR RELOCATION OF ANY TREES ON |
| | THE PROPERTY, A TREE ALTERATION PERMIT SHALL BE |
| | SUBMITTED, REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE DEVELOPMENT |
| | SERVICES DEPARTMENT, PLANNING DIVISION. |
| | 2. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE |
| | RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PERMITTING AND INSTALLATION OF THE |
| | STREET TREES AND RIGHT OF WAY LANDSCAPING AND |
| | IRRIGATION APPROVED WITH THIS PETITION. |
| | 3. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE |
| | RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THE STREET TREES AND |
| | RIGHT OF WAY LANDSCAPING AND IRRIGATION. THIS WILL BE |
| | THROUGH A SEPARATE MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY. |
| | |
| |
Print |
