Plan Review Notes
Plan Review Notes For Project Z22070008
Project Number Z22070008
Review Stop L
Sequence Number 3
Notes
Date Text
2022-10-07 16:11:03FROM: RAY CARANCI, SENIOR LANDSCAPE PLANNER
 561-822-1462
 PROJECT: 1919 N FLAGLER Z22070008
 OCTOBER 7, 2022
 I HAVE REVIEWED THE ABOVE REFERENCED PETITION, AND
 PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS:
  
 1. MAKE THE FOLLOWING CORRECTIONS TO THE TREE
 DISPOSITION LIST:
 ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. ALL TREES AND PALMS MUST BE
 IDENTIFIED ACCURATELY BY SPECIES ON THE DISPOSITION
 PLAN.
 THERE ARE MISIDENTIFIED SPECIES, AND IF THE TREE SURVEY
 IS INCOMPLETE, THIS MUST BE CORRECTED AND SUBMITTED.
 ??? SATISFIED. REMOVE NOTE REGARDING ASSUMPTION THAT
 POOR QUALITY DOES NOT NEED TO BE MITIGATED.
 ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. TREES PROPOSED TO BE REMOVED
 WITH A CANOPY DIAMETER OF 20 FEET OR MORE SHOULD HAVE
 THE MITIGATION SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATED BASED ON THE
 ACTUAL DIAMETER. TREES LESS THAN 20 FEET CANOPY
 DIAMETER AND PALMS SHOULD SHOW THE CATEGORY MITIGATION
 DUE. THE TREE CATEGORY LIST IS AVAILABLE FROM CITY
 STAFF.
 SHOW CATEGORY AND SQUARE FOOTAGE.
 ??? PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW ONE COLUMN ON THE
 DISPOSITION CHART FOR MITIGATION DUE FOR REMOVALS ONLY
 AND PROVIDE THE TOTAL SQUARE FOOTAGE.
 ALL MITIGATION SHOULD BE IN ONE COLUMN. 1:1 COLUMN IS
 NOT NEEDED.
 ??? SATISFIED. CHANGE THE CONDITION RATINGS TO GOOD,
 MODERATE, OR POOR BASED ON THE ARBORIST REPORT.
 ??? SATISFIED. REMOVE THE ASSUMPTIONS FOR CALCULATIONS
 CHART, AS THIS IS NOT APPLICABLE.
 ??? SATISFIED. REMOVE THE FLORIDA FRIENDLY DESIGN
 OPTIONS CHART FROM SHEET L1-0-01 AND PLACE ON SHEET
 L5-5-01WITH THE PLANT LIST.
 ??? NOT SATISFIED. TREE CANOPY CREDIT CALCULATIONS ARE
 NOT APPLICABLE AS SHOWN. THE CREDITS ARE CALCULATED
 FROM THE CITY TREE CATEGORY LIST. PROVIDE THE
 MITIGATION CREDITS BASED ON THE PLANT LIST AND PROVIDE
 A TOTAL.
 CALCULATIONS PROVIDED ARE FOR OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS,
 NOT TREE MITIGATION. TREE CATEGORY LIST FOR MITIGATION
 MUST BE USED.
  
  
 2. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SECTION 94-448 (D)(3) REQUIRES
 NATIVE TREES AND PALMS IN GOOD CONDITION TO BE
 PRESERVED ON SITE OR RELOCATED. IF THERE ARE ANY RATED
 AS GOOD, PROVIDE ANY INFORMATION ON WHERE THEY WILL BE
 RELOCATED.
 INFORMATION ON THE TREE DISPOSITION IS NOT CORRECT.
 NATIVE SPECIES NEED TO BE CORRECTLY IDENTIFIED AND
 RATINGS SHOWN FROM THE ARBORISTS REPORT.
 10/7/22 UPDATED ARBORISTS REPORT NOT FOUND IN THE
 RESUBMITTAL. ROYAL PALMS ARE FLORIDA NATIVE SPECIES AND
 THERE ARE 3 LISTED IN GOOD CONDITION AND PROPOSED TO BE
 REMOVED. THE TREE SPECIES AND LOCATIONS SHOWN ON THE
 PLAN DO NOT MATCH WHAT EXISTS ON SITE.
  
 3. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. THE DIAGRAM OF THE REQUIRED AND
 PROVIDED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN SPACE AREAS MUST SHOW
 THE EXACT AREA OF THE OPEN SPACE DESIGNATED AND PROVIDE
 THE SQUARE FOOTAGE. CORE 1 REQUIRES THE SQUARE FOOTAGE
 AREA OF THE LOT IN THIS CATEGORY TO BE SHOWN AND THE 3%
 PRIVATE OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENT SHOWN. TRANSITION LOT
 SQUARE FOOTAGE MUST BE SHOWN AND THE REQUIRED 3% PUBLIC
 OPEN SPACE AND 10% PRIVATE OPEN SPACE CALCULATED AND
 SHOWN.
 CALCULATIONS MUST BE SHOWN FOR THE SQUARE FOOTAGE FOR
 THE CORE1 AREA AND THE TRANSITION AREA. CALCULATIONS
 MUST BE SHOWN FOR THE REQUIRED OPEN SPACE AREAS FOR
 EACH AND THE TOTAL PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN SPACE AREAS,
 THEN SHOW THE PROVIDED AREA. EACH AREA MUST HAVE THE
 PERIMETER CLEARLY SHOWN FOR EACH PROVIDED OPEN SPACE,
 THE TYPE OF OPEN SPACE SHOWN AND THE REQUIREMENTS OF
 THAT TYPE SHOWN AS WHAT IS REQUIRED AND WHAT IS
 PROVIDED.
  
 10/7/22 SOME PROGRESS IS SHOWN TOWARD SHOWING THE
 REQUIRED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN SPACE. TRANSITIONAL
 LOT PUBLIC AND PRIVATE OPEN SPACE REQUIRED IS CORRECT,
 BUT NOT CLEAR ON WHAT IS PROVIDED. THE CALCULATION FOR
 CORE 1 LOT AREA SHOULD BE 138,368 AND THE 3% PRIVATE
 OPEN SPACE REQUIRED IS 4,151 SQ FT.
 THE LABELING OF THE PRIVATE OPEN SPACE IS NOT CORRECT,
 EACH SEPARATE AREA ON LEVEL 6 MUST BE SHOWN AND SQUARE
 FOOTAGE PROVIDED, THEN IDENTIFIED AS TO TYPE, AND THE
 REQUIREMENTS FOR THAT TYPE SHOWN. VEGETATED AREA NEEDS
 TO BE SHOWN AND ANY TREE CANOPY REQUIREMENT SHOWN.
 PUBLIC OPEN SPACE GARDEN PLAZA IS INCORRECTLY
 IDENTIFIED AS PRIVATE ON THE CHART.
 VEGETATED AREA AND TREE CANOPY MUST BE SHOWN TO MEET
 THE REQUIREMENTS AS A PERCENTAGE OF THE 905 SQ FT. THE
 AREA NEEDS TO BE CLEARLY SHOWN AND CORRECTLY LABELED ON
 THE PLAN.
  
  
  
 4. SATISFIED. THE PARKWAY MUST MEET THE DESIGN
 REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 94-210 FOR THE FLAGLER DRIVE
 PARKWAY SYSTEM. THE PARKWAY MUST HAVE ALL THE DESIGN
 ELEMENTS INCLUDING THE SHADE TREES SPACED AT 30 FOOT
 INTERVALS PROVIDING SHADE TO THE MULTI-PURPOSE PATH. AS
 SUBMITTED, MANY OF THE DESIGN REQUIREMENTS ARE NOT MET.
 THE STREETSCAPE REQUIREMENT IS SEPARATE, AND THE
 PARKWAY MUST BE PROVIDED IN ADDITION AND IN HARMONY
 WITH THE REQUIRED STREETSCAPE. THE RETAINING WALL
 DIVIDES AND DISRUPTS THE FUNCTION OF THE PARKWAY.
 THE DESIGN IS STILL DIVIDED IN FUNCTION AND FURTHER
 DESIGN CORRECTIONS ARE NEEDED.
  
 5. SATISFIED. A 5 FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER MUST BE
 PROVIDED ALONG ALL PROPERTY LINES WITH ADJACENT
 PROPERTIES. BUFFER MUST INCLUDE A HEDGE AND TREES
 SPACED EVERY 30 FEET.
  
 6. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. INCLUDE THE PLANT LIST OF THE
 TREES, SHRUBS AND GROUNDCOVER PROPOSED FOR EACH
 REQUIRED OPEN SPACE AREA ON THE PLAN FOR THAT AREA AND
 SUPPLY THE SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE VEGETATED AREA AND
 TREE CANOPY. CHART IV-8 IN SECTION 94-109 CAN BE
 REFERENCED FOR OPEN SPACE TREE CANOPY CREDITS.
 THE PLANT LIST MUST BE INCLUDED ON EACH OPEN SPACE PAGE
 TO IDENTIFY THE PLANT MATERIAL AND SHOW TREE CANOPY
 SQUARE FOOTAGE PROVIDED. PRIVATE OPEN SPACE SHEETS
 L5-1-03 AND L5-1-04 MUST BE COMPLETE, AND A SEPARATE
 SHEET SHOWING THE PUBLIC OPEN SPACE PROVIDED.
 10/7/22 PLANT LISTS NEED TO BE WITH THE PLAN FOR EACH
 PRIVATE OPEN SPACE.
  
  
 7. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. IDENTIFY RELOCATED TREES OR
 PALMS ON THE PLANT LIST AND COUNT THEM TOWARD THE
 REQUIRED TREES.
 CORRECTIONS NEED TO BE MADE TO THE TREE DISPOSITION
 LIST TO FINALIZE ANY RELOCATIONS.
 10/7/22 ROYAL PALMS ARE AT ISSUE AND LIVE OAK TREES ARE
 NOT INCLUDED IN THE LIST.
  
 8. SATISFIED. PROVIDE CALCULATIONS FOR REQUIRED STREET
 TREES AT MAXIMUM SPACING EVERY 30 FEET OR PORTION
 THEREOF FOR EACH STREETSCAPE LENGTH, AND SHOW THE
 NUMBER PROVIDED.
 THE CALCULATION USES THE TOTAL PROPERTY LINE LENGTH
 FROM THE SURVEY FOR EACH STREETSCAPE SEGMENT.
 DRIVEWAYS, SIDEWALKS, AND OTHER OPENINGS ARE INCLUDED.
 CORRECT THE LENGTH AND RECALCULATE THE REQUIRED NUMBER
 OF STREET TREES.
  
 9. SATISFIED. PROVIDE LOCATIONS AND DETAIL FOR THE
 REQUIRED STRUCTURAL SOIL UNDER HARDSCAPE AND PROVIDE
 THE TYPICAL DETAIL FOR INSTALLATION FOR ALL STREET
 TREES. THE AREA MUST BE 9 X14 FT PARALLEL TO THE CURB
 FOR EACH TREE CONSISTING OF PLANTING AREA AND/OR
 STRUCTURAL SOIL.
  
 STRUCTURAL SOIL DEPTH NEEDS TO BE CORRECTED TO 36 INCH
 DEPTH REQUIRED ON THE PLANS AND THE DETAIL.
  
  
 10. SATISFIED. STREET TREES MUST MEET THE MINIMUM
 HEIGHT OF 20 FEET AND PALMS MUST BE AT LEAST 14 FEET OF
 GREY WOOD TO ASSURE THE FRONDS WILL MEET THE 13.5 FEET
 REQUIRED FOR STREET CLEARANCE.
  
 11. SATISFIED. SHOW ALL EXISTING AND PROPOSED WATER AND
 SEWER AND DRAINAGE LINES ON THE LANDSCAPE PLAN. SHOW
 LOCATIONS OF BACKFLOWS AND ADJUST LOCATIONS OF UTILITY
 LINES TO RESOLVE CONFLICTS WITH EXISTING AND PROPOSED
 TREES AND LANDSCAPING.
 THERE ARE CONFLICTS WITH THE UTILITIES SHOWN ON THE
 LANDSCAPE PLAN. REQUIRED LANDSCAPING TAKES PRECEDENT
 OVER UTILITY LOCATIONS.
  
  
 12. PARTIALLY SATISFIED. SHOW COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION
 94-445 L. PLANT SPECIES. A MINIMUM OF 60 PERCENT OF
 PLANT MATERIAL ADDED SHALL BE FLORIDA NATIVE OR DROUGHT
 TOLERANT SPECIES SELECTED FROM THE CITY LIST OR THE
 LIST OF SPECIES IN THE MOST RECENT EDITION OF SOUTH
 FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT WATERWISE SOUTH
 FLORIDA LANDSCAPES. PROVIDE THE ACTUAL PERCENTAGE BASED
 ON THE PLANT LIST.
 NATIVE PERCENTAGE IS LISTED BUT MUST INCLUDE DROUGHT
 TOLERANT NON-NATIVE SPECIES IN PERCENTAGE.
 10/7/22 PROVIDE ONE PERCENTAGE FOR THE ENTIRE PLANT
 LIST.
  
 13. SATISFIED. PROVIDE SCREENING HEDGES FOR ALL GROUND
 MOUNTED VALVES AND EQUIPMENT AND ADD A NOTE THAT ALL
 EQUIPMENT WILL BE SCREENED.
 SCREENING NEEDS TO BE SHOWN WHEN REVISIONS ARE MADE TO
 THE LOCATIONS.
  
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 9/14/22:
  
 14. SATISFIED. THERE IS AN EASEMENT FOR THE SIDEWALK
 AND THE SEA WALL FOR THE 2 PARCELS EAST OF FLAGLER
 DRIVE. THIS NEEDS TO BE CLARIFIED WHERE THE EASEMENT IS
 AND IF IT NEEDS TO BE CHANGED FOR ANY CHANGES PROPOSED
 WITH THIS PETITION. THE EXISTING ROYAL PALMS ARE PART
 OF THE CITY STREETSCAPE AND MAY BE WITHIN THE EASEMENT.
 STAFF ADVISES NO CHANGES BE PROPOSED WITH THIS
 PETITION, AND THE DESIGN PROPOSED AT A LATER TIME WHEN
 THE DETAILS OF THE EASEMENTS ARE KNOWN.
  
 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
 1. PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OR RELOCATION OF ANY TREES ON
 THE PROPERTY, A TREE ALTERATION PERMIT SHALL BE
 SUBMITTED, REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE DEVELOPMENT
 SERVICES DEPARTMENT, PLANNING DIVISION.
  
 2. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE
 RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PERMITTING AND INSTALLATION OF THE
 RIGHT OF WAY LANDSCAPING AND IRRIGATION APPROVED WITH
 THIS PETITION.
  
  
 3. THE APPLICANT, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS SHALL BE
 RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THE STREETSCAPE
 LANDSCAPING AND IRRIGATION. THIS WILL BE THROUGH A
 SEPARATE MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY.
  
  Print


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved