Plan Review Details - Project E22110015
Plan Review Stops For Project E22110015
Review Stop ENG-A ENGINEERING FORMAL REVIEW
Rev No 2 Status F Date 06-09-2023 Cont ID  
Sent By lquinone Date 06-09-2023 Time 15:50 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lquinone Date 06-09-2023 Time 15:50 Sent To  
Notes
2023-06-09 15:51:09E22110015 (SENT OUT AS E22110019) ??? PUBLIX REMODEL,
 SOUTHERN BL. ??? 4.26.23 RESUBMITTAL
  
 NO COMMENTS FROM LINDA QUI??ONES-CINTRON, PROJECT
 COORDINATOR, ENGINEERING SERVICES DEPT., 561-494-1085
 [email protected] :
  
  
  
 NO COMMENTS FROM MARK HURLEY, FIELD CUSTOMER SERVICE
 SUPER., WPB PUBLIC UTILITIES, 561-822-2262 OR
 [email protected]:
  
  
 COMMENTS FROM TRACY WARD, SR. STORMWATER ENG.,
 ENGINEERING SERVICES, [email protected] 561-494-1120:
  
 1. [PARTIALLY SATISFIED] ON EVERY SHEET WITH ELEVATION
 INFORMATION NOTE THE VERTICAL DATUM USED AND PROVIDE
 THE CONVERSION EQUATION BETWEEN THE VERTICAL DATUM
 BEING USED AND NGVD1929. VERTICAL DATUM AND CONVERSION
 EQUATION MISSING ON SHEETS C-303, C-304, C-602, C-701,
 AND C-903. VERTICAL DATUM MISSING ON SHEETS C-305,
 C-401, C-402, C-403, C-501, AND C-502.
  
 4. [NOT SATISFIED] PROVIDE A DETAIL OF THE WEIR
 (MATERIAL, THICKNESS, ETC.) AND HOW IT IS TO BE
 ATTACHED TO THE CONTROL STRUCTURES.
  
 6. [NOT SATISFIED ??? HEADER CURB DETAIL STILL APPEARS
 ON SHEET C-903] HEADER CURB DETAIL ON SHEET C-903
 APPEARS TO FOR A TYPE ???D??? CURB. STAFF NOTICED BOTH
 CURBS TYPES ARE DETAILED ON SHEET C-911.
  
 7. REVIEW RIM ELEVATIONS FOR STRUCTURES A-9 AND A-10 IN
 THE STORM STRUCTURE SCHEDULE ON SHEET C-401 AND THE
 MATCH EXISTING (ME) GRADES SHOWN IN PLAN VIEW FOR THE
 STRUCTURES. UPDATE A-9 CONTROL STRUCTURE DETAIL ON
 SHEET C-903 IF THE RIM ELEVATION CHANGES.
  
 COMMENTS FROM RICKY ELIZONDO, PUBLIC UTILITIES PLANS
 EXAMINER, [email protected] 561-494-1101:
 -ON SITE WATER FOUND TO BE PRIVATE AFTER FURTHER
 REVIEW. PLEASE INSTALL MASTER METERS ALONGSIDE THE
 PROPERTY LINE ON BOTH THE EAST AND WEST SIDES OF THE
 PROJECT AREA. COORDINATION WITH CUSTOMER SERVICE WILL
 BE NEEDED TO DETERMINE BILLING.
 -CALL OUT THE WEST INVERT OF SSMH 4500 AS THE CITY???S
 POINT OF SERVICE. DENOTE ALL MAIN RUNNING WEST FROM
 THIS INVERT AS ???PRIVATE???
  
 FEEL FREE TO CONTACT US IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
 CONCERNS, THANKS.
  
  
  

Review Stop ENG-A ENGINEERING FORMAL REVIEW
Rev No 1 Status F Date 03-10-2023 Cont ID  
Sent By lquinone Date 03-10-2023 Time 13:52 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lquinone Date 03-10-2023 Time 13:52 Sent To  
Notes
2023-03-10 13:53:30E22110015 (SENT OUT AS E22110019) ??? PUBLIX REMODEL,
 SOUTHERN BL. ??? 11.16.22 SUBMITTAL
 COMMENTS FROM RICK ROSSANO, PROJECT COORDINATOR,
 ENGINEERING SERVICES DEPT., 561-494-1098
 [email protected] :
 1. CONFIRM THAT A COMPLETED LOS ANALYSIS SUMMARY TABLE
 HAS BEEN SUBMITTED DIRECTLY TO ENGINEERING (SHEET 33 OF
 CITY OF WPB DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION).
 2. CHECK TO SEE IF FDEP FORMS FOR PROPOSED SANITARY
 SEWER ARE REQUIRED.
 3. PLEASE PROVIDE CALCULATIONS OF REVISED PERVIOUS AND
 IMPERVIOUS CALCULATIONS FOR THE PROPOSED IMPACTED
 AREAS.
 4. COORDINATE WITH MARK HURLEY, FIELD CUSTOMER SERVICE
 SUPERVISOR WITH CITY OF WPB PUBLIC UTILITIES, REGARDING
 PLACEMENT OF BACKFLOW DEVICES AND WATER METERS. CONTACT
 HIM AT 561-494-2262 OR [email protected]
 5. PLANS SHALL SHOW EXISTING AND PROPOSED LOCATIONS AND
 DIMENSIONS OF ALL WATER, STORMWATER, AND SANITARY AND
 SEWER LINES AND CLEANOUTS, GREASE TRAPS, ETC. INCLUDING
 STUBS TO EACH PROPERTY LINE FOR WATER AND SANITARY
 SEWERS, THE MAKE AND MODEL OF ALL VALVES, POTABLE AND
 IRRIGATION METERS, BACKFLOWS, FIRE HYDRANTS AND FDCS,
 AND OTHER DEVICES TO BE INSTALLED ON THE SYSTEM, CATCH
 BASINS, CULVERTS, DITCHES INCLUDING GRADES, PIPES
 SIZES, MATERIALS, ELEVATIONS, ASSUMPTIONS,
 CALCULATIONS, INVERT ELEVATIONS FOR ALL INLETS AND
 MANHOLES AND PROFILES OF SANITARY SEWER LINES. GATE
 VALVE BOXES SHALL NOT BE INSTALLED IN CURB OR SIDEWALK.
 ALL AVAILABLE ELEVATION SHALL BE SHOWN ON THE PROFILE
 VIEW. DIRECTION OF FLOW SHALL BE SHOWN ON PLAN VIEW ON
 PLAN VIEW FOR ALL SANITARY AND STORM SEWERS. PLEASE
 SHOW SLOPE % ON ALL SANITARY LINES AND CALL OUT
 MATERIAL. ADDITIONALLY, PLAN VIEW SHALL SHOW ALL
 EXISTING AND PROPOSED UNDERGROUND UTILITY LAYOUT,
 INCLUDING FIBER OPTIC, ELECTRIC, GAS, AND CABLEVISION &
 TELECOMMUNICATION FACILITIES INCLUDING PIPES SIZES AND
 MATERIALS, LOCATED ON THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
 6. PLEASE CUT AND CAP UTILITIES NOT IN USE AND REMOVE
 ANY ABANDONED UTILITY LINES LARGER THAN 2 INCHES FROM
 CITY RIGHT OF WAY.
 7. PLEASE CLEARLY LABEL ALL EXISTING AND PROPOSED
 UTILITY EASEMENTS, INCLUDING THOSE PROPOSED TO ALLOW
 ACCESS FOR CITY PERSONNEL TO PROPOSED UTILITY WATER
 METERS.
 8. BACKFLOWS SHALL BE INSTALLED ON PRIVATE PROPERTY
 OUTSIDE OF EASEMENTS AND RIGHTS OF WAY. DOMESTIC WATER
 METERS SHALL BE INSTALLED IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT TO
 PROPERTY LINE. 3 INCH AND LARGER WATER METERS SHALL BE
 INSTALLED ABOVE-GROUND ONLY.
 9. PLEASE CALLOUT DOMESTIC BACKFLOW PREVENTER AS RPPA
 AND FIRE BACKFLOW PREVENTER AS DCDA. SPECIFY LEAD FREE
 DESIGN ON ALL BACKFLOWS.
 10. ENGINEERING PLANS SHALL INCLUDE PIGGING, FLUSHING
 AND SAMPLE POINTS ON ANY WATER RUNS 60 FT. IN LENGTH OR
 GREATER.
 11. FOR FORMAL ENGINEERING SUBMITTAL, SFWMD ERP AND
 NPDES NOI REQUIREMENTS WILL BE ENFORCED.
 - AN NOI IS REQUIRED FOR PROJECTS THAT:
 - 1) DISTURB ONE OF MORE ACRES OF LAND OR DISTURB LESS
 THAN ON ACRE OF LAND BUT ARE PART OF A COMMON PLAN OF
 DEVELOPMENT OR SALE;
 - 2) DISCHARGE STORMWATER TO SURFACE WATERS OF THE
 STATE OR TO SURFACE WATERS OF THE STATE THROUGH A
 MUNICIPAL SEPARATE STORM SEWER SYSTEM (MS4).
 - THE SFWMD ERP CAN BE OBTAINED THROUGH A 10-2 SELF
 CERTIFICATION THROUGH FDEP OR AN ERP APPLICATION
 THROUGH SFWMD. EITHER WAY, THE DEVELOPER/ENGINEER SHALL
 SUBMIT A COPY OF THE ERP PERMIT OR FDEP ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
 OF THE 10-2 CERTIFICATION.
 12. PROVIDE PROFILE AND CLEARANCES BETWEEN WATER, SEWER
 AND STORM LINES AT ALL UTILITY CROSSINGS WITHIN ROW PER
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH STANDARD DETAIL GN-2 SERIES.
 PLEASE SHOW ALL EXISTING AND PROPOSED UNDERGROUND
 UTILITY LAYOUT, INCLUDING FIBER OPTIC, ELECTRIC, GAS,
 AND CABLEVISION & TELECOMMUNICATION FACILITIES WITH
 PIPE MATERIAL AND SIZE, LOCATED ON THE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
 13. WHEN SUBMITTING APPROVED MATERIALS LIST, PLEASE
 PROVIDE MATERIAL/CUT SHEETS FOR ALL PROPOSED BACKFLOW
 DEVICES SHOWING SPECIFIC MODEL NUMBER AND SPECIFYING
 USC APPROVED LEAD-FREE DESIGN.
 14. PLEASE CLEARLY LABEL ROAD RIGHT OF WAY.
 15. PLEASE PROVIDE SANITARY ELEVATIONS AT MANHOLE
 TIE-IN.
 16. IF TRENCHING IN IN CITY-MAINTAINED ROADWAY AREAS
 ADD NOTE TO PROVIDE 50 FT. PAVEMENT RESTORATION
 TRANSITION ON EACH SIDE OF PROPOSED TRENCH PER CITY OF
 WPB STANDARD DETAIL GC-4.
 17. PLEASE PROVIDE LEGEND ON ALL PLAN SHEETS TO INCLUDE
 STREETLIGHT, SIGN POSTS, TRANSFORMER BOXES ETC.
 18. PLEASE RESPOND TO ALL COMMENTS IN WRITING AND
 INCLUDE PROJECT NAME, ADDRESS AND PERMIT NUMBER
 (E-XXXXXXXX).
  
  
 COMMENTS FROM MARK HURLEY, FIELD CUSTOMER SERVICE
 SUPER., WPB PUBLIC UTILITIES, 561-822-2262 OR
 [email protected]:
  
 -SHOW EXISTING WATER MAIN VALVES ON SHEET C501. ALSO
 SHOW ANY EXISTING FIRELINE GATE VALVES THAT ARE
 PROPOSED TO REMAIN.
  
 -CALLOUT EXISTING WATER MAIN PIPE SIZE AND MATERIAL
 TYPE IN BLOWUP 1 AND 2 ON UTILITY PLAN.
  
 -ADD FIRE FLOW CALCULATIONS (FOR EACH FIRELINE) TO PLAN
 SET AS DIRECTED IN WS5 NOTE 9. CALCULATIONS SHOULD SHOW
 THAT FIRELINE WATER SERVICES CAN MEET THE PRIVATE FIRE
 SYSTEM DEMAND.
  
 -THE RELOCATION OF THE PUBLIX FIRELINE TAP FROM PRIOR
 PLAN REVISION HAS NOW OVERLOADED THE WESTERN 8 INCH
 PIPE WITH TWO 8 INCH FIRELINES, FIRE HYDRANT, 1 INCH
 WATER SERVICE, AND 2 INCH WATER SERVICE WHERE EACH MAY
 NOT GET ADEQUATE SUPPLY IN EVENT OF A FIRE. TO RESOLVE
 COULD BRING TAP SOUTH DOWN TO NOTTINGHAM WATER MAIN.
  
 -PROVIDE SEPARATE SHEET WITH PROFILES OF: ALL METERED
 WATER SERVICES FROM WATER MAIN TO METER; FIRELINE FROM
 MAIN TO HYDRANT; EASTERN PROPOSED FIRELINE FROM MAIN TO
 POINT OF SERVICE.
  
 -ON BLOW UP 1, FOR THE WESTERN FIRELINE, LABEL THE GATE
 VALVE AT WATER MAIN FIRELINE POINT OF SERVICE.
  
 -THERE MAY BE LANDSCAPING CONFLICT WITH NEW PROPOSED
 LOCATION OF PUBLIX DCDA. PLEASE CHECK AND RESOLVE IF
 NEEDED.
  
 -IF SAMPLING IS NEEDED, SHOW SAMPLE POINT LOCATIONS.
  
 -VERIFY IF HEALTH PERMIT IS REQUIRED.
  
 -SANITARY MANHOLE S3 SHOULD HAVE AN OUT INVERT. PLEASE
 ADD TO SANITARY STRUCTURE SCHEDULE.
  
 -LABEL THE NEW SANITARY INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE.
  
 -VERIFY 1 INCH METERED WATER SERVICE AT EAST SIDE FOR
 THE SHOPS IS SUFFICIENT BECAUSE ORIGINAL PLAN IN PPRC
 HAD FIVE 1 INCH METERS AND THE PIPE RUN SEEMS LONG.
 ALSO NOT SURE IF THERE MAY BE ISOLATION BACKFLOW
 ASSEMBLIES AT THE SUB METERS.
  
 -CALLOUT GAS CROSSINGS ON BLOW UP 2. ALSO CALLOUT 3
 FEET MINIMUM DISTANCE BETWEEN METER BOX AND WALL.
  
 -VERIFY IF THERE WILL BE ANY FOOD SERVICE BUSINESSES OR
 DENTISTS IN THE SHOPPES PORTION.
  
 -SHOW SANITARY SEWER MAIN RUNNING NORTH SOUTH ON LAKE
 AVE ALONG WITH THE CONNECTING MANHOLE. LABEL SEWER MAIN
 WITH PIPE SIZE. LABEL MANHOLE WITH INVERT ELEVATIONS.
  
 -ARE THE HATCHED MARKS AT THE EASTERN SANITARY MANHOLE
 DEPICTING WORK OR ARE THEY PAVEMENT MARKINGS?
  
 -PAVEMENT RESTORATION BOUNDARY ON NOTTINGHAM DOES NOT
 APPEAR LARGE ENOUGH. REFER TO STANDARD DETAIL P4 NOTE 1
 FOR DIMENSIONS.
  
 -CONSIDER PARALLEL/DUAL BACKFLOW ASSEMBLIES FOR THE
 PUBLIX DOMESTIC WATER SERVICE SO THEY DO NOT EXPERIENCE
 WATER OUTAGE DURING BACKFLOW MAINTENANCE.
  
 -THE GENERAL NOTES ON THE DEMO PLAN ARE VERY GOOD IN
 KEEPING CONSIDERATION FOR THE WESTERN TENANT, BUT
 PLEASE VERIFY THERE WILL BE A WAY FOR THEM TO MAINTAIN
 FIRELINE WATER SERVICE WITHOUT INTERRUPTION.
  
 -SHOW EXISTING AND PROPOSED SANITARY SEWER LATERAL FOR
 THE WESTERN BUILDING. CANNOT FIND ON UTILITY PLAN AND
 CONCERNED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION PROJECT WILL DISRUPT
 THEIR SEWER SERVICE.
  
 -VERIFY EXISTING WATER MAIN DESIGN ON LAKE AVE. WPB GIS
 SHOWS 8 INCH AC WATER MAIN PARALLEL TO 16 INCH AND
 WATER PIPE GOING TO SHOPPING PLAZA CONNECTED TO THE AC
 MAIN.
  
 -WPB GIS SHOWS STORMWATER INFRASTRUCTURE RUNNING DOWN
 NOTTINGHAM TO A MANHOLE AND THEM GOING ACROSS SHOPPING
 PLAZA PARKING LOT TO ANOTHER MANHOLE, BUT I DO NOT SEE
 THAT ON DEMO OR DRAINAGE PLANS. PLEASE VERIFY AND
 UPDATE PLANS AS NEEDED.
  
 COMMENTS FROM TRACY WARD, SR. STORMWATER ENG.,
 ENGINEERING SERVICES, [email protected] 561-494-1120:
  
 1. ON EVERY SHEET WITH ELEVATION INFORMATION NOTE THE
 VERTICAL DATUM USED AND PROVIDE THE CONVERSION EQUATION
 BETWEEN THE VERTICAL DATUM BEING USED AND NGVD1929.
 2. NO PROPOSED DRAINAGE FACILITIES SHOWN OR CALLED OUT
 ON SHEET C-401 (PG&D PLAN).
 3. SHOW PROTECTION OF OFFSITE DRAINAGE STRUCTURES
 SUSCEPTIBLE TO RECEIVING CONSTRUCTION SEDIMENT RUNOFF.
 4. PROVIDE A DETAIL OF THE WEIR (MATERIAL, THICKNESS,
 ETC.) AND HOW IT IS TO BE ATTACHED TO THE CONTROL
 STRUCTURES.
 5. CONSIDER SUSPENDED PAVEMENT OR UNDERGROUND STORAGE
 TYPE UNITS INSTEAD OF EXFILTRATION TRENCH. THERE MAY BE
 MORE VOLUME OF STORAGE PER CUBIC FOOT AND LESS LONG
 TERM MAINTENANCE COSTS WITH THE UNDERGROUND STORAGE
 UNITS.
 6. HEADER CURB DETAIL ON SHEET C-903 APPEARS TO FOR A
 TYPE ???D??? CURB. STAFF NOTICED BOTH CURBS TYPES ARE
 DETAILED ON SHEET C-911.
  
 COMMENTS FROM RICKY ELIZONDO, PUBLIC UTILITIES PLANS
 EXAMINER, [email protected] 561-494-1101:
  
 -WATER MAIN CONFIGURATION WOULD PREFERABLY REMAIN
 LOOPED
 -REMOVE SEWER UP TO SSMH 4500, AND REHAB THE MANHOLE.
 -CALLOUT ALL DIRECTIONS OF MANHOLE INVERTS
 -POINT OF SERVICE GATE VALVE FOR FIRE HYDRANT ON EAST
 END OF PROPERTY WOULD PREFER TO BE OUT OF THE SIDEWALK
 -CALL OUT DOMESTIC BACKFLOW AS RPPA
 -DEMOLITION PLAN DOESN???T SHOW FULL EXTENTS OF SEWER
 -DENOTE THE LENGTH OF WATER/SEWER PIPE BEING REMOVED
  
 FEEL FREE TO CONTACT US IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
 CONCERNS, THANKS.
 RICK ROSSANO, PROJECT COORDINATOR, ENGINEERING SERVICES
 DEPARTMENT (561) 494-1098 [email protected]
  
  

Review Stop ENG-D ENGINEERING DEFICIENCY REVIEW
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop ENG-E ENGINEERING ENVR. MIT. REVIEW
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop ENG-F ENGINEERING FINAL DRAWING REV
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop ENG-M ENGINEERING MODIFICATION REV
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop ENG-P ENGINEERING PLANNING REVIEW
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

Review Stop ENG-T ENGINEERING TRAFFIC STUDY REV
Rev No 1 Status   Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date   Time   Rev Time  
Received By   Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***

  Print


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved