| Date |
Text |
| 2009-09-26 11:13:07 | |
| | |
| | ** DENIED 2ND REVIEW ** |
| | |
| | ** SOME NOTES FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW ARE STILL IN NEED OF |
| | ADDRESSING. |
| | ** THERE ARE ALSO SOME NEW NOTES BASED ON PLANS |
| | SUBMITTED. |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE: NO FIRE ALARM PLANS FOR BASE DESIGN INTENT AS |
| | REQUIRED PER FBC CHAPTER 9 AND FS 633 SUBMITTED. |
| | RESPONSE MENTIONS THAT THESE WILL BE SUBMITTED BEFORE |
| | PERMIT ISSUANCE. HOWEVER AS STATED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW, |
| | THE BASE BUILDING PLANS ARE REQUIRED TO SHOW BASE |
| | DESIGN INTENT REQUIRED BY THE ABOVE CODES AND OTHER |
| | APPLICABLE CODES SUCH AS NFPA-72. |
| | IF PLANS ARE NOT SUBMITTED TO COORDINATE REVIEW WITH |
| | THE SUBMITTED PLANS THERE COULD ALSO BE COMMENTS WHICH |
| | CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME. |
| | ** AS NOTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE |
| | FBC 11-4.28.1,.2 AND .3 FOR ALL MINIMUMS REQUIRED FOR |
| | ADA COMPLIANCE. |
| | |
| | 2) NOTE: PREVIOUS NOTE #26. PLEASE SEE FS 655.962 FOR |
| | REQUIRED LIGHTING FOR ATM AREAS. BASED ON S-LTG SHEET |
| | AND OTHER PHOTO-METRICS PER FAE, THE MINIMUM LEVELS |
| | REQUIRED BY STATUE ARE NOT MET. SEE SECTION OF THE |
| | STATUE WHICH IS NOT ONLY THE LIGHTING LEVELS WITHIN |
| | 10FT. |
| | |
| | 3) NOTE: PLANS STILL INDICATE A CROSS OF WORK OVER |
| | PROPERTY LINES. THE REVISED PLANS HAVE REMOVED THE |
| | PROPERTY LINE BETWEEN BANK AND EAST PARKING LOT. |
| | RESPONSE FROM DESIGN TEAM STATED ONLY THE PHOTO-METRICS |
| | CROSSED PROPERTY LINES. HOWEVER BASED ON PREVIOUS |
| | SUBMITTED PLANS THERE WAS AN ADDITIONAL PROPERTY LINE |
| | SHOWN ON THE EAST SIDE OF BANK BETWEEN PARKING LOT AND |
| | BANK. SEE PREVIOUS PLANS. |
| | SEE COMMENTS FROM OTHER TRADES WHICH MAY AFFECT REVIEW |
| | AND SCOPE OF WORK. |
| | |
| | 4) NOTE: ** NEW COMMENT**: THE DOOR SWING ON THE LOWER |
| | ELECTRICAL ROOM BETWEEN EXECUTIVE OFFICE #10 AND |
| | CONFERENCE ROOM #1 IS SHOWN SWINGING IN. |
| | THIS IS A LIFE SAFETY HAZARD. AN OCCUPANT/ELECTRICAL |
| | WORKING ON ONE OF THE ELECTRICAL PANELS COULD BE PUSHED |
| | INTO A LIVE ELECTRICAL PANEL BY THE DOOR. PLEASE SWING |
| | DOOR OUT. |
| | 110.26, 90.4 |
| | |
| | 5) NOTE: PLEASE GO OVER SUBMITTED ENERGY CALCULATIONS. |
| | 13-415.AB.5, 13-415.AB.2.2 |
| | THE NUMBER OF EXTERIOR 400W SITE LIGHTING FIXTURES ON |
| | PLANS IS HIGHER THAN THE AMOUNT IN THE INPUT DATA |
| | REPORT OF THE SUBMITTED CALCULATIONS. |
| | THE NUMBER OF H/HE FIXTURES ON PLANS IS HIGHER. |
| | THE JAN CLOSET FIRST FLOOR DOES NOT INDICATE THE TYPE |
| | OF FIXTURE. ( ALSO NOTED ON PREVIOUS NOTE #17 FOR |
| | COMPLETING ALL LIGHTS ON PLANS). |
| | THE NUMBER OF G FIXTURES ON PLANS IS NOT CLEAR. ONLY |
| | ONE G IS SHOWN AT LOCATIONS IN WHICH THERE ARE MORE |
| | THAN 2,3 OR 4 FIXTURES. |
| | THE NUMBER OF 64W FIXTURES ON PLANS WHICH PER FIXTURE |
| | LEGEND IS K, B, BE, PE, AND G IS HIGHER THAN IDR. |
| | |
| | ** PLEASE SEE 13-415.AB.5 WHICH REFERENCES TABLE B FOR |
| | SPACE TYPES. 13-415.AB.5 INCLUDES *A* FOR INTERIOR |
| | ALLOWANCES. EVEN AS THERE MAY BE TWO ZONES, THERE ARE |
| | MORE THAN TWO SPACE TYPES. ALL SPACES IN BUILDING ARE |
| | NOTED AS BANKING. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE WHEN THERE ARE |
| | OTHER SPACES? PLEASE EXPLAIN. |
| | |
| | 6) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS NOTE #12. IT IS TO BE |
| | NOTED THAT PLANS DO NOT MEET ASME-17 AS PREVIOUSLY |
| | GIVEN PER FBC AND NEC REFERENCE TO STATE ELEVATOR CODE |
| | REQUIREMENTS. |
| | RESPONSE WAS TO SEE ADDITIONAL LIGHT FIXTURE ADDED ON |
| | E3.03 HOWEVER THIS IS NOT THE ONLY REQUIRED ITEM PER |
| | ASME. |
| | CALL TO GO OVER THIS AS LIGHTING LEVELS IN LOCATIONS |
| | COVER BY THE CODE ARE NOT MEETING MINIMUMS. |
| | |
| | 7) NOTE: ** NEW COMMENT? PANEL SCHEDULES DO INDICATE |
| | THE REQUIRED DEDICATED RECEPTACLE AND LIGHTING CIRCUITS |
| | PER NEC 620.22,23,24 ETC AND E3.03 DOES SHOW PIT DETAIL |
| | HOWEVER NO ELECTRICAL COULD BE LOCATED ON PLANS FOR |
| | GROUPING OF THE DISCONNECTING MEANS FOR THE REQUIRED |
| | DEDICATED CIRCUITS 620.53,620.54,620.51 FOR REQUIRED |
| | DISCONNECTS TO BE LOCATED IN ELEVATOR MACHINE/EQUIPMENT |
| | ROOM. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE AN ENLARGED DETAIL OF BOTH THE ELEVATOR |
| | EQUIPMENT ROOM. |
| | **KEEP IN MIND AS A REFERENCED STANDARD AND CODE, NOTE |
| | #6 ABOVE NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED. |
| | |
| | 8) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS NOTE #18 WITH RESPECT TO |
| | THE GENERATOR WHICH IS BEING PROPOSED TO BE LOCATED ON |
| | THE ROOF. THE RESPONSE MENTIONS THE ATS IS SERVICE |
| | ENTRANCE RATED THEREFORE BASICALLY IF THE ATS MAIN IS |
| | TURNED OFF THE INSTALLATION MEETS CODE AND IS SAFE. |
| | |
| | IF THE BUILDING IS UNDER GENERATOR POWER AND THERE IS |
| | AN EMERGENCY WHERE FIRE DEPARTMENT OR OTHER PERSONAL |
| | NEEDS TO SHUT DOWN THE POWER, THE ATS WILL ONLY SHUT |
| | OFF POWER TO SERVICE EQUIPMENT. THE GENERATOR IS STILL |
| | UNDER POWER AND STILL RUNNING. THE FEEDERS FROM THE |
| | GENERATOR TO THE ATS ARE ALSO STILL ENERGIZED AND |
| | RUNNING THROUGH THE BUILDING. |
| | ALL FEEDERS AND SERVICE ENTRANCE CONDUCTORS ENTERING |
| | AND RUNNING THROUGH THE STRUCTURE SHALL CONTAIN |
| | DISCONNECTING MEANS TO DE-ENERGIZE THESE CONDUCTORS. |
| | THE INTENT OF 230 AND 225 OF THE NEC GIVEN BELOW IS TO |
| | BE ABLE TO DE-ENERGIZE ALL CONDUCTORS IN A STRUCTURE. |
| | |
| | PLEASE SEE 230.70, 230.71, 230.72, 230.76 AND 230.79 |
| | FOR SERVICE CONDUCTORS WHICH REQUIRE DISCONNECTING |
| | MEANS. THE DISCONNECTING MEANS SHALL BE RATED FOR THE |
| | LOAD SERVED AND BE ABLE TO BE DISCONNECTED EVEN UNDER |
| | POWER FAILURE. EVEN OTHER SYSTEMS SUCH AS BACK UP POWER |
| | SYSTEMS ARE REQUIRED TO HAVE DISCONNECTING MEANS TO |
| | SHUT OFF POWER. |
| | PLEASE SEE 225.31-225.39. THESE SECTIONS APPLY TO |
| | FEEDERS TO DETACHED STRUCTURES/BUILDINGS. EVEN AS THIS |
| | IS NOT A DETACHED BUILDING OR STRUCTURE THE INTENT OF |
| | 225 IS THE SAME. THESE SAME SECTIONS WILL SHOW THE |
| | INTENT WHICH IS TO HAVE A DISCONNECTING MEANS TO |
| | DE-ENERGIZE ALL FEEDERS IN A STRUCTURE. |
| | ** |
| | PLEASE SEE NEC 445.18 WHICH REQUIRES THE DISCONNECTING |
| | OF ALL POWER FROM THE UNIT. ALSO (1),(2), |
| | ** A MEANS OF DISCONNECTING THE PRIME MOVER SHALL BE |
| | PROVIDED. IT WAS STATED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW TO CALL FIRE |
| | MARSHAL AND THIS REVIEWER TO GO OVER THIS COMMENT. |
| | HOWEVER TO DATE NO CONTACT TO THIS REVIEWER WAS MADE. |
| | CONTACT WILL BE MADE TO THE FIRE MARSHAL FOR PROPOSED |
| | SCOPE OF WORK. |
| | |
| | ** AS NOTED PREVIOUSLY NO INFORMATION ON MOUNTING THE |
| | GENERATOR, LOCATION, OTHER STRUCTURAL INFORMATION COULD |
| | BE LOCATED ON ANY OTHER SHEETS. ME SHEET INDICATES THE |
| | GAS LINE UP TO ROOF HOWEVER THE S SHEETS DO NOT SHOW |
| | ANY DETAILS. |
| | IT WAS NOTED TO SEE COMMENTS FROM OTHER TRADES HOWEVER |
| | AS GENERATOR UNIT WAS NOT SHOWN ON OTHER PLANS IT MAY |
| | NOT HAVE BEEN NOTED BY THE BUILDING REVIEWER. AN E-MAIL |
| | HAS BEEN SENT TO BUILDING REVIEWER. |
| | COULD NOT LOCATE ANY MOUNTING DETAILS, CURBS, VIBRATION |
| | ISOLATORS ETC. SEE FBC CHAPTER 16 FOR WIND AND NFPA-110 |
| | CHAPTER 7 FOR MOUNTING, LOCATIONS ETC |
| | |
| | 9) NOTE: SPECS WERE SUBMITTED FOR THE GENERATOR UNIT. |
| | WILL THIS BE AN INSIDE UNIT AS NO SHEETS COULD BE |
| | LOCATED FOR THE WEATHER PROOF ENCLOSURE. |
| | 110.3,90.7, FBC CHAPTER 16 ETC AS NOTED. |
| | ** AS NOTED PREVIOUSLY, ALL PRODUCT SPECIFICATIONS ARE |
| | REQUIRED TO CONTAIN *SHOP DRAWING REVIEW STAMPS* AND |
| | SIGNATURE BY THE DESIGNER OF RECORD. |
| | |
| | 10) NOTE: PLEASE REVISE ROOF TOP ELECTRICAL PLANS. AN |
| | EXAMPLE IS NEW EXHAUST FANS ON ROOF HOWEVER NO |
| | ELECTRICAL INFORMATION COULD BE LOCATED NEXT TO UNIT. |
| | EF-1, EF-3, CIRCUIT NUMBERS? DISCONNECTS? |
| | 408.4, 220,310.16, 430.102 |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | IMPORTANT** |
| | IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT |
| | TYPED IN A CLEAR MANNER PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO |
| | CONTACT THIS REVIEWER. |
| | |
| | DEWEY PALMER |
| | ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II |
| | CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT |
| | CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH |
| | 561-805-6717 |
| | [email protected] |
| | |
