| Date |
Text |
| 2008-10-15 17:08:18 | |
| | ** DENIED REVIEW** |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE APPLIED ADDRESS IS AT 1600 N. |
| | FLORIDA MANGO HOWEVER THE PLANS INDICATE 1590 SAME |
| | ROAD. THE PACKAGE WILL BE ROUTED TO ADDRESSING FOR AN |
| | EXTENSION FOR THIS TENANT SPACE. AS THE APPLIED SCOPE |
| | OF WORK IS BEING SHOWN WHAT APPEARS TO BE IN MULTIPLE |
| | TENANT SPACES THE APPLIED ADDRESS IS UNCLEAR AND THERE |
| | ARE SEVERAL UNANSWERED QUESTIONS. |
| | |
| | 2) NOTE: PLEASE BE SURE THE PLANS CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING |
| | DESIGN CODES AT A MINIMUM. THE FLORIDA STATUTES 553.73 |
| | GIVES THE ADOPTION OF THE LATEST CODES THROUGH THE |
| | FLORIDA BUILDING CODE. IN ANY CASE SEE THE FP SHEETS AS |
| | THESE CLEARLY STATE THE SOUTH FLORIDA BUILDING CODE |
| | WHICH HAS NOT BEEN AN ADOPTED CODE IN THE STATE OF |
| | FLORIDA FOR MANY YEARS. |
| | THE FOLLOWING SHALL BE LISTED AT A MINIMUM FOR THIS |
| | REVIEWER. PLEASE BE AWARE OF OTHER CODES FROM OTHER |
| | TRADES. |
| | 2004 FBC W/2007 REVISIONS. |
| | 2003 NFPA-101 |
| | 2002 NFPA-72 |
| | 2005 NFPA-70 |
| | 2002 NFPA-110 |
| | |
| | 3) NOTE: THE PLANS ARE UNCLEAR FOR THE SCOPE OF WORK. |
| | IS THIS ONE BUILDING WITH THREE TENANT SPACES OR ARE |
| | THESE THREE SEPARATE BUILDINGS? PLEASE KNOW THE SERVICE |
| | FOR INSTANCE FOR THE NUMBER OF SERVICES, GROUPING OF |
| | MAINS ETC CAN NOT BE DETERMINED AS CODE COMPLIANT AT |
| | THIS TIME. 230.2, 230.70, 230.70, 230.72, 230.76, |
| | 230.79 ETC |
| | PLEASE SEE THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE FOR DEFINITIONS OF |
| | A BUILDING INCLUDING THE DEFINITIONS FOR THE NEXT |
| | COMMENT WITH RESPECT TO THE ENERGY CALCULATIONS. |
| | |
| | 4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE SUBMITTED ENERGY CALCULATIONS |
| | ARE NOT CODE COMPLIANT. PLEASE SEE THERE WILL BE SOME |
| | EXAMPLES NOTED HOWEVER IT IS NOT A COMPLETE LIST OF ALL |
| | INCONSISTENCIES. IT IS ALSO IMPORTANT TO SEE COMMENTS |
| | FROM OTHER TRADES WITH RESPECT TO ALL BUILDING |
| | COMPONENTS. SOME WILL BE NOTED IN THIS REVIEW FOR |
| | EXAMPLES. |
| | THE SUBMITTED VERSION IS METHOD *A* FOR WHOLE BUILDING |
| | COMPLIANCE. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE? BASED ON PLANS THIS |
| | IS A RENOVATION TOT AN EXISTING BUILDING WHICH MEETS |
| | THE DEFINITIONS IN SECTION 202 OF CHAPTER 13. WHOLE |
| | BUILDING COMPLIANCE MAY ONLY BE USED *IF* ALL SYSTEMS |
| | FOR THE ENTIRE BUILDING IS BEING USED AND KNOWN. PLEASE |
| | SEE 13-101.1.3 RENOVATIONS. |
| | RENOVATED COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS SHALL, WHEN APPLICABLE |
| | (SEE SECTION 202), COMPLY WITH THE PRESCRIPTIVE |
| | REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED IN FORM 400C OR WITH METHOD B OF |
| | SUBCHAPTER 13-4 FOR INSULATION, HVAC SYSTEMS, LIGHTING, |
| | WATER HEATING SYSTEMS AND EXTERIOR ENVELOPE COMPONENTS |
| | BEING RETROFITTED OR REPLACED. |
| | PLEASE SEE THE INPUT DATA REPORT WHICH DOES NOT |
| | COORDINATE WITH THE SUBMITTED PLANS. SOME EXAMPLES WILL |
| | BE GIVEN AND THE INPUT DATA REPORT WILL BE NOTED AS IDR |
| | IN COMMENTS. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: HOW IS IT POSSIBLE THAT THE METHOD OF |
| | CONTROL FOR ALL LIGHTING BE SHOWN AS MANUAL ON/OFF WHEN |
| | THE PLANS CLEARLY SHOW AUTOMATED SYSTEMS AS REQUIRED |
| | PER 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2, .1.3 |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: PLEASE BE SURE ALL INTERIOR LIGHTS ARE THE |
| | SAME ON THE IDR AS ON THE PLANS FOR THE SAME WATTAGE, |
| | NUMBER OF FIXTURES AND TYPES. PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE |
| | 13-415.2, 13-415.2.ABC.1.1, .1.2 AND .1.3. PLEASE SEE |
| | TABLE 13-415.2.B, 13-415.2.C. PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE |
| | NOTE ABOVE FOR METHOD OF CALCULATIONS TO BE SUBMITTED. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: SEE OTHER COMPONENTS SUCH AS THE FLOOR OF |
| | THE ICE RINK ITSELF BEING SHOWN WITH *CARPET AND RUBBER |
| | PADDING*. THIS IS NOT POSSIBLE. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: THE IDR SHOWS *NO* EXTERIOR DOORS FROM |
| | CONDITIONED SPACE WHEN THE PLANS CLEARLY CONTAINS |
| | SEVERAL. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL ROOMS SHOWING*CARPET |
| | AND RUBBING PADDING* WHEN THE ELECTRICAL ROOMS ARE NOT |
| | PERMITTED TO CONTAIN COMBUSTIBLES. SEE COMMENTS FROM |
| | OTHER TRADES ON THIS. |
| | |
| | 5) NOTE: BASED ON THE PLANS SUBMITTED THIS GENERATOR |
| | WILL BE A LIFE SAFETY REQUIRED NEC 700 SYSTEM YET THERE |
| | ARE OTHER WIRING ITEMS ON THIS SAME PANEL, EQUIPMENT |
| | AND ATS WHICH ARE NOT LEGALLY REQUIRED AND ARE OPTIONAL |
| | STAND-BY. PLEASE SEE NEC 700.9 FOR WIRING REQUIRED AS |
| | OTHER SYSTEMS SHALL NOT BE PART OF THE EMERGENCY/LIFE |
| | SAFETY REQUIRED SYSTEMS. NO INFORMATION WAS SUBMITTED |
| | FOR THE ON-SITE REQUIRED FUEL PER 700.12B3 AND |
| | 701.11B3. THERE ARE MANY OTHER SECTIONS INCLUDING |
| | SECTIONS OF NFPA-110 WHICH ALSO APPLY HOWEVER NOT EVERY |
| | POSSIBLE CODE SECTION IS LISTED. |
| | PLEASE SEE THERE WAS NO INFORMATION SUBMITTED FOR |
| | MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT SHEETS OF THE ATS, GENERATOR AND |
| | FUEL TANKS. PLEASE SUBMIT. PLEASE SEE NFPA-110 2002, |
| | NEC 110.3,90.7 ETC |
| | ** PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE NFPA-110 CHAPTER 7 FOR |
| | INSTALLATION REQUIREMENTS. |
| | ** THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS NOT SUBMITTED. AS THIS UNIT |
| | IS BEING SHOWN AS A 700,701 SYSTEM ALL THE ABOVE AND |
| | CODE MUST BE MET. |
| | |
| | 6) NOTE: IT IS BEING NOTED WITH RELEVANCE TO THE NOTE |
| | #56 ABOVE; IF THE INTENT IS FOR THE BUILDING TO BE |
| | OCCUPIED UNDER EMERGENCY POWER THEN BATTERY BACK UP |
| | LIGHTS WILL BE REQUIRED FOR ALL EGRESS PATHS. THE |
| | OCCUPIED BUILDING WOULD BE THEN UNDER EMERGENCY POWER |
| | FOR A *NORMAL OCCUPANCY*. IF THE EMERGENCY GENERATOR IS |
| | THEN LOST THERE WOULD BE NOT EGRESS LIGHTING FOR ANY |
| | OCCUPANCY PUBLIC OR OTHER WISE TO FIND THEIR WAY OUT OF |
| | THE BUILDING. IF THE BUILDING IS NOT GOING TO BE |
| | OCCUPIED UNDER GENERATOR POWER THIS OFFICE WILL |
| | REQUIRED AN ORIGINAL LETTER SIGNED, NOTARIZED FROM THE |
| | NEW BUILDING OWNER STATING THE BUILDING WILL NOT BE |
| | OCCUPIED UNDER EMERGENCY POWER. THIS WILL BE |
| | ENFORCEMENT FROM THIS OFFICE AS WELL AS THE FIRE |
| | MARSHAL OFFICE. |
| | NFPA-101 7.8.1, 7.9.1ETC |
| | THE OTHER OPTION WOULD BE TO INSTALL THE BATTERY BACK |
| | UP LIGHTS FOR MINIMUM EGRESS UNDER AN EMERGENCY |
| | CONDITION AND THE GENERATOR WOULD BECOME AN OPTIONAL |
| | STAND-BY SYSTEM. SEE THE FOLLOWING TWO COMMENTS AS |
| | THESE WILL ALSO AFFECT THE DESIGN. |
| | |
| | 7) NOTE: PLEASE PROVIDE THE SELECTIVE COORDINATION |
| | STUDY FOR ALL EMERGENCY EQUIPMENT ON BOTH THE NORMAL |
| | AND EMERGENCY SIDE OF THE EMERGENCY SYSTEM AS SHOWN. |
| | PLEASE SEE 240.12,700.27, 701.18, NFPA-110 CHAPTER 6, |
| | 6.5. |
| | |
| | 8) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT PHOTO-METRICS FOR STAIRS TO |
| | INDICATE THE MINIMUM LEVELS UNDER NORMAL AND EMERGENCY |
| | CONDITIONS. THE NORMAL LEVELS REQUIRE A MINIMUM OF 10FT |
| | CANDLES AND IS PERMITTED TO 1 FT CANDLE UNDER EMERGENCY |
| | CONDITIONS. |
| | NFPA-101 7.8.1.3 , 709.2.1, .2.2 |
| | |
| | 9) NOTE: PLEASE SEE FBC 106.1.3 AS THE SUBMITTED PLANS |
| | SHALL MEET A MINIMUM OF 1/8INCH SCALE. MAY SHOW A |
| | LARGER VIEW OF THE ENTIRE LAYOUT AS LONG AS ALL AREAS |
| | ARE SHOWN ON A SEPARATE SHEET IN A LARGER VIEW MEETING |
| | THE MINIMUM SCALE. |
| | |
| | 10) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 240.13, 230.95 FOR THE REQUIRED |
| | GROUND FAULT PROTECTION. PLEASE ALSO BE AWARE AS THE |
| | CODE REQUIRES GROUND FAULT SENSING IN 700.7D, 700.26 |
| | AND NFPA-110 IN CHAPTER 6, 6.2.15 |
| | THE ATS WOULD BE A 4-POLE UNIT OTHER WISE THERE WOULD |
| | BE A LACK OF COORDINATION. |
| | THIS WOULD BE A SEPARATELY DERIVED SYSTEM. |
| | ** NOTE #6 ABOVE AND WHETHER OR NOT THIS IS A LIFE |
| | SAFETY GENERATOR WILL HAVE AN AFFECT ON THIS COMMENT. |
| | |
| | 11) NOTE: PLEASE SEE TRANSFORMER TWA WHICH IS SHOWING A |
| | NEUTRAL BEING INSTALLED ON THE LINE SIDE? |
| | PLEASE SEE 250.20,250.30 ETC |
| | |
| | 12) NOTE: PLEASE PROVIDE A GROUNDING ELECTRODE RISER |
| | FOR THE ATTACHMENT OF ALL TRANSFORMERS. |
| | 250.66,250.58,250.56. AS THE SERVICE AND INFORMATION ON |
| | THE ACTUAL BUILDING IS NOT KNOWN AT THIS TIME THIS MAY |
| | AFFECT THE SERVICE AS SHOWN. |
| | |
| | |
| | 13) NOTE: PLEASE SEE FBC 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2 AND |
| | .1.3. PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE PROPOSED |
| | LIGHTING CONTROL SYSTEM. TIMES OF OVER RIDES, LOCATIONS |
| | OF OVER RIDES, ETC. PLEASE BE SURE TO SEE THESE |
| | SECTIONS AS THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS REQUIRED NOT SHOWN. |
| | OCCUPANT MUST SEE ALL LIGHTING BEING OVER RIDDEN. |
| | |
| | 14) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 700.12F FOR CIRCUITING OF |
| | EMERGENCY LIGHTING. THIS IS BASED ON NOTES ABOVE FOR |
| | REQUIRE BATTERY BACK UP FIXTURES. |
| | |
| | 15) NOTE: PLEASE SEE FBC 11-4.28.1,.2 AND .3. PLEASE |
| | PROVIDE ALL MINIMUM LEVELS FOR ADA COMPLIANCE INCLUDING |
| | HEIGHTS, LEVELS OF DEVICES ETC. |
| | |
| | 16) NOTE: ELECTRICAL SITE PLANS ARE MISSING MINIMUM |
| | DESIGN FOR FBC 140MPH 3 SECOND GUST/120 MPH SUSTAINED. |
| | PLEASE SUBMIT. THIS WILL BE UNDER THE STRUCTURAL REVIEW |
| | ONCE SUBMITTED. |
| | |
| | 17) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 225.31-225.39 FOR DISCONNECTING |
| | MEANS REQUIRED FOR THE FEEDERS FROM THE GENERATOR. AS |
| | THE DISCONNECTING MEANS WILL NOT BE READILY ACCESSIBLE |
| | BASED ON POSSIBLE ZONING COMMENTS; A DISCONNECTING |
| | MEANS (NOT WITH OVER CURRENT PROTECTION) WILL BE |
| | REQUIRED. |
| | |
| | ** AS THERE ARE SEVERAL UNANSWERED COMMENTS AND |
| | INFORMATION NOT YET SHOWN, SUBMITTED OR IN DESIGN THERE |
| | MAY VERY WELL BE NEW COMMENTS ON THE FOLLOWING REVIEW |
| | WHICH CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME. |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | **IMPORTANT** |
| | ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP |
| | FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE |
| | ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED |
| | SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. |
| | DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS. |
| | PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY |
| | ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS, |
| | SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO |
| | TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC. |
| | PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS |
| | SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE. |
| | THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID |
| | ANY DELAYS. |
| | |
| | |
| | IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT |
| | TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO |
| | CONTACT THIS REVIEWER. |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | DEWEY PALMER |
| | ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II |
| | CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT |
| | CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH |
| | 561-805-6717 |
| | [email protected] |
| | |
