| Date |
Text |
| 2008-08-05 08:08:25 | |
| | **DENIED 3RD REVIEW** |
| | |
| | ** PLEASE SEE SOME COMMENTS FROM THE PREVIOUS REVIEW |
| | ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING. PLEASE ALSO SEE SOME |
| | NEW COMMENTS BASED ON CHANGES MADE TO PLANS AND THE |
| | NEED FOR COORDINATION. |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW THE THREE SETS OF PLANS ARE NOT |
| | COMPLETE AND ARE MISSING TWO ELECTRICAL SHEETS FROM ONE |
| | SET. THIS PROJECT ONLY REQUIRES TWO SETS AND UP TO |
| | THREE MAY BE STAMPED HOWEVER THE THIRD SET NEEDS TO BE |
| | COMPLETE BEFORE IT COULD BE STAMPED. AS PLANS ARE |
| | COMING BACK FOR OTHER ELECTRICAL COMMENTS AND |
| | CORRECTIONS PLEASE EITHER COMPLETE THE THIRD SET OR |
| | REMOVE FROM SUBMITTING. |
| | |
| | 2) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETED ENERGY CALCULATIONS |
| | WITH AN INPUT DATA REPORT WHICH COORDINATES WITH PLANS. |
| | THE INPUT DATA REPORT WILL BE NOTED AS IDR FOR THE |
| | REMAINDER OF THIS REVIEW. |
| | THESE SECTIONS OF CODE APPLY. 13-415.2, |
| | 13-415.2.ABC.1.1,.1.2 AND .1.3. 13-400.A.3, 13-101.1.1 |
| | (AT A MINIMUM). |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE THE EXTERIOR LIGHTING ON PLANS ARE GREATER |
| | THAN THAT OF THE INFORMATION ON THE IDR.THE 250W |
| | FIXTURES ARE HIGHER ON PLANS. THE 175W WALL FIXTURES |
| | ARE HIGHER ON PLANS. IF COMMENTS WERE BASED ON THESE |
| | FIXTURES ONLY, THIS WOULD NOT CONSTITUTE AS A GROSS |
| | ERROR AS STATED IN THE CODE. HOWEVER SEE COMMENTS |
| | BELOW. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE FIXTURE LEGEND AS THIS SHOWS TYPE TT |
| | FIXTURE(S) YET COULD NOT LOCATE ANY OF THESE ON PLANS? |
| | THE FIXTURE LEGEND LIST THIS FIXTURE IN CONFERENCE ROOM |
| | BASED ON PLANS THIS WAS NOT SHOWN. PLEASE ALSO SEE THE |
| | FIXTURE LEGEND LIST 201WATTS FOR THIS TYPE OF FIXTURE |
| | YET THE IDR DOES LIST ANY 201W FIXTURE OR 200W |
| | FIXTURE. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SEVERAL LOCATIONS WHICH THE LIGHTING METHOD |
| | OF CONTROL INDICATE *MAN ON/OFF* YET THIS CAN NOT BE |
| | POSSIBLE WHEN THE CODE REQUIRES AUTOMATED DEVICES AND |
| | THE PLANS DO SHOW AUTOMATED DEVICES. ROOMS/AREAS/SPACES |
| | 247,248,260,255 ETC ETC. |
| | SOME LOCATIONS OF LIGHT FIXTURES ON PLANS SUCH AS *NL* |
| | FOR NIGHT LIGHTS WOULD STATE THE MANUAL ON/OFF YET |
| | THERE ARE LOCATIONS IN WHICH THE LIGHTING IS BEING |
| | AUTOMATICALLY CONTROLLED. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE THERE ARE TWO SPACES 255. EACH SHOWING |
| | SEPARATE FIXTURE COUNTS AND YET NEITHER COORDINATE WITH |
| | PLANS. ALSO EACH SHOWING MANUAL ON/OFF. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE THERE ARE TWO SPACES 219. EACH SHOWING |
| | SEPARATE FIXTURE COUNTS AND YET NEITHER COORDINATE WITH |
| | PLANS. ALSO EACH SHOWS MANUAL ON/OFF. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 202, PLANS SHOW 8 FIXTURES, THE IDR |
| | SHOWS 6. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEESPACE 234 WHICH INDICATES 1-67WATT FIXTURE |
| | YET BASED ON THE FIXTURE NOTED ON PLANS AND THE |
| | INFORMATION ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND THIS SHOULD BE 134 |
| | WATTS TOTAL. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: PLEASE SEE SPACE 233 WHICH INDICATES 1-67 |
| | WATT FIXTURE YET BASED ON TYPE OF FIXTURE ON PLANS |
| | WHICH CORRELATES WITH THE FIXTURE LEGEND THE FIXTURE |
| | LEGEND CALLS FOR 134WATTS. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 266 AS PLANS INDICATES 5 OR 6 FIXTURES |
| | DEPENDING ON SPACE LINES AND THE IDR SHOWS ONLY ONE |
| | FIXTURE. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 267 AS THE PLANS SHOWS ONE FIXTURE AND |
| | THE IDR SHOW MORE. WHICH DESIGN WILL BE USED? |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE IDR NO SPACE 221 COULD BE LOCATED THEREFORE |
| | NO FIXTURE AS SHOWN ON PLANS IS IN THE IDR. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 101 ON PLANS. THE PLANS CALL FOR |
| | 4-TYPE *D* FIXTURES WHICH ARE 52WATTS BASED ON LEGEND |
| | YET THE IDR DOES NOT CONTAIN ANY 52WATT FIXTURES FOR |
| | THIS SAME ARE. |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 101 ON PLANS. THE PLANS CALL FOR |
| | 12-TYPE *C* 50.4W FIXTURE BASED ON LEGEND YET THE IDR |
| | DOES NOT INDICATE ANY OF THESE 50W FIXTURES. |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 134.THE IDR SHOWS 28 WATT FIXTURES |
| | YET THE PLANS DO NOT INDICATE ANY OF THESE FIXTURES? |
| | |
| | FOR EXAMPLE: |
| | PLEASE SEE SPACE 141 AS THE IDR INDICATES 1-67 YET |
| | PLANS INDICATES 2. |
| | |
| | ** AS GIVEN ON PREVIOUS REVIEW THESE ARE EXAMPLES AND |
| | IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST. THIS CONSTITUTES AS GROSS |
| | ERRORS BOTH ON FACT THERE ARE MORE FIXTURES AND WATTAGE |
| | ON PLANS NOT IN THE IDR AND THE IDR SHOWING FIXTURES |
| | WHICH ARE NOT ON PLANS. THE LIGHTING ON PLANS AND |
| | CALCULATIONS NEED TO COORDINATE. |
| | |
| | 3) NOTE: PLEASE INDICATE MAXIMUM TIMES FOR ALL DEVICES. |
| | PLEASE KNOW THE SYMBOL LEGEND MAY STATE THE MAXIMUM |
| | TIMES FOR OCCUPANCY SENSOR TYPE DEVICES. THE OVER RIDES |
| | AS NOTED ON THE LIGHTING CONTROL PLANS DO SHOW THE |
| | 30MINS MAX AS REQUIRED PER 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2. |
| | |
| | 4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE ROOM/AREA 248 WHICH SHOWS A FIXTURE |
| | *E* FOR EMERGENCY HOWEVER BY THE FIXTURE LEGEND NO |
| | BATTERY BACK UP IS NOTED ON LEGEND. |
| | ON PREVIOUS REVIEWS THE EMERGENCY FIXTURES HAVE CHANGED |
| | YET SOME OF THESE ARE STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING THE |
| | MINIMUM FOR THE LIFE SAFETY CODE. RESPONSE MENTIONS A |
| | NOTE WAS GOING TO BE ADDED TO PLANS FOR THE 100% BACK |
| | UP OF LUMENS ON FIXTURES HOWEVER THIS NOTE COULD NOT BE |
| | LOCATED. SINCE THE EMERGENCY LEVELS OF PHOTO-METRICS |
| | WERE NOT PROVIDED THE NOTES IS REQUIRED OR PROVIDE |
| | LEVELS UNDER EMERGENCY POWER/BACK UP. |
| | 7.8.1.3, 7.9.1.2, 7.9.2.2 |
| | |
| | 5) NOTE: PLEASE SEE SOME ITEMS N RISER WITH PANEL |
| | SCHEDULES STILL NEED TO COORDINATE. |
| | SOME EXAMPLES ARE NOTED. |
| | |
| | PLEASE SEE PANEL 1H1. THE MDP LIST 4/0 YET THE RISER |
| | NOTE FOR THESE FEEDERS INDICATE 3/0. |
| | PLEASE SEE PANEL 1LEQ WHICH SHOWS 225AMP MCB ON RISER |
| | YET THE PANEL SHOWS A 200AMP MCB. |
| | PLEASE SEE 1HL ON RISER WHICH INDICATES A FEED TO PANEL |
| | 2HL YET THE PANEL SCHEDULE FOR 1HL DOES NOT LIST ANY |
| | BRANCH CIRCUIT TO THE PANEL 2HL. |
| | 310.16, 240.4, 408.4 ETC |
| | FBC 106.3.5.1.2, 106.1.1 FOR CLARITY AND COORDINATION. |
| | |
| | 6) NOTE: THE PREVIOUS REVIEW GAVE NOTICE TO FS |
| | 553.80(2)(B) WITH RESPECT TO REPEAT COMMENTS FOR CODE |
| | COMPLIANCE. EVEN AS THERE ARE SEVERAL CODE SECTIONS |
| | REPEATED, BASED ON THE CHANGE IN THE METHOD OF ENERGY |
| | CALCULATIONS THE CALCULATIONS ARE NOT THE SAME. THE |
| | NEXT REVIEW HOWEVER WILL BE THE THIRD REVIEW OF SAID |
| | METHOD *A*. THIS FEE HAS NOT BEEN ASSESSED HOWEVER IF |
| | CALCULATIONS COME BACK IN ON THE NEXT REVIEW WITHOUT |
| | COORDINATION WITH PLANS THIS REVIEWER WILL HAVE NO |
| | CHOICE TO ASSESS FEE OF FOUR TIMES THE PLAN REVIEW FEE |
| | AS STATED IN STATUTE ABOVE. THIS IS A STATUTORY |
| | REQUIREMENT. |
| | THIS FEE OF $18,632.79 WOULD BE THE AMOUNT ASSESSED. |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | IMPORTANT** |
| | ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP |
| | FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE |
| | ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED |
| | SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. |
| | DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS. |
| | PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY |
| | ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS, |
| | SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO |
| | TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC. |
| | PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS |
| | SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE. |
| | THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID |
| | ANY DELAYS. |
| | |
| | DEWEY PALMER |
| | ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II |
| | CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT |
| | CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH |
| | 561-805-6717 |
| | [email protected] |
| 2008-08-04 17:00:34 | 2008-08-04 17:01:34 |
| | NOTES TO FOLLOW ON 8/5 |
