| Date |
Text |
| 2008-02-06 19:23:23 | 2008-02-06 19:23:23 |
| | |
| | ** DENIED REVISIONS FOR THIRD REVIEW ** |
| | |
| | CLARKES HOTEL |
| | REVISIONS FROM PREVIOUS PERMITTED 5 STORY TO 8-STORY |
| | HIGH RISE. |
| | |
| | ** PLEASE SEE MANY NOTES FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW ARE STILL |
| | IN NEED OF ADDRESSING. |
| | PLEASE SEE SOME NEW COMMENTS BASED ON NEW SUBMITTED |
| | DOCUMENTS NOT PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW. PLEASE |
| | SEE SOME OF THE SAME EXACT SHEETS THIS REVIEWER |
| | PERSONALLY REDLINED FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW WERE SUBMITTED |
| | BACK IN NEW SETS WITHOUT ANY CHANGES. |
| | THIS REVIEWER HAS PLACED DIRECT PHONE NUMBER AND E-MAIL |
| | ADDRESS ON ALL PREVIOUS REVIEWS AND NO CONTACT WAS MADE |
| | TO GO OVER ANY OF THESE ITEMS SINCE THE LAST REVIEW. |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE:AS REQUESTED ON ALL PREVIOUS REVIEWS:PLEASE |
| | SUBMIT ALL THE MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT SHEETS FOR ALL OF |
| | THE FOLLOWING. PLEASE SUBMIT FOR; FIRE PUMP, FIRE PUMP |
| | CONTROLLER, GENERATOR, FUEL TANK. (SEENOTES BELOW), |
| | ATS EQUIPMENT (SEENOTES BELOW). 110.3, 90.7.PLEASE |
| | KNOW AT THIS TIME THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS WHICH REMAIN |
| | UNANSWERED FOR REQUIRED CODE ITEMS AND COORDINATION OF |
| | PLANS WITH OUT THESE ITEMS. |
| | PLEASE SEE THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS IN NFPA-110 AND |
| | NFPA-20 WHICH CAN NOT BE REVIEWED FOR COMPLIANCE AND |
| | COORDINATION WITHOUT THESE DOCUMENTS BEING SUBMITTED. |
| | |
| | 2) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON ALL PREVIOUS REVIEW:PLEASE |
| | SUBMIT COMPLETE PHOTO-METRICS FOR ALL EGRESS PATHS |
| | WHICH MEET THE MINIMUM LIFE SAFETY CODE7.8.1.3, |
| | 7.9.2.2. THE MINIMUM LEVELS UNDER THE THESE SECTIONS |
| | REQUIRE 10FT CANDLE MIN FOR STAIRS UNDER NORMAL AND 1FT |
| | CANDLE UNDER EMERGENCY. |
| | PLEASE SEE FOR EXAMPLE EGRESS STAIRS A SPECIFICALLY |
| | MENTIONED ON PREVIOUS REVIEWS WHICH STILL SHOW LESS |
| | THAN THE MINIMUM OF 10FT CANDLES UNDER NORMAL. PLEASE |
| | SEE SHEET E-4A WHICH IS THE SAME EXACT SHEET WHICH WAS |
| | PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED. THIS SHEETS STILL CONTAINS |
| | REDLINES BY REVIEWER ALONG WITH NEW REDLINES TO HELP |
| | RESOLVE. |
| | PREVIOUS REVIEW ALSO MENTIONED TO SHOW LEVELS UNDER |
| | BOTH EMERGENCY AND NORMAL. |
| | PREVIOUS REVIEWS ALSO REQUESTED COORDINATION BETWEEN |
| | FIXTURES FROM THE PHOTO-METRICS TO LIGHTING PLANS FOR |
| | FIXTURE TYPES. FOR EXAMPLE: PLEASE SEE THE SAME EXACT |
| | SHEETS FOR SHEET E-1 WERE SUBMITTED BACK WITH THIS |
| | REVIEWERS SAME REDLINED FIXTURES WHICH CLEARLY SHOW HE |
| | AND DE FIXTURES ON LIGHTING PLANS AND YET THE SAME |
| | SHEET FOR THE SAME FIXTURES ON THE PHOTO-METRICS |
| | INDICATE FE AND EE FIXTURES. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE? |
| | WHICH FIXTURES ARE PROPOSED? |
| | PLEASE SEE FAC 61G15-33.004. THIS SECTION OF THE |
| | FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE IS WITH RESPECT TO MINIMUM |
| | REQUIREMENTS FOR LIGHTING DESIGN BY THE ENGINEERING |
| | PROFESSIONAL. |
| | |
| | 3) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW BASED ON THE NEW ELECTRICAL DATA |
| | SUBMITTED FOR THE PARKING LIFT SYSTEM, ALL EQUIPMENT |
| | MUST BE LISTED ASSEMBLY. THE DOCUMENTS CLEARLY STATE UL |
| | LISTED COMPONENTS OR PARTS, HOWEVER COULD NOT LOCATE |
| | ANY LISTING FOR SYSTEM CONTROL PANELS ETC. |
| | PLEASE SUBMIT LISTED SYSTEM DOCUMENTS OR KNOW THE |
| | SYSTEM WILL BE REQUIRED TO BE LISTED BY A NRTL( |
| | NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED TESTING LABORATORY) BEFORE FINAL. |
| | THIS WOULD INCLUDE ALL INSTALLED AT RISK WITH *PROVISO* |
| | TO OBTAIN LISTINGS. |
| | 110.3 |
| | |
| | 4) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES THE |
| | LIGHTNING PROTECTION SYSTEM NOTED ON PLANS WILL BE |
| | REQUIRED TO BE SUBMITTED UNDER SEPARATE PLANS AND |
| | PERMIT. |
| | ALL WORK SHALL BE PER NFPA-780 AND MASTER LABEL SHALL |
| | ALSO BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE CITY FOR RECORD PLANS. |
| | |
| | 5) NOTE: PLEASE SEE NO REVISED FBC ENERGY CALCULATIONS |
| | WERE SUBMITTED AS REQUIRED PER FBC CHAPTER 13. PLEASE |
| | KNOW AS THE FIXTURES HAVE CHANGED AND ENERGY |
| | CONSUMPTION HAS CHANGED, THIS WILL AFFECT THE |
| | STRUCTURE. PLEASE SUBMIT THESE ENERGY CALCULATIONS |
| | BASED ON THE 2001 CODE WHICHIS WHAT THIS PROJECT IS |
| | PERMITTED UNDER. |
| | FBC CHAPTER 13, 13-400.1.A, 13-415.2 ETC |
| | |
| | 6) NOTE: PLEASE VERIFY THE SMOKE DEVICES IN UNITS ARE |
| | IN FACT SMOKE DETECTORS AS SHOWN OR SMOKE ALARMS PER |
| | NFPA-72. PLANS CAME BACK STILL SHOWING THESE AS SMOKE |
| | DETECTORS. IF THESE DEVICES DETECT SMOKE AND SOUND AN |
| | ALARM FROM THE UNIT ITSELF THEN THIS IS A SMOKE *ALARM* |
| | AND NOT DETECTOR. A SMOKE DETECTOR ONLY DETECTS AND |
| | DOES NOT SOUND AN ALARM. BASED ON PLANS AND DESIGN, IF |
| | THESE WERE SMOKE DETECTORS, EACH UNIT WOULD REQUIRE A |
| | FIRE ALARM PANEL. |
| | PLEASE CALL TO GO OVER THIS IF THERE ARE STILL ANY |
| | QUESTIONS. |
| | |
| | 7) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON ALL PREVIOUS REVIEWS: PLEASE |
| | SUBMIT THE REVISED FIXTURE SCHEDULE/LEGEND WHICH IS NOT |
| | ON ELECTRICAL PLANS. PLEASE BE SURE TO COORDINATE ALL |
| | INFORMATION ON THE FIXTURE LEGEND WITH THAT OF THE |
| | INPUT DATA REPORT ON UPDATED ENERGY CALCULATIONS TO BE |
| | SUBMITTED. |
| | ORIGINAL PLANS CLEARLY DID CONTAIN THE INFORMATION AND |
| | WAS REMOVED. |
| | FBC CHAPTER 13, NFPA-101, NFPA-70 ETC |
| | FBC 104.1.2 |
| | |
| | 8) NOTE:THIS NOTE IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY: PLEASE |
| | KNOW BASED ON THE OCCUPANCY USE AT THIS TIME NEWLY |
| | PASSED HOUSE BILL 7121 DOES NOT APPLY HOWEVER GIVEN |
| | INFORMATION AT THIS TIME IF THE USE WAS TO CHANGE FROM |
| | HOTEL TO CONDOS, THEN HB 7121 WOULD APPLY. |
| | THIS IS ONLY NOTED FOR INFORMATION ONLY AND NO CHANGE |
| | NEEDS TO MADE TO PLANS FOR CURRENT USE. |
| | |
| | 9) NOTE: AS STATED ON THE PREVIOUS REVIEW:PLEASE SEE |
| | NFPA-110 CHAPTER 7,7.2.3 FOR MIN ELEVATION REQUIRED |
| | FOR ALL EPSS EQUIPMENT INCLUDING GEN. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE MIN LEVELS FOR "SLOSH" ( SEA, LAKE, |
| | OVERLAND , SURGES, BY HURRICANES) CHARTS BASED ON A CAT |
| | 4 STORM OR THE 100YR ELEVATION ON PLANS. |
| | THE RESPONSE MENTIONS, BUILDING LOCATED ABOVE FLOOD |
| | LEVEL. PLEASE KNOW HOWEVER THE MINIMUM LEVEL FOR EPSS |
| | EQUIPMENT BASED ON THE CHARTS NOTED ABOVE NEEDS TO BE |
| | STATED AND SHOWN ON PLANS. PLEASE SEE NO ELEVATIONS ON |
| | ELECTRICAL PLANS FOR LIFE SAFETY EQUIPMENT IS BEING |
| | SHOWN. (FIRE PUMP ON MEZZANINE LEVEL IS NOT NEEDED) AS |
| | THIS IS A GIVEN DUE TO ITS LOCATION. |
| | SAME NOTE: |
| | |
| | 10) NOTE:PLEASE SEE THE GROUNDING ELECTRODE FOR THE |
| | FIRE PUMP SERVICE HAS NOW BEEN REMOVED?? |
| | PREVIOUS NOTE WAS WITH RESPECT TO THE SIZE OF THE |
| | GROUNDING ELECTRODE CONDUCTOR BEING TOO SMALL AND NOW |
| | IT CAN NOT BE LOCATED? |
| | PLEASE ALSO SEE THE FEEDER SCHEDULE INDICATES AN |
| | *EQUIPMENT GROUNDING CONDUCTOR* NOW FROM THE FPL |
| | TRANSFORMER TO THE FIRST MEANS OF DISCONNECT WHICH IS |
| | NOT PERMITTED PER 250.6 AND 250.24. |
| | PLEASE CALL TO GO OVER THIS SCENARIO IN ORDER TO MAKE |
| | THE NEEDED ADJUSTMENTS. |
| | PLEASE SEE 250.50, 250.66 ETC |
| | |
| | 11) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE FUEL TANK IS NOW SHOWN AS 400 |
| | GALLONS ON THE FUEL CALCULATIONS AND 500 GALLONS ON |
| | RISER UNDER GENERATOR? |
| | WHICH ONE IS IT? |
| | PLEASE SEE NOTES ABOVE WITH RESPECT TO THE SUBMISSION |
| | OF MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT SHEETS. |
| | FBC 104.1.2 FOR COORDINATION OF PLANS. |
| | |
| | 12) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE FP SHEETS SHALL STATE THE CODE |
| | RELEVANT FOR DESIGN. THIS COULD BE REDLINED IF THIS WAS |
| | THE ONLY COMMENT ON SHEET FP-1 THIS SHOULD REFLECT 1999 |
| | NFPA-20 ( CAN NOT BE LATEST EDITION AS THERE IS MOST |
| | CERTAINLY ONE NEW NFPA-20ALREADY ADOPTED BY THE STATE |
| | AND WILL HAVE ANOTHER NEW CODE ADOPTED BY THE STATE |
| | BEFORE FINAL. |
| | |
| | 13) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEWS: THIS |
| | COMMENT WILL REMAIN AS THE INFORMATION WHICH WILL BE |
| | SUBMITTED ON GENERATOR WILL CONFIRM AVAILABLE FAULT |
| | CURRENT ON THE GENERATOR. THE LEVELS ON THE MANUFACTURE |
| | SPECS/CUT SHEETS WILL ALSO BE REVIEWED. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE ALL AIC RATINGS FOR ALL EQUIPMENT, ATS, |
| | DISCONNECTS ETC. PLEASE SEE 701.6, NFPA-20 6-3.2.2.4, |
| | 110.9, 240.12 ETC. PLEASE SEE NFPA-110 6.5.2 ETC. |
| | PLEASE BE SURE ALL EQUIPMENT/MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT |
| | SHEETS SHOWS THIS COORDINATION. |
| | THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THIS COMMENT IS THE |
| | SELECTIVE COORDINATION REQUIRED FOR LIFE SAFETY SYSTEMS |
| | AS NOTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW PER 240.12 OF THE NEC AND |
| | OTHER SECTIONS OF NFPA-110 ETC |
| | PLEASE SUBMIT THE SELECTIVE COORDINATION STUDY FOR THE |
| | REQUIRED AND LIFE SAFETY SYSTEMS. |
| | FAC 61G15-33.003 |
| | FBC 104.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. |
| | |
| | 14) NOTE:PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS REVIEWS REQUESTED THE |
| | MINIMUM LEVELS FOR ADA COMPLIANCE WITH RESPECT TO HORN |
| | AND STROBE LEVELS. THE PLANS DO NOT SHOW ALL LEVELS, |
| | HOWEVER SYMBOL LEGEND WAS REVISED FOR STROBE LEVELS. |
| | THE NOTES HOWEVER FOR HORN AND SOUND LEVELS STATE |
| | LEVELS SHALL MEET NFPA-72. THIS IS TRUE TO A POINT AS |
| | THEY ARE REQUIRED TO MEET THE MINIMUM LEVELS PER |
| | NFPA-72 HOWEVER THE LEVELS PER THE FBC ARE MORE |
| | RESTRICTIVE WHICH WOULD APPLY. |
| | PLEASE ADJUST LEVELS AND NOTES. |
| | SECTIONS GIVEN IN PREVIOUS REVIEWS: PLEASE PROVIDE ALL |
| | MINIMUM AUDIBLE AND VISUAL LEVELS PER FBC 2001 11-4.28, |
| | 11-4.28.2 AND MOST IMPORTANT 11-4.28.3(4). ALL AREA AS |
| | STATED IN 11-4.28.1 SHALL BE NOTED AND INCLUDED. |
| | |
| | 15) NOTE: PLEASE KNOW A RESPONSE LETTER FROM DESIGN |
| | TEAM IS NOT REQUIRED HOWEVER DOES HELP IN THE REVIEW |
| | PROCESS. AS CONTACT WAS NOT MADE WITH THIS OFFICE SINCE |
| | LAST REVIEW PLEASE SEE NOTE BELOW. |
| | |
| | AS STATED ON THE PREVIOUS REVIEW: |
| | PLEASE BE SURE TO CALL IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS OR |
| | COMMENTS WITH RESPECT TO THE TYPED COMMENTS ABOVE. IF |
| | THERE ARE ANY COMMENTS WHICH ARE NOT CLEAR IN ANY WAY, |
| | NOT UNDERSTOOD OR NOT TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR, PLEASE DO |
| | NOT HESITATE IN CONTACTING THIS OFFICE AND THIS |
| | REVIEWER. |
| | |
| | * ** IMPORTANT** |
| | ONCE ALL REVIEWS ARE DONE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP FOR |
| | CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE ALL |
| | OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED SHEETS |
| | INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. DO NOT |
| | LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS. |
| | PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS |
| | SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE. |
| | THIS WILL HELP IN THE REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID ANY |
| | DELAYS. |
| | |
| | |
| | DEWEY PALMER |
| | ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II |
| | CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPT. |
| | CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH |
| | 561-805-6717 |
| | [email protected] |
