| Date |
Text |
| 2007-09-17 16:51:24 | **** NOTE ADDED*** |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE: PLEASE SEE FBC 2001, CHAPTER 13, |
| | 415.1.ABCD.1.1.4 FOR REQUIRED MISSING MASTER LIGHTING |
| | CONTROL SWITCH. |
| | ** PLEASE SEE LIGHTING PERFORMANCE CALCULATIONS IN |
| | 13-415.2 |
| | PLEASE SEE ALL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE 2001 FBC CHAPTER 13 |
| | WHICH ARE REQUIRED TO BE MET. |
| | |
| | THIS COMMENT WAS NOT MADE ON PREVIOUS REVIEW HOWEVER IT |
| | IS REQUIRED OF THE DESIGN TEAM TO MEET THE MINIMUM |
| | REQUIREMENTS OF THE FBC. |
| 2007-08-24 18:00:11 | 2007-08-24 18:00:11 |
| | |
| | *** DENIED2ND REVIEW OF REVISIONS *** |
| | |
| | *** PLEASE SEE SOME COMMENTS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW ARE |
| | STILL IN NEED OF ADDRESSING ALONG WITH NEW COMMENTS |
| | BASED ON SOME INFORMATION ON REVISED PLANS. |
| | |
| | ** REVIEW FOR REVISION OF CLARKES HOTEL FROM 5-STORIES |
| | TO 8 STORIES. |
| | |
| | ** PLEASE KNOW THAT AT THIS TIME THERE IS NOT ENOUGH |
| | INFORMATION SUBMITTED FOR A COMPLETE REVIEW FOR CODE |
| | COMPLIANCE AS THE BUILDING HAS NOW BEEN CLASSIFIED AS A |
| | HIGH-RISE. |
| | PLEASE SEE SOME ITEMS WERE NOT SUBMITTED AS PREVIOUSLY |
| | REQUESTED FOR REVIEW. |
| | |
| | |
| | 1) NOTE:THIS IS THE SAME NOTE AS SOME SHEETS STILL |
| | ONLY INDICATE LESS REVISIONS THAN THE PROJECT HAS |
| | PLEASE SEE THAT ALL REVISIONS ON PLANS SHALL BE DATED, |
| | CLOUDED/TRIANGLE NOTATIONS ACCORDINGLY. PLEASE SEE |
| | DATES AND REVISION NUMBERS SHOW A REV #1, HOWEVER THIS |
| | HAS BEEN REVISED AT LEAST THREE OR FOUR TIMES. HOW IS |
| | THIS FIRST REVISION?? |
| | |
| | 2) NOTE: PLEASE CLARIFY HOW SHEET E-3 BE TYPICAL FOR |
| | ALL FLOORS WHEN THE FLOOR PLAN LAYOUT FOR THE |
| | ELECTRICAL ROOMS ARE DIFFERENT. THE LARGER ROOMS WOULD |
| | INDEED AFFECT THE FLOOR PLANS FOR LAYOUTS OF WALLS, |
| | SPACES ETC. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE EACH. |
| | FBC 104.1.2 |
| | |
| | 3) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON THE PREVIOUS REVIEW:PLEASE |
| | SUBMIT ALL THE MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT SHEETS FOR ALL OF |
| | THE FOLLOWING. PLEASE SUBMIT FOR; FIRE PUMP, FIRE PUMP |
| | CONTROLLER, GENERATOR, FUEL TANK. (SEENOTES BELOW), |
| | ATS EQUIPMENT (SEENOTES BELOW). 110.3, 90.7 PLEASE |
| | KNOW AT THIS TIME THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS WHICH REMAIN |
| | UNANSWERED FOR REQUIRED CODE ITEMS AND COORDINATION OF |
| | PLANS WITH OUT THESE ITEMS. |
| | |
| | 4) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW: |
| | PLEASE SUBMIT COMPLETE PHOTO-METRICS FOR ALL EGRESS |
| | PATHS. (ALL CORRIDORS AND STAIR TOWERS) PLEASE SEE |
| | LS-1017.8.1.3, 7.9.2.2 10FT CANDLE MIN FOR STAIRS UNDER |
| | NORMAL AND 1FT CANDLE UNDER EMERGENCY. |
| | PLEASE SEE THERE ARE SEVERAL STAIR AREAS WHERE NO |
| | PHOTO-METRIC LEVELS WERE SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW. PLEASE |
| | ALSO SEE THAT THE COMMENT REQUESTED THE LEVELS UNDER |
| | NORMAL AND UNDER EMERGENCY. |
| | PLEASE SEE SOME STAIR AREAS WHICH SHOW LEVELS ARE UNDER |
| | THE MINIMUM AS REQUIRED PER THE LIFE SAFETY CODE UNDER |
| | NORMAL. |
| | PLEASE SUBMIT THESE FOR ALL EGRESS PATHS TO THE PUBLIC |
| | RIGHT OF WAY AWAY FROM BUILDING. |
| | ** EXAMPLE: PLEASE SEE STAIRS FROM MEZZANINE LEVEL TO |
| | REAR OF BUILDING ON E-2, PLEASE SEE ROOF PLANS FROM |
| | POOL AREA WHICH CONTAINS STAIRS HOWEVER NO LEVELS WERE |
| | SHOWN. |
| | ** IMPORTANT: PLEASE SEE NOW THE PHOTO-METRICS HAVE |
| | BEEN SUBMITTED AND FIGURED SHOWING DIFFERENT FIXTURES |
| | THAN THAT ON PLANS FOR THE SAME LOCATIONS. |
| | FE, IS HE ETC. |
| | FAC 61G15-33.004 |
| | |
| | 5) NOTE:THIS NOTE REMAINS AS IT IS NOT KNOWN WHETHER |
| | OR NOT PLANS AND PERMITTING FOR GARAGE WILL BE REQUIRED |
| | AT THIS TIME. |
| | PLEASE SEE ZONING COMMENTS, PLEASE SEE IF A GARAGE IS |
| | NOW REQUIRED, THIS WILL COMPLETELY CHANGE ELECTRICAL |
| | SERVICE AND ELECTRICAL SHEETS SUBMITTED. |
| | |
| | 6) NOTE: PLEASE VERIFY THE SMOKE DEVICES IN UNITS ARE |
| | IN FACT SMOKE DETECTORS AS SHOWN OR SMOKE ALARMS PER |
| | NFPA-72. |
| | PLEASE SEE AS SHOWN WITH THE 120V POWER AND IF THERE |
| | ARE DETECTION AND SOUNDING DEVICES THESE WOULD IN FACT |
| | BE *SD* FOR SMOKE ALARMS. |
| | PLEASE KNOW THAT A STATEMENT WAS ISSUED FROM NFPA THAT |
| | THESE DEVICES SHALL BE CLEARLY IDENTIFIED FOR USE AND |
| | THE GENERAL ACCEPTANCE OF USING SD FOR ACTUAL SMOKE |
| | ALARMS SHOULD BE ADDRESSED. |
| | |
| | 7) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW: PLEASE SEE |
| | ALL FIXTURE SCHEDULE AND TYPE INFORMATION WHICH WAS ON |
| | PREVIOUS PLANS HAS BEEN REMOVED FOR EM FIXTURES? PLEASE |
| | SEE ALL OF THE FOLLOWING IN ORDER TO REVIEW FOR CODE |
| | COMPLIANCE SHALL BE PLACED BACK ON PLANS. |
| | LS 101. |
| | THE RESPONSE MENTIONS THIS WAS NOT DONE, HOWEVER PLEASE |
| | SEE THE ORIGINAL PERMITTED SETS OF PLANS CLEARLY |
| | INDICATE THIS SCHEDULE/LEGEND ON SHEET E1. |
| | PLEASE SEE THE FIXTURE LEGEND ON SHEET E-6 DOES NOT |
| | CLEARLY INDICATE THE BATTERY BACK UP FOR CERTAIN |
| | FIXTURES WHICH WAS INDICATE ON LEGEND ON PREVIOUS |
| | PLANS. |
| | PLEASE SEE COMMENT #4 ABOVE WITH RESPECT TO THE |
| | DIFFERENCES ON PLANS IF LIGHTING FIXTURES. |
| | |
| | 8) NOTE:AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW: |
| | PLEASE SEE THAT NOW THAT A GENERATOR IS INSTALLED AND |
| | REQUIRED AND USE IS TO A HIGH-RISE, PLEASE SEE NFPA-20 |
| | 6-6.2 AS THE MINIMUM FUEL REQUIRED FOR FIRE PUMP IS |
| | 8HRS AT 100%, AND 5% FOR EXPANSION AND 5% FOR SUMP. |
| | PLEASE SEE TANK AS SHOWN AND FUEL CALCULATIONS CAN NOT |
| | VERIFIED AS NO INFORMATION WAS SUBMITTED. |
| | ** PLEASE SEE THE RESPONSE LETTER GIVES SOME |
| | INFORMATION HOWEVER ALSO STATES 30GALLONS PER MINUTE |
| | FOR USE. |
| | PLEASE KNOW THE CALCULATIONS FOR CONSUMPTION NEEDS TO |
| | BE SHOWN ON PLANS. |
| | PLEASE SEE COMMENTS BELOW AS THE SIZE OF THE FIRE PUMP |
| | DOES NOT COORDINATE ON PLANS. PLEASE ALSO BE AWARE THAT |
| | THE INFORMATION ON MANUFACTURES SPECS/CUT SHEETS HAS |
| | NOT BEEN SUBMITTED TO CONFIRM OR COORDINATE WITH |
| | PLANS. |
| | |
| | 9) NOTE: THIS REMAINS: PLEASE SEE NFPA-20 CHAPTER 6 AND |
| | 7 FOR FIRE PUMP, ASTHERE ARE TOO MANY SECTIONS TO BE |
| | LISTED FOR ITEMS NEEDED FOR REVIEW. |
| | PLEASE SEE THAT BESIDES THE MISSING MANUFACTURES |
| | SPECS/CUT SHEETS, PLEASE SEE THE RISER SHEETS SHOWS TWO |
| | DIFFERENT SIZES OF FIRE PUMPS, TWO DIFFERENT SIZES OF |
| | OVER CURRENT PROTECTION OF MAINS ETC. |
| | VERIFICATION OF SEVERAL ITEMS CAN NOT BE DONE AT THIS |
| | TIME. (CONDUCTORS, OVER CURRENT PROTECTION, CORRECT |
| | GROUNDING (SEE COMMENT BELOW) CONDUIT SIZES, ISOLATION |
| | SWITCHES ETC. |
| | ** IMPORTANT, SEE COMMENT WITH RESPECT TO THE GENERATOR |
| | BEING NOTED AS BEING A *SEPARATELY DERIVED SYSTEM* |
| | WHICH WOULD REQUIRE THE FIRE PUMP CONTROLLER ATS TO BE |
| | FOUR POLE. |
| | |
| | 10) NOTE: AS STATED ON THE PREVIOUS REVIEW:PLEASE SEE |
| | NFPA-110 CHAPTER 7,7.2.3 FOR MIN ELEVATION REQUIRED |
| | FOR ALL EPSS EQUIPMENT INCLUDING GEN. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE MIN LEVELS FOR "SLOSH" ( SEA, LAKE, |
| | OVERLAND , SURGES, BY HURRICANES) CHARTS BASED ON A CAT |
| | 4 STORM OR THE 100YR ELEVATION ON PLANS. |
| | THE RESPONSE MENTIONS, BUILDING LOCATED ABOVE FLOOD |
| | LEVEL. PLEASE KNOW HOWEVER THE MINIMUM LEVEL FOR EPSS |
| | EQUIPMENT BASED ON THE CHARTS NOTED ABOVE NEEDS TO BE |
| | STATED AND SHOWN ON PLANS. PLEASE SEE NO ELEVATIONS ON |
| | ELECTRICAL PLANS FOR LIFE SAFETY EQUIPMENT IS BEING |
| | SHOWN. (FIRE PUMP ON MEZZANINE LEVEL IS NOT NEEDED) AS |
| | THIS IS A GIVEN DUE TO ITS LOCATION. |
| | |
| | 11) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE GROUNDING ELECTRODE SHOWN FOR |
| | THE FIRE PUMP SERVICE IS TOO SMALL BASED ON 250.66. |
| | PLEASE ADJUST. (SHOWN AS #4 ON E-7) |
| | |
| | 12) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE SIZE OF THE FIRE PUMP |
| | CONTROLLER ON E-7 SHOWN AS 800AMPS AND 500AMPS? PLEASE |
| | CORRELATE WITH THE UPDATED SIZE OF THE NEW FIRE PUMP. |
| | FBC 104.1.2 FOR COORDINATION. |
| | |
| | 13) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE NOTE BELOW THE GENERATOR |
| | CLEARLY STATES THE GENERATOR WILL BE A SEPARATELY |
| | DERIVED SYSTEM, YET IF THIS IS THE CASE, THE OTHER NOT |
| | ON THE GROUNDING ELECTRODE AT GENERATOR STATES ONLY |
| | GROUND TO CASE WHICH DOES NOT CONFIRM OR CORRELATE WITH |
| | THE SEPARATELY DERIVED NOTE. |
| | PLEASE ALSO KNOW IF INDEED THIS IS A SDS, PLEASE ADJUST |
| | RISER AS ALL ATS EQUIPMENT WILL NEED TO BE FOUR POLES. |
| | 250.20,250.30 ETC |
| | |
| | 14) NOTE: AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW: THIS COMMENT |
| | WILL REMAIN AS THE INFORMATION WHICH WILL BE SUBMITTED |
| | ON GENERATOR WILL CONFIRM AVAILABLE FAULT CURRENT ON |
| | THE GENERATOR. THE LEVELS ON THE MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT |
| | SHEETS WILL ALSO BE REVIEWED. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE ALL AIC RATINGS FOR ALL EQUIPMENT, ATS, |
| | DISCONNECTS ETC. PLEASE SEE 701.6, NFPA-20 6-3.2.2.4, |
| | 110.9, 240.12 ETC. PLEASE SEE NFPA-110 6.5.2 ETC. |
| | PLEASE BE SURE ALL EQUIPMENT/MANUFACTURE SPECS/CUT |
| | SHEETS SHOWS THIS COORDINATION. |
| | |
| | 15) NOTE: THIS NOTE REMAINS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTE |
| | #18. |
| | PLEASE SEE MISSING A DISCONNECTING MEANS REQUIRED FOR |
| | THE FEEDERS COMING FROM THE GENERATOR TO MEET |
| | 701.11(B)5. |
| | ** PLEASE SEE THAT THE RESPONSE MENTIONS THE GENERATOR |
| | MEETS THE EXCEPTION, HOWEVER KNOWN TO THIS OFFICE IS |
| | THE REQUIREMENTS FROM ZONING WHICH WILL NEED A |
| | WALL/SCREENING AROUND THE UNIT ON ALL FOUR SIDES. THIS |
| | WOULD ALSO LOCK THE BREAKER ON THE INSIDE OF THE UNIT |
| | WHICH WOULD NOT BE READILY ACCESSIBLE. |
| | PLEASE SEE THAT BREAKERS SOMETIMES MAY BE USED, HOWEVER |
| | THEY MAY NOT |
| | |
| | 19) NOTE: AS REQUESTED FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW: PLEASE |
| | PROVIDE DETAIL FOR VERTICAL CONDUCTOR SUPPORTS PER |
| | 300.19(A). |
| | ** RESPONSE LETTER MENTIONS TO SEE DETAIL ON E-7, |
| | HOWEVER NO DETAIL COULD BE LOCATED ON THIS SHEET AS |
| | REFERENCED. |
| | |
| | 20) NOTE:THIS NOTE REMAINS FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTE |
| | #21. |
| | PLEASE PROVIDE ALL MINIMUM AUDIBLE AND VISUAL LEVELS |
| | PER FBC 2001 11-4.28, 11-4.28.2 AND MOST IMPORTANT |
| | 11-4.28.3(4). ALL AREA AS STATED IN 11-4.28.1 SHALL BE |
| | NOTED AND INCLUDED. THIS COMMENT WAS NEVER UNDER |
| | ELECTRICAL REVIEW SCOPE ON PREVIOUS REVIEWS UNTIL |
| | RECENTLY. |
| | ** RESPONSE LETTER MENTIONS TO SEE REVISED NOTES ON |
| | FA-5 WHICH WAS LOCATED HOWEVER THE PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTE |
| | REQUESTED ALL MINIMUM LEVELS TO BE STATED ON LEGEND FOR |
| | THE REQUIRED DEVICES. PLEASE SEE THE DEVICES STILL DO |
| | NOT INDICATE THE LEVELS. |
| | PLEASE KNOW THAT QUOTING THE CODE SECTIONS IN LIEU OF |
| | THE REQUIRED DETAIL FOR CONSTRUCTION AND DESIGN IS NOT |
| | ACCEPTABLE AND MUST SHOW DESIGN DETAIL. |
| | |
| | 21) NOTE:AS REQUESTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTE #22. |
| | PLEASE INCLUDE A NOTE ON ROOF TOP PLANS WHICH WILL |
| | STATE THAT "ANY LIGHTNING PROTECTION SYSTEM TO BE |
| | INSTALLED SHALL MEET NFPA-780" OR WORDS TO THAT AFFECT. |
| | A SYSTEM IS NOT REQUIRED, HOWEVER THE NOTE IS, AS THERE |
| | ARE MANY SYSTEMS BEING "PROMOTED AND SOLD" IN THE STATE |
| | OF FLORIDA WHICH ARE STRICTLY NOT PERMITTEDAND MANY |
| | KNOWN SYSTEMS ARE ACTUALLY A HEALTH AND LIFE SAFETY |
| | HAZARD. PLEASE SEE ONLY IF IN NFPA-780. |
| | ** PLEASE KNOW THERE ARE SEVERAL ITEMS NOT YET SHOWN, |
| | CLARIFIED OR SUBMITTED. AS STATED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW |
| | THERE MAY VERY WELL BE NEW COMMENTS ON THE FOLLOWING |
| | REVIEW ONCE THE COMPLETED PLANS ARE SUBMITTED. |
| | ** RESPONSE LETTER MENTIONS THIS WAS ADDED TO NOTES ON |
| | SHEET E-4 HOWEVER THIS WAS NOT LOCATED ON THIS SHEET |
| | AND NOTE COULD NOT BE FOUND. |
| | PLEASE COMPLETE. |
| | |
| | AS STATED ON THE PREVIOUS REVIEW: |
| | PLEASE BE SURE TO CALL IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS OR |
| | COMMENTS WITH RESPECT TO THE TYPED COMMENTS ABOVE. IF |
| | THERE ARE ANY COMMENTS WHICH ARE NOT CLEAR IN ANY WAY, |
| | NOT UNDERSTOOD OR NOT TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR, PLEASE DO |
| | NOT HESITATE IN CONTACTING THIS OFFICE AND THIS |
| | REVIEWER. |
| | |
| | DEWEY PALMER |
| | ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II |
| | CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPT. |
| | CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH |
| | 561-805-6717 |
| | [email protected] |
| 2007-08-24 07:54:55 | 2007-08-24 07:54:55 |
| | REVIEW IN PROGRESS |
| 2007-08-14 13:41:04 | 1-SET IN ELEC FOR REVIEW. |
