Plan Review Details - Permit 21040258
Plan Review Stops For Permit 21040258
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 6 Status N Date 2021-10-04 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-10-04 Time 07:57 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-10-04 Time 07:57 Sent To  
Notes
2021-10-04 07:58:30THESE DRAWINGS ARE MECHANICAL DRAWINGS - ARCHITECTURAL
 DRAWINGS TO BE REVISED
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 5 Status F Date 2021-09-16 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-09-16 Time 14:12 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-09-16 Time 14:12 Sent To  
Notes
2021-09-16 14:13:00REVISION
 REVIEWED BY ROGER MCPHERSON
 561-805-6716
 [email protected].
 CODE USED FOR REVIEW - 2020 FBC WITH WPB CHAPTER 1
 AMENDMENTS
  
 CORRECTIONS NEEDED -
 1) DRAWINGS SHOW THAT WALLS HAVE BEEN REVISED TO SHOW
 ROOMS TO BE FIRE RATED - PLEASE PROVIDE THE PERMIT
 NUMBER THAT SHOWS THESE FIRE RATED WALL REVISIONS ON
 THE LIFE SAFETY PLANS.
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status F Date 2021-08-17 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-08-17 Time 07:53 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-08-17 Time 07:53 Sent To  
Notes
2021-08-17 07:54:02REVISION
 REVIEWED BY ROGER MCPHERSON
 561-805-6716
 [email protected].
 CODE USED FOR REVIEW - 2020 FBC WITH WPB CHAPTER 1
 AMENDMENTS
  
 CORRECTIONS NEEDED -
 1) DRAWINGS SHOW THAT WALLS HAVE BEEN REVISED TO SHOW
 ROOMS TO BE FIRE RATED - PLEASE PROVIDE THE PERMIT
 NUMBER THAT SHOWS THESE FIRE RATED WALL REVISIONS ON
 THE LIFE SAFETY PLANS.
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2021-07-27 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-07-27 Time 13:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-07-27 Time 13:10 Sent To  
Notes
2021-07-27 13:19:59REVISION
 REVIEWED BY ROGER MCPHERSON
 561-805-6716
 [email protected].
 CODE USED FOR REVIEW - 2020 FBC WITH WPB CHAPTER 1
 AMENDMENTS
  
 CORRECTIONS NEEDED -
 1) DRAWINGS SHOW THAT WALLS HAVE BEEN REVISED TO SHOW
 ROOMS TO BE FIRE RATED - PLEASE PROVIDE THE PERMIT
 NUMBER THAT SHOWS THESE FIRE RATED WALL REVISIONS ON
 THE LIFE SAFETY PLANS.
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2021-07-09 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-07-09 Time 08:30 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-07-09 Time 08:30 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2021-05-20 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-05-20 Time 10:45 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-05-20 Time 10:45 Sent To  
Notes
2021-05-20 10:46:08MECHANICAL DRAWINGS
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2021-08-06 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2021-08-06 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2021-08-06 Time 12:11 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2021-07-16 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2021-07-16 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2021-07-16 Time 13:16 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2021-05-07 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2021-05-07 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2021-05-07 Time 09:25 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status P Date 2021-04-23 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2021-04-23 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2021-04-21 Time 13:19 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 7 Status N Date 2021-10-04 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-10-04 Time 07:58 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-09-29 Time 08:24 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 6 Status N Date 2021-09-20 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-09-20 Time 07:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-09-07 Time 16:09 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 5 Status N Date 2021-08-19 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-08-19 Time 14:16 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-08-03 Time 10:19 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 4 Status N Date 2021-07-27 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-07-27 Time 13:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-07-15 Time 11:58 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2021-07-09 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-07-09 Time 08:30 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-06-30 Time 16:21 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2021-05-20 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-05-20 Time 10:46 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-04-28 Time 10:07 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2021-04-23 Cont ID  
Sent By lmarchan Date 2021-04-23 Time 15:16 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lmarchan Date 2021-04-12 Time 12:36 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 7 Status P Date 2021-09-30 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-09-30 Time 09:54 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-09-30 Time 09:54 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 6 Status F Date 2021-09-20 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-09-20 Time 07:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-09-20 Time 07:40 Sent To  
Notes
2021-09-20 07:41:296TH REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) SHEET AFS-12: THE NEW FIRE RATED ROOM ON THE 4TH
 FLOOR HAVE SEVERAL MECHANICAL DUCTS PENETRATING THE
 RATED WALLS, PLEASE PROVIDE THE CORRECT PROTECTION FOR
 EACH DUCT PENETRATION OF THE RATED WALLS. FBC M 607
  
 2) THE RESPONSE FOR THE MAKE UP AIR FROM ERIK GONZALEZ
 DOES NOT MEET THE CODE. PLEASE PROVIDE MAKE UP AIR PER
 FMC 508.1.1.
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 5 Status F Date 2021-08-19 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-08-19 Time 14:16 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-08-18 Time 10:50 Sent To  
Notes
2021-08-19 14:15:595TH REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) SHEETS AFS-13 AND AFS-14: THE CLOUDED AREA WHERE THE
 GREASE DUCT EXHAUST FAN IS LOCATED REFERENCES FMC
 506.1.2.1 THIS REVIEWER CAN NOT FIND THIS CODE SECTION
 IN EITHER THE 2014 FBC M OR THE 2020 FBC M. PLEASE
 PROVIDE THE CORRECT CODE REFERENCE. PLEASE REMEMBER
 THIS PROJECT IS BEING REVIEWED AND INSPECTED UNDER THE
 2014 FBC M.
  
 2) IS THE POOL HOOD EXHAUST DUCT EXHAUSTING AGAINST A
 WALL?
  
 3) SHEET AFS-12: THE SEPARATE DETAIL SECTIONS FOR
 KEF-1, KEF-2 AND KEF-3 ALL SHOW THE FIRE WRAP STOPPING
 AT THE FLOOR OF THE RATED ROOM AND THEN STARTING BACK
 AGAIN AT THE CEILING. THESE DUCTS MUST BE WRAPPED TO
 THE EXHAUST FAN AND START AGAIN AT THE EXHAUST OUTLET
 OF THE FAN. FBC M 506.3.11.2
  
 4) PLEASE PROVIDE THE VENTILATION INSTRUCTIONS FROM THE
 GREASE DUCT FAN MANUFACTURER?S INSTRUCTIONS. FBC M
 506.5.1.2
  
 5) THE REVISIONS TO THE MECHANICAL AND BUILDING DESIGN
 FOR THE HOOD SYSTEMS MUST BE SUBMITTED BEFORE THE HOOD
 SYSTEMS CAN BE APPROVED. FBC 107.2.1
  
 6) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE REMOVE THE NOTES STATING THE
 FIRE WRAP IS NOT REQUIRED IN THE MECHANICAL ROOM AS
 THIS INFORMATION IS INCORRECT AND WE DO NOT WANT
 INCONSTANT INFORMATION IN THE FIELD. FBC M 506.3.11.2
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 4 Status F Date 2021-07-27 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-07-27 Time 07:38 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-07-26 Time 16:47 Sent To  
Notes
2021-07-27 07:39:004TH REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) IN REFERENCE TO YOUR RESPONSE TO COMMENT 1 OF THE
 3RD CYCLE REVIEW: THE 2014 FBC M DOES NOT MENTION AN
 INLINE FAN EXCEPT TO SAY THEY SHALL HAVE A CLEAN OUT ON
 BOTH THE INLET AND OUTLET SIDES. THE INLINE FANS BEING
 IN A RATED ROOM IS ONLY REFERENCED IN THE 2020 FBCM. IF
 YOU ARE WANTING TO USE THE 2020 FBC M INSTEAD OF THE
 2014 FBC M THAT THE ORIGINAL PROJECT WAS PERMITTED
 UNDER YOU WILL NEED TO APPLY THE 2020 FBC M TO THE
 ENTIRE DESIGN AND SUBMIT IT AS AN ALTERNATE MEANS AND
 METHOD TO OUR CBO FOR REVIEW.
  
 2) IN REFERENCE TO YOUR RESPONSE TO COMMENTS 2 & 4 OF
 THE 3RD CYCLE REVIEW: AGAIN, THIS CODE SECTION IS NOT
 IN THE 2014 FBC M. SECTION 506.3.11.2 REQUIRES THE
 SURFACE OF THE DUCT SHALL BE CONTINUOUSLY COVERED ON
 ALL SIDES FROM THE POINT AT WHICH THE DUCT ORIGINATES
 TO THE OUTLET TERMINAL. THE SECOND PART OF THIS IS THE
 LOCATION OF THE FANS- 506.5.1.2 IN-LINE FAN LOCATION.
 WHERE ENCLOSED DUCT SYSTEMS ARE CONNECTED TO IN-LINE
 FANS NOT LOCATED OUTDOORS, THE FAN SHALL BE LOCATED IN
 A ROOM OR SPACE HAVING THE SAME FIRE-RESISTANCE RATING
 AS THE DUCT ENCLOSURE. ACCESS SHALL BE PROVIDED FOR
 SERVICING AND CLEANING OF FAN COMPONENTS. SUCH ROOMS OR
 SPACES SHALL BE VENTILATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FAN
 MANUFACTURER?S INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS. THESE ARE 2
 SEPARATE SECTIONS, 506.3.11.2 TELLS US THAT THE FIELD
 APPLIED DUCT FIRE WRAP MUST BE CONTINUOUS FROM START TO
 FINISH ON THE GREASE DUCT ONLY. SECTION 506.5.1.2 TELLS
 US ? WHERE ENCLOSED DUCT SYSTEMS ARE CONNECTED TO
 IN-LINE FANS ( WHICH MEANS THE DUCT WRAP IS CONNECTED
 TO THE GREASE DUCT THAT IS CONNECTED TO THE IN-LINE
 FAN) THE FAN SHALL BE LOCATED IN A FIRE-RESISTANT RATED
 ROOM OR SPACE WITH THE SAME RATING AS THE FIELD APPLIED
 FIRE WRAP. SO THE FIRE WRAP MUST INCLUDE ALL OF THE
 GREASE DUCT. SECTION 506.3.11.2 IS ALLOWING THE FAN TO
 BE IN A RATED ROOM OR SPACE AND NOT HAVE TO BE WRAPPED
 ITSELF.
  
  
 3) IN REFERENCE TO YOUR RESPONSE TO COMMENT 5 OF THE
 3RD CYCLE REVIEW: PLEASE SUBMIT THIS REVISION OF THE
 AIR BALANCE SCHEDULE ONCE IT HAS BEEN ADJUSTED. FBC
 107.2.1
  
 4) IN REFERENCE TO YOUR RESPONSE TO COMMENT 6 OF THE
 3RD CYCLE REVIEW: PLEASE SUBMIT THE DOCUMENTATION FOR
 THE MAKE-UP AIR REQUIREMENTS WHEN COMPLETED. FBC
 107.2.1
  
 5) PLEASE PROVIDE THE INLINE FANS SPECIFICATIONS AND
 INSTRUCTION MANUALS. FBC 107.2.1
  
 6) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE SHOW HOW THE TERMINATION DESIGN
 WILL NOT ALLOW WATER TO BLOW INTO THE HOOD EXHAUST
 DUCT. FBC 107.2.1
  
 7) PLEASE UNDERSTAND THAT THE FIELD APPLIED GREASE DUCT
 ENCLOSURE MUST BE INSTALLED PER FBC M 506.3.11.2, THE
 LISTING OF THE PRODUCT AND THE MANUFACTURE?S
 INSTRUCTIONS. YOU CANNOT STOP THE FIELD APPLIED DUCT
 WRAP AT THE FLOOR OF THE 4TH FLOOR AND THEN START IT
 AGAIN AT THE CEILING OF THE 4TH FLOOR. YOU ARE LEAVING
 THE GREASE DUCT EXPOSED WHICH GOES AGAINST THE FBC M
 506.3.11.2.
  
 8) SHEET M-5.0.07: PLEASE SHOW THE REQUIRED PROTECTION
 OF THE PENETRATIONS IN THE NEW FIRE RATED WALLS IN THE
 4TH FLOOR MECHANICAL ROOM AT ALL DUCT PENETRATIONS. FBC
 M 607
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2021-07-08 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-07-08 Time 14:01 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-07-08 Time 10:21 Sent To  
Notes
2021-07-08 14:01:563RD REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) AFTER DOING SO MORE RESEARCH I HAVE DISCOVERED THAT
 THIS PROJECT WAS PERMITTED UNDER THE 2014 FBC M, PLEASE
 FOLLOW THIS EDITION OF OUR MECHANICAL CODE AND ALL
 REFERENCES MUST BE FOR THE 2014 FBC M.
  
 2) THE PIZZA OVEN HAS A TYPE I HOOD INSTALLED ABOVE IT.
 ACCORDING TO SHEET A-1.2.01 OF THE ORIGINAL APPROVED
 PLANS FOR THIS PROJECT THE WALL SEPARATING THE KITCHEN
 FROM THE MANICURE/PEDICURE AREA IS A 2 HOUR RATED WALL.
 THE GREASE DUCT FROM THE TYPE I HOOD AT THE PIZZA OVEN
 IS PENETRATING THIS 2 HOUR WALL, PLEASE SHOW HOW YOU
 WILL PROTECT THE OPENING. FBC M 506.3.11
  
 3) THE 3 OTHER GREASE DUCTS FOR THE KITCHEN HOODS ARE
 PENETRATING THE 2 HOUR RATED WALL SEPARATING THE
 KITCHEN FROM THE HSKP SHOWN ON A-1.2.01. PLEASE SHOW
 HOW YOU WILL PROTECT THE OPENING. FBC M 506.3.11
  
 4) ALL GREASE DUCT THAT HAS FIELD APPLIED GREASE SHALL
 MEET FBC M 506.3.11.2
  
 506.3.11.2 FIELD-APPLIED GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE.
 COMMERCIAL KITCHEN GREASE DUCTS CONSTRUCTED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 506.3.1 SHALL BE ENCLOSED BY
 FIELD APPLIED GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE THAT IS A LISTED
 AND LABELED MATERIAL, SYSTEM, PRODUCT, OR METHOD OF
 CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICALLY EVALUATED FOR SUCH PURPOSE IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM E 2336.
 THE SURFACE OF THE DUCT SHALL BE CONTINUOUSLY COVERED
 ON ALL SIDES FROM THE POINT AT WHICH THE DUCT
 ORIGINATES TO THE OUTLET TERMINAL. DUCT PENETRATIONS
 SHALL BE PROTECTED WITH A THROUGH-PENETRATION FIRE-STOP
 SYSTEM CLASSIFIED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM E 814 OR UL
 1497 AND HAVING A ?F? AND ?T? RATING EQUAL TO THE
 FIRE-RESISTANCE RATING OF THE ASSEMBLY BEING
 PENETRATED. SUCH SYSTEMS SHALL BE INSTALLED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH THE LISTING AND THE MANUFACTURER?S
 INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS. PARTIAL APPLICATION OF A
 FIELD-APPLIED GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE SYSTEM SHALL NOT BE
 INSTALLED FOR THE SOLE PURPOSE OF REDUCING CLEARANCES
 TO COMBUSTIBLES AT ISOLATED SECTIONS OF GREASE DUCT.
 EXPOSED DUCT-WRAP SYSTEMS SHALL BE PROTECTED WHERE
 SUBJECT TO PHYSICAL DAMAGE.
 5) SHEET M-1.4.02: THE PIZZA HOOD AND THE BATH EXHAUST
 ARE NOT ON THE AIR BALANCE SCHEDULE, PLEASE INCLUDE
 THEM ON AN UPDATED SCHEDULE. FBC 107.2.1
  
 6) PLEASE SHOW THAT THE MAKE UP AIR MEETS THE 10 DEG.
 AIR TEMPERATURE DIFFERENCE FOR THE MAKE UP AIR UNITS.
 FBC M 508.1.1
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2021-05-06 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-05-06 Time 12:50 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-05-06 Time 12:51 Sent To  
Notes
2021-05-06 12:50:242ND REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) IN RESPONSE TO COMMENT #1: THIS DUCT ORIGINATES AT
 THE TYPE I HOOD ABOVE THE PIZZA OVEN. THE SUBMITTED
 DRAWING SHOWS THE ENTIRE DUCT IS ENCLOSED FROM THE HOOD
 TO THE IN-LINE EXHAUST FAN, THEN ENCLOSED AGAIN FROM
 THE OTHER SIDE OF THE IN-LINE FAN TO THE TERMINATION
 LOCATION. ACCORDING TO MASTER PERMIT # 17020796 SHEET
 A-1.2.01 THIS DUCT PASSES THROUGH A 2 HOUR RATED WALL
 SEPARATING THE KITCHEN FROM THE MANICURE/PEDICURE ROOM
 ONCE THE DUCT PENETRATES THE 2 HOUR RATED WALL IT WOULD
 BE REQUIRED TO BE EITHER IN AN ENCLOSURE OR A FIELD
 APPLIED ENCLOSURE (FBC M 506.3.11 LAST SENTENCE STATES
 ? FIRE DAMPERS AND SMOKE DAMPERS
 SHALL NOT BE INSTALLED IN GREASE DUCTS. THE CODE
 SECTION YOU REFERENCED (FBC M 506.3.11) EXCEPTION: A
 DUCT ENCLOSURE SHALL NOT BE REQUIRED FOR A GREASE DUCT
 THAT PENETRATES ONLY A NON-FIRE-RESISTANCE RATED
 ROOF/CEILING ASSEMBLY DOES NOT APPLY TO THIS DUCT AS
 THIS DUCT DOES NOT PENETRATE A NON-FIRE RESISTANCE
 RATED ROOF/CEILING ASSEMBLY BUT DOES PENETRATE A 2-HOUR
 FIRE RATED WALL. THE CODE SECTION I REFERENCED ON THE
 ORIGINAL REVIEW WOULD APPLY AND IS COPIED BELOW FOR
 YOUR REFERENCE.
 506.5.1.2 IN-LINE FAN LOCATION. WHERE ENCLOSED DUCT
 SYSTEMS ARE CONNECTED TO IN-LINE FANS NOT LOCATED
 OUTDOORS, THE FAN SHALL BE LOCATED IN A ROOM OR SPACE
 HAVING THE SAME FIRE-RESISTANCE RATING AS THE DUCT
 ENCLOSURE. ACCESS SHALL BE PROVIDED FOR SERVICING AND
 CLEANING OF FAN COMPONENTS. SUCH ROOMS OR SPACES SHALL
 BE VENTILATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FAN MANUFACTURER?S
 INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS.
  
 2) IN RESPONSE TO QUESTION #2: PLEASE SHOW THE KEF-4
 MEETS ALL OF SECTION ? 506.3.13.2 TERMINATION THROUGH
 AN EXTERIOR WALL?.
  
 ? EXHAUST OUTLETS SHALL BE PERMITTED TO TERMINATE
 THROUGH EXTERIOR WALLS WHERE THE SMOKE, GREASE, GASES,
 VAPORS AND ODORS IN THE DISCHARGE FROM SUCH
 TERMINATIONS DO NOT CREATE A PUBLIC
 NUISANCE OR A FIRE HAZARD. ?
  
 3) IN RESPONSE TO COMMENT #3: IN REFERENCE OF SHEET
 A-1.2.01 OF THE MASTER DRAWINGS IT APPEARS THAT THE
 DUCT WORK FOR HOODS 1, HOOD 2 AND HOOD 3 PENETRATE THE
 2-HOUR FIRE WALL THAT SEPARATES THE KITCHEN FROM HSKP
 BEFORE TURNING UP AND PENETRATING THE SHAFT AND EXITING
 THE SHAFT ON THE 4TH FLOOR IN THE MECHANICAL ROOM. THIS
 DUCT MUST EACH BE ENCLOSED FROM THE HOOD TO THE
 TERMINATION LOCATION AT THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDING.
 FBC M 506.3.11 & 506.3.11.2 SEE BELOW.
  
 506.3.11.2 FIELD-APPLIED GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE.
 GREASE DUCTS CONSTRUCTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION
 506.3.1 SHALL BE ENCLOSED BY A LISTED AND LABELED FIELD
 APPLIED GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE MATERIAL, SYSTEMS,
 PRODUCT, OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICALLY
 EVALUATED FOR SUCH PURPOSE IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
 E2336. THE SURFACE OF THE DUCT SHALL BE CONTINUOUSLY
 COVERED ON ALL SIDES FROM THE POINT AT WHICH THE DUCT
 ORIGINATES TO THE OUTLET TERMINAL. DUCT PENETRATIONS
 SHALL BE PROTECTED WITH A THROUGH-PENETRATION FIRESTOP
 SYSTEM TESTED AND LISTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM E814
 OR UL 1479 AND HAVING A ?F? AND ?T? RATING EQUAL TO THE
 FIRE-RESISTANCE RATING OF THE ASSEMBLY BEING
 PENETRATED. THE GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE AND FIRESTOP
 SYSTEM SHALL BE INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
 LISTING AND THE MANUFACTURER?S
 INSTRUCTIONS. PARTIAL APPLICATION OF A FIELD APPLIED
 GREASE DUCT ENCLOSURE SHALL NOT BE INSTALLED FOR THE
 SOLE PURPOSE OF REDUCING CLEARANCES TO COMBUSTIBLES AT
 ISOLATED SECTIONS OF GREASE DUCT. EXPOSED DUCT-WRAP
 SYSTEMS SHALL BE PROTECTED WHERE SUBJECT TO PHYSICAL
 DAMAGE.
  
 4) IN RESPONSE TO COMMENT 4: THE RATED ROOM THAT THE
 IN-LINE FANS ARE LOCATED MUST BE VENTILATED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH THE FAN MANUFACTURER?S INSTALLATION
 INSTRUCTIONS, PLEASE SHOW THIS ON THE DRAWINGS. FBC M
 506.5.1.2
  
 5) IN RESPONSE TO COMMENT #5, 6 AND 7: THE EOR MUST
 SUBMIT REVISED DRAWINGS FOR THE ORIGINALLY APPROVED
 DRAWINGS SHOWING THE REQUIRED FIRE RATED WALL AND THE
 REQUIRED PROTECTION AT ALL DUCT PENETRATIONS. FBC
 107.2.1
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2021-04-23 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-04-23 Time 09:58 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-04-23 Time 09:58 Sent To  
Notes
2021-04-23 10:41:411ST REVIEW FBC-2020 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT-21040258
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION
 FBC FG- FLORIDA FUEL GAS
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE
 FBC RES- FLORIDA RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CODE
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) SHEET AFS-9 INSTALLATION DETAILS: KEF-4 FAN MUST BE
 LOCATED IN A ROOM OR SPACE RATED WITH THE SAME RATING
 AS THE DUCT WRAP PROTECTION. THE ROOM OR SPACE MUST BE
 VENTILATED PER THE FAN MANUFACTURE?S INSTALLATION
 INSTRUCTIONS. FBC M 506.5.1.2
  
 2) PLEASE SHOW DETAILS OF PROPERTY LINES, BUILDINGS AND
 OPENINGS INTO BUILDINGS ALONG WITH EXTERIOR WALL
 RATINGS WHERE KITCHEN HOOD EXHAUST DUCT TERMINATES
 THROUGH THE EXTERIOR WALLS. FBC M 506.3.13.2 &
 506.3.13.3
  
 3) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE REMOVE STATEMENT ABOUT THE FIRE
 WRAP NOT BEING REQUIRED IN THE ROOM. THE FIRE WRAP
 SHALL START AT THE HOOD AND END AT THE DUCT TERMINATION
 LOCATION AT THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDING. FBC M
 506.3.11.2
  
 4) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE SHOW THE ROOM WITH THE GREASE
 DUCT IN-LINE FANS ARE VENTILATED ACCORDING TO THE FAN
 MANUFACTURE?S INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS. FBC M
 506.5.1.2
  
 5) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE SHOW PROTECTION AT THE RATED
 WALLS WHERE EXHAUST DUCTS PENETRATING THE 2 HR. WALL AT
 THE 4TH FLOOR ROOM.
  
 6) SHEET AFS-12: PLEASE IDENTIFY THE DUCTWORK AND
 LOUVERS INSIDE THE RATED ROOM BESIDE OF THE SHAFT. FBC
 107.2.1
  
 7) PLEASE PROVIDE THE AIR BALANCE SCHEDULE OR REPORT
 FOR EACH BUILDING WITH A KITCHEN, IT MUST INCLUDE THE
 BATHROOM EXHAUST. FBC M 508.1.2
  
  
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM.
  
 MICHAEL EDWARDS
 MECHANICAL EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL. 33401
 561-805-6728
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 6 Status P Date 2021-09-30 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-09-30 Time 09:57 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-09-30 Time 09:57 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 5 Status P Date 2021-09-16 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-09-16 Time 14:15 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-09-16 Time 14:15 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2021-08-17 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcphers Date 2021-08-17 Time 07:59 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcphers Date 2021-08-17 Time 07:59 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2021-07-27 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-07-27 Time 07:43 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-07-27 Time 07:43 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2021-07-08 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-07-08 Time 14:02 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-07-08 Time 14:02 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 1 Status P Date 2021-04-23 Cont ID  
Sent By medwards Date 2021-04-23 Time 10:45 Rev Time 0.00
Received By medwards Date 2021-04-23 Time 10:41 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved