Plan Review Details - Permit 19080446
Plan Review Stops For Permit 19080446
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2020-01-03 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2020-01-03 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2019-12-30 Time 16:23 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2019-12-09 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2019-12-09 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2019-12-09 Time 10:57 Sent To  
Notes
2019-12-09 11:01:47THIS PLAN WAS REVIEWED AND FAILED BY PETER LEDUC, FIRE
 MARSHAL, WITH THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS:
  
  
 1) THE SLS DOCUMENT INDICATES 89 PAGES, ON REVIEW PAGES
 46 THRU 89 ARE BLACK.
  
 PLEASE REVIEW AND CORRECT.
  
  
 2) THERE ARE NO INDICATIONS OF CHANGES TO THE SLS
 DOCUMENT.
  
 ARE THERE CHANGES TO THIS DOCUMENT?
  
 PLEASE PROVIDE PAGE NUMBERS FOR THE CHANGES.
  
  
 3) WHEN RESUBMITTING, PLEASE PROVIDE PLAN SHEET
 REVISION CLOUDS OR NUMBERED NARRATIVE RESPONSES TO THE
 ABOVE.
  
  
 4) ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY BE PROVIDED ON THE
 RE-SUBMITTAL OF THE ABOVE.
  
  
 PETER LEDUC
 FIRE MARSHAL
 561-804-4709
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2019-10-18 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2019-10-18 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2019-10-09 Time 12:28 Sent To I
Notes
2019-10-18 15:24:04PLEASE ADDRESS MECHANICAL COMMENTS AS FIRE IS IN
 AGREEMENT WITH THOSE ITEMS AND WILL NOT BE LISTED
 SEPARATELTY HERE.
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, PLEASE PROVIDE PLAN SHEET REVISION
 CLOUDS OR NUMBERED NARRATIVE RESPONSES TO THE ABOVE.
  
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY BE PROVIDED ON THE RE-SUBMITTAL
 OF THE ABOVE.
  
  
 PETER LEDUC
 FIRE MARSHAL
 561-804-4709
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2019-08-13 Cont ID  
Sent By pleduc Date 2019-08-13 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By pleduc Date 2019-08-13 Time 11:31 Sent To M
Notes
2019-08-13 13:33:48THIS PLAN WAS REVIEWED AND FAILED BY PETER LEDUC, FIRE
 MARSHAL, WITH THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS:
  
 1) THE SUBMITTED PAPERWORK DOES NOT INDICATE WHAT THE
 REVISIONS IS AND WHERE, HOW AND WHY THE REVISIONS TAKE
 PLACE.
  
 BASICALLY, WHAT CHANGED AND WHY? THERE SHOULD BE SOME
 SORT OF NARRATIVE EXPLAINING THE CHANGE.
  
 AM I TO BELEIVE THE ENTIRE DOCUMENT IS THE REVISION?
  
 PER NFPA 1
 1.14 PLAN REVIEW.
 1.14.5 WHEN REQUIRED BY THE AHJ, REVISED CONSTRUCTION
 DOCUMENTS OR SHOP DRAWINGS SHALL BE PREPARED AND
 SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL TO ILLUSTRATE
 CORRECTIONS OR MODIFICATIONS NECESSITATED BY FIELD
 CONDITIONS OR OTHER REVISIONS TO APPROVED PLANS.
 PLEASE SUBMIT PLANS THAT HAVE INDICATIONS WHERE THE
 REVISIONS OR MODIFICATIONS, FROM THE ORIGINAL PLANS,
 ARE LOCATED.
  
  
 2) WHEN RESUBMITTING, PLEASE PROVIDE PLAN SHEET
 REVISION CLOUDS OR NUMBERED NARRATIVE RESPONSES TO THE
 ABOVE.
  
  
 3) ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY BE PROVIDED ON THE
 RE-SUBMITTAL OF THE ABOVE.
  
 PETER LEDUC
 FIRE MARSHAL
 561-804-4709
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 4 Status N Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date 2020-01-06 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By cpuell Date 2019-12-30 Time 08:55 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date 2019-12-12 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By lmarchan Date 2019-12-02 Time 07:59 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2019-10-18 Cont ID  
Sent By lmarchan Date 2019-10-18 Time 15:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lmarchan Date 2019-10-08 Time 10:51 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2019-08-19 Cont ID  
Sent By hmoser Date 2019-08-19 Time 11:08 Rev Time 0.00
Received By hmoser Date 2019-08-08 Time 15:42 Sent To  
Notes
2019-08-09 15:42:51ROUTED TO FIRE INBOX
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2020-01-06 Cont ID  
Sent By ccole Date 2020-01-06 Time 09:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By ccole Date 2020-01-06 Time 09:01 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2019-12-12 Cont ID  
Sent By ccole Date 2019-12-12 Time 12:14 Rev Time 0.00
Received By ccole Date 2019-12-12 Time 12:14 Sent To  
Notes
2019-12-12 12:17:432ND REVIEW FBC-2017 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT #19080446
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE SIXTH EDITION
 2017
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION
 2017
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC SIXTH
 EDITION 2017
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 COMMENTS #1 & 2 FROM THE 1ST REVIEW HAVE NOT BEEN
 COMPLETELY ADDRESSED- SEE BELOW AND COMPLY.
  
 1) PLEASE PROVIDE A REVISON APPLICATION AND A DETAILED
 NARRATIVE TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF WORK RELATING TO THE
 SLS PERFORMANCE BASED SMOKE ANALYSIS.
  
 2) THE SLS PERFORMANCE BASED SMOKE ANALYSIS SHALL EACH
 BE ELECTRONICALLY SIGNED AND SEALED- SECTION
 61G15-23.005 FAC AND SECTION 471.025 FL. STATUTES.
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM ALONG WITH THE CITY
 RE-SUBMITTAL FORM. ADDITIONALLY, PLEASE INSERT
 CORRECTED PLAN SHEETS INTO THE SETS, REMOVE THE
 PREVIOUSLY REVIEWED SHEETS AND MARK VOID ON THEM, AND
 KEEP THEM WITH THE SUBMITTALS.
  
 CHRISTOPHER L. COLE
 MECHANICAL PLANS EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL 33401
 561-805-6719
 [email protected]
  
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2019-10-18 Cont ID  
Sent By hmoser Date 2019-10-18 Time 08:52 Rev Time 0.00
Received By ccole Date 2019-10-11 Time 14:24 Sent To  
Notes
2019-10-18 08:56:521ST REVIEW FBC-2017 MECHANICAL
 PERMIT #19080446
  
 CODES IN EFFECT:
  
 FBC B- FLORIDA BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017
 FBC M- FLORIDA MECHANICAL CODE SIXTH EDITION 2017
 FBC EC- FLORIDA ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE SIXTH EDITION
 2017
 FBC EX- FLORIDA EXISTING BUILDING CODE SIXTH EDITION
 2017
 FS- FLORIDA STATUTES
 FAC- FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 WPB- WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC SIXTH
 EDITION 2017
  
 PLAN REVIEW RESULTS: DENIED.
  
 1) PLEASE PROVIDE A REVISON APPLICATION AND A DETAILED
 NARRATIVE TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF WORK RELATING TO THE
 FLAMEBAR SUBMITTAL AND THE SLS PERFORMANCE BASED SMOKE
 ANALYSIS. IT APPEARS THAT THESE TWO ITEMS ARE NOT
 RELATED BECAUSE THE USE OF THE FLAMEBAR AS AN ALTERNATE
 TO CONSTRUCTED SHAFTS IS NOT INCLUDED IN THE ANALYSIS
 FOR THE ATRIUM.
  
 2) THE TWO SUBMITTAL DOCUMENTS- IBC 104.11 ALTERNATE
 MEANS AND METHODS- FIRE RATED VENTILATION DUCT THE
 CANOPY HOTEL BY HILTON BY STEVEN FELLER P.E., AND THE
 SLS PERFORMANCE BASED SMOKE ANALYSIS SHALL EACH BE
 ELECTRONICALLY SIGNED AND SEALED- SECTION 61G15-23.005
 FAC.
  
 3) IBC 104.11 ALTERNATE MEANS AND METHODS- FIRE RATED
 VENTILATION DUCT THE CANOPY HOTEL BY HILTON- SHEET
 AC-2-4 LEVEL-2 WEST: THE FLAMEBAR LAUNDRY EXHAUST DUCTS
 PENETRATING THE INTERIOR EXIT STAIR #2 APPEAR TO BE NOT
 IN COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 1023.5 FBC B WHICH PROHIBITS
 PENETRATIONS INTO AND THROUGH THE STAIRWAY ENCLOSURE.
 PLEASE NOTE THAT NO DETAIL FOR THIS ALTERNATE
 INSTALLATION HAS BEEN PROVIDED IN THE PACKAGE, AND THE
 USE OF FLAMEBAR FOR THE INSTALLATION IS NOT INCLUDED IN
 THE FLORIDA BUILDING COMMISSION DECALARATORY STATEMENT
 DS 2016-078 THAT WAS SUBMITTED WITH THE ALTERNATE
 APPROVAL LETTER.
  
 4) SHEET M2.08A: THERE ARE VARIOUS FLAMEBAR/NON-RATED
 DUCT CONNECTORS CALLED OUT IN THE ENLARGED PENETRATION
 DETAIL. PLEASE SELECT ONE SPECIFIC CONNECTOR AND
 SUBMIIT MANUFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS AND INSTALLATION
 INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE CONNECTOR. PLEASE INDICATE WHERE
 THE CONNECTORS ARE SHOWN AND INCLUDED IN THE
 ALTERNATIVE APPROVAL PACKAGE.
  
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM ALONG WITH THE CITY
 RE-SUBMITTAL FORM. ADDITIONALLY, PLEASE INSERT
 CORRECTED PLAN SHEETS INTO THE SETS, REMOVE THE
 PREVIOUSLY REVIEWED SHEETS AND MARK VOID ON THEM, AND
 KEEP THEM WITH THE SUBMITTALS.
  
 CHRISTOPHER L. COLE
 MECHANICAL PLANS EXAMINER
 401 CLEMATIS STREET
 WEST PALM BEACH FL 33401
 561-805-6719
 [email protected]
  
  
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2019-08-19 Cont ID  
Sent By ccole Date 2019-08-19 Time 11:07 Rev Time 0.00
Received By hmoser Date 2019-08-19 Time 11:07 Sent To I
Notes
2019-08-19 11:08:14PLAN DENIED
 SEE FIRE COMMENTS HM.
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2020-01-06 Cont ID  
Sent By ccole Date 2020-01-06 Time 09:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By ccole Date 2020-01-06 Time 09:10 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2019-12-12 Cont ID  
Sent By ccole Date 2019-12-12 Time 12:17 Rev Time 0.00
Received By ccole Date 2019-12-12 Time 12:17 Sent To  
Notes
2019-12-12 12:20:50AS NOTED IN THE PREVIOUS MECHANICAL AND SIGNATURE
 REVIEWS, THE SLS SMOKE CONTROL ANALYSIS SHALL BE
 ELECTRONICALLY SIGNED AND SEALED BY THE ENGINEER WHO
 PREPARED THE DOCUMENT- SECTION 471.025 FL. STATUTE, AND
 SECION 61G15-23.005 FAC.
 CCOLE- 12/12/19
Review Stop SIGNATURE ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE SHEET
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2019-10-18 Cont ID  
Sent By lmarchan Date 2019-10-18 Time 15:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By lmarchan Date 2019-10-18 Time 15:41 Sent To  
Notes
2019-10-18 15:42:07THE TWO DOCUMENTS ARE NOT DIGITALLY SIGNED.


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved