Plan Review Details - Permit 15061008
Plan Review Stops For Permit 15061008
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2015-08-13 Cont ID  
Sent By wjolin Date 2015-08-13 Time 16:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By albarran Date 2015-08-13 Time 17:29 Sent To I
Notes
2015-08-13 17:40:51THIS TIME AROUND ALL THAT WAS NEEDED FROM ME WAS TO
 STAMP THE NEW SHEETS.
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2015-08-05 Cont ID  
Sent By albarran Date 2015-08-05 Time 15:23 Rev Time 0.00
Received By albarran Date 2015-08-05 Time 14:18 Sent To I
Notes
2015-08-05 15:25:22THE RE-SUBMITTAL WAS INCOMPLETE. PLEASE PROVIDE COPIES
 OF SHEETS D1.02 & SE700 DATED JULY 15, 2015 AND INSERT
 THEM INTO THE CONTRACTORS SET OF PLANS. ONCE THAT IS
 COMPLETED, I WILL GLADLY SIGN OFF ON THAT SET.
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2015-07-07 Cont ID  
Sent By dhayes Date 2015-07-14 Time 11:36 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dhayes Date 2015-07-07 Time 14:09 Sent To FIRE
Notes
2015-07-07 14:15:207/7/2015
 PROJECT: LOFTIN PLACE ACCESS CONTROL
 PERMIT#: 15061008
 CODE: 2008 EDITION OF THE NEC, 2010 EDITION OF THE FBC
 ,2010 WPB AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC, CHAPTER 1,
 ADMINISTRATION, 2012 FBC SUPPLEMENTS.
 1ST ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 REVISE YOUR PLANS IN RESPONSE TO THE FOLLOWING REVIEW
 COMMENTS:
  
 1) PROVIDE MANUFACTURER PRODUCT SUBMITTALS FOR
 EQUIPMENT, COMPONENTS AND CABLES PROPOSED TO BE
 INSTALLED.
  
 2) PROVIDE UL FIRE RATED ASSEMBLIES TO BE USED FOR
 PENATRATION OF FIRE RATED SURFACES.
  
 3) INDICATE THE LOCATION FOR ANY LINE VOLTAGE POWER
 SUPPLIES PROPOSED TO BE INSTALLED. THE INSTALLATION OF
 LINE VOLTAGE CONNECTIONS SHALL BE BY OTHERS.
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING, IT IS HELPFUL TO PROVIDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER ADDRESSING EACH ITEM ALONG WITH THE CITY
 RE-SUBMITTAL FORM. SEE LINK:
 HTTP://WPB.ORG/DEVELOPMENT/WP-CONTENT/UPLOADS/SITES/33/
 2013/09/APPLICATION_RESUBMITTAL_FORM_04132010.PDF
  
 A THOROUGH REVIEW CANNOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME, AS A
 RESULT OF THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUESTED
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY APPEAR THAT WERE NOT PART OF
 THIS REVIEW.
 ADDITIONALLY, IT IS REQUIRED TO INSERT THE CORRECTED
 PAGES INTO THE DENIED SUBMITTAL PACKAGE. VOID THE
 PREVIOUSLY REVIEWED SHEETS AND LEAVE FOR COMPARATIVE
 REVIEW.
 DAVID HAYES, ELECTRICAL PLANS EXAMINER, PX3421,
 561-805-6717 OR [email protected]
  
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2015-08-13 Cont ID  
Sent By albarran Date 2015-08-13 Time 17:42 Rev Time 0.00
Received By wjolin Date 2015-08-13 Time 09:54 Sent To E
Notes
2015-08-13 10:37:29705 NORTH OLIVE AVENUE
 PERMIT #15061008
 REVIEW COMMENTS - FIRE DEPARTMENT
  
 ***UPDATE: PLANS HAVE BEEN PASSED WITH THE
 UNDERSTANDING THAT REVISED PLANS WILL BE SUBMITTED
 BASED UPON A MEETING HELD AT CITY HALL (08/13/15 @ 1600
 HOURS) TO WHICH THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND
 DESIGN/CONSTRUCTION TEAM REACHED A MUTUAL AGREEMENT TO
 RELOCATE THE ACCESS CONTROL HARDWARE TO THE PARKING
 GARAGE DOORS ADJACENT TO STAIR#5 AND PROVIDE SELECTIVE
 STAIRWELL RE-ENTRY (8TH, 7TH, AND 3RD FLOORS) WITH
 APPROPRIATE STAIRWELL SIGNAGE IN ACCORDANCE WITH NFPA
 101.***
  
  
  
 2ND RESPONSE: THE ENGINEER'S RESPONSE INDICATES THE
 LOCKED CORRIDOR DOOR WILL UNLOCK WITH A FIRE ALARM.
 HAVING THE LOCKED CORRIDOR DOOR UNLOCK DURING A FIRE
 ALARM ONLY RESTRICTS EGRESS AND IS NOT COMPLIANT WITH
 NFPA 101. OCCUPANT ACCESS TO TWO EXITS IS REQUIRED AT
 ALL TIMES.
 RESPONSE COMMENT: OCCUPANTS UTILIZING THE TRASH CHUTE
 ADJACENT TO STAIR #5 REQUIRE ACCESS TO TWO EXITS AT ALL
 TIMES. THE LOCATION OF THE THIS CARD READER REQUIRES
 THE OCCUPANTS TO HAVE A KEY OR TOOL TO ACCESS THE
 SECONDARY MEANS OF EGRESS. EGRESS FROM THE RESIDENTIAL
 APARTMENTS THROUGH THE PARKING GARAGE (STORAGE
 OCCUPANCY) IS NOT PERMITTED.
 ORIGINAL COMMENT: THE CARD READERS AND EQUIPMENT
 LOCATED ADJACENT TO STAIR #5 DOOR (NORTH CENTRAL) WILL
 NEED TO BE REMOVED OR RELOCATED TO THE PARKING GARAGE
 DOOR (TYPICAL LEVEL 2 AND HIGHER) TO ALLOW FREE EGRESS
 AT ALL TIMES TO AT LEAST TWO STAIRS.
  
 2ND RESPONSE: THE ENGINEER'S RESPONSE INDICATES THAT
 ALL STAIRWELL DOORS WILL UNLOCK DURING A FIRE ALARM
 (OPTION #2 BELOW); HOWEVER, THE LETTER ALSO INDICATES
 THAT THERE WILL BE SELECTIVE STAIRWELL RE-ENTRY (OPTION
 #3 BELOW) ON FLOORS 3 AND 6, WHICH IS NOT COMPLIANT
 WITH A RE-ETNRY NEEDED ON THE 7TH OR 8TH FLOOR. THE
 DESIGN NEEDS TO FULLY COMPLY WITH ONLY ONE OPTION, NOT
 PARTS OF TWO DIFFERENT OPTIONS.
 NEW COMMENT: THE ORIGINAL ARCHITECTURAL LIFE SAFETY
 DESIGN INDICATED THAT THE EXIT STAIRS WERE TO BE
 ACCESS-CONTROLLED (LOCKED) FROM THE NON-EGRESS SIDE AT
 THE LOWEST FLOOR ONLY; ALL OTHER LEVELS WOULD BE FREE
 EGRESS AND FREE RE-ENTRY BACK ONTO THE FLOORS. THE
 LOCATION OF CARD READERS COMBINED WITH STAIRWELL DOORS
 WITHOUT DOOR HARDWARE FROM THE STAIR ENCLOSURE POSES
 CHALLENGES. INDICATE HOW COMPLIANCE WITH NFPA 101
 SECTION 7.2.1.5.7 WILL BE OBTAINED:EVERY DOOR ASSEMBLY
 IN A STAIR ENCLOSURE SERVING MORE THAN FOUR STORIES
 SHALL MEET ONE OF THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
 (1) RE-ENTRY FROM THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO THE INTERIOR
 OF THE BUILDING SHALL BE PROVIDED AT ALL TIMES AT ALL
 LEVELS
 (2) AN AUTOMATIC RELEASE THAT IS ACTUATED WITH THE
 INITIATION OF THE BUILDING FIRE ALARM SYSTEM SHALL BE
 PROVIDED TO UNLOCK ALL STAIR ENCLOSURE DOOR ASSEMBLIES
 TO ALLOW RE-ENTRY.
 (3) SELECTED RE-ENTRY SHALL BE PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH 7.2.1.5.7.1. PER 7.2.1.5.7.1 DOOR ASSEMBLIES ON
 STAIR ENCLOSURES SHALL BE PERMITTED TO BE EQUIPPED WITH
 HARDWARE THAT PREVENTS RE-ENTRY INTO THE INTERIOR OF
 THE BUILDING, PROVIDED THAT THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA ARE
 MET:
 (A) THERE SHALL BE NOT LESS THAN TWO LEVELS WHERE IT IS
 POSSIBLE TO LEAVE THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO ACCESS ANOTHER
 EXIT.
 (B) THERE SHALL BE NOT MORE THAN FOUR STORIES
 INTERVENING BETWEEN STORIES WHERE IT IS POSSIBLE TO
 LEAVE THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO ACCESS ANOTHER EXIT.
 (C) RE-ENTRY SHALL BE POSSIBLE ON THE TOP STORY OR
 NEXT-TO-TOP STORY SERVED BY THE STAIR ENCLOSURE, AND
 SUCH STORY SHALL ALLOW ACCESS TO ANOTHER EXIT.
 (D) DOOR ASSEMBLIES ALLOWING RE-ENTRY SHALL BE
 IDENTIFIED AS SUCH ON THE STAIR SIDE OF THE DOOR LEAF.
 (E) DOOR ASSEMBLIES NOT ALLOWING RE-ENTRY SHALL BE
 PROVIDED WITH A SIGN ON THE STAIR SIDE INDICATING THE
 LOCATION OF THE NEAREST DOOR OPENING, IN EACH DIRECTION
 OF TRAVEL, THAT ALLOWS RE-ENTRY OR EXIT.
  
 NOTE: THE REVISED PLANS INDICATE THE INSTALLATION OF
 MAGNETIC LOCKS ON 3RD AND 6TH FLOOR STAIRWELL FIRE
 DOORS. MAG LOCKS SHALL NOT PROTRUDE INTO THE REQUIRED
 EGRESS HEADROOM SPACE (6'-8" CLEARANCE NEEDED). FIRE
 RATED DOORS ARE REQUIRED TO BE POSITIVELY LATCHING.
  
 WESLEY JOLIN
 ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 WEST PALM BEACH FIRE RESCUE
 [email protected]
 (561) 805-6730
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2015-07-23 Cont ID  
Sent By wjolin Date 2015-07-23 Time 14:02 Rev Time 0.00
Received By wjolin Date 2015-07-23 Time 12:52 Sent To E
Notes
2015-07-23 13:44:30705 NORTH OLIVE AVENUE
 PERMIT #15061008
 REVIEW COMMENTS - FIRE DEPARTMENT
  
 RESPONSE COMMENT: OCCUPANTS UTILIZING THE TRASH CHUTE
 ADJACENT TO STAIR #5 REQUIRE ACCESS TO TWO EXITS AT ALL
 TIMES. THE LOCATION OF THE THIS CARD READER REQUIRES
 THE OCCUPANTS TO HAVE A KEY OR TOOL TO ACCESS THE
 SECONDARY MEANS OF EGRESS. EGRESS FROM THE RESIDENTIAL
 APARTMENTS THROUGH THE PARKING GARAGE (STORAGE
 OCCUPANCY) IS NOT PERMITTED.
 ORIGINAL COMMENT: THE CARD READERS AND EQUIPMENT
 LOCATED ADJACENT TO STAIR #5 DOOR (NORTH CENTRAL) WILL
 NEED TO BE REMOVED OR RELOCATED TO THE PARKING GARAGE
 DOOR (TYPICAL LEVEL 2 AND HIGHER) TO ALLOW FREE EGRESS
 AT ALL TIMES TO AT LEAST TWO STAIRS.
  
 NEW COMMENT: THE ORIGINAL ARCHITECTURAL LIFE SAFETY
 DESIGN INDICATED THAT THE EXIT STAIRS WERE TO BE
 ACCESS-CONTROLLED (LOCKED) FROM THE NON-EGRESS SIDE AT
 THE LOWEST FLOOR ONLY; ALL OTHER LEVELS WOULD BE FREE
 EGRESS AND FREE RE-ENTRY BACK ONTO THE FLOORS. THE
 LOCATION OF CARD READERS COMBINED WITH STAIRWELL DOORS
 WITHOUT DOOR HARDWARE FROM THE STAIR ENCLOSURE POSES
 CHALLENGES. INDICATE HOW COMPLIANCE WITH NFPA 101
 SECTION 7.2.1.5.7 WILL BE OBTAINED:
  
 EVERY DOOR ASSEMBLY IN A STAIR ENCLOSURE SERVING MORE
 THAN FOUR STORIES SHALL MEET ONE OF THE FOLLOWING
 CONDITIONS:
 (1) RE-ENTRY FROM THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO THE INTERIOR
 OF THE BUILDING SHALL BE PROVIDED AT ALL TIMES AT ALL
 LEVELS
 (2) AN AUTOMATIC RELEASE THAT IS ACTUATED WITH THE
 INITIATION OF THE BUILDING FIRE ALARM SYSTEM SHALL BE
 PROVIDED TO UNLOCK ALL STAIR ENCLOSURE DOOR ASSEMBLIES
 TO ALLOW RE-ENTRY.
 (3) SELECTED RE-ENTRY SHALL BE PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH 7.2.1.5.7.1.
  
 7.2.1.5.7.1 DOOR ASSEMBLIES ON STAIR ENCLOSURES SHALL
 BE PERMITTED TO BE EQUIPPED WITH HARDWARE THAT PREVENTS
 RE-ENTRY INTO THE INTERIOR OF THE BUILDING, PROVIDED
 THAT THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA ARE MET:
 (1) THERE SHALL BE NOT LESS THAN TWO LEVELS WHERE IT IS
 POSSIBLE TO LEAVE THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO ACCESS ANOTHER
 EXIT.
 (2) THERE SHALL BE NOT MORE THAN FOUR STORIES
 INTERVENING BETWEEN STORIES WHERE IT IS POSSIBLE TO
 LEAVE THE STAIR ENCLOSURE TO ACCESS ANOTHER EXIT.
 (3) RE-ENTRY SHALL BE POSSIBLE ON THE TOP STORY OR
 NEXT-TO-TOP STORY SERVED BY THE STAIR ENCLOSURE, AND
 SUCH STORY SHALL ALLOW ACCESS TO ANOTHER EXIT.
 (4) DOOR ASSEMBLIES ALLOWING RE-ENTRY SHALL BE
 IDENTIFIED AS SUCH ON THE STAIR SIDE OF THE DOOR LEAF.
 (5) DOOR ASSEMBLIES NOT ALLOWING RE-ENTRY SHALL BE
 PROVIDED WITH A SIGN ON THE STAIR SIDE INDICATING THE
 LOCATION OF THE NEAREST DOOR OPENING, IN EACH DIRECTION
 OF TRAVEL, THAT ALLOWS RE-ENTRY OR EXIT.
  
 WESLEY JOLIN
 ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 WEST PALM BEACH FIRE RESCUE
 [email protected]
 (561) 805-6730
  
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2015-07-08 Cont ID  
Sent By wjolin Date 2015-07-08 Time 13:28 Rev Time 0.00
Received By wjolin Date 2015-07-08 Time 13:18 Sent To E
Notes
2015-07-08 13:28:53705 NORTH OLIVE AVENUE
 PERMIT #15061008
 REVIEW COMMENTS - FIRE DEPARTMENT
  
 THE ADDRESS PROVIDED ON THE PLANS DOES NOT MATCH THE
 ADDRESS PROVIDED ON THE PERMIT APPLICATION.
  
 THE CARD READERS AND EQUIPMENT LOCATED ADJACENT TO
 STAIR #5 DOOR (NORTH CENTRAL) WILL NEED TO BE REMOVED
 OR RELOCATED TO THE PARKING GARAGE DOOR (TYPICAL LEVEL
 2 AND HIGHER) TO ALLOW FREE EGRESS AT ALL TIMES TO AT
 LEAST TWO STAIRS.
  
 THE PARKING GARAGE CARD READERS LOCATED ADJACENT TO
 STAIR #3 PREVENT ACCESS INTO THE BUILDING BUT ALLOW
 ACCESS INTO THE EXIT STAIR. STAIR #3 HAS TWO EXIT
 ACCESS DOORS, ONE FROM THE PARKING GARAGE AND ONE FROM
 THE APARTMENT BUILDING. WHAT IS PREVENTING OCCUPANTS
 FROM ENTERING THE STAIR FROM THE PARKING GARAGE AND
 THEN ENTER THE APARTMENT BUILDING FROM THE SECONDARY
 DOOR? (TYPICAL LEVEL 2 AND HIGHER).
  
 THE WEST CARD READER ON LEVEL 7 PREVENTS OCCUPANTS ON
 THE RECREATIONAL ROOF DECK FROM ACCESSING TWO EXITS.
  
 WESLEY JOLIN
 ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 WEST PALM BEACH FIRE RESCUE
 [email protected]
 (561) 805-6730
  
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2015-08-13 Cont ID  
Sent By albarran Date 2015-08-13 Time 17:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By albarran Date 2015-08-07 Time 14:28 Sent To FIRE
Notes
2015-08-13 17:42:108/13/15 - PASSED ALL REVIEWS AS NOTED. CONTRACTOR
 NOTIFIED VIA EMAIL. SENT TO SMALL READY BIN "A". MA
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2015-08-05 Cont ID  
Sent By albarran Date 2015-08-05 Time 15:29 Rev Time 0.00
Received By albarran Date 2015-07-16 Time 16:06 Sent To  
Notes
2015-08-05 15:31:108/5/15 - FAILED ELECTRICAL REVIEW DUE TO AN INCOMPLETE
 SUBMITTAL, RUNNER NOTIFIED VIA EMAIL. SENT TO SMALL
 DENIED BIN "A". MA
2015-07-16 16:06:50ROUTED TO FIRE
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2015-07-14 Cont ID  
Sent By dhayes Date 2015-07-07 Time 11:36 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dhayes Date 2015-06-23 Time   Sent To E
Notes
2015-06-24 11:58:13ON D. HAYES DESK


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved