Plan Review Details - Permit 09080581
Plan Review Stops For Permit 09080581
Review Stop AD ADDRESSING
Rev No 1 Status P Date 2009-10-14 Cont ID  
Sent By jnguyen Date 2009-10-14 Time 11:42 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jnguyen Date 2009-10-13 Time 10:13 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-14 11:20:5910-14-09: CHERYL HORTON OF PAPA GOT BACK TO ME
 REGARDING THE ISSUE WITH THE RETAIL TENANT SPACES (A, B
 & C) WITHIN THE 17-DIGIT CONDO PCN# 74434322170010031
 AT 400 N FLAGLER DR # C1 (COMMERCIAL MARINA OF
 WATERVIEW CONDOMINIUM). THE CONTENT OF HER E-MAIL WAS
 AS FOLLOWED:
  
 "RETAIL SPACE A THRU C IS A PORTION OF COMMERCIAL UNIT
 C-1 WHICH ENCOMPASSES THE ENTIRE MARINA. THE PCN YOU
 LISTED IS FOR THE UNIT C1. THERE IS NO SEPARATE LEGAL
 DESCRIPTION FOR TENANT SPACES A THRU C ON THE TAX ROLL.
 THIS INFORMATION WAS PROVIDED TO ME FROM GENE POTTER,
 CONDOMINIUM DEPARTMENT. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS,
 PLEASE CONTACT GENE AT 355-3261."
  
 SINCE THE RETAIL TENANT SPACES ARE DIRECTLY A PART OF
 UNIT # C1, I HAVE ADDED THEM AS EXTENSIONS OFF PCN#
 74434322170010031 IN COMMUNITYPLUS (TO BE ABLE TO
 DIFFERENTIATE THEM). THEY WERE IMPLEMENTED AS FOLLOWED:
 SEQUENTIAL UNIT RECORD 0002 - 400 N FLAGLER DR # C1
 TENANT A, SEQUENTIAL UNIT RECORD 0003 - 400 N FLAGLER
 DR # C1 TENANT B & SEQUENTIAL UNIT RECORD 0004 - 400 N
 FLAGLER DR # C1 TENANT C. AS A RESULT, I HAVE MOVED
 PERMIT# 09080578 FROM THE MAIN LOCATION RECORD OF PCN#
 74434322170010031 TO BE INSTEAD REFERENCED TO
 SEQUENTIAL UNIT RECORD 0002 - 400 N FLAGLER DR # C1
 TENANT A. I ALSO MOVED PERMIT# 09080581 TO BE APPLIED
 INSTEAD TO SEQUENTIAL UNIT RECORD 0003 - 400 N FLAGLER
 DR # C1 TENANT B. I MADE THE ADJUSTMENTS ON THEIR
 ORIGINAL PERMIT APPLICATIONS TOO. I RETURNED THE
 ASSOCIATED DOCUMENTS BACK TO THE B14 & B18 BOXES
 DOWNSTAIRS.
  
 JOHN NGUYEN
 GIS SUPPORT SPECIALIST
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 MIS DEPARTMENT
 OFFICE: (561) 822-1239
 FAX: (561) 822-1249
 [email protected]
2009-10-13 13:40:42 
  
  
 10-13-09: I CURRENTLY HAVE THE SITE PLANS CHECKED OUT.
 THE RENOVATION SHOWS THAT THIS PART OF THE WATERVIEW
 CONDOMINIUM IS BEING DESIGNATED AS THREE DISTINCT
 TENANT SPACES OF A, B & C. I AM NOT AWARE IF EACH ONE
 OF THESE ALPHA CHARACTERS HAVE THEIR OWN DISTINCT
 17-DIGIT PCN#, SO I CONTACTED CHERYL HORTON OF PAPA
 WITH THE FOLLOWING MESSAGE:
  
 "THE EASTERN PART (DIRECTLY FACING THE DOCK) OF THE
 WATERVIEW TOWERS CONDOMINIUM IS CURRENTLY BEING
 RENOVATED WITH TENANT SPACES A, B & C (SHOWN AS PCN#
 74434322170010031 AT 400 N FLAGLER DR # C1 ON THE
 AERIAL). SINCE IT IS THE DEVELOPER'S JURISDICTION TO
 ASSIGN SUITE ADDRESSES FOR UNITS WITHIN CONDOMINIUMS, I
 AM NOT AWARE OF THE ASSOCIATED PCN#S FOR TENANT SPACES
 A & B. DOES # A & B SHARE THE SAME 17-DIGIT CONDO PCN#
 74434322170010031 ASSOCIATED WITH # C1 OR DO THEY HAVE
 THEIR OWN UNIQUE ONES? IS # A & B ALREADY ON FILE AS
 ONE OF THE UNIT # PH ALPHA CHARACTERS OR ARE THESE PH
 UNITS UNRELATED (AS SHOWN IN THE PAPA SCREENSHOTS
 BELOW)?"
  
 UNTIL I HEAR BACK FROM CHERYL, I AM NOT SURE IF
 SUITES/UNITS # A & B SHOULD BE EXTENSIONS OFF PCN#
 74434322170010031, HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED NEW 17-DIGIT
 CONDO PCN#S OR IF THEY WERE ALREADY IN EXISTENCE?
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2009-12-15 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2009-12-15 Time 16:47 Rev Time 0.77
Received By jwitmer Date 2009-12-15 Time 16:47 Sent To  
Notes
2009-12-15 16:48:05BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 09080581
 ADD: 400 N FLAGLER / TENANT B
 CONT: SHAKMAN HOSPITALITY
 TEL: (561)756-2553
  
  
 FL BLD CODE= 2007 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2009 FBC SUPPLEMENTS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
  
 REVISION- REVIEW- 09110611
  
  
 1) SHEET A-4/ DETAIL# 1 & M1.01. PLANS INDICATE A
 PLENUM RETURN.
 BUILDING APPROVED WITH EXCEPTION!
  
 THIS PLAN HAS BEEN APPROVED PROVISIONALLY. FAILURE TO
 CORRECT THE LISTED DEFICIENCIES IN THIS PLAN PRIOR TO
 INSPECTION WILL RESULT IN FAILED INSPECTION(S) AND THE
 ASSESSMENT OF REINSPECTION FEE(S).
  
 PLENUMS- MECHANICAL 602.2.1.5.1, SEPARATION REQUIRED.
 THE FOAM PLASTIC INSULATION SHALL BE SEPARATED FROM THE
 PLENUM BY A THERMAL BARRIER COMPLYING WITH SECTION
 2603.4 OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, BUILDING.
  
 2603.4 THERMAL BARRIER. EXCEPT AS PROVIDED FOR IN
 SECTIONS 2603.4.1 AND 2603.9, FOAM PLASTIC SHALL BE
 SEPARATED FROM THE INTERIOR OF A BUILDING BY AN
 APPROVED THERMAL BARRIER OF 0.5-INCH (12.7 MM) GYPSUM
 WALLBOARD OR EQUIVALENT THERMAL BARRIER MATERIAL THAT
 WILL LIMIT THE AVERAGE TEMPERATURE RISE OF THE
 UNEXPOSED SURFACE TO NOT MORE THAN 250??F (120??C)
 AFTER 15 MINUTES OF FIRE EXPOSURE, COMPLYING WITH THE
 STANDARD TIME-TEMPERATURE CURVE OF ASTM E 119. THE
 THERMAL BARRIER SHALL BE INSTALLED IN SUCH A MANNER
 THAT IT WILL REMAIN IN PLACE FOR 15 MINUTES BASED ON FM
 4880, UL 1040, NFPA 286 OR UL 1715. COMBUSTIBLE
 CONCEALED SPACES SHALL COMPLY WITH SECTION 717.
  
  
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)805-6731
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2009-12-01 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2009-12-01 Time 09:24 Rev Time 0.50
Received By jwitmer Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
2009-12-01 09:25:12BUILDING PROVISO: 2603.4 THERMAL BARRIER.
 EXCEPT AS PROVIDED FOR IN SECTIONS 2603.4.1 AND 2603.9,
 FOAM PLASTIC SHALL BE SEPARATED FROM THE INTERIOR OF A
 BUILDING BY AN APPROVED THERMAL BARRIER OF 0.5-INCH
 (12.7 MM) GYPSUM WALLBOARD OR EQUIVALENT THERMAL
 BARRIER MATERIAL THAT WILL LIMIT THE AVERAGE
 TEMPERATURE RISE OF THE UNEXPOSED SURFACE TO NOT MORE
 THAN 250??F (120??C) AFTER 15 MINUTES OF FIRE EXPOSURE,
 COMPLYING WITH THE STANDARD TIME-TEMPERATURE CURVE OF
 ASTM E 119. THE THERMAL BARRIER SHALL BE INSTALLED IN
 SUCH A MANNER THAT IT WILL REMAIN IN PLACE FOR 15
 MINUTES BASED ON FM 4880, UL 1040, NFPA 286 OR UL 1715.
 COMBUSTIBLE CONCEALED SPACES SHALL COMPLY WITH SECTION
 717.
  
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2009-10-05 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2009-10-05 Time 11:44 Rev Time 0.75
Received By jwitmer Date 2009-10-05 Time 11:01 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2009-08-27 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2009-08-27 Time 12:27 Rev Time 1.50
Received By jwitmer Date 2009-08-27 Time 11:00 Sent To  
Notes
2009-08-27 12:20:58BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 09080581
 ADD: 400 N FLAGLER DR UNIT C-1
 CONT: SHAKMAN HOSPITALITY LLC
 TEL: (561)756-2553
 FL BLD CODE= 2007FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2009FBC SUPPLEMENTS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 1ST REVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
 AUGUST 27/2009
  
  
 1) PLEASE REVIEW THE LOCATION OF PROJECT ON THE PERMIT
 APPLICATION VERSES THE PLANS. THE PLANS INDICATE WORK
 TO BE COMPLETED UNDER THIS PERMIT AS TENAT "B" CREW
 QUARTERS WHERE-AS THE PERMIT APPLICATION INDICATES
 TENAT "C-1". PLEASE CORRELATE INFORMATION, 106.1.2
 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED.
  
 2) THE ENERGY CALCULATIONS WERE SUBMITTED ON FORM
 400A-2008 PLEASE SEE THIS IS FOR WHOLE BUILDING METHOD,
 PLEASE REVIEW:
  
 13-400.0.B METHOD B, THE BUILDING PRESCRIPTIVE METHOD.
 THIS IS A PRESCRIPTIVE METHODOLOGY THAT IS ALLOWED FOR
 SHELL BUILDINGS, RENOVATIONS, CHANGE OF OCCUPANCY,
 LIMITED OR SPECIAL USE BUILDINGS, AND BUILDING SYSTEM
 CHANGEOUTS. THE BUILDING ENVELOPE COMPLIES WITH THE
 STANDARD IF THE PROPOSED BUILDING MEETS OR EXCEEDS THE
 MANDATORY REQUIREMENTS AND ALL RELEVANT CRITERIA ON
 FORM 400B OR THEENERGYGAUGE SUMMIT FLA/COM 2008
 COMPUTER PRINTOUT. ONLY THE PRESCRIPTIVE ENVELOPE
 MEASURES OF METHOD B ARE PERMITTED FOR SHELL BUILDINGS.
 13-400.0.B.4 RENOVATED BUILDINGS. RENOVATED BUILDINGS
 SHALL, WHEN APPLICABLE (SEE SECTION 13-202), MEET THE
 EFFICIENCIES LISTED ON FORM 400B FOR COMPONENTS BEING
 CHANGED OR SHALL COMPLY WITH THE ENVELOPE OR SYSTEMS
 CRITERIA IN METHOD B OF ENERGYGAUGE SUMMIT FLA/COM FOR
 THE COMPONENTS BEING CHANGED. EXISTING BUILDINGS NOT
 MEETING THE DEFINITION OF A RENOVATION IN WHICH NEW
 HEATING, COOLING, WATER HEATING, ELECTRICAL OR LIGHTING
 SYSTEMS ARE INSTALLED SHALL MEET THE MANDATORY MINIMUM
 EFFICIENCIES LISTED IN THIS CODE FOR THE SYSTEM(S)
 BEING CHANGED.
  
 STARTING AUGUST 21, 2009, THE CONSTRUCTION SERVICES
 DEPARTMENT WILL BE CLOSED ON FRIDAYS UNTIL FURTHER
 NOTICE.
  
 OPENING HOURS MONDAY - THURSDAY WILL REMAIN AT 8:00 AM
 - 5:00 PM.
  
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)805-6731
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
 SURVEY:
 WWW.SURVEYMONKEY.COM/WESTPALMBEACHCONSTRUCTIONSERVICES
  
 PLEASE NOTE: FLORIDA HAS A VERY BROAD PUBLIC RECORDS
 LAW. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS TO OR FROM LOCAL OFFICIALS
 REGARDING CITY BUSINESS ARE PUBLIC RECORD, AVAILABLE TO
 THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. YOUR E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS ARE
 THEREFORE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.
  
 MEMBER OF BOAF: BUILDING OFFICIALS ASSOCIATION OF
 FLORIDA SAVING LIVES AND PROPERTY SINCE 1953
  
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2009-10-20 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2009-10-20 Time 10:46 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2009-10-20 Time 10:46 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-20 10:47:40NEW REVISED ELECTRICAL SHEET INSERTED INTO REVISED SET.
  
 OTHER REVISED SHEETS SEPARATE FROM ORIGINAL SETS TO BE
 DONE BY CONTRACTOR PER LUIS MARTINEZ BEFORE PERMIT
 ISSUANCE.
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2009-10-10 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2009-10-10 Time 12:06 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2009-10-10 Time 12:06 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-10 12:08:29** TEMPORARY FAILED **
  
 TENANT *B*
  
 ADDRESS FOR APPLIED LOCATION STILL NEEDS TO BE
 CORRECTED. THERE IS CURRRENTLY NUMEROUS PERMITS APPLIED
 AND ISSUED FOR 400 N FLAGLER #C1. THIS INCLUDES PERMITS
 FOR THREE DIFFERENT DOCKS, ELECTRICAL AND OTHER TENANT
 SPACES. ADDRESS/SUITE/UNIT EXTENSIONS NEED TO BE ADDED.
 NOT ALL PERMITS CAN BE ISSUED TO THE SAME
 TENANT/LOCATION
  
 1) NOTE: AS NOTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW PLEASE REMOVE OLD
 SHEETS FROM SETS AND INSERT NEW SHEETS INTO TWO
 COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
  
 ADDRESS FOR APPLIED LOCATION STILL NEEDS TO BE
 COORECTED. THERE IS CURRRENTLY NUMEROUS PERMITS APPLIED
 AND ISSUED FOR 400 N FLAGLER #C1 FROM THE THREE DIFFENT
 DOCKS, ELECTRICAL AND OTHER TENANT SPACES.
 ADDRESS/SUITE/UNIT EXTENSIONS NEED TO BE ADDED. NOT ALL
 PERMITS CAN BE ISSUED TO THE SAME TENANT/LOCATION.
  
 2) NOTE: BASED ON A CONVERSATION WITH FAE CONSULTING
 NEW ELECTRICAL SHEETS WERE TO BE BROUGHT IN FOR REVIEW
 BEFORE ELECTRICAL REVIEW WAS TO BE DONE. THE NEW SHEET
 E2.01 SUBMITTED ON OCTOBER 2ND WAS INADVERTENTLY NOT
 SIGNED BY THE ENGINEER OF RECORD. ENGINEER OF RECORD
 CALLED OFFICE. ALSO SPOKE TO REPRESENTATIVE FROM FAE
 AND NEW SHEET WILL BE BROUGHT IN AS ENGINEER WAS OUT OF
 TOWN UNTIL MONDAY THE 12TH OF OCTOBER. SHEET MAY BE
 BROUGHT IN WITHOUT ANY FEE.
 SETS OF PLANS NEED TO BE PLACED TOGETHER BY CONTRACTOR.
  
  
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
 TYPED IN A CLEAR MANNER PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
 CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2009-09-18 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2009-09-18 Time 19:27 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2009-09-18 Time 19:27 Sent To  
Notes
2009-09-18 19:27:41 
  
 ** DENIED **
  
 ** REVIEW IS BASED ON PLANS AND SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS
 SUBMITTED.
  
 1A) NOTE: ADDED, PERMIT APPLICATION STATES TENANT SPACE
 #C1, HOWEVER PLANS STATE TENANT SPACE *A*.
  
 1) NOTE: IN THE PACKAGE THERE ARE SUPPORTING METHOD *A*
 WHOLE BUILDING COMPLIANCE ENERGY CALCULATIONS. THIS IS
 NOT A WHOLE BUILDING BY DEFINITION. PLEASE ALSO SEE
 THAT PLANS ARE SHOWING A SEPARATE METHOD OF COMPLIANCE.
 IN FACT PLANS ARE SHOWING PRESCRIPTIVE SPACE BY SPACE
 METHOD *B*.
 PLEASE SEE SECTIONS NOTED:
  
 THE LIGHTING PLANS SUBMITTED CLEARLY INDICATE METHOD
 *B*. IN FACT THE PLANS STATE COMPLIANCE FOR SPACE BY
 SPACE PER 13-415.B.1. PLEASE SEE 13-415.AB.5 OF THE
 FBC. THIS SECTION CLEARLY STATES THE FOLLOWING.
  
 ??? TRADE-OFFS OF INTERIOR LIGHTING POWER ALLOWANCE
 AMONG PORTIONS OF THE BUILDING FOR WHICH A DIFFERENT
 METHOD OF CALCULATION HAS BEEN USED IS NOT PERMITTED*.
  
 THIS MEANS IT IS NOT PERMISSIBLE TO USE TWO DIFFERENT
 METHODS TO SHOW COMPLIANCE. THE SUBMITTED INPUT DATA
 REPORT OF THE METHOD *A* IN BOTH CASES IS NOT COMPLETE.
  
 ** THEREFORE COMPLIANCE WITH PRESCRIPTIVE FOR NEW BEING
 INSTALLED IS REQUIRED TO BE MET.
 COMPLIANCE FOR METHOD *B* IS SHOWN ON PLANS FOR
 LIGHTING PERFORMANCE LEVELS AND IS ACCEPTABLE TO THIS
 OFFICE.
 13-415.AB.5, 13-415.B.1, 13-400.0.B.4. PLEASE TAKE A
 LOOK AT THE LAST SENTENCE FOR * BUILDINGS NOT MEETING
 THE DEFINITION OF A RENOVATION.
  
 ** PLANS INDICATE ALLOWANCES FOR TWO AHU CLOSETS, YET
 THE PLANS ONLY CONTAIN ONE.
  
 ** AT SOME POINT THE FIXTURE K TYPE WILL BE REQUIRED TO
 BE IDENTIFIED ON FINAL PLANS OF RECORD.
  
  
 ** BASED ON THE ABOVE AND THE INFORMATION NOT YET
 SHOWN, THE LIGHTING PERFORMANCE CALCULATIONS ARE OVER
 THE ALLOWANCES OF THE FLORIDA ENERGY CODE.
  
 2) NOTE: ONE OF THE COPIES OF THE SUBMITTED METHOD *A*
 CALCULATIONS ARE PHOTO-COPIES OF SIGNED DOCUMENTS. THIS
 IS NOT PERMITTED PER FAC 61G15-23.002, FS 471.025
  
 3) NOTE: COMPLIANCE FOR NEW LIGHTING CONTROLS BEING
 INSTALLED SHALL MEET 13-415.AB.1.1,.1.2 AND .1.3.
 PLEASE SEE 13-415.AB.1.3 SPECIFICALLY AS OTHER LIGHTING
 SUCH AS TRACK LIGHTING WHICH IS NOT PART OF THE GENERAL
 LIGHTING SHALL HAVE SEPARATE CONTROLS.
 PLANS INDICATE SOME SORT OF SWITCHES HOWEVER THERE IS
 NOT ENOUGH INFORMATION FOR PROPOSED SYSTEM. ARE THESE
 OVER RIDES? NO INFORMATION ON PROPOSED SYSTEM, TIMES OF
 OVER RIDES, ETC
  
 4) NOTE: IS THE STAIRS AN EGRESS PATH BY DEFINITION? IF
 SO, PLEASE SEE NFPA-101 7.8.1.3, 7.9.2.2 FOR MINIMUM
 LIGHTING LEVELS REQUIRED.
  
 5) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 210.8B2 AS ALL RECEPTACLES 15/20AMP
 IN KITCHEN AREA SHALL BE GFI/ GFI PROTECTED. THIS IS
 REQUIRED WHETHER OR NOT RECEPTACLES SERVES A COUNTER
 SPACE OR DEDICATED EQUIPMENT.
  
 6) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 422.13 FOR STORAGE TYPE OF WATER
 HEATERS AND REQUIRED MINIMUM 125% LOAD TO BE FIGURED
 FOR CALCULATIONS OF SERVICES AND FEEDERS.
 ** SEE 2005 NEC COMMENTARY LAST SENTENCE. THIS IS
 CONSIDERED A CONTINUOUS LOAD.
  
 7) NOTE: PLEASE ALSO SHOW LOAD CALCULATION COMPLIANCE
 FOR SIZING SERVICE FEEDERS PER 220.43B
  
 9) NOTE: DISCONNECT FOR EXHAUST FAN IS MISSING. PLANS
 STATE TO TIME CLOCK FOR CONTROL?
 PLEASE SEE 430.102B
  
 10) NOTE: DISCONNECT FOR CU DOES NOT MEET 110.26 FOR
 MINIMUM CLEARANCES.
  
 11) NOTE: PLANS APPEAR TO SHOW HOUSE PANEL IN THIS
 TENANT SPACE. WHAT IS THIS TENANT SPACE A PART OF? BASE
 BUILDING?
  
 ** LOW VOLTAGE SYSTEMS, INCLUDING FIRE ALARMS ARE NOT
 INCLUDED. SEPARATE PERMITS AS INDICATED ON PLANS
 REQUIRED.
  
  
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
 TYPED IN A CLEAR MANNER PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
 CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
 CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
  
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2009-10-20 Cont ID  
Sent By mawillia Date 2009-10-20 Time 12:43 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mawillia Date 2009-10-20 Time 12:24 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-20 12:43:28*****PARTIAL APPROVAL******
  
  
 THE COMMENTS FROM THE PREVIOUS REVIEW HAVE BEEN
 ADDRESSED; PLAN SHEETS LS-1, A-1.0, A-2.0, E2.01, AND
 FA1.01 WERE STAMPED, INITIALED, AND DATED.
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2009-09-09 Cont ID  
Sent By mawillia Date 2009-09-09 Time 15:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mawillia Date 2009-09-09 Time 14:25 Sent To  
Notes
2009-09-09 15:10:28*****DENIED*****
  
 1. THE PROJECT SITE ADDRESS, INCLUDING THE SUITE
 NUMBER, SHALL BE IN THE TITLE BLOCK OF EACH SUBMITTED
 PLAN SHEET.
  
 2.. THE PLANS AND PROJECT LOCATION SHALL CORRELATE WITH
 THE PERMIT APPLICATION AS PER THE CONSTRUCTION SERVICES
 DEPARTMENT.
  
  
 TO EXPEDITE THE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS, INCLUDE A RESPONSE
 LETTER INDICATING (ON THE APPROPIATE PLAN SHEET) WHERE
 EACH ITEM WAS ADDRESSED
  
  
 CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 561-805-6722
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 4 Status N Date 2009-11-17 Cont ID  
Sent By btrobaug Date 2009-11-17 Time 15:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By btrobaug Date 2009-11-17 Time 15:10 Sent To B
Notes
2009-11-17 15:11:16TTO JIM'S DESK./WRT
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2009-10-28 Cont ID  
Sent By rmcdouga Date 2009-10-27 Time 13:33 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rmcdouga Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-28 13:34:37B15
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2009-09-30 Cont ID  
Sent By shill Date 2009-09-30 Time 16:55 Rev Time 0.00
Received By shill Date 2009-09-30 Time 16:55 Sent To  
Notes
2009-09-30 16:56:06B18
  
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date   Cont ID  
Sent By   Date 2009-09-18 Time   Rev Time 0.00
Received By lmartine Date 2009-08-26 Time 14:10 Sent To  
Notes
2009-08-26 14:11:04B-23
Review Stop IMPACT COUNTY IMPACT FEES
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2009-09-18 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2009-09-18 Time 19:27 Rev Time  
Received By dpalmer Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2009-11-09 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2009-11-09 Time 20:32 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2009-11-09 Time 20:31 Sent To  
Notes
2009-11-09 20:32:37REVISED M1.01 DELTA 3
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2009-11-02 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2009-11-02 Time 08:18 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2009-11-02 Time 08:18 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2009-10-17 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2009-10-17 Time 13:34 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2009-10-17 Time 13:06 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-17 13:34:01REVIEW #: 2ND
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 FBC 2007 CODE FAMILY W/ 2009 SUPPLEMENTS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
  
 THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS ARE NUMBERED TO CORRESPOND WITH
 PREVIOUS REVIEW COMMENTS AS WELL AS DESIGNER'S WRITTEN
 RESPONSES FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONTINUITY.
  
 1. PLAN INDICATES 4" ROUND SUPPLY DUCT TO COMPLY WITH
 EXCEPTION #3 PER FBC-M 607.5.3. FIRST, FLEX DUCTS MAY
 NOT PENETRATE ANY FIRE RESISTANCE RATED ASSEMBLY IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 607.7. PLAN STILL SHOWS FLEX DUCT
 PENETRATING THE RATED WALL. ALSO, ANY DUCT PENETRATION
 NOT REQUIRED TO HAVE A FIRE DAMPER SHALL COMPLY WITH
 SECTION 712 OF THE FBC-B PER FBC-M 607.1.1.
 NOTE: THIS ISSUE CAN BE ELIMINATED BY MOVING THE 4"
 ROUND TAP FURTHER DOWNSTREAM IN THE SUPPLY TRUNK TO THE
 OTHER SIDE OF THE RATED WALL, ELIMINATING THE NEED FOR
 THE 4" SUPPLY DUCT TO PENETRATE ANY RATED ASSEMBLIES.
  
 2. OK
  
 3. PROVIDE BOOSTER FAN MANUFACTURER'S INSTALLATION
 INSTRUCTIONS AS WELL AS ANY LISTING INFORMATION PER
 FBC-M 504.6. NO SUCH LISTING COULD BE FOUND. ALSO,
 PROVIDE DRYER MANUFACTURER'S INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS
 WHICH SHOW PROVISIONS FOR A DRYER BOOSTER FAN AS WELL
 AS FOR INTERLOCKING OF BOSSTER FAN WITH DRYER. CLOTHES
 DRYERS SHALL BE EXHAUSTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
 MANUFACTURER'S INSTRUCTIONS PER FBC-M 504.1.
 NOTE: IT IS LIKELY THAT A CLOTHES DRYER CAN BE FOUND
 AND SPECIFIED WHICH WILL ALLOW THE LENGTH OF DRYER DUCT
 SHOWN ON PLANS WITHOUT THE USE OF A BOSSTER FAN. IF
 THIS OPTION IS USED, PROVIDE THE DRYER MANUFACTURER'S
 INSTRUCTIONS WHICH SHOW THE ALLOWABLE DUCT LENGTH IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 504.6.1.
  
 4 THROUGH 8: OK
  
 9. THE OCCUPANT LOADS AND VENTILATION RATES SHOWN ON
 PAGE M2.01 VENTILATION CALCULATIONS DO NOT CORRESPOND
 WITH THE VENTILATION REQUIREMENTS BASED ON ASHRAE
 62.1-2004 TABLE 6-1. THE BAR, LOUNGE, FOYER AND
 BILLIARD AREAS SHALL BE CALCULATED WITH AN OCCUPANT
 LOAD OF 100 PEOPLE PER 1000 SQUARE FEET AND AT A
 VENTILATION RATE OF 7.5 CFM/PERSON PLUS 0.18 CFM/SQ FT
 OF AREA.
 NOTE: WHILE IT IS UNDERSTOOD THAT VENTILATION
 CALCULATIONS SHOULD NOT BE PERFORMED BASED ON BUILDING
 CODE OCCUPANT LOADS, IT IS UNNREASONABLE TO PROVIDE
 VENTILATION CALCULATIONS FOR 22 PEOPLE WHEN THE LIFE
 SAFETY PLAN SHOWS AN OCCUPANT LOAD OF 121 PEOPLE.
  
 10. BASED ON COMMENT #9 ABOVE, IT IS LIKELY THAT
 MOTORIZED DAMPERS WILL BE REQUIRED ON OUTSIDE AIR
 INTAKES PER FBC-B 13-409.AB.3.3. ALSO, PROVIDE UPDATED
 COOLING LOAD CALCULATIONS SHOWING INCREASED VENTILATION
 RATES AND PROPERLY SIZED APPLIANCES IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBC-M 312.1 AND FBC-B 13-407.AB.1.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J. REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2009-09-08 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2009-09-08 Time 10:18 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2009-09-03 Time 16:59 Sent To  
Notes
2009-09-08 10:18:30REVIEW #: 1ST
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 FBC 2007 CODE FAMILY W/ 2009 SUPPLEMENTS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
  
 1. FLOOR PLAN SHOWS SEVERAL DUCTS PENETRATING RATED
 WALL ASSEMBLIES WITHOUT PROTECTION. EXAMPLES: 4 INCH
 SUPPLY AND EXHAUST AT STAFF RESTROOM B14, 10X3 EXHAUST
 AT GAME ROOM B03. THESE ARE EXAMPLES AND NOT INTENDED
 TO BE AN EXHAUSTIVE LIST. CHECK ALL WALL PENETRATIONS
 FOR REQUIRED PROTECTION OF PENETRATIONS IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH FBC-M 607.1.
  
 2. AHU 3 AND AHU 4 SHARE A COMMON RETURN AIR PLENUM.
 EACH UNIT SHALL BE PROVIDED WITH DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS
 IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 606.2.2. THE DUCT SMOKE
 DETECTORS SHALL BE CONNECTED TO THE BUILDING FIRE ALARM
 SYSTEM IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 606.4.1.
  
 3. PLANS APPEAR TO SHOW THE DRYER EXHAUST DUCT
 CONNECTING TO AN EXTERIOR, WALL MOUNTED EXHAUST FAN. AN
 EXHAUST FAN USED FOR THIS PURPOSE MUST BE LISTED AND
 LABELED AS A DRYER BOOSTER FAN IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M
 504.6. ALSO, THE DRYER MANUFACTURER'S INSTALLATION
 INSTRUCTIONS MUST ALSO INCLUDE THE USE OF AN ADDITIONAL
 FAN (AS WELL AS THE INTERLOCK OF FAN WITH DRYER AS
 CALLED FOR ON THE FAN SCHEDULE) IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 FBC-M 504.1.
  
 4. THE CLOTHES DRYER EXHAUST DUCT IS SHOWN PENETRATING
 A RATED WALL WITH A FIRE DAMPER. FIRE DAMPERS AND ANY
 SIMILAR DEVICES THAT WILL OBSTRUCT THE EXHAUST FLOW
 SHALL BE PROHIBITED IN CLOTHES DRYER EXHAUST DUCTS IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 504.2. THIS DUCT PENETRATION MAY
 BE PROTECTED AS A THROUGH-PENETRATION IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH FBC-B SECTION 712.
  
 5. THE DRYER EXHAUST DUCT SHALL NOT BE LOCATED IN A
 PLENUM IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 601.5.
  
 6. OUTDOOR EXHAUST FANS AND CONDENSING UNITS SHALL BE
 DESIGNED AND INSTALLED FOR WIND RESISTANCE IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M 301.12. PROVIDE MANUFACTURER'S
 DATA FOR FANS AND CONDENSERS SHOWING THESE APPLIANCES
 ARE DESIGNED FOR WIND RESISTANCE. PROVIDE
 MANUFACTURER'S INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS FOR WIND
 RESISTANT INSTALLATION IF APPLICABLE. THERE IS NO
 INSTALLATION DETAIL ON PLANS FOR THE FANS.
 NOTE: THE CONDENSER INSTALLATION DETAIL REFERENCES
 FBC-M 301.13.1, WHICH WAS A PRESCRIPTIVE METHOD OF
 INSTALLATION IN THE 2004 FBC FOR R-3 OCCUPANCIES ONLY.
 THIS PRESCRIPTIVE METHOD IS NOT APPLICABLE. AN
 ENGINEERED DESIGN IS REQUIRED. THE MANUFACTURER'S WIND
 CERTIFICATION MAY CONTAIN SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS FOR A
 WIND RESISTANCE COMPLIANT INSTALLATION.
  
 7. SUBMIT PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR WALL LOUVERS IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FAC RULE 9B-72.
  
 8. EMPLOYEE LOUNGE B13 IS SEPARATED FROM THE AHU BY A
 1-HOUR FULL HEIGHT PARTITION. SHOW HOW BALANCED RETURN
 IS TO BE ACHIEVED IN THIS AREA IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-M
 601.4.
  
 9. THE VENTILATION CALCULATIONS CLASSIFY ALL AREAS
 SERVED BY THESE SYSTEMS AS "OFFICE." THIS IS NOT
 CORRECT. THESE VENTILATION SYSTEMS SHALL BE DESIGNED TO
 HAVE THE CAPACITY TO SUPPLY THE MINIMUM OUTDOOR AIRFLOW
 RATE DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH TABLE 403.3 BASED ON
 THE OCCUPANCY OF THE SPACE AND THE OCCUPANT LOAD. THE
 FLOOR PLAN SHOWS SEVERAL DIFFERENT AREAS WITH DIFFERENT
 VENTILATION REQUIREMENTS, SUCH AS (EXAMPLES) THE BAR,
 GAME ROOM, LOUNGE AND FITNESS CENTER. PROVIDE
 SPACE-BY-SPACE VENTILATION CALCULATIONS SHOWING THE
 CORRECT OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATION, OCCUPANT LOAD AND
 VENTILATION RATE FOR EACH SPACE.
 NOTE: COOLING LOADS MAY ALSO BE AFFECTED BY INCREASED
 VENTILATION.
  
 10. NOTE ON PAGE M2.01 CALLS FOR MANUAL VOLUME DAMPER
 IN LIEU OF A MOTORIZED DAMPER ON THE OUTSIDE AIR
 INTAKES. ACCORDING TO FBC-B 13-409.AB.3.3, A GRAVITY
 OPERATED DAMPER MAY BE USED IN LIEU OF A MOTORIZED
 DAMPER IF THE INTAKE IS LESS THAN 300 CFM. IN ADDITION
 TO THE GRAVITY DAMPER, A MANUAL VOLUME DAMPER IS
 REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-B 13-409.AB.1.1.
 NOTE: VENTILATION QUANTITIES ARE LIKELY TO EXCEED 300
 CFM ONCE VENTILATION RATES ARE RECALCULATED PER COMMENT
 #9 ABOVE. IF SO, PROVIDE MOTORIZED VOLUME DAMPERS IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-B 13-409.AB.3.3.
  
 ENERGY CALCULATIONS: THE METHOD A COMPLIANCE FORM
 SUBMITTED WILL NOT BE REVIEWED FOR THIS PROJECT. THIS
 IS AN ALTERATION TO A PORTION OF AN EXISTING BUILDING
 WHICH DOES NOT MEET THE DEFINITION OF A RENOVATION. AN
 ENERGY CODE COMPLIANCE FORM IS NOT REQUIRED. THE
 DESIGNER IS ONLY REQUIRED TO DEMONSTRATE COMPLIANCE
 WITH THE PRESCRIPTIVE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR NEW
 SYSTEMS BEING INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC-B
 13-101.6.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J. REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 4 Status N Date 2009-12-15 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2009-12-15 Time 11:16 Rev Time  
Received By kstevens Date   Time   Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2009-10-29 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2009-10-29 Time 14:52 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2009-10-29 Time 14:52 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-29 14:53:40PASSED/PROVISO:
 GRAB BARS ON THE BACK WALL OF THE SHOWER SHALL COMPLY
 WITH FIGURE 37 OF CHAPTER 11 FBC-BUILDING.
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2009-10-01 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2009-10-01 Time 13:59 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2009-10-01 Time 13:59 Sent To  
Notes
2009-10-01 14:00:16PASSED/PROVISO:
 GRAB BARS ON THE BACK WALL OF THE SHOWER SHALL COMPLY
 WITH FIGURE 37 OF CHAPTER 11 FBC-BUILDING.
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2009-08-26 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2009-08-26 Time 16:29 Rev Time 0.00
Received By kstevens Date 2009-08-26 Time 16:29 Sent To  
Notes
2009-08-26 17:03:05DENIED
 REFERENCE:
 FBC-2007 PLUMBING
 FBC-2007 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2007 CHAPTER 11
  
 1. SUBMIT A DETAIL FOR THE DRINKING FOUNTAIN SHOWING
 COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 11-4.15 WITH ALL SUBSECTIONS AS
 WELL AS SECTION 11-4.1.3(10)(A) PROVISIONS FOR THOSE
 WHO HAVE DIFFICULTY BENDING OR STOOPING.
  
 2. SHT A-3.0 SHOW COMPLIANCE FOR THE FOLLOWING
 ACCESSIBILITY REQUIREMENTS:
 ___FOR W/C'S
 A. 11-4.16.3 HEIGHT
 B. 11-4.16.5 FLUSH CONTROLS
 C. FIG. 28 W/C SHALL BE 1'6" OFF THE WALL TO THE
 CENTERLINE OF THE FIXTURE
 ___FOR LAVS
 A. 11-4.19.4 EXPOSED PIPES & SURFACES
 B. 11-4.19.5 FAUCETS
 C. 1104.19.3 LAV SHALL BE MINIMUM 15" OFF THE WALL TO
 THE CENTERLINE OF THE FIXTURE.
 ____FOR SHWRS
 A. 11-4.21.2 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE
 B. 11-4.21.4 GRAB BARS
  
 3. SHT P1.01 KEY NOTES #10 THE CONDENSATE SHALL BE
 PIPED OUT SEPARATELY OUT OF THE BUILDING AND DRAIN INTO
 THE STORM LINE WITH A RELIEF VENT, (GOOSENECK),
 INSTALLED AS THE CONDENSATE EXITS THE BUILDING, OR TO A
 DRYWELL OR A PLANTED AREA. THIS SHALL BE CORRECTED ON
 SHT P-2.01 RISER #1 RAIN WATER AS WELL. SECTION
 314.2.1.
  
 4. SHT P-2.01 RISER #1 RAIN WATER SHOW ALL PIPE SIZES
 AND INDICATE THE SQUARE FOOTAGE BEING DRAIN BY EACH
 DRAIN. TABLE 1106.3.
  
 5. SHTS P-1.01 & P-2.01 A FLOOR DRAIN IS NOT AN
 APPROVED INDIRECT WASTE RECEPTOR FOR THE ICE MACHINE. A
 FLOOR SINK OR HUB DRAIN IS REQUIRED PER SECTIONS 802.3
 & 802.3.2.
  
 6. SHT P-2.01 RISER #3 WATER. THE WATER HAMMER
 ARRESTORS SHALL BE LOCATED NEAR THE FIXTURE IN AN
 "EFFECTIVE RANGE" FOR THE WASH MACHINE, NOT IN THE
 CEILING AS SHOWN. PDI-WH 201.
  
 7. SHT P-2.01 RISER #2 SANITARY. 3 INCH PIPE IS
 REQUIRED FOR THE WASH MACHINE STACK AND BRANCH DRAIN
 PER SECTION 406.3. PLEASE INDICATE ON RISER.
  
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER,
 WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION MADE,
 IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
 PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. REMOVE
 ALL VOID SHEETS FROM ALL PLANS AND PLACE
 ONE SET OF THEM LOOSELY ON TOP OF THE
 COLLATED PLANS TO BE REVIEWED.
 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 805-6731
 E-MAIL [email protected]
  
  
  
Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2009-09-11 Cont ID  
Sent By aaponte Date 2009-09-11 Time 16:10 Rev Time 0.00
Received By aaponte Date 2009-09-11 Time 16:10 Sent To  
Notes
2009-09-11 16:11:17INTERIOR IMPROVMENTS ONLY. NO ZONING REQUIRED.


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved