City of West Palm Beach eGovPlus

Plan Review Details - Permit 08070134

Plan Review Stops For Permit 08070134

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	7	Status	P	Date	2009-01-06			Cont ID
Sent By	shill			Date	2009-01-06	Time	11:11	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	shill			Date	2009-01-06	Time	11:11	Sent To

Notes

2009-01-06 11:12:50	WIND LOAD CALCS FOR ROOFTOP UNIT, LENNOX L SERIES DATED
	12/23/8 PREPARED BY SALAM BLANEY, PE

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	6	Status	F	Date	2008-12-19			Cont ID
Sent By	shill			Date	2008-12-19	Time	14:21	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	shill			Date	2008-12-19	Time	14:21	Sent To

Notes

2008-12-19 14:26:29	**CORRECTIONS**

	SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
	561-805-6724 [email protected]

	FBC FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
	FBC EB FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
	CODE
	FBC R FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL
	FBC* CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
	FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
	FS FLORIDA STATUTE


	COMMENT FROM PREVIOUS LIST:

	4. IF PULLOUT VALUE FOR #10 SCREW IS 109, WITH A SAFETY
	FACTOR OF 2, SHOULDN'T IT BE DIVIDED BY TWO RATHER THAN
	MULTIPLIED BY TWO? CAPACITY WITH STRESS INCREASE FROM
	CALCULATIONS PROVIDED IS 290; IT DOES NOT SEEM LOGICAL
	WHEN PRODUCT DATA STATES 109. THIS COMMENT ALSO APPLIES
	TO SHEAR FOR #10 AND PULLOUT AND SHEAR FOR #12. PLEASE
	EXPLAIN CALCULATION.

	2ND ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT WIND LOAD CALC REVIEW:

	ALL COMMENTS WERE ADDRESSED EXCEPT FOR ITEM 4. PLEASE
	CONTACT ME TO EXPLAIN RATIONALE. IT APPEARS THAT THE
	CAPACITY OF THE SCRE HAS BEEN INCREASED BY 3/2 (109
	PULLOUT TIMES 3/2). FOR A FACTOR OF SAFETY OF 2,
	SHOULDN'T IT BE MULTIPLIED BY 1/2, REDUCING IT BY HALF?
	IT APPEARS THAT THE SCREW CAPACITY HAS BEEN INCREASED
	BY 50%.

	DUE TO THE URGENCY OF GETTING THIS MATTER RESOLVED,
	PLEASE SUBMIT THE CALCULATIONS VIA EMAIL FOR
	PRELIMINARY REVIEW. PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ME IF
	YOU DISAGREE WITH THE COMMENTS.

	3RD ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT WIND LOAD CALC REVIEW:

	PER CONVERSATION WITH ENGINEER, THE SCREW HAS A 3.0
	FACTOR OF SAFETY. THEREFORE, THE ENGINEER FELT THAT A
	FACTOR OF SAFETY OF 2 FOR THE UNIT WAS INCLUDED THROUGH
	THE FACTOR OF SAFETY OF 3 IN THE SCREW VALUES. IT IS
	OUR OPINION THAT THIS RATIONALE IS NOT CORRECT; THERE
	IS A FACTOR OF SAFETY ON THE LOAD, AND A FACTOR OF
	SAFETY ON THE MATERIAL, AND THE TWO ARE DIFFERENT. ONE
	CANNOT SUBSTITUTE FOR THE OTHER. IT SEEMS THAT THE
	FACTOR OF SAFETY FOR THE LOAD SHOULD BE APPLIED TO THE
	LOAD VALUE, THEN DEMONSTRATED THAT THE SCREWS PROPOSED
	MEET THAT DESIGN REQUIREMENT. PLEASE EITHER REVISE THE
	CALCULATIONS ACCORDINGLY OR PROVIDE DOCUMENTATION TO
	SUPPORT YOUR ARGUMENT (CODE REFERENCES, PUBLISHED
	DOCUMENTS, NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED STANDARDS, ETC.). YOU
	ARE WELCOME TO SUBSTANTIATE THE CALCULATIONS SUBMITTED;
	ANY DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED WILL BE REVIEWED AND CONSIDERED
	PROMPTLY. DUE TO THE URGENCY, PLEASE SUBMIT VIA EMAIL.

	REVIEW DONE AT REQUEST OF RR (EXPEDITED)

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	5	Status	F	Date	2008-12-18			Cont ID
Sent By	shill			Date	2008-12-18	Time	08:25	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	shill			Date	2008-12-18	Time	08:25	Sent To

Notes

2008-12-18 08:40:26	**CORRECTIONS**

	SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
	561-805-6724 [email protected]

	FBC FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
	FBC EB FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
	CODE
	FBC R FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL
	FBC* CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
	FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
	FS FLORIDA STATUTE

	COMMENT FROM PREVIOUS LIST:

	4. IF PULLOUT VALUE FOR #10 SCREW IS 109, WITH A SAFETY
	FACTOR OF 2, SHOULDN'T IT BE DIVIDED BY TWO RATHER THAN
	MULTIPLIED BY TWO? CAPACITY WITH STRESS INCREASE FROM
	CALCULATIONS PROVIDED IS 290; IT DOES NOT SEEM LOGICAL
	WHEN PRODUCT DATA STATES 109. THIS COMMENT ALSO APPLIES
	TO SHEAR FOR #10 AND PULLOUT AND SHEAR FOR #12. PLEASE
	EXPLAIN CALCULATION.

	2ND ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT WIND LOAD CALC REVIEW:

	ALL COMMENTS WERE ADDRESSED EXCEPT FOR ITEM 4. PLEASE
	CONTACT ME TO EXPLAIN RATIONALE. IT APPEARS THAT THE
	CAPACITY OF THE SCRE HAS BEEN INCREASED BY 3/2 (109
	PULLOUT TIMES 3/2). FOR A FACTOR OF SAFETY OF 2,
	SHOULDN'T IT BE MULTIPLIED BY 1/2, REDUCING IT BY HALF?
	IT APPEARS THAT THE SCREW CAPACITY HAS BEEN INCREASED
	BY 50%.

	DUE TO THE URGENCY OF GETTING THIS MATTER RESOLVED,
	PLEASE SUBMIT THE CALCULATIONS VIA EMAIL FOR
	PRELIMINARY REVIEW. PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ME IF
	YOU DISAGREE WITH THE COMMENTS.

	REVIEW DONE AT REQUEST OF RR (EXPEDITED)

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	4	Status	F	Date	2008-11-07			Cont ID
Sent By	shill			Date	2008-11-07	Time	12:35	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	shill			Date	2008-11-06	Time	13:39	Sent To

Notes

2008-11-07 12:35:49	**CORRECTIONS**

	SAMANTHA HILL, BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER
	561-805-6724 [email protected]

	FBC FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004
	FBC EB FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 EXISTING BUILDING
	CODE
	FBC R FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2004 RESIDENTIAL
	FBC* CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO THE FBC2004
	FAC FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
	FS FLORIDA STATUTE

	1. TITLE BLOCK REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
	FAC61G15-23.002. (COFA MISSING)

	2. THE FIRST PAGE OF CALCS STATES THAT A 33% ALLOWABLE
	STRESS INCREASE WAS TAKEN. SEE FBC1605.3.1.1(2) AND
	CLARIFY USE OF STRESS INCREASE.

	3. REPORTS ARE TO USE AN INDEX SHEET IN ACCORDANCE WITH
	FAC61G15-23.002. THE CALCULATIONS SUBMITTED DO NOT HAVE
	PAGE NUMBERS AND ARE NOT OTHERWISE IDENTIFIED. PLEASE
	REVISE.

	4. IF PULLOUT VALUE FOR #10 SCREW IS 109, WITH A SAFETY
	FACTOR OF 2, SHOULDN'T IT BE DIVIDED BY TWO RATHER THAN
	MULTIPLIED BY TWO? CAPACITY WITH STRESS INCREASE FROM
	CALCULATIONS PROVIDED IS 290; IT DOES NOT SEEM LOGICAL
	WHEN PRODUCT DATA STATES 109. THIS COMMENT ALSO APPLIES
	TO SHEAR FOR #10 AND PULLOUT AND SHEAR FOR #12. PLEASE
	EXPLAIN CALCULATION.

	5. THE ENGINEER'S SEAL IS TO BE ONE ACCEPTABLE TO THE
	BOARD, FAC61G15. THE SEAL IS TO STATE "LICENSE" RATHER
	THAN "CERTIFICATE".

	REVIEW DONE AT REQUEST OF RR (EXPEDITED)

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	3	Status	P	Date	2008-09-11			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-09-11	Time	16:00	Rev Time	1.22
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-09-11	Time	15:53	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-08-21			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-08-21	Time	09:01	Rev Time	0.88
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-08-21	Time	09:01	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	B			BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-24			Cont ID
Sent By	jwitmer			Date	2008-07-24	Time	13:39	Rev Time	2.22
Received By	jwitmer			Date	2008-07-24	Time	13:39	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-24 15:18:38	BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
	PERMIT: 08070134
	ADD: 2021 OKEECHOBEE BLVD # A2
	CONT: GERARDI CONSTRUCTION
	TEL: (813)433-3868

	FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
	W/ 2007 FBC REVISIONS
	* WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS

	REVIEW
	ACTION: DENIED

	1A)INFORMATIONAL: WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE
	INDICATE THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY PAGES AS
	NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL
	REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE
	REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION
	PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND WILL HELP TO
	EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED
	COOPERATION.

	1B) INFORMATIONAL FL S S 713.13NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT, TO BE FILED WITH THE CLERK OF THE COURT.
	NOTE: 713.13(2) IF THE WORK DESCRIBED IN THE NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT IS NOT ACTUALLYCOMMENCED WITHIN 90 DAYS
	AFTER THE RECORDING THEREOF, SUCH NOTICE IS NULL &
	VOID. NOTE: 713.13(6) THE POSTING OF THE NOTICE OF
	COMMENCEMENT AT THE CONSTRUCTION SITE BEFORE THE FIRST
	INSPECTION.

	1C) INFORMATIONAL: PLANS SUBMITTED FOR PERMIT (FIRST
	TIME REVIEW) AFTER JULY 1ST, 2007 SHALL BE REVIEWED TO
	THE 2004 FBC BUILDING WITH THE2007 SUPPLEMENTS.

	2) COVER SHEET CVR, CODE REVIEW
	2A) PLEASE UPDATE TO THE 2007 SUPPLEMENTS, BUILDING
	2B) COMMENT# 7 ENERGY CODE COMMONWEALTH OF
	MASSACHUSETTS, PLEASE CORRECT
	2C) COMMENT# 9 THIS IS NOT THE PALM BEACH COUNTY
	PLANNING, ZONING AND BUILDING DEPARTMENTPLEASE CORRECT
	TO THE CORRECT JURISDICTION
	2D) UNDER THE CODE REVIEW PLANS FAIL TO INDICATE THE
	2004 EXISTING BUILDING CODE AND TO WHAT LEVEL OR
	COMBINATION OF LEVELS THE DESIGN PROFESSIONAL OR OWNER
	HAS DESIGNED TO. FBC EXISTING BUILDING
	CODE301.5.

	3) SHEET A5 INDICATES A DETAIL 12/ A9.1 WHICH IS A
	SOFFIT DETAIL INDICATING A SINGLE # 12 PAN HEAD SCREW
	2'-0" O.C. IN TENSION TO HOLD THE 5/8" DRYWALL AND WALL
	FRAMING FROM WHAT TYPE OF STRUCTURE ABOVE?
	PLEASE INDICATE WHAT STRUCTURAL MEMBER THIS SOFFIT
	WILL BE HUNG FROM AND PROVIDE CLALCULATIONS ON THE
	FASTENER IN TENTION LISTED ABOVE AND THE DEAD LOADING
	ON THIS SCREW AND SAFETY FACTORS INVOLVED.
	1604.2 STRENGTH.

	4) SHEET A7 DETAIL# 4 INDICATES A BREAK ROOM SINK,
	PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION:
	11-4.24.2 HEIGHT. SINKS SHALL BE MOUNTED WITH THE
	COUNTER OR RIM NO HIGHER THAN 34" ABOVE THE FINISH
	FLOOR.
	11-4.24.3 KNEE CLEARANCE THAT IS AT LEAST 27" HIGH 30"
	WIDE, AND 19" DEEP SHALL BE PROVIDED UNDERNEATH SINKS.
	11-4.24.5 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE. A CLEAR FLOOR SPACE AT
	LEAST 30 INCHES BY 48 INCHES (760 MM BY 1219 MM)
	COMPLYING WITH SECTION 11-4.2.4 SHALL BE PROVIDED IN
	FRONT OF A SINK TO ALLOW FORWARD APPROACH. THE CLEAR
	FLOOR SPACE SHALL BE ON AN ACCESSIBLE ROUTE AND SHALL
	EXTEND A MAXIMUM OF 19 INCHES (485 MM) UNDERNEATH THE
	SINK.

	5) SHEET A11 INDICATES WOOD BACKING OR BLOCKING, PLEASE
	SEE 603.1 FOR AREAS WHERE FIRE RETARDANT TREATED WOOD
	CAN BE USED.

	6) I COULD NOT FIND IN THE PLANS A ACTUAL FINISH
	SCHEDULE, PLEASE COMPLY WITH 1210.2 WALLS WITHIN 2 FEET
	OF URINALS AND WATER CLOSETS SHALL HAVE A SMOOTH, HARD,
	NON ABSORBANT SURFACE, TO A HEIGHT OF 4'-0".

	JIM WITMER C. B. O.
	BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II

	TEL: (561)805-6715
	FAX: (561)659-8026
	E-MAIL: [email protected]

	PLEASE NOTE: FLORIDA HAS A VERY BROAD PUBLIC RECORDS
	LAW. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS TO OR FROM LOCAL OFFICIALS
	REGARDING CITY BUSINESS ARE PUBLIC RECORD, AVAILABLE TO
	THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. YOUR E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS ARE
	THEREFORE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE.

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	4	Status	P	Date	2008-09-24			Cont ID
Sent By	dpalmer			Date	2008-09-24	Time	14:35	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	dpalmer			Date	2008-09-24	Time	14:35	Sent To	PC

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	3	Status	F	Date	2008-09-16			Cont ID
Sent By	dpalmer			Date	2008-09-16	Time	08:28	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	dpalmer			Date	2008-09-16	Time	08:28	Sent To	PC

Notes

2008-09-16 08:29:36
	DENIED

	1) NOTE: PLANS NEED ADJUSTMENTS FOR FBC
	13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2.
	CLOSET/STORAGE ROOM MISSING LIGHT FIXTURE AND CONTROL.
	MISSING OVER RIDE CONTROLS AT REAR OF STORE FOR
	OCCUPANTS ENTERING RETAIL SPACE(S).
	MISSING OCCUPANCY SENSOR/OVER RIDE FROM HALL TO REAR
	(WEST) STOCK RECEIVING AREA. THE SINGLE DEVICE AS SHOWN
	WOULD NOT PROVIDE COVERAGE WITH THE RACKING SYSTEM AS
	SHOWN ON PLANS.
	SPOKE TO KEN SNARE HE IS GOING TO VERY THE WATTAGE ON
	WALL-PACK FIXTURES AS THE FIXTURE LEGEND AND INPUT DATA
	REPORT SHOW SOME DIFFERENCES.
	MR. SNARE WILL ALSO VERIFY THE PHOENIX FIXTURE WHICH
	IS ON FIXTURE LEGEND HOWEVER NOT ON PLANS. THIS FIXTURE
	CAN BE REDLINED AS NOT TO BE USED WITHOUT HAVING TO
	REVISE PLANS.
	SHEET E-2.1 NEEDS TO BE RE-DONE.




	IMPORTANT
	ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
	FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
	ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
	SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
	DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
	PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
	ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
	SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
	TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
	PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
	SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
	THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
	ANY DELAYS.


	IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
	TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
	CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.


	DEWEY PALMER
	ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
	CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
	CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
	561-805-6717
	[email protected]

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	2	Status	F	Date	2008-08-26			Cont ID
Sent By	dpalmer			Date	2008-08-26	Time	13:36	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	dpalmer			Date	2008-08-26	Time	13:36	Sent To

Notes

2008-08-26 13:37:38




	DENIED 2ND REVIEW

	** PLEASE SEE SOME NOTES FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW ARE STILL
	IN NEED OF ADDRESSING.




	1) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE COVER SHEET WHICH STATES
	CHAPTER 13 OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE FOR
	ACCESSIBILITY. THIS NEEDS TO BE CHAPTER 11. IF THIS
	WERE THE ONLY COMMENT THE PLANS COULD BE REDLINED
	HOWEVER THERE ARE OTHER COMMENTS BELOW WHICH ARE IN
	NEED OF ADDRESSING.

	2) NOTE: PLEASE SEE MISSING CERTIFICATE OF
	AUTHORIZATION NUMBER IS STILL MISSING FROM ALL
	NOTATIONS OF ENGINEERING FIRM(S). PLEASE SEE COVER
	SHEET WHICH STILL SHOWS HALLBERG ENGINEERING. THIS IS
	SHOWN FOR ELECTRICAL AND OTHER TRADES.
	PLEASE ALSO SEE THE FIRE PROTECTION SHEETS WHICH STILL
	CONTAIN ARCHITECTURAL FIRM INFORMATION WHICH WOULD
	REQUIRE THE CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER.

	FAC 61G15-23.002, FS 471.023 FOR ENGINEERS
	FAC61G1-16.004, FS 481.219 FOR ARCHITECTS.

	** THESE ARE REQUIRED FOR ALL TRADES AND FOR ALL
	LOCATIONS ON PLANS WHETHER OR NOT COMMENT IS MADE BY
	THOSE OTHER TRADE REVIEWER(S).

	3) NOTE: PLEASE SEE PREVIOUS REVIEW NOTES FOR LIGHTING
	CONTROLS REQUIRED PER FBC 13-415.1.ABC.1.1, .1.2 AND
	.1.3. PLEASE SEE PLANS AS THERE ARE LOCATIONS IN WHICH
	ARE CONSIDERED SEPARATE SPACES AND ONLY STANDARD SINGLE
	POLE DEVICES ARE SHOWN. THESE ARE NOT ACCEPTABLE AND
	REQUIRE SOME SORT OF AUTOMATED MEANS FOR CONTROLLING
	LIGHTING. IF A SYSTEM IS PROVIDED THEN SEPARATE
	CONTROLS OF OVER RIDING THAT SYSTEM IS REQUIRED.
	PLEASE SEE OTHER AREAS SUCH AS STAGING AREA WHICH ONLY
	SEEMS TO SHOW ONE OCCUPANCY SENSOR TYPE DEVICE. PLEASE
	PROVIDE SPECS ON THIS PROPOSED DEVICE WHICH WILL
	PROVIDE COMPLETE COVERAGE OF THE OVER RIDE FUNCTION.

	4) NOTE: PLEASE COMPLETE ALL FIXTURE DESIGNATIONS ON
	PLANS AND CLEARLY INDICATE EACH FIXTURE. FOR EXAMPLE
	SOME FIXTURES SUCH AS THE CORELIGHT BRAND DOES NOT
	INDICATE ANY CLEAR DELINEATION OF THE FIXTURE. THE
	FIXTURE LEGEND NOTES A CERTAIN LENGTH HOWEVER BASED ON
	PLANS AND SCALE SHOWN THE LINEAR FEET OF FIXTURES IS
	SUBSTANTIALLY MORE THAN WHAT IS LISTED ON LEGEND. THIS
	IS ALSO NOTED FOR OTHER FIXTURES SUCH AS THE TRACK
	FIXTURE.
	PLEASE SEE THE INPUT DATA REPORT SUBMITTED DOES NOT
	COORDINATE WITH PLANS. IN FACT THERE ARE FIXTURES SHOWN
	ON PLANS WHICH ARE NOT IN THE INPUT DATA REPORT AT ALL.

	ONE EXAMPLE OF THIS IS THE EXTERIOR LIGHTING SHOWN IN
	THE IDR. THE LAST REVIEW OF THESE DOCUMENTS DID NOT
	INDICATE ANY FIXTURES AND NOW THE FIXTURE WHICH ARE
	SHOWN IN THE IDR ARE NOT THE SAME AS FIXTURES ON PLANS.
	IN FACT THERE ARE 250WATT FIXTURES AND 300WATT
	FIXTURE(S) WHICH ARE NOT IN THE IDR AT ALL AND YET
	THESE ARE ON PLANS.

	ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS THE INTERIOR LIGHTS WHICH NEED TO
	COORDINATE ALL ZONES AND SPACES. ONE OF THESE IS THE
	DESIGNATIONS OF OFFICES. THE IDR SHOWS 23 FIXTURES IN
	OFFICES AND BASED ON THE SHEET A-2, THERE ARE ONLY TWO
	OFFICES AND BOTH OF THEM TOGETHER DO NOT CONTAIN 23
	FIXTURES.
	HOW ARE THESE THINGS POSSIBLE?
	PLEASE COORDINATE ALL LIGHTING FIXTURES ON PLANS WITH
	THE ALLOWANCES. PLEASE SEE TABLE C IN 13-415.2.C. IF
	C METHOD IS CHOSEN THEN THE LIGHTING WATTAGE PER SQ
	FT OF THE ENTIRE SPACE MAY NOT EXCEED THE LEVEL OF 1.5
	WATTS PER SQUARE FOOT.
	THIS IS NOT AN EXHAUSTED LIST AS THERE ARE OTHER
	INCONSISTENCIES. PLEASE BE SURE TO COORDINATE ALL AND
	CALL TO GO OVER HOW TO SHOW COMPLIANCE.

	*** PLEASE SEE 13-415.2.ABC.1.1,.1.2,.1.3, 13-415.2.B,
	13-415.2.C ETC.

	5) NOTE: PLEASE COORDINATE AND COMPLETE ALL ROOM AND
	AREA DESIGNATIONS AS SHOWN ON A-2 WITH THAT OF
	ELECTRICAL PLANS. ONE EXAMPLE OF THIS IS ROOM 114 WHICH
	ON THE A2 SHEET IS SHOWN AS AN ELECTRICAL ROOM AND
	NOTES EQUIPMENT ETC. HOWEVER BASED ON THE ELECTRICAL
	PLANS THIS SAME ROOM DOES NOT SHOW ANY ELECTRICAL
	EQUIPMENT.

	110.26, 240.24, 408.17 ETC
	FBC 106.1.1 FOR CLARITY AND COORDINATION.

	6) NOTE: PLEASE SEE AS NOTED ON PREVIOUS REVIEW THE
	WORST CASE VOLTAGE DROP NEEDS TO BE SHOWN FOR BRANCH
	CIRCUIT(S). THE PLANS ONLY CHANGED TO QUOTE THE
	REQUIREMENT AND DID NOT PROVIDE THE INFORMATION.
	RESPONSE LETTER MENTIONS THIS WAS DONE AND COULD BE
	FOUND ON E-2 HOWEVER NO VOLTAGE DROP CALCULATION WAS
	PLACED ON PLANS.



	IMPORTANT
	ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
	FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
	ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
	SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
	DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
	PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
	ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
	SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
	TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
	PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
	SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
	THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
	ANY DELAYS.


	IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS; OR IF COMMENTS ARE NOT
	TYPED IN A CLEAR MANOR PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO
	CONTACT THIS REVIEWER.



	DEWEY PALMER
	ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
	CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
	CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
	561-805-6717
	[email protected]

Review Stop	E			ELECTRICAL
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-29			Cont ID
Sent By	dpalmer			Date	2008-07-29	Time	09:52	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	dpalmer			Date	2008-07-29	Time	09:52	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-29 09:52:49
	DENIEDREVIEW


	1) NOTE:PLEASE SEE THE JURISDICTION IN WHICH THIS
	SCOPE OF WORK HAS BEEN APPLIED IN LOCATED IN THE CITY
	OF WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA. THERE ARE REFERENCES ON
	PLANS TO PALM BEACH COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT. PLEASE
	ADJUST.

	2) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE FOLLOWING CODES SHALL BE STATED
	ON PLANS INCLUSIVE OF ARCHITECTURAL PLANS AS WELL AS
	ELECTRICAL SHEETS.
	SOME CODES LISTED SUCH AS THE 2004 ELECTRICAL CODE AND
	2002 LIFE SAFETY CODE DO NOT EXIST. PLEASE SEE THE
	PLANS ALSO INDICATE THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
	FOR THE ENERGY CODE. THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE CHAPTER
	13 IS THE STATE OF FLORIDA ENERGY CODE.
	PLEASE ADJUST.
	2005 NFPA-70
	2003 NFPA-101
	2002 NFPA-72
	2004 FBC W/2007 REVISIONS.

	3) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE MISSING INFORMATION ON THE
	TITLE BLOCKS ON FIRE ALARM PLANS. THE FLORIDA
	ADMINISTRATIVE CODE 61G15-23.002 REQUIRES THE PRINTED
	NAME, PRINTED LICENSE NUMBER OF THE ENGINEER ALONG WITH
	THE REQUIRED CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER.
	PLEASE SEE FLORIDA STATUTES 471.023 FOR THE REQUIREMENT
	OF LICENSING FOR FIRM.

	4) NOTE: PLEASE SEE COMMENT #3 ABOVE THE MEP PLANS ARE
	ALSO MISSING THE REQUIRED INFORMATION TO BE COMPLETED
	ON TITLE BLOCKS.
	THE MISSING CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER IS ALSO
	REQUIRED.
	FAC 61G15-23.002, FS 471.023.

	5) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT THE COMPLETE PERFORMANCE
	CALCULATIONS AS REQUIRED PER 13-415.2.ABC.1.1, .1.2,
	.1.3, 13-415.2.
	PLEASE SEE THE SQUARE FOOTAGE SHOWN ON THE CALCULATIONS
	AS SUBMITTED ARE LESS THAN THE SQ FT SHOWN ON
	ARCHITECTURAL PLANS.
	PLEASE SEE THE SUBMITTED CALCULATIONS ALONG WITH THE
	INPUT DATA REPORT DO NOT COORDINATE WITH PLANS. ALL
	FIXTURE WATTAGES, FIXTURE COUNTS ETC NEED TO MATCH WITH
	PLANS.
	IN FACT PLEASE SEE THE INPUT DATA REPORT. SOME ITEMS IN
	THE IDR ARE BLANK. HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE WHEN THESE
	ITEMS ARE IN FACT ON PLANS.
	JUST ONE EXAMPLE OF THIS IS THE EXTERIOR LIGHTING ON
	THE IDR. THIS IS BLANK WITH NO INPUT.
	** THIS IS ONE EXAMPLE ONLY.

	**PLEASE NOTE: THE PERSON AS SIGNED ON THE
	CERTIFICATION SHEET OF THE ENERGY CALCULATIONS AS THE
	PREPARER IS NOT LISTED AS ONE OF THE ENGINEERS OF
	RECORD. AS THE SCOPE OF WORK FALLS UNDER THE
	REQUIREMENTS OF AN ENGINEER THIS PERSON MUST BE
	LICENSED IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS SUCH.
	PLEASE PROVIDE LICENSE INFORMATION FOR SAID PREPARER
	MR. TREVOR GILBERTSON.
	13-103.1, FS 471.003

	6) NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT PLANS COMPLYING WITH THE FBC
	CHAPTER 13 FOR LIGHTING CONTROLS. THE EMS SYSTEM AS
	SUBMITTED DOES NOT COMPLETELY COMPLY WITH THE FOLLOWING
	SECTIONS. 13-415.1.ABC.1.1,.1.2, .1.3.
	PLEASE SEE NO OVER RIDES FOR OCCUPANTS COULD BE LOCATED
	ON PLANS.
	PLEASE SUBMIT ALL MAXIMUM TIMES ON OVER RIDES AND SPACE
	CONTROLS.
	PLEASE SEE NO SEPARATE SPACE CONTROLS ARE SHOWN ON
	PLANS. THE STANDARD DEVICES AS SHOWN DO NOT COMPLY WITH
	13-415.1.ABC.1.2.
	PLEASE COMPLETE LIGHTING CONTROLS AND CIRCUITING FOR
	CONTACTOR SCHEDULES. PLEASE KNOW THIS MAY CHANGE BASED
	ON THE NOTES ABOVE WITH THE SYSTEM DESIGN AT PRESENT.
	** AS A COMPLETE SYSTEM AND MANY DEVICES ARE NOT SHOWN
	THERE MAY VERY WELL BE NEW COMMENTS ON THE FOLLOWING
	REVIEW WHICH CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME.

	7) NOTE: PLEASE INCLUDE NOTES ON PLANS PER
	13-413.1.ABC.2.1
	DRAWINGS.
	CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SHALL REQUIRE THAT WITHIN 30
	DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF SYSTEM ACCEPTANCE, RECORD
	DRAWINGS OF THE ACTUAL INSTALLATION SHALL BE PROVIDED
	TO THE BUILDING OWNER, INCLUDING:
	1. A SINGLE-LINE DIAGRAM OF THE BUILDING ELECTRICAL
	DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM AND
	2. FLOOR PLANS INDICATING LOCATION AND AREA SERVED FOR
	ALL DISTRIBUTION.
	13-413.1.ABC.2.2 MANUALS.
	CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SHALL REQUIRE THAT AN OPERATING
	MANUAL AND MAINTENANCE MANUAL BE PROVIDED TO THE
	BUILDING OWNER. THE MANUALS SHALL INCLUDE, AT A
	MINIMUM, THE FOLLOWING:
	1. SUBMITTAL DATA STATING EQUIPMENT RATING AND SELECTED
	OPTIONS FOR EACH PIECE OF EQUIPMENT REQUIRING
	MAINTENANCE.
	2. OPERATION MANUALS AND MAINTENANCE MANUALS FOR EACH
	PIECE OF EQUIPMENT REQUIRING MAINTENANCE. REQUIRED
	ROUTINE MAINTENANCE ACTIONS SHALL BE CLEARLY
	IDENTIFIED.
	3. NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF AT LEAST ONE QUALIFIED
	SERVICE AGENCY.

	8) NOTE: PLEASE INCLUDE WORST CASE VOLTAGE DROP PER
	13-413.1.ABC.1.1 AND .1.2.

	9) NOTE: PLEASE INCLUDE REQUIRED MINIMUM FOR ADA
	COMPLIANCE FOR FIRE ALARM DEVICES INCLUSIVE OF ALL
	LEVELS LISTED IN 11-4.28.1, .2 AND .3 OF THE FLORIDA
	BUILDING CODE.

	10) NOTE: PLEASE SEE 700.12F FOR CIRCUITING OF THE
	EMERGENCY LIGHTS AND EXIT LIGHTS TO THE LOCAL LIGHTING
	BRANCH CIRCUITS. THE PLANS CALL FOR A LOCK OFF BREAKER
	TO MEET THE EXCEPTION IN THE NEC. PLEASE KNOW THE LOCK
	OFF BREAKER SHALL HAVE THE LOCK OFF MECHANISM PART OF
	THE BREAKER. THE SNAP ON OR CLIP ON TYPE LOCK OFF
	DEVICES ARE NOT ACCEPTABLE. PLEASE BE SURE TO CHECK THE
	LISTING OF THE UNIT IN DESIGN FOR PERMANENT
	INSTALLATION.110.3
	NOT CIRCUITING TO LOCAL BRANCH CIRCUIT IS THE EXCEPTION
	TO THE CODE.

	11) NOTE: PLEASE SEE THE RISER AS THIS NOTES FEEDERS
	BEFORE THE FIRST MEANS OF DISCONNECT. PLEASE SEE
	DEFINITIONS IN THE NEC AS THESE ARE THE SERVICE
	ENTRANCE CONDUCTORS.
	NEC 100.

	12) NOTE: PLEASE SHOW THE LOCATION OF THE SERVICE MAIN
	ON PLANS.
	110.26, 240.24, 230.70, 230.71 ETC

	13) NOTE: PLEASE SEE RISER AS THIS SHOWS THE
	TRANSFORMER BEING FED FROM THE RENAMED PANEL A YET
	THE PANEL A SCHEDULE DOES NOT INDICATE ANY OVER
	CURRENT PROTECTION OR FEED TO THIS TRANSFORMER. NEED TO
	VERIFY LOADS, OVER CURRENT PROTECTION, FEEDERS,
	EQUIPMENT GROUNDING ETC. 250.110,240.4,450.3,310.16,
	215.5 ETC
	FBC 106.1.1, 106.1.2 FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND
	CLARITY.

	14) NOTE: AS THE CIRCUITING FOR EXTERIOR LIGHTS THROUGH
	THE TIME CLOCKS FOR ANY OUTSIDE LIGHTING IS NOT SHOWN
	COMPLIANCE WITH FBC 13-415.1.ABC.1.4 CAN NOT BE
	VERIFIED AS CODE COMPLIANT.

	15) NOTE: PLEASE BE SUR EOT INLCUDE THE ADDRESS
	LOCATION AS APPLIED ON TITLE BLOCKS. THE ADDRESS
	LOCATION AS APPLIED IS 2021 OKEECHOBEE BLVD.
	FAC 61G1-16.004, 61G15-23.002

	**


	IMPORTANT**
	ONCE AUDIT/REVIEWS ARE COMPLETE AND PLANS ARE PICKED UP
	FOR CORRECTIONS, PLEASE BE SURE TO COMPLETELY REMOVE
	ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND ONLY INSERT NEW REVISED
	SHEETS INTO TWO COMPLETE SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING.
	DO NOT LEAVE ANY OLD/VOIDED SHEETS IN SETS.
	PLEASE DO NOT ATTACH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO PLANS. ANY
	ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION SUCH AS PRODUCT APPROVALS,
	SPEC/CUT SHEETS, CALCULATIONS ETC SHOULD BE PLACED INTO
	TWO SETS/FOLDERS/BINDERS ETC.
	PLEASE KNOW ONLY ONE SET OF THE OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
	SHOULD BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE.
	THIS WILL HELP IN THE AUDIT/REVIEW PROCESS AND AVOID
	ANY DELAYS.

	DEWEY PALMER
	ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW II
	CONSTRUCTION SERVICES DEPARTMENT
	CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
	561-805-6717
	[email protected]

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	4	Status	P	Date	2008-10-07			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-10-07	Time	17:39	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-10-07	Time	16:51	Sent To

Notes

2008-10-07 17:38:55	***REVISION # 2, DATED 10/01/08, APPROVED***

	REVISED PLAN SHEETS PLAN SHEETS FP1, FP2, AND FP3WERE
	STAMPED, INITIALED, AND DATED.


	CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	561-805-6722

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	3	Status	P	Date	2008-09-10			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-09-10	Time	14:26	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-09-10	Time	13:49	Sent To

Notes

2008-09-10 14:26:23	***APPROVED***

	THE COMMENTS FROM THE PREVIOUS FIRE PLAN REVIEWS HAVE
	BEEN ADDRESSED; PLAN SHEETS IND, A1,A5, A8, FP1, FP2,
	FP3, E2, AND E2.1 WERE STAMPED, INITIALED, AND DATED.


	CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	561-805-6722

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	2	Status	F	Date	2008-08-25			Cont ID
Sent By	mawillia			Date	2008-08-25	Time	19:19	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mawillia			Date	2008-08-25	Time	17:50	Sent To

Notes

2008-08-25 19:13:17	***UNSAT***


	THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS TAKEN FROM THE PREVIOUS FIRE
	PLAN REVIEW STILL NEED TO BE ADDRESSED. THE HIGHLIGHTED
	RESPONSES BY THE PLAN EXAMINER SUGGEST HOW EACH COMMENT
	CAN BE ADDRESSED:


	01. DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS SHALL INITIATE A GENERAL FIRE
	ALARM IN ACCORDANCE WITH LOCAL REQUIREMENTS. SINCE
	THERE ARE NO FIRE ALARM SHEETS, ADD COMMENT TO POWER
	NOTE #32 (SHEET E2) .

	02 FIRE ALARM SYSTEM TO BE UL CERTIFIED FOR CENTRAL
	STATION SEVICE. SINCE THERE ARE NO FIRE ALARM SHEETS,
	ADD COMMENT TO POWER NOTE #7 (SHEET E2) .

	03. FIRE ALARM SHALL BE CLASS A OR FULLY ADDRESSABLE.
	SINCE THERE ARE NO FIRE ALARM SHEETS, ADD COMMENT TO
	POWER NOTES (SHEET E2) .

	06. PHYSICAL ADDRESS REQUIRED ON EACH SHEET. ADD
	ADDRESS TO THE TITLE BLOCK OF SHEET FP-1, FP-2, & FP-3

	11. ADDRESS REQUIRED ON BUILDING SHALL BE A MINIMUM OF
	6" IN HEIGHT AND 1" IN WIDTH CONTRASTING WITH THE
	BACKGROUND FOR COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS. ON SHEET A8,
	DISPLAY/SHOW THE ACTUAL ADDRESS NUMBERS ON THE
	APPROPIATE EXTERIOR ELEVATION WHICH FRONTS OKEECHOBEE
	BOULEVARD

	12. KNOX BOX IS REQUIRED ON THE BUILDING FOR AFTER
	NORMAL BUSINESS HOURS EMERGENCY ACCESS. ON SHEET A8,
	DISPLAY/SHOW THE LOCATION OF THE KNOX BOX ON THE
	APPROPIATE EXTERIOR ELEVATION WHICH FRONTS OKEECHOBEE
	BOULEVARD

	13. PLEASE EXPLAIN NOTES ON SHEET FP-1 REFERENCING FLOW
	TEST RESULTS TAKEN BY TVA FIRE AND LIFE SAFETY. PLAN
	EXAMINER TO VERIFY FINDINGS REFERRING TO RESULTS
	OBTAINED FROM WEST PALM BEACH WATER AUTHORITY ON 3/08
	OR 18/2008

	14. IF THE FIRE DEPARTMENT CONNECTION FOR THE PROJECT
	IS NEW, KNOX LOCKING CAPS ARE REQUIRED. ADD COMMENT TO
	AN APPROPIATE FP SHEET


	CAPT. MICHAEL A. WILLIAMS
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	561-805-6722
	FIRE INSPECTIONS
	561-804-4751

Review Stop	FIRE			FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-31			Cont ID
Sent By	mwennerg			Date	2008-07-31	Time	13:56	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mwennerg			Date	2008-07-31	Time	13:56	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-31 14:14:16	*DENIED*

	1) DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS SHALL INITIATE A GENERAL FIRE
	ALARM IN ACCORDANCE WITH LOCAL REQUIREMENTS. SHEET FA-1
	NOTE C-1

	2) FIRE ALARM SYSTEM TO BE UL CERTIFICATED FOR CENTRAL
	STATION SERVICE. PROVIDE NOTE WITH SPECIFIC LANGUAGE ON
	FA SHEET.

	3) FIRE ALARM SHALL BE CLASS A OR FULLY ADDRESSABLE.

	4) DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS REQUIRED IN SUPPLY DUCT WHERE
	UNIT IS GREATER THAN 2000 CFM UNLESS REQUIRED IN SUPPLY
	AND RETURN FOR LARGER UNITS. FA-1 NOTE 22.

	5) IN ADDITION TO APPLICABLE BUILDING CODES, LIFE
	SAFETY TO COMPLY WITH NFPA 101, 2003. CONSTRUCTION,
	ALTERATION AND DEMOLITION TO COMPLY WITH NFPA 241.
	PLEASE ADD TO CODE REVIEW ON SHEET CVR.

	6) PHYSICAL ADDRESS REQUIRED ON EACH SHEET.

	7) PHONE NUMBER FOR WEST PALM BEACH FIRE RESCUE IS
	INCORRECT. THE CORRECT NUMBER IS (561) 804-4700. SHEET
	CVR

	8) PROVIDE LIFE SAFETY PLAN ILLUSTRATING REQUIRED MEANS
	OF EGRESS AND TRAVEL DISTANCES.

	9) PROVIDE MINIMUM INTERIOR FINISH CLASSIFICATION FOR
	WALLS AND CEILING THAT COMPLIES WITH NFPA 101,
	CHAPTER-10.

	10) INDICATE ANY DOORS THAT ARE FIRE RATED AND PROVIDE
	RATING IN MINUTES IN DOOR SCHEDULE. IN ADDITION, RATED
	DOORS SHALL BE PROVIDED WITH UL LISTED DOOR CLOSERS.

	11) ADDRESS REQUIRED ON BUILDING THAT SHALL BE MINIMUM
	OF 6" IN HEIGHT, 1" WIDTH AND CONTRASTING WITH
	BACKGROUND FOR COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS.

	12) KNOX BOX IS REQUIRED ON BUILDING FOR AFTER NORMAL
	BUSINESS HOURS EMERGENCY ACCESS. CONTACT WPBFR BUREAU
	OF FIRE PREVENTION AT (561) 804-4724 FOR ASSISTANCE.

	13) PLEASE EXPLAIN NOTES ON SHEET FP-1 REFERENCING FLOW
	TEST RESULTS TAKEN BY TVA FIRE AND LIFE SAFETY?

	14) IF FIRE DEPARTMENT CONNECTION FOR PROJECT IS NEW,
	KNOX LOCKING CAPS ARE REQUIRED.


	A RESPONSE LETTER INDICATING HOW AND WHERE ON PLANS
	COMMENTS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED WOULD HELP EXPEDITE THE
	PLAN REVIEW PROCESS.


	MIKE WENNERGREN, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
	FIRE PLAN REVIEW
	FIRE PREVENTION (561) 804-4756










2008-07-31 13:46:50

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	5	Status	N	Date	2008-10-03			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-10-03	Time	16:51	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-10-03	Time	16:51	Sent To

Notes

2008-10-03 16:51:44

TO "F" BOX/REV

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	4	Status	N	Date	2008-09-18			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-09-18	Time	09:26	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-09-18	Time	09:26	Sent To	E

Notes

2008-09-18 09:27:23

TO "DPALMER" DESK/RESUB

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	3	Status	N	Date	2008-09-02			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-09-02	Time	11:38	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-09-02	Time	11:38	Sent To

Notes

2008-09-02 11:41:08

TO "COMM" BD#48

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	2	Status	N	Date	2008-08-06			Cont ID
Sent By	adarroug			Date	2008-08-06	Time	09:17	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	adarroug			Date	2008-08-06	Time	09:17	Sent To

Notes

2008-08-06 09:20:09

TO "COMM" BD#38

Review Stop	I			INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No	1	Status	N	Date	2008-07-31			Cont ID
Sent By	mwennerg			Date	2008-07-31	Time	14:16	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mwennerg			Date	2008-07-03	Time	16:36	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-03 16:36:59

TO "COMM" BD#38

Review Stop	M			MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-08-25			Cont ID
Sent By	rregueir			Date	2008-08-25	Time	13:51	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	rregueir			Date	2008-08-21	Time	14:19	Sent To

Notes

2008-08-25 13:51:52	***********PROVISO************

	DOCUMENTATION FROM APPLIANCE MANUFACTURER SHALL BE
	PROVIDED SHOWING ALL OUTDOOR APPLIANCES WHICH ARE
	EXPOSED TO WIND ARE DESIGNED TO RESSIST WIND PRESSURES
	IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM SECTION 301.13. THIS
	INFORMATION SHALL BE SUBMITTED FOR PLAN REVIEW PRIOR TO
	INSTALLATION OF OUTDOOR APPLIANCES.

	IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
	RONALD J. REGUEIRO
	561.805.6719
	[email protected]

Review Stop	M			MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-21			Cont ID
Sent By	rregueir			Date	2008-07-21	Time	16:28	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	rregueir			Date	2008-07-18	Time	13:57	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-21 16:27:58	REVIEW #: 1ST
	ACTION: DENIED

	FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/ 2007 SUPPLEMENTS
	FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH

	ADMINISTRATIVE COMMENTS:

	1. PG CVR: IN THE CODE REVIEW SECTION, PLEASE NOTE THE
	FOLLOWING DISCREPANCIES:
	ITEM #4 SHOULD BE: 2005 NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE
	ITEM #5 SHOULD BE: 2003 FLORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE?
	ITEM #7 SHOULD BE: 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, BUILDING
	CHAPTER 13.
	ITEM #9 SHOULD BE: WEST PALM BEACH CONSTRUCTION
	SERVICES DEPARTMENT / 561-805-6700
	ITEM #11 SHOULD BE: WEST PALM BEACH FIRE DEPARTMENT /
	561-804-4724

	2. PAGES CVR, IND AND ALL A PAGES: THESE PAGES (ON ONE
	OF THE TWO SETS SUBMITTED) DO NOT CONTAIN ORIGINAL
	SIGNATURE AND RAISED SEAL OF THE ARCHITECT. RATHER THEY
	CONTAIN WHAT APPEARS TO BE A PRINTED SEAL AND
	PHOTOCOPIED SIGNATURE. PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS SHALL
	BE SIGNED AND SEALED BY THE DESIGNER OF RECORD IN
	ACCORDANCE WIT FBCB 106.1, FS 481 AND FAC RULE
	61G1-16.

	3. PAGE CVR: THIS IS AN EXISTING BUILDING. THE DESIGN
	PROFESSIONAL MUST ELECT ONE OR A COMBINATION OF LEVELS
	OF ALTERATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCEB 301.5.

	4. PAGES MP, E AND FP: A TITLE BLOCK SHALL BE USED ON
	EACH SHEET CONTAINING THE PRINTED NAME, ADDRESS, AND
	LICENSE NUMBER OF THE ENGINEER, AND IF PRACTICING
	THROUGH A DULY AUTHORIZED ENGINEERING BUSINESS, THE
	NAME, ADDRESS AND CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER
	OF THE ENGINEERING BUSINESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH FAC RULE
	61G15-23.002(2).

	CODE COMMENTS:

	5. PG MP-1: THE AIR DISTRIBUTION DEVICE SCHEDULE
	REMARKS FOR SD1 AND SD2 REFER TO A DETAIL ON PAGE
	MP-1.3. PAGE MP-1.3 IS NOT INCLUDED IN THE SUBMITTED
	PLANS. PLEASE SHOW WHERE THIS INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND.
	FBCM 603.1, FBCM 106.1.1.

	6. PG MP-1: PROVIDE OUTSIDE AIR CALCULATIONS SHOWING
	OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATIONS, OCCUPANT LOADS, REQUIRED
	VENTILATION RATES AND AMOUNTS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE
	WITH FBCM 403.3 OR 403.4.

	7. PG MP-1: EF SCHEDULE NOTE #1 CALLS FOR EF-1 TO BE
	INTELOCKED WITH LIGHT SWITCH IN BATHROOMS. THIS FAN
	NEEDS TO RUN WHENEVER RTU-2 IS RUNNING (WHETHER OR NOT
	LIGHT SWITCH IS ON) AS RECIRCULATION OF AIR FROM THESE
	SPACES IS PROHIBITED AND ALL AIR SUPPLIED TO THE
	BATHROOMS SHALL BE EXHAUSTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM
	403.2.1(3).

	8. PG MP-1.1: FLOOR PLAN SHOWS A 20X14 SUPPLY DUCT AND
	AN 18X12 RETURN DUCT, BOTH FROM RTU-5, PENETRATING A
	2-HOUR FIRE RESISTANCE RATED WALL. THESE PENETRATIONS
	ARE REQUIRED TO BE PROTECTED WITH FIRE DAMPERS IN
	ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 607.5. SHOW HOW THESE DUCT
	PENETRATIONS ARE TO BE PROTECTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH
	THIS SECTION. THE RATED DUCT PENETRATION DETAIL #6 ON
	PAGE MP-1.2 IS NOT APPLICABLE AS IT IS RATED FOR 1-HOUR
	(THE WALL IS 2-HOUR) AND THE SIZES OF THE PENETRATING
	DUCTS EXCEED THE MAXIMUM ALLOWED IN THE INSTRUCTIONS
	WHICH ACCOMPANY THE THROUGH-PENETRATION DETAIL.

	9. PG MP-1.1: SEVERAL DUCT BRANCHES DO NOT HAVE SIZES
	SHOWN ON FLOOR PLAN. SOME OF THESE BRANCH SISZES CAN BE
	DETERMINED BASED ON THE NECK SIZE SHOWN ON THE AIR
	DISTRIBUTION SCHEDULE BUT SOME CAN NOT. EXAMPLE: PLEASE
	SHOW ON PLANS THE SIZES OF THE TRANSFER DUCTS AT
	RESTROOM VESTIBULE 114. PLEASE CHECK PLANS FOR ALL
	DUCTS WHICH ARE MISSING SIZES ON PLANS AND PROVIDE THE
	MISSING INFORMATION. AIR DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS SHALL BE
	DESIGNED AND INSTALLED TO SUPPLY THE REQUIRED
	DISTRIBUTION OF AIR IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 603.1.


	10. PG MP-1.2: CURB AND HURRICANE STRAP DETAILS CONTAIN
	CONFLICTING INFORMATION. PLEASE COORDINATE DETAILS AND
	CLARIFY THE WIND RESISTANCE METHOD TO BE USED FOR CURB,
	RTU AND EXHAUST FANS. PROVIDE WIND LOAD CALCULATIONS
	FOR OVERTURN AND UPLIFT FOR ALL ROOFTOP APPLIANCES FOR
	BUILDING REVIEW IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBCM 301.13.

	11. PG MP-1.2: IN ADDITION TO THE COMMENTS ABOVE,
	MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES AND SUPPORTS THAT ARE
	EXPOSED TO WIND SHALL BE DESIGNED TO RESIST THE WIND
	PRESSURES ON THE EQUIPMENT AND THE SUPPORTS AS
	DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FLORIDA BUILDING
	CODE, BUILDING PER FBCM 301.13. PROVIDE SUPPORTING
	DOCUMENTATION FROM THE APPLIANCE MANUFACTURER SHOWING
	THESE RTU?S AND EXHAUST FANS ARE DESIGNED TO RESIST
	WIND PRESSURES IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION. PLEASE
	NOTE THAT THIS REQUIREMENT APPLIES TO THE CONSTRUCTION
	OF THE APPLIANCES THEMSELVES AND NOT JUST THE
	ATTACHMENT TO THE BUILDING STRUCTURE.

	12. PG MP-2.1 CONDENSATE DRAIN DETAIL: AUXILIARY OR
	SECONDARY DRAIN PROTECTION IS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE
	WITH FBCM 307.2.3. A FLOAT SWITCH MAY BE INSTALLED
	INSIDE THE RTU ON THE PRIMARY DRAIN PAN TO COMPLY WITH
	THIS SECTION.

	IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
	RONALD J. REGUEIRO
	561.805.6719
	[email protected]

Review Stop	P			PLUMBING
Rev No	2	Status	P	Date	2008-08-11			Cont ID
Sent By	kstevens			Date	2008-08-11	Time	09:03	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	kstevens			Date	2008-08-11	Time	09:03	Sent To

Notes

***NONE***

Review Stop	P			PLUMBING
Rev No	1	Status	F	Date	2008-07-22			Cont ID
Sent By	mperson			Date	2008-07-22	Time	13:50	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	mperson			Date	2008-07-22	Time	13:50	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-22 13:57:11	PLUMBING PLAN REVIEW:
	DENIED:

	PLAN REVIEW UNDER THE 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODES WITH
	2007 REVISIONS, CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS TO
	CHAPTER 1 (W.P.B.), FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
	(F.A.C.), AND FLORIDA STATUTES (F.S.).

	THE FOLLOWING CORRECTIONS/INFORMATION ARE REQUIRED FOR
	PLUMBING PLAN REVIEW TO MEET CODE COMPLIANCE.

	1. SHEET A0 DEMOLITION PLAN, KEYED NOTES #3 STATES
	"REMOVE EXISTING RESTROOM FIXTURES", HOWEVER SHEET A2
	FLOOR PLAN IN WOMENS #111 AND MENS #112 BATHROOM
	HANDICAP STALLS THE LAVATORIES ARE NOT BEING
	REINSTALLED. PER FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11, FLORIDA
	ACCESSIBILITY CODE SECTION 11-4.17.3 EXCEPTIONS
	(1)(2).

	(1)THE STANDARD ACCESSIBLE RESTROOM STALL SHALL
	CONTAIN AN ACCESSIBLE LAVATORY WITHIN IT, THE SIZE OF
	SUCH LAVATORY TO BE NOT LESS THAN 19 INCHES WIDE BY 17
	INCHES (483 MM BY 432 MM) DEEP, NOMINAL SIZE, AND WALL
	MOUNTED. THE LAVATORY SHALL BE MOUNTED SO AS NOT TO
	OVERLAP THE CLEAR FLOOR SPACE AREAS REQUIRED BY SECTION
	11-4.17 [SEE FIGURE 30 (A) AND FIGURE 30 (E)] AND TO
	COMPLY WITH SECTION 11-4.19 OF THE CODE. SUCH
	LAVATORIES SHALL BE COUNTED AS PART OF THE REQUIRED
	FIXTURE COUNT FOR THE BUILDING.
	(2)THE ACCESSIBLE WATER CLOSET SHALL BE LOCATED IN
	THE CORNER, DIAGONAL TO THE DOOR.

	2. SHEET A7 DETAIL 1, ENLARGED RESTROOM: CLEARLY
	INDICATE THE CLEAR FLOOR SPACE AND WHEELCHAIR TURNING
	SPACE FOR THE FOLLOWING FIXTURES ON THE DETAIL
	COMPLIANT WITH FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11, FLORIDA
	ACCESSIBILITY CODE THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS.
	A} SECTION 11-4.15.5 CLEARANCES, DRINKING FOUNTAIN
	(30"X48").
	B} SECTION 11-4.16.2 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE, WATER CLOSETS
	(SEE FIGURE 28).
	C} SECTION 11-4.18.3 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE, URINALS
	(30"X48").
	D} SECTION 11-4.19.3 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE, LAVATORIES
	(30"X48" AND SHALL EXTEND A MAXIMUM OF 19" UNDERNEATH
	THE LAVATORY).
	E} SECTION 11-4.22.3 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE. WHEELCHAIR
	TURNING SPACE SHALL BE 180-DEGREE WITH A MINIMUM 60"
	CLEAR FLOOR SPACE. (CLEARLY INDICATE TURNING SPACE IN
	BATHROOM, BATHROOM ACCESSIBLE STALLS, AND DRINKING
	FOUNTAIN ROOM)

	3. SHEET A7 DETAIL 4, ENLARGED OFFICE/BREAKROON PLAN:
	CLEARLY INDICATE THE CLEAR FLOOR SPACE AND WHEELCHAIR
	TURNING SPACE FOR THE BREAKROOM SINK ON THE DETAIL
	COMPLIANT WITH FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11, FLORIDA
	ACCESSIBILITY CODE THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS.
	A} SECTION 11-4.24.5 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE, SINK (30"X48"
	AND CLEAR FLOOR SPACE SHALL EXTEND A MAXIMUM OF 19"
	UNDERNEATH THE SINK).
	B} SECTION 11-4.22.3 CLEAR FLOOR SPACE. WHEELCHAIR
	TURNING SPACE SHALL BE 180-DEGREE WITH A MAIMUM 60"
	CLEAR FLOOR SPACE.

	4. SHEET MP-1 NOTES LOCATED BELOW PLUMBING FIXTURE
	SCHEDULE: PLEASE ADD THE FOLLOWING FOR THE HC
	ACCESSIBLE URINAL COMPLIANT WITH FBC-2004 CHAPTER 11,
	FLORIDA ACCESSIBILITY CODE SECTION 11-4.18.4 FLUSH
	CONTROL FOR THE URINAL MAXIMUM 44" A.F.F.

	5. SHEET MP-2 DETAIL 3, WATER RISER DIAGRAM: THE 12"
	AIR CHAMBERS SPECIFIED IN THE DETAIL ARE NOT COMPLIANT
	WITH THE FBC-2004 PLUMBING, SECTION 604.9 WATER HAMMER.
	PER 604.9, A WATER-HAMMER ARRESTOR SHALL BE INSTALLED
	WHERE QUICK CLOSING VALVES ARE UTILIZED. PLEASE DELETE
	THE 12" AIR CHAMBERS ON THE RESUBMITTAL.

	6. SHEET MP-2 DETAIL 5, WATER HEATER DETAIL: CLEARLY
	INDICATE THE FOLLOWING ON THE WATER HEATER DETAIL
	COMPLIANT WITH THE FBC-2004 PLUMBING SECTIONS.
	A} SECTION 504.4 RELEIF VALVE.
	B} SECTION 504.5 RELIEF VALVE APPROVAL.
	C} SECTION 504.6 RELIEF OUTLET WASTE.
	D} SECTION 504.6.1 DISCHARGE.
	E} SECTION 607.3 THERMAL EXPANSION CONTROL.

	7. ALL MP SHEETS FROM MP-1 THRU MP2.1 REQUIRE A
	CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER ON THESE SHEETS.
	PER FAC 61G15-23.002(2).

	******IMPORTANT INFORMATION******
	WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS, PLEASE PROVIDE A COPY OF THE
	OLD PLANS, CLEARLY INDICATE THE REVISION ON THE NEW
	PLANS, REMOVE AND REPLACE ANY PAGES AS NECESSARY. A
	TRANSMITTAL LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT
	NUMBER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION MADE,
	IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION PAGE WHERE
	CHANGES CAN BE FOUND WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT.
	THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.

	END OF COMMENTS:

	REVIEW BY: MIKE PERSON
	PLUMBING PLANS EXAMINER
	PHONE= (561) 805-6730
	FAX= (561) 805-6731
	E-MAIL= [email protected]

Review Stop	Z			ZONING
Rev No	1	Status	N	Date	2008-07-22			Cont ID
Sent By	kdfreema			Date	2008-07-22	Time	09:24	Rev Time	0.00
Received By	kdfreema			Date	2008-07-22	Time	09:24	Sent To

Notes

2008-07-22 09:27:11	NOT REQUIRED: NO EXTERIOR WORK FALLING UNDER THE
	PURVIEW OF ZONING IS PROPOSED.