Plan Review Details - Permit 07040994
Plan Review Stops For Permit 07040994
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2007-09-19 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2007-09-19 Time 13:29 Rev Time 1.33
Received By jwitmer Date 2007-09-19 Time 13:29 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status F Date 2007-09-08 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2007-09-08 Time 12:15 Rev Time 2.22
Received By jwitmer Date 2007-09-08 Time 12:15 Sent To  
Notes
2007-09-08 12:21:26BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 07040994
 ADD: 4300 NFLAGLER DR
 CONT: MECHANICAL INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
 TEL: (813)247-2868
  
 FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2006 FBC REVISIONS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 3RDREVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 1)--- VERY IMPORTANT STATEMENT ---
 PLEASE DO NOT IGNORE!
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUM-
 BER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION
 MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICA
 TION PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. THANK
 YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 2-5 COMPLIED.
  
 6A) THIRD REVIEW ,110.2* W. P. B. ADMINISTRATIVE
 CODE, INFORMATION THAT IS REQUIRED FOR
 RECORD KEEPING & FOR CERTIFICATE OF
 OCCUPANCY:
 A) THE EDITION OFTHE CODE UNDER WHICH
 THE PROJECT IS DESIGNED.
 B) THE USE AND OCCUPANCY, IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 3.
 C) THE TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION AS DEFINED
 IN CHAPTER 6, TABLE 601.
 D) THE OCCUPANT LOAD, SEE 1004.
 E) IF AN AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEM IS
 PROVIDED
 F) WHETHER THE SPRINKLER SYSTEM IS REQUIRED.
 G) ANY SPECIAL STIPULATIONS & CONDITIONS
 OF THE BUILDING PERMIT
 H) FLOOD ZONE.
  
 6B) (1) 2ND REQUEST, THE NEXT ISSUE WILL BE HOW TO
 CLASSIFY THE SAWDUSST THAT IS CREATED WHEN WORK IS
 BEING COMPLETED. THE WOOD BEFORE IT IS CUT IS A MINOR
 HAZARD BUT WHEN SAWDUST IS CREATED, THE SAWDUST IS VERY
 COMBUSTIBLE AND CREATES A HIGH HAZARD OR H-2 OCCUPANCY.
 TABLE 307.7(1)IS FOR THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE QUANITIES
 OF MATERIAL ALLOWED PER CONTROL AREA, THAT POSES A
 PHYSICAL HAZARD. WHEN YOU SCAN THE TABLE THERE IS NO
 CATEGORY FOR COMBUSTIBLE DUST, THERE IS FOR COMBUSTIBLE
 FIBERS NOT COMBUSTIBLE DUST! PLACING THE COMBUSTIBLE
 DUST INTO A H-2 CATEGORY. SEE 415.7 GROUP H-2
  
 415.7.1 COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS, GRAIN PROCESSING AND
 STORAGE.
 THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 415.7.1.1 THROUGH 415.7.1.5
 SHALL APPLY TO BUILDINGS IN WHICH MATERIALS THAT
 PRODUCE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS ARE STORED OR HANDLED.
 BUILDINGS THAT STORE OR HANDLE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS SHALL
 COMPLY WITH THE APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF NFPA 61, NFPA
 120, NFPA 651, NFPA 654, NFPA 655, NFPA 664 AND NFPA
 85, AND THE FLORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE.
  
 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE VARIOUS NFPA REQUIREMENTS ABOVE
 664 IS THE STANDARD TO BE USED . NFPA 664 IS THE
 STANDARDFOR THE PREVENTION OF FIRE AND EXPLOSIONS IN
 WOOD PROCESSING FACILITIES 2007 EDITION. WE BELIEVE
 THAT THIS STILL CAN BE CLASSIFIED AS A F-1 FACTORY USE
 WITH ONE CONTROLED AREA THE WOOD SHOP AND THE DUST
 COLLECTION SYSTEM HAS TO TIED INTO
 OPERATION OF ANY EQUIPMENT THAT CREATES SAWDUST. THIS
 WOULDMAKE THE COLLECTION SYSTEM AND HOLDING TANK THE
 H-2 HAZARD ZONE.
  
 IN PREVIOUS REVIEWS A PRINTED COPY OF NFPA 664 WAS
 INCLUDED IN THE PLAN REVIEW. PART OF THE NFPA 664
 INDICATES UNDER 4.4 THE DESIGNER BE AN ENGINEER WHO IS
 KNOWLEDGEABLE OF THESE SYSTEMS AND THEIR ASSOCIATED
 HAZARDS, WHICH THE DESIGNER STATES THAT HE TAKES NO
 RESPONSIBLIITY FOR THE FOLLOWING :
 (1)DUCT INCORPORATED SUBMITTALS PROVIDED FOR THE THE
 DUST HANGER DESIGN, NOR,
 (2) THE AMERICAN AIR FILLER SUBMITTALS PROVIDED FOR THE
 WIND DESIGN CALCULATIONS OF THE DUST COLLECTION SYSTEM,
 NOR,
 (3) FLAMEX INC. DRAWINGS AS PROVIDED ON SHEET 5 FOR THE
 SPARK DETECTION SYSTEM.
  
 6B) (2) NFPA 6644.6 COMPLIANCE OPTIONS ARE EITHER:
 4.6..2 PREFORMANCE BASED DESIGN MEETING ALL
 THE REQUIREMENTS OF CHAPTER 5 OR,
 4.6.3 PRESRIPTIVE-BASED DESIGN MEETING THE
 REQUIREMENTS OF CHAPTER 6-11.
 PLEASE PROVIDE THE INFORMATION REQUIRED FOR EITHER
 METHOD.
  
 6C) A NEW COMMENT SINCE THE FIRST REVIEW AND SECOND
 REVIEW PE J F SHANNON WAS TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
 STRUCTURAL DESIGN AND FOUND IT IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE
 2004 FBC AND 2005/ 2006 SUPPLEMENTS.
 THIS REVIEW NOW HAS DOCUMENTS FROM THE UNIFORM BUILDING
 CODE ATTESTING TO THE 140 MPH WIND ZONE! PLEASE PROVIDE
 SIGNED AND SEALED DOCUMETS, CALCULATIONS TO RESIST THE
 MOMENT OF OVER-TURNINGIN A 140MPH 3 SECOND GUST WITH
 A COSTAL EXPOSURE. ALSO PROVIDE THE HEIGHT FACORS OF
 THE BUILDING THAT THIS SYSTEM WILL BE NEXT TO AND ALSO
 INVESTIGATE IF THE LOCATION OF THE DUST COLLECTOR IS IN
 AN END ZONEOR IF THE CLOSENESS OF THE EQUIPMENT WILL
 CREATE A VORTEX OR ADDITIONAL FLUTTERING WHICH WOULD
 NEED TO BE CONSIDERED AS PART OF THE WIND DESIGN. A
 REGISTERD FLORIDA PE WILL NEED TO SUBMIT 2 ORIGINAL
 SIGNED AND SEALED SETS OF PLANS FOR ATTACHEMENT OF DUST
 COLLECTOR AND CALCULATIONS.
  
 1609.6.4 MAIN WIND FORCE RESISTING SYSTEM (MWFRS).
 ALL ELEMENTS AND CONNECTIONS OF THE MWFRS SHALL BE
 DESIGNED FOR VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL LOADS BASED ON THE
 COMBINED LEEWARD AND WINDWARD WALL PRESSURES AND ROOF
 PRESSURES DETERMINED FROM TABLE 1609.6A . PRESSURES
 SHALL BE APPLIED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LOADING
 DIAGRAMS SHOWN IN FIGURE 1609.6A TO THE END ZONE AND
 INTERIOR ZONE AS SHOWN IN FIGURE 1609.6B . THE BUILDING
 SHALL BE DESIGNED FOR ALL WIND DIRECTIONS. FOR
 BUILDINGS HAVING FLAT ROOFS, A RIDGE LINE NORMAL TO THE
 WIND DIRECTION SHALL BE ASSUMED AT THE MIDLENGTH
 DIMENSION OF THE ROOF FOR ALL DIRECTIONS CONSIDERED.
 EACH CORNER SHALL BE CONSIDERED IN TURN AS THE WINDWARD
 CORNER.
  
 6D) AGAIN IF THE PRESCRIPTIVE METHOD OF COMPLIANCE IS
 SELECTED REQUIREMEENTS OF CHAPTER 11 WITH EMPLOYEE
 TRAING PROGRAM WILL NEED TO BE SUBMITTED.
  
  
 102.1* WHERE, IN ANY SPECIFIC CASE, DIFFERENT SECTIONS
 OF THIS CODE SPECIFY DIFFERENT MATERIALS, METHODS OF
 CONSTRUCTION OR OTHER REQUIREMENTS, THE MOST
 RESTRICTIVE SHALL GOVERN. WHERE THERE IS A CONFLICT
 BETWEEN A GENERAL REQUIREMENT AND A SPECIFIC
 REQUIREMENT, THE SPECIFIC
 REQUIREMENT SHALL BE APPLICABLE.
  
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW II
  
  
  
  
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)659-8026
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-08-15 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2007-08-15 Time 10:31 Rev Time 3.33
Received By jwitmer Date 2007-08-15 Time 10:31 Sent To PC
Notes
2007-08-15 11:50:58BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 07040994
 ADD: 4300 NFLAGLER DR
 CONT: MECHANICAL INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
 TEL: (813)247-2868
  
 FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2006 FBC REVISIONS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 2NDREVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 1)--- VERY IMPORTANT STATEMENT ---
 PLEASE DO NOT IGNORE!
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATETHE REVISION &
 REMOVE & REPLACE ANY PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL
 LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUMBER, WITH
 A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION
 MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICATION PAGE WHERE
 THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR
 PERMIT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 2)FL S S 713.13
 NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT, TO BE FILED WITH THE CLERK OF
 THE COURT.NOTE: 713.13(2) IF THE WORK DESCRIBED IN
 THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT IS NOT ACTUALLYCOMMENCED
 WITHIN 90 DAYS AFTER THE RECORDING THEREOF,
 SUCH NOTICE IS NULL & VOID. NOTE: 713.13(6)THE
 POSTING OF THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT AT THE
 CONSTRUCTION SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
  
 3) COMPLIED.
  
 4) 2ND REQUEST,DIGITAL DESIGN AND DRAFTING IS ACTING
 AS AN ENGINEER AND ARE NOT CERTIFIED OR LICENSED AS AN
 ENGINEER OR ENGINEERING BUSINESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 CHAPTER 471,
 FLORIDA STATUTE. PLEASE SEE DBPR CASENO. 03-0489. IT
 APPEARS THAT DIGITAL DESIGN IS PRACTICING ENGINEERING,
 IF THE FIRM WERE DIRECTLY ENGAGED BY THE ENGINEER THEY
 WOULD NOT NEED TO HAVE THEIR NAME ON THE HEADER STRIP,
 IT APPEARS THAT THEY ARE ADVERTISING THEMSELVES AS
 ENGINEERS. THIS WILL BE TURNED OVER TO THE STATE TO
 INVESTIGATE AS PER CONVERSATION WITH STATE INVESTIGATOR
 MR. JACK BEMESS.
  
 5) 2ND REQUEST,LS & SS SERVIDES INC,IS ACTING AS AN
 ENGINEER AND ARE NOT CERTIFIED OR LICENSED AS AN
 ENGINEER OR ENGINEERING BUSINESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 CHAPTER 471,FLORIDA STATUTE. PLEASE SEE DBPR NO
 03-0489 . ALL RESPONSE SHEET COMMENTS DO NOT INDICATE
 THAT THEY ARE THE DESIGN ENGIEENERS BUT LYLE
 SCHARENBURG OF LS & SS SERVICES INC. BOTH THE
 MECHANICAL AND BUILDING REVIEWER HAVE HAD
 MULTIPLE TELEPHONE CALLS WITH MR SCHARENBURG WHERE HE
 IMPLIED THAT THIS IS HIS DESIGN AND SEALED BY ENGINEER
 J. F. SHANNON. THE RESPONSE TO BUILDINGS COMMENT NUMBER
 (5
 ) DOESN'T INDICATE THE PLANS WERE DESIGNED BUT SEALED
 BY THE ENGINEER OF RECORD.
  
 6A)SEMI- COMPLIED, 106.1.2 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IS
 REQUIRED TO BE ABLE TO DO AN ADEQUATE REVIEW,PLEASE
 PROVIDE:110.2* W. P. B. ADMINISTRATIVE
 CODE, INFORMATION THAT IS REQUIRED FOR
 RECORD KEEPING & FOR CERTIFICATE OF
 OCCUPANCY:
 A) THE EDITION OFTHE CODE UNDER WHICH
 THE PROJECT WAS DESIGNED.
 B) THE USE AND OCCUPANCY, IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 3.
 C) THE TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION AS DEFINED
 IN CHAPTER 6, TABLE 601.
 D) THE OCCUPANT LOAD, SEE 1004.
 E) IF AN AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEM IS
 PROVIDED, WHETHER THE SPRINKLER SYSTEM
 IS REQUIRED.
 F) ANY SPECIAL STIPULATIONS & CONDITIONS
 OF THE BUILDING PERMIT.
  
 6B) THE DESIGN PROFESSIONAL HAS NOT COMMENTED ON THIS
 ISSUE, AGAIN LYLE SCHARENBERG OF LS & SS SERVES INC
 MAKES THE REBUTTAL NOT THE DESIGNER OF RECORD!!!!! THE
 REMAINDER OF THE REVIEW WILL USE THE FOLLOWING
 ASSUMPTIONS:
 NOTE: THIS REVIEW WILL BE COMPLETED WITH THE FOLLOWING
 ASSUMPTION, THE WOOD WORKING SHOP WILL BE CONSIDERED
 FACTORY-INDUSTRIAL F1 SINCE SECTION 306 OF THE BUILDING
 CODE DOES LIST MILLWORK (SASH & DOOR) AS AN F1
 OCCUPANCY.
  
 THE NEXT ISSUE WILL BE HOW TO CLASSIFY THE SAWDUSST
 THAT IS CREATED WHEN WORK IS BEING COMPLETED. THE WOOD
 BEFORE IT IS CUT IS A MINOR HAZARD BUT WHEN SAWDUST IS
 CREATED, THE SAWDUST IS VERY COMBUSTIBLE AND CREATES A
 HIGH HAZARD OR H-2 OCCUPANCY. TABLE 307.7(1)IS FOR
 THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE QUANITIES OF MATERIAL ALLOWED PER
 CONTROL AREA, THAT POSES A PHYSICAL HAZARD. WHEN YOU
 SCAN THE TABLE THERE IS NO CATEGORY FOR COMBUSTIBLE
 DUST, THERE IS FOR COMBUSTIBLE FIBERS NOT COMBUSTIBLE
 DUST! PLACING THE COMBUSTIBLE DUST INTO A H-2 CATEGORY.
 SEE 415.7 GROUP H-2
  
 415.7.1 COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS, GRAIN PROCESSING AND
 STORAGE.
 THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 415.7.1.1 THROUGH 415.7.1.5
 SHALL APPLY TO BUILDINGS IN WHICH MATERIALS THAT
 PRODUCE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS ARE STORED OR HANDLED.
 BUILDINGS THAT STORE OR HANDLE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS SHALL
 COMPLY WITH THE APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF NFPA 61, NFPA
 120, NFPA 651, NFPA 654, NFPA 655, NFPA 664 AND NFPA
 85, AND THE FLORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE.
  
 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE VARIOUS NFPA REQUIREMENTS ABOVE
 664 IS THE STANDARD TO BE USED . NFPA 664 IS THE
 STANDARDFOR THE PREVENTION OF FIRE AND EXPLOSIONS IN
 WOOD PROCESSING FACILITIES 2007 EDITION. WE BELIEVE
 THAT THIS STILL CAN BE CLASSIFIED AS A F-1 FACTORY USE
 WITH ONE CONTROLED AREA THE WOOD SHOP AND THE DUST
 COLLECTION SYSTEM HAS TO TIED INTO
 OPERATION OF ANY EQUIPMENT THAT CREATES SAWDUST. THIS
 WOULDMAKE THE COLLECTION SYSTEM AND HOLDING TANK THE
 H-2 HAZARD ZONE.
  
 IN STUDYING 415.7.1 THE NFPA WHICH REFERS TO WOOD AND
 OR COMBUSTIBLE SAWDUST IS NFPA 664 AND IS TO BE
 FOLLOWED COMPLETELY.
 4.4 DESIGNER AND INSTALLER QUALIFICATIONS. SYSTEMS THAT
 HANDLE COMBUSTIBLE PARTICLES SHALL BE DESIGNED BY AND
 INSTALLED UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF QUALIFIED ENGINEERS
 WHO ARE KNOWLEGABLE OF THESE SYSTEMS AND THEIR
 ASSOCIATED HAZARDS. PLEASE NOTE THAT THE ENGINEER OF
 RECORD STATES HE HAS DESIGNED THE STRUCTURE
 STRUCTURALLY TO THE 2004 FBC NOT THE MECHANICAL
 ASSPECTS OF THE SYSTEM.
 ATTACHED IS A COPY OF NFPA 664 TO FOLLOW IN THE DESIGN
 OF THE SYSTEM PLEASE COMPLY WITH ALL SECTION OF THIS
 STANDARD, INCLUSIVE OF CHAPTER 12.
  
 PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE BULK STORAGE TANK
 SIZE IN WIDTH DEPTH AND HEIGTH AS WELL AS CU FT
  
 PROVIDE THE EMPLOYEE TRAINING PROGRAM IN SECTION IN
 11.1 AND 11.3.
  
 A THOROUGH REVIEW CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME, AS A
 RESULT OF THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUESTED
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY APPEAR THAT WERE NOT PART OF
 THIS REVIEW.
  
  
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)659-8026
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
  
  
  
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-05-14 Cont ID  
Sent By jwitmer Date 2007-05-14 Time 16:18 Rev Time 3.33
Received By jwitmer Date 2007-05-14 Time 16:18 Sent To  
Notes
2007-05-15 13:41:34BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 PERMIT: 07040994
 ADD: 4300 NFLAGLER DR
 CONT: MECHANICAL INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
 TEL: (813)247-2868
  
 FL BLD CODE= 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE
 W/ 2006 FBC REVISIONS
 * WEST PALM BEACH AMENDMENTS
  
 1STREVIEW
 ACTION: DENIED
  
 1)--- VERY IMPORTANT STATEMENT ---
 PLEASE DO NOT IGNORE!
 WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS PLEASE INDICATE
 THE REVISION & REMOVE & REPLACE ANY
 PAGES AS NECESSARY. A TRANSMITTAL LETTER
 LISTING THE ORIGINAL REVIEW COMMENT NUM-
 BER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE REVISION
 MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR SPECIFICA
 TION PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN BE FOUND
 WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR PERMIT. THANK
 YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED COOPERATION.
  
 2)FL S S 713.13
 NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT, TO BE FILED WITH THE CLERK OF
 THE COURT.
 NOTE: 713.13(2) IF THE WORK DESCRIBED IN THE NOTICE OF
 COMMENCEMENT
 IS NOT ACTUALLYCOMMENCED WITHIN 90 DAYS AFTER THE
 RECORDING THEREOF,
 SUCH NOTICE IS NULL & VOID. NOTE: 713.13(6)THE
 POSTING OF THE NOTICE
 OF COMMENCEMENT AT THE CONSTRUCTION SITE BEFORE THE
 FIRST INSPECTION.
  
 3) PLEASE CORRECT THE ADDRESS ON THE PLANS TO THE
 CORRECT LOCATION.
  
 4)DIGITAL DESIGN AND DRAFTING IS ACTING AS AN
 ENGINEER AND ARE NOT CERTIFIED OR LICENSED AS AN
 ENGINEER OR ENGINEERING BUSINESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 CHAPTER 471,
 FLORIDA STATUTE. PLEASE SEE DBPR CASENO. 03-0489
  
 5)LS & SS SERVIDES INC, I BELIEVE THIS MAY BE
 MISPLELLED AND TO BE LS & SS SERVICES INC. IS ACTING AS
 AN ENGINEER AND ARE NOT CERTIFIED OR LICENSED AS AN
 ENGINEER OR ENGINEERING BUSINESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
 CHAPTER 471,FLORIDA STATUTE. PLEASE SEE DBPR NO
 03-0489
  
 6)106.1.2 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IS REQUIRED TO BE
 ABLE TO DO AN ADEQUATE REVIEW,PLEASE PROVIDE:110.2*
 W. P. B. ADMINISTRATIVE
 CODE, INFORMATION THAT IS REQUIRED FOR
 RECORD KEEPING & FOR CERTIFICATE OF
 OCCUPANCY:
 A) THE EDITION OFTHE CODE UNDER WHICH
 THE PROJECT WAS DESIGNED.
 B) THE USE AND OCCUPANCY, IN ACCORDANCE
 WITH THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 3.
 C) THE TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION AS DEFINED
 IN CHAPTER 6, TABLE 601.
 D) THE OCCUPANT LOAD, SEE 1004.
 E) IF AN AUTOMATIC SPRINKLER SYSTEM IS
 PROVIDED, WHETHER THE SPRINKLER SYSTEM
 IS REQUIRED.
 F) ANY SPECIAL STIPULATIONS & CONDITIONS
 OF THE BUILDING PERMIT.
  
  
 NOTE: THIS REVIEW WILL BE COMPLETED WITH THE FOLLOWING
 ASSUMPTION, THE WOOD WORKING SHOP WILL BE CONSIDERED
 FACTORY-INDUSTRIAL F1 SINCE SECTION 306 OF THE BUILDING
 CODE DOES LIST MILLWORK (SASH & DOOR) AS AN F1
 OCCUPANCY.
  
 THE NEXT ISSUE WILL BE HOW TO CLASSIFY THE SAWDUSST
 THAT IS CREATED WHEN WORK IS BEING COMPLETED. THE WOOD
 BEFORE IT IS CUT IS A MINOR HAZARD BUT WHEN SAWDUST IS
 CREATED, THE SAWDUST IS VERY COMBUSTIBLE AND CREATES A
 HIGH HAZARD OR H-2 OCCUPANCY. TABLE 307.7(1)IS FOR
 THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE QUANITIES OF MATERIAL ALLOWED PER
 CONTROL AREA, THAT POSES A PHYSICAL HAZARD. WHEN YOU
 SCAN THE TABLE THERE IS NO CATEGORY FOR COMBUSTIBLE
 DUST, THERE IS FOR COMBUSTIBLE FIBERS NOT COMBUSTIBLE
 DUST! PLACING THE COMBUSTIBLE DUST INTO A H-2 CATEGORY.
 SEE 415.7 GROUP H-2
  
 415.7.1 COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS, GRAIN PROCESSING AND
 STORAGE.
 THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 415.7.1.1 THROUGH 415.7.1.5
 SHALL APPLY TO BUILDINGS IN WHICH MATERIALS THAT
 PRODUCE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS ARE STORED OR HANDLED.
 BUILDINGS THAT STORE OR HANDLE COMBUSTIBLE DUSTS SHALL
 COMPLY WITH THE APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF NFPA 61, NFPA
 120, NFPA 651, NFPA 654, NFPA 655, NFPA 664 AND NFPA
 85, AND THE FLORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE.
  
 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE VARIOUS NFPA REQUIREMENTS ABOVE
 664 IS THE STANDARD TO BE USED . NFPA 664 IS THE
 STANDARDFOR THE PREVENTION OF FIRE AND EXPLOSIONS IN
 WOOD PROCESSING FACILITIES 2007 EDITION. WE BELIEVE
 THAT THIS STILL CAN BE CLASSIFIED AS A F-1 FACTORY USE
 WITH ONE CONTROLED AREA THE WOOD SHOP AND THE DUST
 COLLECTION SYSTEM HAS TO TIED INTO
 OPERATION OF ANY EQUIPMENT THAT CREATES SAWDUST. THIS
 WOULDMAKE THE COLLECTION SYSTEM AND HOLDING TANK THE
 H-2 HAZARD ZONE.
  
 IN STUDYING 415.7.1 THE NFPA WHICH REFERS TO WOOD AND
 OR COMBUSTIBLE SAWDUST IS NFPA 664 AND IS TO BE
 FOLLOWED COMPLETELY.
 4.4 DESIGNER AND INSTALLER QUALIFICATIONS. SYSTEMS THAT
 HANDLE COMBUSTIBLE PARTICLES SHALL BE DESIGNED BY AND
 INSTALLED UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF QUALIFIED ENGINEERS
 WHO ARE KNOWLEGABLE OF THESE SYSTEMS AND THEIR
 ASSOCIATED HAZARDS. PLEASE NOTE THAT THE ENGINEER OF
 RECORD STATES HE HAS DESIGNED THE STRUCTURE
 STRUCTURALLY TO THE 2004 FBC NOT THE MECHANICAL
 ASSPECTS OF THE SYSTEM.
 ATTACHED IS A COPY OF NFPA 664 TO FOLLOW IN THE DESIGN
 OF THE SYSTEM PLEASE COMPLY WITH ALL SECTION OF THIS
 STANDARD, INCLUSIVE OF CHAPTER 12.
  
 PLEASE PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THE BULK STORAGE TANK
 SIZE IN WIDTH DEPTH AND HEIGTH AS WELL AS CU FT
  
 PROVIDE THE EMPLOYEE TRAINING PROGRAM IN SECTION IN
 11.1 AND 11.3.
  
 A THOROUGH REVIEW CAN NOT BE MADE AT THIS TIME, AS A
 RESULT OF THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUESTED
 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS MAY APPEAR THAT WERE NOT PART OF
 THIS REVIEW.
  
 BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 JIM WITMER C. B. O.
  
 TEL: (561)805-6715
 FAX: (561)659-8026
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2007-09-10 Cont ID  
Sent By btrobaug Date 2007-09-10 Time 12:06 Rev Time 0.00
Received By btrobaug Date 2007-09-10 Time 10:34 Sent To  
Notes
2007-09-10 11:31:08 
  
  
  
 PROVISO
  
  
 THE COMMENT FROM THE PREVIOUS REVIEW REGARDING THE
 LISTING FOR THE DUST COLLECTOR HAS NOT BEEN RESPONDED
 TOO. THE LISTING GIVEN IN THE RESPONSE IS FOR THE
 CONTROL CENTER. PROVIDE A LISTING FROM A NATIONAL
 RECOGNIZED TESTING LABORITORYPRIOR TO USING THE DUST
 COLLECTOR OR CALLING FOR FINAL ELECTRICAL INSPECTION.
 ALLOW AT LEAST ONE WEEK FOR PLAN REVIEW FOR THIS
 SUBMITTAL.
  
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CALL.
  
 BILL TROBAUGH
 ELECTRICAL PLANS EXAMINER
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561/805-6718
 [email protected]
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-07-24 Cont ID  
Sent By btrobaug Date 2007-07-24 Time 16:48 Rev Time 0.00
Received By btrobaug Date 2007-07-24 Time 12:41 Sent To  
Notes
2007-07-24 16:38:17 
  
 NONCOMPLIANT
  
 PLEASE MAKE THE FOLLOWING CORRECTIONS FOR CODE
 COMPLIANCE AND RESUBMIT FOR REVIEW.
  
 1} PROVIDE THE LISTING AGENCY AND LISTING NUMBER FOR
 THE DUST COLLECTOR AND THE FLAMEX DETECTION SYSTEM.
  
 2} INDICATE THE PURPOSE OF THE TWO 1HP 3PHASE MOTORS
 SHOWN BEING FED FROM THE DUST COLLECTER CONTROL PANEL
 ON SHEET E-1
  
 3}THE ENGINEERING FIRM LISTED ON THE TITLE BLOCK,
 SHEET E-1, SHALL INDICATE THE CERTIFICATE OF
 AUTHORIZATIONNUMBER ALONG WITH OTHER INFORMATION
 REQUIRED BY 61G15-23.002FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE.
  
 4} SEE MECHANICAL REVIEW FORCOMMENTS REGARDING THE
 ENGINEERS ADDRESS AND STATEMENT "STRUCTURAL PROVISIONS"
 IN THE TITLE BLOCK, SHEET 5.(FLAMEX FIRE SYSTEM).
  
 IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CALL.
  
 WILLIAM R. TROBAUGH
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561/805-6718
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-05-22 Cont ID  
Sent By btrobaug Date 2007-05-22 Time 11:01 Rev Time 1.00
Received By btrobaug Date 2007-05-22 Time 10:53 Sent To  
Notes
2007-05-22 11:00:08 
  
  
 DENIED/INCOMPLETE INFORMATION
  
 THE ELECTRICAL WORK ASSOCIATED WITH THIS PERMIT WAS
 REVIEWED UNDER PERMIT NUMBER 06030729.
  
 BILL TROBAUGH
 ELECTRICAL PLANS EXAMINER
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 561/805-6718
 [email protected]
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2007-09-21 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2007-09-21 Time 14:24 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2007-09-21 Time 14:24 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2007-07-27 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2007-07-27 Time 15:33 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2007-07-27 Time 15:33 Sent To  
Notes
2007-07-27 15:36:23***PROVISO***
  
 1) COMMENTS FROM PREVIOUS FIRE REVIEW APPEAR TO HAVE
 BEEN ADDRESSED. PLEASE SEE OTHER REVIEW COMMENTS
 REGARDING FAC REQUIREMENTS FOR PLANS.
  
 PLANS WILL BE STAMPPED WHEN RESUBMITTED FOR OTHER
 REVIEW COMMENTS PROVIDED COMMENTS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED.
  
  
 MIKE WENNERGREN, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 FIRE PREVENTION (561) 804-4756
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-05-23 Cont ID  
Sent By mwennerg Date 2007-05-23 Time 15:14 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mwennerg Date 2007-05-23 Time 15:14 Sent To  
Notes
2007-05-23 15:41:57***DENIED***
  
 1) PLEASE SUBMIT MORE INFORMATION FOR REVIEW.
  
 2) SEE OTHER REVIEW COMMENTS REGARDING FLORIDA STATUTE
 REQUIREMENTS FOR DESIGN PROFESSIONALS.
  
 3) PLEASE ILLUSTRATE HOW THIS WORK WILL COMPLY WITH
 APPLICABLE CODES. FORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE, 2004 AND
 NFPA 664, 2007.
  
 4) IS THIS BUILDING PROTECTED BY AN AUTOMATIC FIRE
 SPRINKLER SYSTEM?
  
 5) WORK SHALL ILLUSTRATE HOW THE PREVENTION OF A
 POTENTIAL DUST EXPLOSION WILL BE ACCOMPLISHED IN
 ACCORDANCE WITH APPLICABLE CODES.
  
  
 MIKE WENNERGREN, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 FIRE PLAN REVIEW
 FIRE PREVENTION (561) 804-4756
  
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2007-08-31 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-08-31 Time 11:57 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-08-31 Time 11:57 Sent To  
Notes
2007-09-20 09:45:33TO "COMM" BD#61
2007-08-31 11:58:08WAITING FOR "COMM" BD
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2007-06-20 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-06-20 Time 10:11 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-06-20 Time 10:11 Sent To  
Notes
2007-08-13 09:08:34TO "COMM" BD#63
2007-06-20 10:11:20WAITING FOR "COMM" BD
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2007-06-04 Cont ID  
Sent By adarroug Date 2007-06-04 Time 14:17 Rev Time 0.00
Received By adarroug Date 2007-04-30 Time 16:31 Sent To  
Notes
2007-04-30 16:31:10TO "M" BOX
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2007-09-09 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2007-09-09 Time 15:35 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2007-09-09 Time 14:25 Sent To  
Notes
2007-09-10 09:47:06THE LATEST SET OF PLANS AND SUBMITTALS HAS ADEQUATELY
 ADDRESSED ALL PREVIOUS MECHANICAL PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS.
 AS A RESULT, MECHANICAL PLAN REVIEW HAS PASSED. THIS
 NOT AN INDICATION, HOWEVER, AS TO WHETHER OR NOT THERE
 WAS ANY WRONGOING ON THE PART OF JF SHANNON, DIGITAL
 DESIGN & DRAFTING OR LS & SS SERVICES RELATED TO
 PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS RELATED TO
 THIS PERMIT. THE MATTER HAS BEEN FORWARDED TO FBPE FOR
 INVESTIGATION AND THEY WILL MAKE THE FINAL
 DETERMINATION. IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS RELATED TO
 THE INVESTIGATION, PLEASE CONTACT JACK BEMESH AT
 (850)521-0500.
  
 RONALD J REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-07-18 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2007-07-18 Time 13:22 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2007-07-17 Time 19:17 Sent To  
Notes
2007-07-18 13:22:47--------------DENIED------------------
  
 FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/ 2006 REVISIONS
 FBC CH.1 AS AMENDED BY THE CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 NFPA 664-02
  
 1.NOTE ON PLANS IN TITLE BLOCK STILL INDICATES THAT THE
 ENGINEER IS ONLY TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
 STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OF THIS PLAN. PLEASE CORRECT AND
 RESUBMIT.
  
 2. ENGINEER'S ADDRESS AS SHOWN ON PLANS DOES NOT MATCH
 THE ADDRESS SHOWN IN DBPR'S RECORDS. PLEASE SEE FAC
 RULE 61G15-23.002(2). PLEASE CORRECT THE ADDRESS ON
 PLANS OR UPDATE LICENSE INFORMATION WITH DBPR.
  
 3. CODES AS STATED ON PAGE 4 OF PLANS: NFPA 91 IS
 LISTED. HOWEVER, NFPA 91 IS THE STANDARD FOR EXHAUST
 AND CONVEYANCE OF NON COMBUSTIBLE PARTICULATE SOLIDS.
 THE CORECT STANDARD IS NFPA 654 FOR THE HANDLING OF
 COMBUSTIBLE PARTICULATE SOLIDS. SEE NFPA 664-02 SEC
 8.2.2.1.1.
  
 4. AN IMPORTANT PART OF THE "FLAMEX" SYSTEM
 DOCUMENTATION WAS NOT PROVIDED, SUCH AS PART V COVERING
 THE LOCATION OF COMPONENTS FOR INSTALLATION. PLEASE
 PROVIDE ALL RELEVANT INFORMATION TO FACILITATE A
 COMPLETE REVIEW OF PLANS. FBC 106.1.2
  
 5. PLEASE PROVIDE "DUCT INC." SUBMITTAL DATA WITH
 INSTRUCTIONS. THE HANGER SPACING AS SHOWN ON PLANS IS
 GREATER THAT WHAT IS CALLED FOR IN SMACNA DUCT
 CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS. ALSO, PLEASE PROVIDE HANGING
 DETAIL SHOWIN HOW DUCT IS TO BE SUPPORTED FROM THE
 BUILDING STRUCTURE.
  
 6. PG 5 STATES "MINIMUM SENSOR-TO-VALVE DISTANCE IS 20'
 BASED ON A MAXIMUM AIR VELOCITY OF 4,000 FPM." HOWEVER,
 24" ROUND DUCT CARRYING 13,000 CFM HAS A VELOCITY OF
 4,140 CFM. PLEASE SEE COMMENT 4 REGARDING MISSING
 INFORMATION NEEDED TO DETERMINE PROPER SENSOR-TO-VALVE
 DISTANCE.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:
 RONALD J REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-05-03 Cont ID  
Sent By rregueir Date 2007-05-03 Time 14:29 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rregueir Date 2007-05-02 Time 17:10 Sent To  
Notes
2007-05-03 14:29:28----------------DENIED----------------
  
 FBC 2004 CODE FAMILY W/2006 REVISIONS
 NFPA 966
  
  
 1. THIS PLAN HAS BEEN SIGNED/SEALED BY AN ENGINEER FOR
 STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS ONLY. WHO IS THE DESIGN
 PROFESSIONSAL RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DUST COLLECTION
 SYSTEM? DIGITAL DESIGN AND DRAFTING MAY NOT OFFER
 ENGINEERING SERVICES PER F.S. 471.003. PLEASE RESUBMIT
 DRAWINGS SIGNED AND SEALED BY A PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER
 TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE DESIGN OF THE DUST
 COLLECTION SYSTEM.
  
 2. THE USAGE OF THIS PORTION OF THE BUILDING AS A
 WOODWORKING FACILITY REQUIRES CONFORMANCE WITH NFPA 664
 IN ACCORDANCE WITH FBC,M 511.4.
  
 3. BUILDING, FIRE, ELECTRICAL AND ZONING REVIEWS ARE
 ALSO REQUIRED. A CHANGE OF USAGE CLASS FOR THIS PORTION
 OF THE BUILDING MAY BE REQUIRED PENDING THESE OTHER
 REVIEWS.
  
 4. THE INSTALLATION AND APPROVAL OF THE DUST COLLECTION
 SYSTEM WILL BE REQUIRED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE PRIOR TO
 ISSUANCE OF A C.O. FBC,M 510.2.1. A COMPLETE REVIEW OF
 THE DUST COLLECTION SYSTEM WILL BE PERFORMED ONCE THE
 REQUIREMENTS OF COMMENT #1 HAVE BEEN MET.
  
 REVIEWED BY:
 RONALD J REGUEIRO
 561.805.6719
 [email protected]
Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2007-09-12 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2007-09-12 Time 22:47 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2007-09-12 Time 22:47 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2007-07-22 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2007-07-22 Time 20:28 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2007-07-22 Time 20:22 Sent To  
Notes
2007-07-22 20:38:21***FAILED***
  
 1) MINOR AMENDMENT TO THE RYBOVICH SPENCER COMMERCIAL
 MARINED PLANNED DEVELOPMENT (CMPD) SHALL BE APPROVED
 PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING PERMIT.ONCE
 APPROVED, THE PERMIT PLANS SHALL MATCH THAT OF THE
 MINOR AMENDMENT.
  
 QUESTIONS/COMMENTS, CONTACT JOHN ROACH, SENIOR PLANNER,
 AT (561) 822-1435.
Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2007-06-04 Cont ID  
Sent By jroach Date 2007-06-04 Time 14:07 Rev Time 0.00
Received By jroach Date 2007-06-04 Time 14:07 Sent To  
Notes
2007-06-04 14:09:45***FAILED***
  
 1) MINOR AMENDMENT TO THE RYBOVICH SPENCER COMMERCIAL
 MARINE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT (CMPD) SHALL BE SUBMITTED
 TO, AND APPROVED BY, THE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
 PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING PERMIT.
  
 2) UPON INITIAL REVIEW, THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT HAS
 SIGNIFICANT CONCERNS REGARDING THE IMPACT OF THE
 PROPOSED DUST COLLECTION SYSTEM ON THE ARCHITECTURE OF
 THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDING.
  
 QUESTIONS/COMMENTS, CONTACT JOHN ROACH, SENIOR PLANNER,
 AT (561) 822-1435.


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved