Plan Review Details - Permit 04041900
Plan Review Stops For Permit 04041900
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 4 Status P Date 2004-08-04 Cont ID  
Sent By rbrown Date 2004-08-04 Time 14:11 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rbrown Date 2004-08-04 Time 14:11 Sent To  
Notes
2004-08-04 00:00:00SHEET A-1.3, DOOR TYPE 3 RED-LINED TO
 OMIT VISION PANEL UNLESS AN ALTERNATIVE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL IS SUBMITTED.
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2004-07-16 Cont ID  
Sent By rbrown Date 2004-07-16 Time 17:41 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rbrown Date 2004-07-16 Time 11:55 Sent To  
Notes
2004-07-29 00:00:00PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS AMENDED TO REFLECT
 SUBMITTED PRODUCT APPROVALS, PLAN CHECK
 STATUS CHANGED TO PERMIT APPLICATION
 STATUS AND PAYMENT OF IMPACT FEES.
 APPLICANT AGREED TO PROVIDE THE REQUIRED
 PRODUCT APPROVALS BEFORE PERMIT ISSUE
 RATHER THAN APPLY FOR A SEPARATE PERMIT
 LATER.SEE BELOW.
 .
2004-07-16 00:00:00BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 ******PROVISO*******
 ROBERT BROWN(561) 805 6716
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
 FBC = FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2001
 FBC*= FLORIDA BUILD'G CODE (CITY AMEND)
  
 INFORMATIVE:
 THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT SHALL BE
 RECORDED AT PALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE
 AND A COPY SUBMITTED TO THIS OFFICE
 BEFORE A PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED.BLANK
 FORMS ARE AVAILABLE FROM THIS OFFICE.
  
 INFORMATIVE:
 A SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION IS
 REQUIRED FOR THE AWNINGS AND CANOPIES
  
 PROVISO - PRODUCT APPROVALS:
 (A) NOT USED
  
 (B) SUBMIT TWO COPIES OF A PRODUCT
 APPROVAL FOR THE HOLLOW METAL DOORS
  
 (C) THE SUBMITTED ALUFAB STORM PANEL
 SHUTTER PRODUCT APPROVAL NOA# 01-0913.01
 DOES NOT HAVE A MATCHING STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL.SUBMIT TWO COPIES OF
 AN ALTERNATIVE THAT HAS STATEWIDE OR
 LOCAL PRODUCT APPROVAL.
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2004-06-16 Cont ID  
Sent By rbrown Date 2004-06-16 Time 18:59 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rbrown Date 2004-06-16 Time 17:23 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-16 00:00:00BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 *******DENIED*******
 ROBERT BROWN(561) 805 6716
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
 FBC = FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2001
 FBC*= FLORIDA BUILD'G CODE (CITY AMEND)
  
 FOR CONSISTENCY, THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS
 ARE NUMBERED AS PER THE BUILDING PLAN
 REVIEW OF 5/20/04:
  
 1) INFORMATIVE (COMMENT RESPONSE NOTED):
 WORKING DRAWING REVIEW ONLY.NO
 PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED UNTIL THE PERMIT
 APPLICATION AND FEES ARE SUBMITTED.
  
 2) INFORMATIVE (COMMENT RESPONSE NOTED):
 THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT SHALL BE
 RECORDED AT PALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE
 AND A COPY SUBMITTED TO THIS OFFICE
 BEFORE A PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED.BLANK
 FORMS ARE AVAILABLE FROM THIS OFFICE.
  
 3) INFORMATIVE (COMMENT RESPONSE NOTED):
 IMPACT FEES. THE PLANS SHALL BE TAKEN
 TO PALM BEACH COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT
 FOR IMPACT FEE ASSESSMENT. THEY SHALL BE
 STAMPED AT THAT OFFICE AND A COPY OF THE
 PAID RECEIPT SUBMITTED TO THE CITY OF
 WEST PALM BEACH DEPT OF CONSTRUCTION
 SERVICES BEFORE A PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED.
  
 4) INFORMATIVE (COMMENT RESPONSE NOTED):
 A SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION IS
 REQUIRED FOR THE AWNINGS AND CANOPIES.
  
 6) FBC* 104.2.4SITE SURVEY.THIS
 COMMENT HAS NOT BEEN PROPERLY ADDRESSED.
 THE SIGNATURE ON THE SUBMITTED SURVEY
 DRAWING IS A PHOTOCOPIED.THE DRAWING
 SHALL HAVE THE ORIGINAL 'WET' SIGNATURE
 OF THE LICENSED SURVEYOR/MAPPER (REF:
 472.025(1) FL. STATUTES)
  
 9) 61G15-23.002(2)FL. ADMIN. CODE.
 ENGINEER'S TITLE BLOCK.THIS COMMENT
 HAS NOT BEEN PROPERLY ADDRESSED.ONLY
 SHEET S-5.1 HAS A REVISED TITLE BLOCK,
 AND IT STILL DOES NOT SHOW A FLORIDA
 CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION (CA) NUMBER
 (FLORIDA REGISTERED ENGINEER'G BUSINESS)
 FOR BRITTINGHAM AND ASSOCIATES.ADD A
 VALID CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION
 NUMBER OR REMOVE 'BRITTINGHAM AND
 ASSOCIATES' FROM THE PLANS AND ADD/LEAVE
 THE NAME, LICENSE NUMBER AND ADDRESS OF
 GROVER M. BRITTINGHAM, P.E. INSTEAD.
 (REF: 471.025 F.S. AND 471.023 F.S.)
 NOTE: THE TITLE BLOCK ON SHEETS S-1.1 TO
 S-4.3 SHALL ALSO BE AMENDED AS ABOVE.
  
 18) SUBMIT PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR THE
 MODIFIED BITUMEN ROOFING SYSTEM.THESE
 CAN BE SUBMITTED BY THE CONTRACTOR WHEN
 GOING TO PERMIT APPLICATION STATUS FROM
 THE CURRENT 'PLAN REVIEW ONLY STATUS'.
 THE COMMENT RESPONSE, REFERING TO A
 SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION BY THE
 CONTRACTOR, IS NOTED BUT IS NOT
 APPROPRIATE FOR THE ROOF COVERING.
 NOTE: FL. ADMIN CODE RULE 9B-72 (IN
 EFFECT SINCE OCTOBER 1, 2003) REQUIRES
 THAT PRODUCTS HAVE STATEWIDE, LOCAL OR
 SITE-SPECIFIC PRODUCT APPROVAL.THE
 SUBMITTAL SHOULD INCLUDE THE STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL NUMBER (FL###),
 AVAILABLE FROM THE DEPT OF COMMUNITY
 AFFAIRS PRODUCT APPROVAL WEBSITE
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/PR/PR_SRCH.ASP
  
 19) WINDOW/DOOR PRODUCT APPROVALS
 IT IS NOTED THAT THE RESPONSES TO
 COMMENTS 14, 15 AND 16 STATE THAT THE
 CONTRACTOR WILL SUBMIT PRODUCT APPROVALS
 UNDER A SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION.AS
 THE CURRENT STATUS IS 'PLAN REVIEW ONLY'
 AND THE GENERAL CONTRACTOR WILL BE
 REQUIRED TO MAKE THE PERMIT APPLICATION,
 THE PRODUCT APPROVALS MAY BE SUBMITTED
 BY THE G.C. AT THAT STAGE.IF NOT,
 SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION AND FEES
 (COVERING THE VALUE OF THE WINDOW/DOOR/
 SHUTTER/STOREFRONT PACKAGE) WILL BE
 REQUIRED. IN LIGHT OF THE ABOVE OPTIONS,
 THE APPROPRIATE COMMENTS ARE REPRODUCED
 BELOW:
 (A) SUBMIT PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR THE
 WINDOWS, MULLIONS, STOREFRONT, EXTERIOR
 DOORS (AND SHUTTERS IF ANY OF THESE ARE
 NOT IMPACT RESISTANT).
 NOTE: FL. ADMIN CODE RULE 9B-72 (IN
 EFFECT SINCE OCTOBER 1, 2003) REQUIRES
 THAT PRODUCTS HAVE STATEWIDE, LOCAL OR
 SITE-SPECIFIC PRODUCT APPROVAL.THE
 SUBMITTAL SHOULD INCLUDE THE STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL NUMBER (FL###),
 AVAILABLE FROM THE DEPT OF COMMUNITY
 AFFAIRS PRODUCT APPROVAL WEBSITE
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/PR/PR_SRCH.ASP
 (B) PRODUCT APPROVAL.RULE 9B-72 FAC.
 FOR PRODUCTS WHICH DO NOT HAVE STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL, LOCAL PRODUCT APPROVAL
 CAN BE ACHIEVED IF THERE IS A QUALITY
 ASSURANCE PROGRAM IN PLACE WITH A STATE
 APPROVED QUALITY ASSURANCE ENTITY.IF
 NEITHER IS APPLICABLE, THEN SITE
 SPECIFIC APPROVAL IS REQUIRED.LOCAL
 PRODUCT APPROVAL WILL ALLOW A PRODUCT TO
 BE USED, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE TEST
 CRITERIA, THROUGHOUT THE JURISDICTION OF
 WEST PALM BEACH.SITE SPECIFIC PRODUCT
 APPROVAL WILL ALLOW A PRODUCT TO BE
 USED ONLY ON THE PROJECT FOR WHICH THAT
 SITE SPECIFIC APPROVAL IS GRANTED.
 LOCAL AND SITE SPECIFIC PRODUCT APPROVAL
 APPLICATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE FROM
 THIS OFFICE.APPROVED QUALITY ASSURANCE
 ENTITIES ARE LISTED ON THE DCA WEBSITE:
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/COMMON/C_ORG_
 REGI_SRCH.ASP
  
 20) FBC 1606.1SHEET ES-2.0LIGHTING
 POLE.THE 'HAPCO SERIES 50' REFERENCE
 ON THIS SHEET DOES NOT CORRELATE WITH
 THE REFERENCE GIVEN ON THE SUBMITTED
 LITHONIA LIGHTING LETTER DATED 5/19/04
 AND ACCOMPNYING CALCULATIONS.SEE ALSO,
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW NOTE REGARDING
 THE ENGINEERING FOR THE SAME.
  
 **QUOTE PERMIT# ON ALL CORRESPONDENCE**
  
 END OF REVIEW COMMENTS
 THE CODE REFERENCES GIVE ADDITIONAL INFO
 TELEPHONE: (561) 805 6716ROBERT BROWN
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
Review Stop B BUILDING (STRUCTURAL)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-05-21 Cont ID  
Sent By rbrown Date 2004-05-21 Time 18:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rbrown Date 2004-05-20 Time 10:53 Sent To  
Notes
2004-05-20 00:00:00BUILDING PLAN REVIEW
 *******DENIED*******
 ROBERT BROWN(561) 805 6716
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
  
 FBC = FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2001
 FBC*= FLORIDA BUILD'G CODE (CITY AMEND)
  
 1) WORKING DRAWING REVIEW ONLY.NO
 PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED UNTIL THE PERMIT
 APPLICATION AND FEES ARE SUBMITTED.
  
 2) THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT SHALL BE
 RECORDED AT PALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE
 AND A COPY SUBMITTED TO THIS OFFICE
 BEFORE A PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED.BLANK
 FORMS ARE AVAILABLE FROM THIS OFFICE.
  
 3) IMPACT FEES. THE PLANS SHALL BE TAKEN
 TO PALM BEACH COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT
 FOR IMPACT FEE ASSESSMENT. THEY SHALL BE
 STAMPED AT THAT OFFICE AND A COPY OF THE
 PAID RECEIPT SUBMITTED TO THE CITY OF
 WEST PALM BEACH DEPT OF CONSTRUCTION
 SERVICES BEFORE A PERMIT CAN BE ISSUED.
  
 4) A SEPARATE PERMIT APPLICATION IS
 REQUIRED FOR THE AWNINGS AND CANOPIES.
  
 5) FBC* 1804.2.2AREA OF QUESTIONABLE
 SOIL.SUBMIT A GEOTECHNICAL REPORT
 TO VERIFY THE SAFE BEARING CAPACITY OF
 THE SOIL.
  
 6) FBC* 104.2.4SITE SURVEY.THE
 SUBMITTED SURVEY DRAWING SHALL BE SIGNED
 AND SEALED BY A LICENSED SURVEYOR/MAPPER
 (REF: 472.025(1) FL. STATUTES)
  
 7) FBC* F102.1SHEET C-2.0, HIRING
 TRAILER.NOTE THAT TYPE VI BUILDINGS
 ARE NOT PERMITTED IN THE FIRE DISTRICT.
 SUBMIT DETAILS OF THE PROPOSED TRAILER,
 DEMONSTRATING COMPLIANCE, OR DELETE THE
 TRAILER.THE CONSTRUCTION TRAILER DOES
 NOT REQUIRE PERMITTING, AND CAN THEREFOR
 BE TYPE VI.
  
 8) FBC* 104.2.1.3THE BUILDING ADDRESS
 SHALL BE CORRECT ON PLANS TO BE RETAINED
 FOR PUBLIC RECORD.THE ADDRESS IS
 STATED INCORRECTLY ON EVERY PLAN SHEET
 TITLE BLOCK FROM SHEET T-1.1 ONWARD.
 THIS MAY BE CORRECTED BY HAND ON THOSE
 SHEETS THAT DO NOT REQUIRE REPLACEMENT
 TO ADDRESS OTHER PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS.
  
 9) 61G15-23.002(2)FL. ADMIN. CODE.
 THE TITLE BLOCK ON THE STRUCTURAL PLANS
 DOES NOT INCLUDE ALL REQUIRED INFO.
 PLANS SIGNED & SEALED BY A PROFESSIONAL
 ENGINEER SHALL INCLUDE THE PRINTED NAME
 AND LICENSE NUMBER OF THE ENGINEER AND
 THE NAME AND CERTIFICATE OF
 AUTHORIZATION NUMBER OF THE ENGINEERING
 COMPANY THROUGH WHICH THE ENGINEER IS
 PRACTICING (471.025 F.S. & 471.023 F.S.)
  
 10) FBC 2405.2SHEET A-1.3. OFFICE DOOR
 (#4) WHICH IS A TYPE 3 DOOR, HAS A GLASS
 PANEL, SPECIFIED AS 1/4" ANNEALED GLASS.
 THE GLASS PANEL SIZE EXCEEDS THE MAXIMUM
 SIZE ALLOWED BY FBC 2405.2.2(1) WITHOUT
 MEETING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR SAFETY
 GLASS.AS THE GLASS IS IN A 'HAZARDOUS
 LOCATION', AND IS NOT EXEMPT, IT IS
 REQUIRED TO BE SAFETY GLASS SATISFYING
 THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CONSUMER PRODUCT
 SAFETY COMMISSION 16, CODE OF FEDERAL
 REGULATIONS, PART 1201 (CPSC 16-CFR,
 PART 1201).SUBMIT DETAILS TO
 DEMONSTRATE COMPLIANCE.
  
 11) FBC* F102.2.4SHEET A-1.7, ROOF
 PLAN, ROOFING NOTES.ROOF COVERINGS, ON
 BUILDINGS LOCATED IN THE FIRE DISTRICT,
 SHALL CONFORM TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF
 CLASS A OR B ROOF COVERINGS, AS DEFINED
 IN FBC 1505.ANNOTATE THE PLANS TO
 DEMONSTRATE COMPLIANCE.
  
 12) FBC 1606.1.7WIND LOAD. SHEET S5.1,
 NOTE 7 STATES THE BASIC WIND SPEED, WIND
 IMPORTANCE FACTOR AND WIND EXPOSURE
 CATEGORY.AMEND THE PLANS TO ALSO STATE
 THE INTERNAL PRESSURE COEFFICIENT AND
 THE EXTERIOR COMPONENT AND CLADDING
 DESIGN WIND PRESSURES FOR THE DOORS AND
 WINDOWS.
  
 13) FBC 3501REFERENCE STANDARDS.
 SHEET S5.1, REINFORCED CONCRETE NOTE #1
 AND #5 BOTH REFER TO ACI 318-95. FLORIDA
 BUILDING CODE 2001 (WITH 2003 REVISIONS)
 REFERENCES ACI 318-02.AMEND THE NOTES.
  
 14) FL. ADMIN CODE RULE 9B-72.
 A SEARCH AT THE DEPT OF COMMUNITY
 AFFAIRS PRODUCT APPROVAL WEBSITE
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/PR/PR_SRCH.ASP
 SHOWS NO MATCHING STATEWIDE PRODUCT
 APPROVAL FOR THE SUBMITTED MIAMI-DADE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL NOA# 03-0225.02 FOR
 ALUFAB HURRICANE SHUTTER'S GALVANIZED
 STEEL STORM PANELS.HOWEVER, THERE ARE
 TWO CURRENT STATEWIDE PRODUCT APPROVAL
 LISTINGS FOR GALVANISED STEEL STORM
 PANELS (SEE ATTACHED PRINT-OUT FROM
 THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS-DCA-
 PRODUCT APPROVAL SEARCH WEBPAGE).
 PROVIDE TWO COPIES OF THE SELECTED
 STATE APPROVED LISTING TOGETHER WITH THE
 APPROPRIATE EVALUATION REPORT FROM THE
 DCA WEB-SITE).
  
 15) SUBMIT PRODUCT APPROVALS FOR THE
 MODIFIED BITUMEN ROOFING SYSTEM,
 WINDOWS, MULLIONS, STOREFRONT AND
 EXTERIOR DOORS.
 NOTE: FL. ADMIN CODE RULE 9B-72 (IN
 EFFECT SINCE OCTOBER 1, 2003) REQUIRES
 THAT PRODUCTS HAVE STATEWIDE, LOCAL OR
 SITE-SPECIFIC PRODUCT APPROVAL.THE
 SUBMITTAL SHOULD INCLUDE THE STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL NUMBER (FL###),
 AVAILABLE FROM THE DEPT OF COMMUNITY
 AFFAIRS PRODUCT APPROVAL WEBSITE
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/PR/PR_SRCH.ASP
  
 16) PRODUCT APPROVAL.RULE 9B-72 FAC.
 FOR PRODUCTS WHICH DO NOT HAVE STATEWIDE
 PRODUCT APPROVAL, LOCAL PRODUCT APPROVAL
 CAN BE ACHIEVED IF THERE IS A QUALITY
 ASSURANCE PROGRAM IN PLACE WITH A STATE
 APPROVED QUALITY ASSURANCE ENTITY.IF
 NEITHER IS APPLICABLE, THEN SITE
 SPECIFIC APPROVAL IS REQUIRED.LOCAL
 PRODUCT APPROVAL WILL ALLOW A PRODUCT TO
 BE USED, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE TEST
 CRITERIA, THROUGHOUT THE JURISDICTION OF
 WEST PALM BEACH.SITE SPECIFIC PRODUCT
 APPROVAL WILL ALLOW A PRODUCT TO BE
 USED ONLY ON THE PROJECT FOR WHICH THAT
 SITE SPECIFIC APPROVAL IS GRANTED.
 LOCAL AND SITE SPECIFIC PRODUCT APPROVAL
 APPLICATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE FROM
 THIS OFFICE.APPROVED QUALITY ASSURANCE
 ENTITIES ARE LISTED ON THE DCA WEBSITE:
 WWW.FLORIDABUILDING.ORG/COMMON/C_ORG_
 REGI_SRCH.ASP
  
 17) TO EXPEDITE REVIEW OF A RESUBMITTAL
 WHICH REQUIRES NEW PLANS IN ORDER TO
 ADDRESS THE ABOVE COMMENTS, THE OLD
 SHEETS SHALL BE REMOVED AND THE NEW
 SHEETS INSERTED.ONE COPY OF EACH OLD
 SHEET SHOULD BE STAPLED/CLIPPED TO THE
 REMAINING OLD SHEETS FOR COMPARISON OF
 REVISIONS WHEN REVIEWING THE RESUBMITTED
 PLANS.
  
 **QUOTE PERMIT# ON ALL CORRESPONDENCE**
  
 END OF REVIEW COMMENTS
 THE CODE REFERENCES GIVE ADDITIONAL INFO
 TELEPHONE: (561) 805 6716ROBERT BROWN
 E-MAIL: [email protected]
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2004-07-07 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2004-07-07 Time 16:13 Rev Time 0.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2004-07-07 Time 16:14 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2004-06-16 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2004-06-15 Time 20:10 Rev Time 1.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2004-06-15 Time 19:44 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-15 00:00:00*********** UNSAT ***********
  
 PLEASE SEE SOME COMMENTS FROM FIRST
 REVIEW STILL NEED TO BE ADDRESSED.
 PLEASE SEE NOTES BELOW.
  
 NOTE #1 OK.
  
 NOTE #2 NOTE:
 PLEASE SEE WIND LOADING REPORT WILL
 BE REQUIRED TO BE REVIEWED BY BLDG PLAN
 REVIEW. THIS REPORT WILL ALSO BE
 REQUIRED TO BE SIGNED,DATED AND SEALED
 BY A FLORIDA PE. REPORT WILL REQUIRE
 TITLE BLOCK AND INFORMATION AS SET FORTH
 UNDER FAC 61G15-23.002/ FS 471.025
 PLEASE SEE INFORMATION FOUND ON ES-2.0
 DOES NOT SEEM TO CORRELATE WITH # OF
 FIXTURES, TYPE OF FIXTURES AS SHOWN
 ON REPORT AND PLANS.
  
 NOTE #3 NOTE: PLEASE SEE PANEL SCHEDULE
 INFORMATION FOR MDP INDICATES PANEL AS
 MLO. A SHUNT TRIP SHALL NOT BE CONSIDER-
 -ED A "MEANS OF DISCONNECT". 230.76,230-
 -79.
 PLEASE SEE MDP ALSO SHOWS MORE THAN
 6 MEANS OF DISC. PANEL SCHEDULE SHOWS
 18 SPACES CAPABLE OF HAVING 18 MEANS
 OF DISCONNECT.230.71
  
 NOTE #4 NOTE: PLANS STILL NOTE, "WHERE
 2002 NEC IS IN EFFECT" PLEASE NOTE:
 PLANS PER 2002 NEC.
 PLEASE ALSO SEE OPT LOAD SUMMARY, PLANS
 STILL NOTE 96 AND 99 NEC.SEE ONE SET
 HAS BEEN REDLINED FOR THIS.
  
 PLEASE SEE PLANS ARE ONLY IN FOR "PLAN
 REVIEW" AND NOT FOR PERMIT.
  
 PLEASE REMOVE ALL OLD/VOIDED SHEETS AND
 ONLY INSERT NEW SHEETS FOR REVIEW AND
 STAMPING. ONE SET OF OLD/VOIDED SHEETS
 MAY BE SUBMITTED FOR REFERENCE ONLY,
 WHICH MAY BE REQUIRED BY SOME REVIEWERS.
  
 PLEASE SUBMIT THE ABOVE INFORMATION FOR
 REVIEW. IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS,
 PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO CALL.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 CONSTUCTION SERVICES DEPT.
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
Review Stop E ELECTRICAL
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-05-08 Cont ID  
Sent By dpalmer Date 2004-05-08 Time 20:14 Rev Time 1.00
Received By dpalmer Date 2004-05-08 Time 20:06 Sent To  
Notes
2004-05-08 00:00:00************** UNSAT *****************
  
 1)NOTE: PLEASE SEE FAC 61G15-23.002 FOR
 ALL INFORMATION REQ'D ON TITLE BLOCK.
 PLEASE ALSO SEE FS 471.023 FOR REQ'D
 CA LICENSE #.
 THIS IS REQ'D FOR ALL TRADES WEATHER OR
 NOTE COMMENT IS MADE BYOTHER REVIEWER.
  
 2)NOTE: PLEASE SUBMIT/SHOW WIND LOAD FOR
 ANY PARKING LOT LT FIXTURES AND POLES.
 FBC 140 MPH..
 COULD NOT BE LOCATED ON ES-1.0,2.0 OR
 E1-1.
  
 3)NOTE: PLEASE CLARIFY MANUAL MEANS OF
 DISCONNECT FOR SHUNT TRIP BRKRS IN
 MDP IN THE EVENT OF SHUNT TRIP FAILURE.
 230.76,230.79
  
 4)NOTE: PLEASE SEE E-6.1, SHOWS LOADS
 SUMMARYS REFERENCING 1996/1999 NEC
 PLEASE SEE THAT WE NOW UNDER THE 2002
 NEC WHICH WAS ADOPTED BY THE STATE ON
 7/1/2003
 ALL GFI PROTECTION WILL BE REQ'D UNDER
 2002 NEC.
  
 5)NOTE: PLEASE INCLUDE/SHOW WINDOW
 RECEPTS WILL BE REQ'D PER 210.62
  
 PLEASE NOTE: PLANS ARE ONLY IN FOR
 PLAN REVIEW AND NOT FOR PERMIT.
  
 PLEASE REMOVE ALL OLD/ VOIDED SHEEST
 AND ONLY INSERT NEW SHEETS INTO COMPLETE
 SETS FOR REVIEW AND STAMPING. ONE SET
 OF OLD MAY BE SUBITTED FOR REFERENCE
 REQ'D BY SOME REVIEWERS.
  
 PLEASE SUBMIT THE ABOVE INFORMATION FOR
 REVIEW. IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS,
 PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO CALL.
  
 DEWEY PALMER
 ELECTRICAL PLAN REVIEW
 CITY OF WEST PALM BEACH
 CONSTUCTION SERVICES DEPT.
 561-805-6717
 [email protected]
Review Stop ENG ENGINEERING CSD
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2004-06-07 Cont ID  
Sent By mamini Date 2004-06-07 Time 11:21 Rev Time 1.00
Received By mamini Date 2004-06-07 Time 11:21 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop ENG ENGINEERING CSD
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-05-06 Cont ID  
Sent By mamini Date 2004-05-06 Time 15:21 Rev Time 1.00
Received By mamini Date 2004-05-06 Time 15:21 Sent To  
Notes
2004-05-06 00:00:00FAILED:
 1. CIVIL PLANS MUST BE APPROVED FOR ALL
 THE CONNECTIONS TO THE SERVICES AND
 STAMPED BY THE PUBLIC UTILITIES AND
 ENGINEERING.
 2. ALL COMMERCIAL SITES MUST BE DESIGNED
 PER CITY OF WPB CRITERIA FOR STORM WATER
 3. PROPOSED 10' UTILITY EASEMENT,
 GRANTING TO THE CITY MUST BE FINALIZED,
 ATT; VINCE NOEL, 659-8040.
 4. BACKFLOW PREVENTERS MUST BE HIDDEN
 FROM VIEW WITH SHRUBS.
  
 IF ANY QUESTION PLEASE CONTACT 805-6723
 MOHAMMAD R. AMINI
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2004-07-09 Cont ID  
Sent By nmccray Date 2004-07-09 Time 11:00 Rev Time 0.00
Received By nmccray Date 2004-07-09 Time 11:00 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2004-06-03 Cont ID  
Sent By mcarsill Date 2004-06-03 Time 16:19 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mcarsill Date 2004-06-03 Time 16:19 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-03 00:00:001) DOORS SUBJECT TO AN OCCUPANCY OF
 100 OR MORE PERSONS SHALL BE EQUIPPED
 WITH APPROVED PANIC HARDWARE. THE
 DOOR SCHEDULE INDICATES PANIC HARDWARE
 ON DOOR # 19 BUT NO DOOR # 19 COULD
 BE LOCATED. PLEASE ADVISE.
  
 2) TACTILE SIGNAGE REQUIRED AT EXIT
 DOORS.
  
 MIKE CARSILLO, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 835-2910
Review Stop FIRE FIRE DEPARTMENT
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-04-29 Cont ID  
Sent By mcarsill Date 2004-04-29 Time 14:20 Rev Time 0.00
Received By mcarsill Date 2004-04-29 Time 14:20 Sent To  
Notes
2004-04-29 00:00:001) DEMOLITION, RENOVATION AND
 CONSTRUCTION TO COMPLY WITH NFPA 241.
  
 2) THE PLANS INDICATE TYPE VI
 CONSTRUCTION BEING PROPOSED. TYPE VI
 CONSTRUCTION IS NOT PERMITTED IN THE
 CITY FIRE LIMITS. SINCE THE LOCATION
 IS WITHIN THE CITY FIRE LIMITS CERTAIN
 RESTRICTIONS WILL APPLY. PLEASE SEE
 APPENDIX F LOCAL AMENDMENTS TO THE
 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE. PLEASE REVISE
 PLANS AS REQUIRED.
  
 3) MORE DETAILS REQUIRED ON HIRING
 TRAILER. AGAIN TYPE VI CONSTRUCTION
 IS NOT ALLOWED IN THE FIRE LIMITS.
 ONLY TRAILERS ASSOCIATED WITH
 CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES ARE ALLOWED
 TO BE TYPE VI.
  
 4) WRONG BUILDING ADDRESS NOTED ON
 TILE PAGE.
  
 5) SEPARATE PLANS AND PERMITS
 REQUIRED FOR ALL HOOD, DUCT, AND
 FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS.
  
 6) PLEASE INDICATE INTERIOR FINSH
 CLASSIFICATION FOR WALLS AND CEILINGS.
  
 7) PLEASE PROVIDE PRODUCT DATA ON
 KITCHEN HOOD DUCT WRAP.
  
 8) PLEASE ADVISE LOCATIONS OF PFE'S.
  
 9) FIRE LIMITS-ROOF COVERING SHALL
 BE CLASS A OR B.
  
 10) BUILDING ADDRESS REQUIRED. MINIMUM
 6" HIGH NUMBERS THAT CONTRAST ARE
 REQUIRED.
  
 MIKE CARSILLO, ASSISTANT FIRE MARSHAL
 835-2910
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 3 Status N Date 2004-06-29 Cont ID  
Sent By csiegber Date 2004-06-29 Time 16:35 Rev Time 0.00
Received By csiegber Date 2004-06-29 Time 16:35 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-29 00:00:00TO COMM BD#59
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 2 Status N Date 2004-06-03 Cont ID  
Sent By csiegber Date 2004-06-03 Time 10:18 Rev Time 0.00
Received By csiegber Date 2004-06-03 Time 10:18 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-03 00:00:00TO COMM BD#37
Review Stop I INCOMING/PROCESSING
Rev No 1 Status N Date 2004-05-21 Cont ID  
Sent By csiegber Date 2004-05-21 Time 18:23 Rev Time 0.00
Received By rbrown Date 2004-04-28 Time 14:30 Sent To  
Notes
2004-04-28 00:00:00TO COMM BD#37
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 2 Status P Date 2004-06-09 Cont ID  
Sent By pkrauss Date 2004-06-16 Time 10:25 Rev Time 0.55
Received By pkrauss Date 2004-06-09 Time 09:01 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop M MECHANICAL (A/C)
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-05-13 Cont ID  
Sent By pkrauss Date 2004-05-12 Time 10:32 Rev Time 1.00
Received By pkrauss Date 2004-05-12 Time 10:19 Sent To  
Notes
2004-05-12 00:00:00DENIED:
 1.ADDITIONAL PERMITS REQUIRED FOR THE
 HOOD, FIRE SUPPRESSION AND WALK-IN
 COOLERS.PROVIDE MANUFACTURER
 SUBMITTAL & INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS
 FOR THE WALK-IN COOLERS WITH PERMIT
 APPLICATION.SHOULD CONDENSORS BE
 REMOTE, PROVIDE MANUFACTURER SUBMITTAL
 FOR THE ROOF STANDS.
  
 2.PLAN SHEETS M-1 & M-2 INDICATE
 EXHAUST FROM HOOD SHALL BE 10 FT FROM
 PARAPETS.PER 2001 FBC(M) 506.3.14.3,
 OUTLETS SHALL BE NOT LESS FROM PROPERTY
 LINES & FRESH AIR INTAKES.
  
 3.PLAN SHEET M-2 INDICATES 3M FIRE
 BARRIER WRAP 15A, PROVIDE MANUFAUCTURER
 INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS ON THE
 JOBSITE AT THE TIME OF INSPECTION.DO
 NOT COVER WELDS TO GREASE DUCT PRIOR TO
 INSPECTION.
  
 4.PLAN SHEET M-3 DETAIL #5, NOTE
 INDICATES FACTORY INSTALLED DUCT SMOKE
 DETECTORS ARE TO BE RELOCATED FROM THE
 SUPPLYTO THE RETURN.PER 2001 FBC(M)
 606.2.1, DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS SHALL BE
 INSTALLED IN THE SUPPLY AIR SYSTEM.
  
 5.PLEASE PROVIDE OUTSIDE AIR
 CALCULATIONS PER 2001 FBC(M) 403.3.
  
 6.PLAN SHEET M-3 DETAIL 7, PLEASE NOTE
 PER 2001 FBC 1511.7 CURB HEIGHT FOR THE
 RTU SHALL BE NO LESS THAN 8" ABOVE THE
 ROOF SURFACE.
  
 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE
 CONTACT PATTY KRAUSS AT (561) 805-6719.
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 3 Status P Date 2004-07-10 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2004-07-10 Time 15:14 Rev Time 1.50
Received By kstevens Date 2004-07-10 Time 15:14 Sent To  
Notes
***NONE***
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 2 Status F Date 2004-06-16 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2004-06-16 Time 09:32 Rev Time 2.00
Received By kstevens Date 2004-06-15 Time 18:54 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-16 00:00:00DENIED
 REFERENCE: FBC-2001 PLUMBING
 FBC-2001 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2001 FUEL GAS
  
 1) PLANS ROUTED TO DBPR HOTEL AND REST-
 URANT. TWO COPIES ARE REQUIRED WITH THE
 WORKSHEETS ONLY ATTACHED. SHEETS SHALL
 BE PART OF THE PLANS SUBMITTED AND ALL
 OTHER "K" SHEETS REMOVED. SEC. 104.2.1
 ONLY ONE SET HAS BEEN STAMPED BY HOTEL
 AND RESTURANT DIVISION.
 2) FROM PREVIOUS REVIEW: #4 SHEET C-4.0
 NO CONNECTION TO FLOOR DRAIN FOR THE RE-
 FUSE ENCLOSURE IS SHOWN. THIS SHALL BE
 CONNECTED TO THE GREASE LINE. RESPONSE
 NOTED, BUT SHT PS-1.0 PLUMBING SITE PLAN
 DOES NOT SHOW A CONNECTION. PLEASE INDI-
 CATE WHERE THIS IS SHOWN. SEC 104.2.1
 3) PER TABLE 1106.3 THE MAXIMUM SQUARE
 FEET OF RAIN WATER FOR A 3" PIPE @ 1/2"
 PER FT. IS 1,461. PLAN INDICATES THAT
 THE AREA FOR EACH ROOF DRAIN IS 1,468.
 4" PIPE SHALL BE REQUIRED FOR THE HORIZ-
 ONTAL STORM PIPING.
 4) GAS RISER DIAGRAM DOES NOT SHOW PIP-
 ING TO THE METER. SHOW PIPING TO THE GAS
 METER AND THE LENGTH OF ALL CUT SECTIONS
 TO THE METER.
 - SHOW THE DISTANCE FROM THE POINT OF
 DELIVERY (METER) TO THE MOST REMOTE OUT-
 LET. RESPONSE NOTED, BUT METER NOT SHOWN
 ON RISER DIAGRAM THUS NO MEASURMENT TO
 METER SHOWN.
 - SUBMIT MANUFACTURE SHEETS FOR ALL GAS
 EQUIPMENT TO VERIFY COMPLIANCE WITH
 STANDARDS NFPA 54, NFPA 58, AND THE FBC-
 2001 FUEL GAS CODE SEC 402.2. RESPONSE
 NOTED, BUT NO SHEETS WERE FOUND WITH
 PLANS. PLEASE CLARIFY.
 NEW COMMENT:***********
 1B) EMERGENCY HOOD SHUT DOWN SHUT OFF
 VALVE TO BE BELOW CEILING. MANUAL SHUT
 OFF VALVE TO BE UPSTREAM. UNION TO BE
 DOWN STREAM OF MANUAL VALVE.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 653-2692
 E-MAIL [email protected]
Review Stop P PLUMBING
Rev No 1 Status F Date 2004-05-15 Cont ID  
Sent By kstevens Date 2004-05-15 Time 08:49 Rev Time 5.00
Received By kstevens Date 2004-05-14 Time 18:45 Sent To  
Notes
2004-05-15 00:00:00DENIED
 REFERENCE: FBC-2001 PLUMBING
 FBC-2001 FUEL GAS
 FBC-2001 CHAPTER 1
 FBC-2001 CHAPTER 11
 WPC CITY CODE
 FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
 FLORIDA STATUTES
  
 1) PLANS SHALL BE ROUTED TO THE DEPT.
 BUSINESS REGULATION HOTEL & RESTURANT
 DIVISION FOR REVIEW PRIOR TO RESUBMITT-
 ING FOR REVIEW. PLANS SHALL BE STAMPED
 AND WORKSHEETS FROM DBPR ATTACHED TO
 EACH SET OF PLANS. SEC. 101.4.7
 2) CONTACT RODNEY COMPO, ENVIRONMENTAL
 COMPLIANCE FOR SIZING OF GREASE INTER-
 CEPTOR. WASTE ORD. #2938-96. (561) 837-
 4074.
 3) SEPARATE PERMITS REQUIRED FOR GAS,
 IRRIGATION, AND GREASE INTERCEPTOR.
 4) SHT C-4.0 NO CONNECTION TO FLOOR
 DRAIN FOR THE REFUSE ENCLOSURE IS SHOWN.
 THIS SHALL BE TIED INTO THE GREASE LINE.
 5) SHTS A-1.7 & P-2 NOTE STATES "CONDEN-
 SATE TO MOP SINK BELOW". THIS IS NOT
 APPROVED. CONDENSATE SHALL DRAIN SEPAR-
 ATELY OUT OF THE BLDG. TO A CATCH BASIN,
 A STORM LINE, OR APPROVED DRYWELL MIN.
 1' FROM STRUCTURAL SIDEWALL. CITY CODE
 SECTION 90-125(5).
 6) SHT P-2 CONDENSATE LINE FOR FREEZER/
 COOLER. A SEPARATE TRAP REQUIRED FOR
 EACH UNIT AND NO DOUBLE TRAPPING. SEC
 1002.1 - TRAP OUTSIDE COOLER TO BE RE-
 MOVED.
 7) SHT P-2 KEY NOTES #3, FLOOR DRAIN NOT
 AN APPROVED INDIRECT WASTE INTERCEPTOR.
 SEE SECTIONS 802.3 & 802.3.2, FLOOR SINK
 OR HUB DRAIN REQUIRED.
 8) SHT P-4 MORE INFORMATION ON PIPE SUP-
 PORT ON ROOF REQUIRED. INDICATE HOW SUP-
 PORTS WILL BE FASTENED TO THE ROOF. SHOW
 HOW SUPPORTS WILL BE ABLE TO WITHSTAND
 THE 140 MPH WIND LOADS.
 9) SHT P-5 WATER RISER DIAGRAM, WATER
 HAMMER ARRESTORS SHALL BE LOCATED NEAR
 THE FIXTURES IN AN "EFFECTIVE RANGE" NOT
 IN THE CEILING AS SHOWN. PDI-WH 201 AND
 MANUF. INSTALL. INSTRUCTIONS. - BALL
 CHECKS AT MOP SINK AND CAN WASH SHALL BE
 ACCESSIBLE.
 10) P-6 FIXTURE CONNECTION SHEDULE #36
 CATALOG INDICATES D50-064 IS A FLOOR
 DRAIN WHICH IS NOT AN APPROVED INDIRECT
 WASTE RECEPTOR. SEC 802.3 & 802.3.2.
 11) WATER FILTER SHALL BE NSF APPROVED
 PER SECTION 611.1. SUBMIT MANUF. SPECI-
 FICATION SHEETS.
 12) SHT P-7 PLUMBING SPECIFICATIONS PART
 3 - #7 PIPING SUPPORT SHALL BE PER TABLE
 308.5.
 13) SUBMIT CALCULATIONS FOR PRIMARY AND
 SECONDARY ROOF DRAINS PER SECTIONS 1106
 AND 1107 AND ALL ALL SUBSECTIONS. SHOW
 SQUARE FOOTAGE OF ROOF AND SHOW 1/2 AREA
 OF ALL VERTICAL WALLS INCLUDING PARAPETS
 BEING ADDED TO ROOF S.F.
 14) RAIN WATER SHALL DISCHARGE A MINIMUM
 OF 1 FOOR FROM THE SIDE WALL OF THE
 STRUCTURE PER SECTION 1503.4.4
 15) THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION IS REQUIR-
 ED FOR GAS PERMIT,
 A. SUBMIT AN ISOMETRIC DRAWING THAT
 CLEARLY SHOWS ALL CUT SECTIONS OF PIPE
 AND CORRESPONDING LENGTHS PER FBC-2001
 FUEL GAS CODE.
 B. SHOW THE DISTANCE FROM THE POINT OF
 DELIVERY, (METER), TO THE MOST REMOTE
 OUTLET IN THE BUILDING AND/OR SYSTEM PER
 FBC-2001 FUEL GAS CODE APPENDIX A - USE
 OF CAPACITY TABLES (A)(3).
 C. INDICATE THE DELIVERY PRESSURE (PSI)
 PER FBC-2001 FUEL GAS CODE SEC. 402.2.
 NATURAL GAS SPECIFY .5 PSI OR 2 PSI.
 MINIMUM 1/2 LB SYSTEM SUPPLIED.
 D. SUBMIT MANUFACTURE SHEETS FOR ALL GAS
 EQUIPMENT TO VERIFY COMPLIANCE WITH
 STANDARDS NFPA 54, NFPA 58, AND THE
 FBC-2001 FUEL GAS CODE SEC 402.2
 ****************************************
 A PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER SHALL SIGN HIS
 NAME AND AFFIX HIS SEAL TO ALL PLANS,
 SPECIFICATIONS, REPORTS AND FINAL BID
 DOCUMENTS PROVIDED TO THE OWNER OR THE
 OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE, OR OTHER DOCU-
 MENTS PREPARED OR ISSUED BY SAID REGIS-
 TRANT AND BEING FILED FOR PUBLIC RECORD.
 THE DATE THAT THE SIGNATURE AND SEAL IS
 AFFIXED AS PROVIDED HEREIN SHALL BE EN-
 TERED ON SAID PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, RE-
 PORTS, OR OTHER DOCUMENTS IMMEDIATELY
 UNDER THE SIGNATURE OF THE PROFESSIONAL
 ENGINEER, FAC 61G15-23.002(1)
 FS 471.025
 EACH SHEET OF PLANS AND PRINTS WHICH
 MUST BE SEALED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF
 CHAPTER 471 SHALL BE SEALED, SIGNED AND
 DATED BY THE PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER IN
 RESPONSIBLE CHARGE. FAC 61G15-23.002(2)
 FS 471.025
 ENGINEERS SHALL LEGIBLY INDICATE THEIR
 NAME, ADDRESS AND LICENSE NUMBER ON EACH
 SHEET. IF PRACTICING THROUGH A DULY
 AUTHORIZED ENGINEERING BUSINESS, ENGIN-
 EERS, ENGINEERS SHALL LEGIBLY INDICATE
 THEIR NAME AND LICENSE NUMBER, AS WELL
 AS, THE NAME, ADDRESS AND CERTIFICATE OF
 AUTHORIZATION NUMBER OF THE ENGINEERING
 BUSINESS ON EACH SHEET. A TITLE BLOCK
 WILL SATISFY THIS REQUIREMENT. FAC
 61G15-23.002(2) - FS 471.025
 ****************************************
 <<<<<<<<>>>>>>>
 PLEASE CLEARLY INDICATE THE REVISION AND
 REMOVE AND REPLACE ANY PAGES AS NECESS-
 ARY. SUBMIT (1) SET OF OLD DRAWINGS WITH
 THE PLANS WHEN RESUBMITTING PLANS. A
 TRANSMITTAL LETTER LISTING THE ORIGINAL
 REVIEW NUMBER, WITH A DESCRIPTION OF THE
 REVISION MADE, IDENTIFYING THE SHEET OR
 SPECIFICATION PAGE WHERE THE CHANGES CAN
 BE FOUND, WILL HELP TO EXPEDITE YOUR
 PERMIT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ANTICIPATED
 COOPERATION.
  
 REVIEW BY KEN STEVENS
 (561) 805-6721
 FAX (561) 653-2692
 E-MAIL [email protected]
Review Stop Z ZONING
Rev No 1 Status P Date 2004-06-17 Cont ID  
Sent By gjoyce Date 2004-05-13 Time 13:43 Rev Time 0.15
Received By nleiva Date 2004-06-17 Time 10:23 Sent To  
Notes
2004-06-17 00:00:00OK PER GRACE JOYCE
2004-05-13 00:00:00STALL DEPTH MUST BE 19.10, IT'S ONLY 18'
 SENT AN E-MAIL TO RACHEL HALL


Account Summary | Usage Policy | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005 – 2014, SunGard Pentamation, Inc & City of West Palm Beach, FL – All Rights Reserved